Man assaulted by NZ Catholic brother wants say in election of new Pope
Cardinals walk to take their places ahead of the late Pope Francis' funeral ceremony at St Peter's Square at The Vatican on April 26, 2025.
Photo:
AFP/MANDEL NGAN
A Fijian man sexually abused as a boy by a Catholic brother says he has a right to lobby the conclave in Rome over who it chooses as the next pope.
"I'm afraid that the new Pope that's going to be picked is tainted in some way and may not fully commit to ending sex abuses and not survivor friendly," Felix Fremlin told RNZ.
Assaulted as a seven year old
by a New Zealand Marist brother
at his Suva school, Fremlin has now joined an international group that has set up a database, Conclave Watch, aimed at vetting cardinals and posting details online.
"From a survivor's point, you know it's always good to put up history of cardinals so that, you know, we hope that the right choice is made," Fremlin said.
He demands a say - though he is not a Catholic any more - even if believers protested at this as interference.
"From my history of being a Catholic and my history of being abused by Catholic priests and the Marist Brothers, I have a right to speak out to protect the children that's coming up."
He was among abuse survivors banding together and speaking up to a greater extent than at past conclaves.
Behind the watch database was the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP), which said the response had been overwhelming.
"Survivors and advocates from around the world continue to send us critical information," said spokesperson Sarah Pearson.
Fremlin said conclaves were too secretive and should be open.
"To be honest, I can't do much, but all I can do is just to make sure that from small country we try to just raise our voice up."
Cardinals have discussed clerical abuse in pre-conclave talks, the Vatican said on Monday.
One who took part, Jean Luis Cipriani Thorne of Peru, was secretly disciplined in 2019 following allegations of sexual abuse - he denied wrongdoing - but has defied various orders from the late Pope Francis.
"This man has no place there," Pearson said.
Cipriani is too old (over 80) to take part in the election once the conclave begins on 7 May, however, Catholic news site Crux said how the cardinals handled him now was an
immediate "litmus test"
.
Fremlin said the problem was of tainted cardinals doing the choosing, as well as who they might choose.
"We can't stop them choosing whoever they want to choose, but we're just hoping that common sense can prevail and they choose someone who can make a fresh start."
Francis, like some other popes before him, had said the right things but not gone far enough, he added.
Fremlin did not like how New Zealand cardinal John Dew had handled abuse allegations, contrasting that with what he said was more openess from Tonga's cardinal Soane Patita Paini Mafi.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsroom
an hour ago
- Newsroom
Middle East military action ‘extremely worrying', but no call yet on bombing
This story first appeared on RNZ and is republished with permission The foreign affairs minister says the Government will gather facts before taking a position on the United States' airstrikes on Iran. The US attacked three Iranian nuclear sites over the weekend, with President Donald Trump saying the country's key nuclear enrichment facilities have been 'completely and totally obliterated.' Trump said Iran 'must now make peace' or there would be further attacks. In response, Iran has accused the US of launching 'a dangerous war,' and of violating the United Nations Charter and international law. But on Sunday afternoon, shortly after the attack was launched, Foreign Affairs Ministers Winston Peters said the New Zealand government was waiting for the facts. 'Look, this has just happened. These are circumstances in which we will first of all gather the facts, and the circumstances, before we give our opinion.' Peters said the crisis was 'extremely worrying' and New Zealand would continue to call for diplomacy and dialogue. 'Ongoing military action in the Middle East is extremely worrying, and it's critical further escalation is avoided. We strongly support efforts towards diplomacy and urge all parties to return to talks,' he said. 'Iran's nuclear activities have long worried New Zealand. We want Iran to comply with its international obligations. Our concern is that further military action is not going to deliver a sustainable solution to this problem. 'We're a long way from the region, but New Zealand will continue to convey these measures in favour of diplomacy and dialogue directly to Iran, Israel, and the other parties involved in possible talks.' Labour's defence spokesperson Peeni Henare backed Peters' calls for a return to talks, but said the government should acknowledge the US breached international law and be 'perhaps a bit stronger' in the first instance. Henare said Trump's statements had made it 'quite clear' what had happened. 'Countries can't call for peace and de-escalation, only to take the action that's been taken.' Waikato University law professor Alexander Gillespie said the airstrikes were 'clearly' illegal in terms of international law. 'There's nowhere in the UN charter that says you can bomb someone who won't negotiate with you. But whether you get to a point where that is actually condemned is going to be very different,' he said. 'There's the theory of international law, with the UN Charter, and then there's the reality of international politics at the moment, which means that America will not be condemned internationally by the Security Council or even through the International Court of Justice.' The Prime Minister is heading to NATO this week. New Zealand is not a member, but in recent years has been invited as a partner along with fellow Indo-Pacific Four nations Australia, Japan and South Korea. While Christopher Luxon would be 'on the margins,' Gillespie expected he would be watching closely to see what like-minded partners were saying. 'This is an act which is not self-defence, and even if you argued it was pre-emptive self-defence, it wasn't necessary because there were other options of diplomacy still open. It will create difficulties if we speak out and say that, I don't think we're in a position to do that right now, for fear of the reaction that you get from America.' Australia's government has already issued a statement on the airstrikes. 'We have been clear that Iran's nuclear and ballistic missile program has been a threat to international peace and security,' the statement said. 'We note the US president's statement that now is the time for peace. The security situation in the region is highly volatile. We continue to call for de-escalation, dialogue, and diplomacy.' Defence Force plane leaves today The Government is sending a C-130J Hercules plane to the Middle East, with Defence Force and Foreign Affairs personnel, to assist New Zealanders stranded in Iran and Israel. Defence minister Judith Collins said the plane was a contingency, and would not be able to aid in evacuation flights until airspace restrictions in the region eased. In the meantime, those who were able to leave via a safe route were urged to do so. Peters said the flights would get people to a safe place. 'We're not bringing them home. We're getting them to where they can make arrangements to get home.' The Government has been warning New Zealanders in the region to leave for a long time, Peters said. The number of New Zealanders registered as being in Iran or Israel had increased in recent days. The decision to send the Hercules was made even before knowledge of the airstrikes had come through. 'Our anxiety was enunciated and formulated into policy, warnings, and collections of views months ago. We've been saying it, and it's a sad circumstance here, but we said 'look this is very dangerous, get out,'' Peters said. Citing security reasons, Collins would not say where the plane and personnel would be based. Both Henare and Gillespie supported the move. 'I think if we're ready and on standby, at the very least, to make sure we can respond to our citizens and their needs, and also those of our diplomatic staff, I think that's a really smart move,' Henare said. Gillespie said sending a plane was prudent in case the situation worsened quickly, and the damage became more indiscriminate.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Urban Issues: The case for keeping the Gordon Wilson flats
The Gordon Wilson flats in Wellington. Photo: RNZ / Krystal Gibbens Urban issues correspondent Bill McKay discusses the government's decision to introduce a bill to demolish Wellington's Gordon Wilson Flats and why he believes it's a new low in the story of our architectural heritage. Bill McKay is a Senior Lecturer in the School of Architecture and Planning at the University of Auckland.
NZ Herald
4 hours ago
- NZ Herald
What visuals show of damage to Iran's nuclear sites after US strikes
This combination of pictures created on June 22 using handout satellite images released by Maxar Technologies shows Iran's Isfahan nuclear enrichment facility on June 16, 2025 (top), and Iran's Isfahan nuclear enrichment facility in central Iran after US strikes on June 22, 2025. Photo / Satellite image Maxar Technologies, AFP Satellite imagery taken today shows at least six apparent bomb entry points at Iran's key Fordow uranium enrichment facility, according to a Washington Post visual analysis and multiple experts. The images are the first look at damage to one of Iran's main nuclear facilities after American bombers struck
