Stella McCartney hits back at 'false' objections to plans for £5million Scottish retreat

She is renowned worldwide for her commitment to animal welfare in the fashion industry.
But Stella McCartney has been forced to hit back at 'false' objections to plans for her £5million Scottish retreat - after being accused of threatening wildlife.
The fashion designer and her husband Alasdhair Wills have faced backlash to their plans to build a modern glass-fronted home on the Moidart Peninsula, Lochaber, with more than 60 objections lodged with Highland Council so far.
Claims that their four-bedroom Commando Rock home would destroy a wildlife haven, however, has promoted the celebrity couple to hit back saying the proposed home was carefully designed to have 'minimal environmental impact' and would be 'barely visible'.
Their statement to the Daily Record read: 'The latest allegations sadly, continue to reflect falsehoods and factual inaccuracies relating to the planning application.
'What seems to have been largely overlooked is that there is already planning permission for a dwelling on the site dating from 2000 through a previous owner. This already consented scheme, unlike the proposed home, does not take into account environmental sensitivities.'
It added: 'Allegations have been made that the proposed house will be visible from all directions. In fact, the proposed house has been sympathetically designed and will be secluded and barely visible due to the site's contours, including views from the water.
'This highly sustainable home in terms of visual impact will therefore be considerably better than the existing permission.'
The daughter of The Beatles singer Paul McCartney and her husband made the comments following the latest objection from Professor Calum Sutherland who claimed the development would impact on seals, porpoises, otters and birds, which 'will most likely not cope with the proposed escalation in noise and light pollution.'
He wrote: 'It is a shame that the ability of so many individuals to experience such an idyllic wildlife area will be adversely affected by the habitat damaging intentions of a celebrity.
'The size and design of the buildings, extending out to be clearly visible from almost every direction across the bay, with significant upgrading of transport access near to quiet wildlife havens is highly likely to have a significant impact on wildlife habitat and visitor experience.
'Wildlife tourists will be forced away from what has until now been a scenic and peaceful vacation area.'
A previous complaint - thought to be from a birdwatcher - had earlier claimed the presence of Ring Ouzel, Wood Warbler and Redstart mean further studies should be done later in the year.
That would set the project back a further six months.
The objector wrote: 'Because a field survey has only been carried out on a single day in a single month - December - the ecological appraisal is incomplete.
'It fails to acknowledge that a corresponding survey between June and September would reveal butterflies and other insect life plus summer-visiting birds which may include declining species such as Ring Ouzel, Wood Warbler and Redstart, all of which would be vulnerable to human disturbance.
'It would thus be remiss of the planning authority to determine this application in advance of a further field survey which should be carried out on at least one day between June 1 and September 15.'
The backlash prompted Mr Willis earlier this year to publicly defend the plans when he said: 'We want a house that is in tune with the landscape, not working against it.'
Highland Council has yet to make a decision.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

BBC News

an hour ago

• BBC News

Moray schoolgirl's message in a bottle gets reply from Norway 31 years later

A Scottish schoolgirl's message in a bottle has finally received a reply more than 30 years later - after being discovered in Beresford, from Portknockie in Moray, sent the message in 1994 when she was 12 as part of a school washed up across the North Sea where it was found by a volunteer cleaning up a Norwegian island - who then dispatched a postcard to the delighted sender to let her told BBC Scotland News she could not believe her original letter was in such good condition after three decades. Her handwritten letter had been sent in an empty bottle of Moray Cup, a fizzy drink produced in the north east of Scotland. It said: "Dear finder. My name is Alaina Stephen and I am 12 years of age. I come from Portknockie and I am doing a project on water so I decided to send a message in a bottle."My teacher's husband took them and dropped them in the middle of the ocean."When you find this message, please write back with your name, hobbies, where you found the message, when, and if you could, a little information about your area. Yours sincerely, Alaina Stephen. PS I come from Scotland." Now, 31 years on, Alaina has received a postcard from Pia Brodtmann, telling her the good news, with pictures of the said: "My name is Pia and I am from Germany. Today I found your message in a bottle on Lisshelløya, a tiny island around Vega in Norway."I am here for beach cleaning as a volunteer for four months and today we cleaned Lisshelløya. On the front of the postcard you can see our workboat Nemo and our sailboat Fonn, where we live. You can also see the area around Vega. I wonder when and where your teacher's husband threw your bottle in the ocean?"It added: "PS I am 27 years old and I like rock climbing and sailing a lot!" Alaina, now 42, said she as stunned when she picked up the post and noticed the postcard addressed to herself."I'm at the same address," she said."I did live in Buckie, and another house in Portknockie for a while, but moved back in with my parents."I couldn't believe it, as I had sent it when I was 12 years old, 31 years ago." Alaina was able to find Pia via social media, and messaged her asking to send a photo of her letter."I was shocked when she did, I couldn't believe how legible it was," she said."I can't remember actually writing the message, but I do remember it was a Moray Cup bottle, and that my teacher's husband had dropped it into the sea when he was a fisherman."According to my message, I had done it as part of a project on water. It was when I was in P7."She added: "Pia and I have been keeping in touch and hopefully we will continue to do so."

Daily Record

2 hours ago

• Daily Record

Babyshambles star Patrick Walden dies aged 46 as band pay tribute

Patrick Walden, Babyshambles former guitarist, has tragically died aged 46. Babyshambles former guitarist Patrick Walden has tragically died aged 46, the band have confirmed in an emotional statement. The group, fronted by Pete Doherty, shared the heartbreaking news with fans, they said: "It is with deep regret and sadness that we share the news of Patrick Walden's death. We feel very fortunate to have known, loved and worked with him and we kindly ask for respect and privacy during these difficult times. Peter, Drew, Mik, Adam", reports the Mirror. ‌ Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. ‌ Tributes have poured in from heartbroken fans, one wrote: "Very sad to hear the news… Biggest love to all." A second penned: "Can't believe this. Absolute genius on the guitar, Babyshambles were at their peak with Pat. But more importantly a genuine lovely guy. Down in Albion will always be a masterpiece to me." A third typed: "Such a genius, made so much from his sound which meant Pete only had to sing live, which was difficult in them days considering it was also 50/50 if the shows even happened! Thanks for the music Pat, at least we'll always have that, and the greatest of memories...." The band was formed 21 years ago and became Pete Doherty's main outlet for poetic yet chaotic rock after he was driven out of The Libertines. Babyshambles released their self-titled debut 7" in April that year. By the summer, the group consisted of Pete, guitarist Patrick, bassist Drew McConnell, and drummer Gemma Clarke. In 2005, they released their debut album, Down in Albion, which landed in the Top 10 of the Album Charts.

The Sun

2 hours ago

• The Sun

Fresh twist as Wagatha Christie battle between Coleen Rooney and Rebekah Vardy makes legal history

THE Wagatha Christie libel fight between Coleen Rooney and Rebekah Vardy has made legal history — with the judgment shaping case law. Decisions made in the celebrity battle have been used by a judge to settle a row between siblings. 3 3 It was applied to Andrew Wills' legal fight with sister Bernadette Rogers who wanted £135,000 for looking after their dying mum. Judge Paul Matthews urged them to settle their dispute by mediation before drawing on Vardy vs Rooney judge Mrs Justice Steyn's verdict. He said he was allowed to draw an inference about a participant if they had failed to provide documents which should have been disclosed. In his judgment, he noted: 'Steyn J applied the principle in the case of Vardy v Rooney (2022) where an order was made for the inspection of the telephone of the claimant's witness, but the phone was allegedly lost overboard whilst on a boat trip a few days later.' Judge Matthews was referring to Vardy's then-agent, Caroline Watt, whose phone was apparently lost off Scotland days after 39-year-old Coleen's lawyers asked to search it for WhatsApp chats. Mrs Justice Steyn later ruled Becky, 43, and Miss Watt leaked stories about Coleen, who was seen on holiday in Ibiza this week with footballer husband Wayne. The couple were spotted at the Cala Bassa Beach Club in Ibiza, with Wayne sporting a full beard and a black baseball cap. Major blow for Becky Vardy as Coleen Rooney WINS latest Wagatha Christie battle 3