Daughter of one-time billionaire in tax dispute over payments from Russian companies
Aoife Quinn, daughter of one-time billionaire Seán Quinn, is embroiled in a dispute with the Revenue Commissioners over tax payable on money she received from Russian companies owned by her family's business empire.
The Revenue Commissioners has appealed to the High Court a Tax Appeals Commission determination published last year in respect of Ms Quinn's income tax assessment for 2011 and 2012, when she received monies arising from 'bogus' employment contracts signed with three Quinn Group-owned Russian companies: Finansstroy, Red Sector, and Logistica.
The High Court heard Wednesday that Ms Quinn contends these contracts were a cash extraction scheme, primarily used to fund the Quinn family's legal battle with the Irish Bank Resolution Corporation (IBRC).
In the 2010s, Seán Quinn and his children, including Ms Quinn, were involved in proceedings against IRBC, home to the remnants of the Anglo Irish Bank, which collapsed during the economic crash of 2008.
The proceedings centred on IBRC's attempts to recover billions in debts owed to Anglo Irish Bank by the Quinn family. Following various cases, the litigation was resolved in 2019.
According to court documents, Ms Quinn received almost €540,000 in gross payments from the three Russian companies owned by Quinn Group between 2011 and 2012. The total tax bill issued by the Revenue for the two years came to €301,718.
Last year, the Tax Appeals Commission determined the money received by Ms Quinn from Finansstroy (€351,465.20 gross) should be removed from Revenue's assessment of her income tax returns for 2011 and 2012, after finding the money was incorrectly assessed.
The commissioner's determination was based on Ms Quinn's evidence, and the findings of Russian courts, that the 'employment' relationship between Ms Quinn and Finansstroy 'was wholly bogus and unlawful'.There is a specific provision in Irish law that allows for taxing of profits or gains obtained unlawfully, but the Revenue did not assess the Finansstoy money under this provision.The commissioner noted there was no finding of criminality in respect of the employment relationship.
Ms Quinn had appealed to the Tax Appeals Commission following Revenue's assessment of her tax returns for 2011 and 2012.
The Revenue appealed the commissioner's determination to the High Court last year, seeking the court's opinion on several points of law it says arises from the determination.
Opening the case, counsel Aoife Goodman, appearing with Kieran Binchy, submitted to Ms Justice Siobhán Stack that the commissioner erred in finding the income received from Finansstroy could only be assessed under Section 58 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997. This section allows for taxation of profits or gains where the source of which is unknown, or arises from an unlawful source or activity.
The Revenue assessed the Finansstroy money under Section 18 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, which allows for taxing of income arising from an employment outside the State.
Ms Goodman also submitted that the Commissioner was wrong to conclude that the Revenue was 'aware of the unlawfulness' of the source of the Finansstroy money when it made its income tax assessment.
Bernard Dunleavy, appearing with Eoin O'Shea for Ms Quinn, will lay out his client's case on Thursday
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
34 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Billionaire Telegram founder and serial sperm donor Pavel Durov says he plans to leave fortune to all the 100-plus children he has fathered
Today at 21:30 Pavel Durov, the Russian-French billionaire and founder of messaging app Telegram, claims he's fathered more than 100 children through sperm donation over the last 15 years. The 40-year-old messaging mogul said in a recent interview that he's planning to share his fortune with all of his children, even though he's only the 'official father' of six.
Irish Independent
34 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Shortlist for €2bn race to buy Energia is whittled down to four bidders
A joint-venture between the UK's Octopus Energy and Canada Pension Plan Investment Board has emerged as one of the second-round bidders in a €2bn-plus race to buy Irish power firm Energia.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
UN questions Irish family courts over 'concept of parental alienation'
Ireland has been asked to respond to the UN on why "the concept of parental alienation" is being considered by the family law courts. Parental alienation is typically used to describe a situation where one parent wrongfully influences a child or children to turn against the other parent, usually in situations of relationship breakdown. The issue was raised on Friday afternoon by Dafna Hacker Dror of the UN's committee on the elimination of discrimination against women and girls. Ms Hacker Dror told the Irish delegation attending a hearing in Geneva: 'It seems that formal bodies are using the concept of parental alienation as if not contested, while it is highly contested on many levels including due to the risk that use of this concept holds for women and children who suffer from domestic violence.' Ms Hacker Dror asked why the concept was being used and added: 'What is done to prevent its potential harm to victims of domestic violence?" Minister for migration Colm Brophy led the Irish government's delegation and agreed to respond to that and some other questions in writing. It comes after minister for justice Jim O'Callaghan said last month that recommendations arising from a consultation process on parental alienation are currently being progressed. He said the process had resulted in a public consensus that 'the means to address parental alienation lie in improvements to the Irish family courts and family justice system'. He acknowledged that parental alienation is a highly contested and divisive concept. The consultation process on the issue was launched in 2022 by then-Justice Minister Helen McEntee. The aim of the consultation process was to seek the views of stakeholders and individuals around the issue of parental alienation. A report on parental alienation in other jurisdictions was also reviewed by the department as part of a process examining whether policy or legislative changes are required in Ireland. Meanwhile, concern was also raised during the hearing in Geneva that although Travellers make up just 0.7% of the Irish population, 15% of the male prison population and 22% of the female prison population in Ireland are Travellers. Department of Justice representative Lisa Doherty acknowledged that the 'disproportionate representation' of Travellers in the prison system is a 'cause for concern and is a reflection of the challenges facing Travellers in our society.'
