Book review: Reinterpreting the Irish Famine as a consequence of unbridled capitalism
More than six million visitors attended the Great Exhibition in London in 1851.
Held in the cast iron, specially-built Crystal Palace in Hyde Park, this global fair showcased the industrial might of the UK, the world's most powerful economy.
But it failed to acknowledge the tragedy unfolding within its borders.
During the Great Famine (1845-52), at least 1m people died of starvation in Ireland and about 1.5m fled.
In 1847, Britain's prime minister, Lord John Russell, likened the spiralling calamity to a 'famine of the 13th century'.
For Padraic X Scanlan, this gross juxtaposition of commercial celebration and human catastrophe encapsulates Britain's ruthless attitude to the Great Famine.
The historian's central contention in Rot is that Westminster's response to the starvation was defined by its overarching commitment to the principles of the free market.
Underlining the book's polemical tone, Scanlan argues that Ireland during the Famine was a laboratory in which the most exploitative aspects of 'capitalist modernity' were unleashed.
'The blight was a consequence of a novel pathogen spreading among fields of vulnerable plants,' he writes.
But the famine — a complex ecological, economic, logistical, and political disaster — was a consequence of colonialism.
The dependence of the working poor on the potato in pre-Famine Ireland was unmatched anywhere in the world.
Many Britons regarded the potato as the source of Irish poverty, associating the food with the lower classes' innate laziness and lack of civilisation.
This perspective ignored the transformative effect of the land settlement achieved by Oliver Cromwell's conquest of the country.
In pre-Famine Ireland, about 2.7m people (more than 20% of the population) were landless, while only 4,000 people owned almost 80% of Irish land.
Successive Westminster administrations viewed the Famine through the lens of eliminating Ireland's dependence on the potato — and an opportunity to civilise its poor.
Charles Trevelyan, a treasury secretary who's often portrayed as arch villain of the Great Hunger, characterised the humanitarian crisis as a 'sharp but effectual remedy' to 'cure' the problem of Irish backwardness.
Tellingly, he published his account of the Famine in 1848, just over halfway through the event.
Scanlan is an associate professor at the University of Toronto. Reinterpreting history is a hallmark of the Canadian's approach and a refrain in the author's two previous books, both of which focused on the British slave trade.
Scanlan adopts a similar angle in Rot and balances wide research into the politics and economy of Famine Ireland with unsettling closeups of starvation.
From contemporary accounts, we glimpse the extent of the devastation: people eating wild birds' eggs, rotting carrion, grass, moss, dirt, worms, cats, dogs, and rats.
But his didactic analysis is a blunt instrument to untangle the complexities of the era.
Likewise, Scanlan's suggestion that current societal problems, such as gaping inequality, exorbitant rents, and insecure employment, echo the anxieties of pre-Famine Ireland is a misstep.
In 1861, the Irish nationalist John Mitchel wrote: 'the Almighty, indeed, sent the potato blight, but the English created the famine'.
Rot revisits the question of British responsibility because 'blame matters'.
The British government didn't intentionally starve Ireland during the Famine, Scanlan admits, but 'it was not innocent'.
No country in Europe was affected as profoundly as Ireland by the 1840s potato blight.
In Belgium, the potato failure caused a severe food crisis, but from 1846 to 1856 the population increased by 200,000.
Ultimately, Scanlan identifies the ideologies underpinning Britain's reaction to the Irish Famine as the lynchpin.
'Colonialism and capitalism created conditions that turned blight into famine.'
Scanlan's arguments lack the rigour to always convince, but they make Rot a provocative read.
Read More
Book review: Fleeing Famine and oppression for the land of opportunity
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Taoiseach ‘not aware' of any talk in Fianna Fáil about backing Colum Eastwood for president
FIANNA FÁIL LEADER and Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said he is not aware of any engagement with former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood over becoming the party's candidate for the Irish presidency. It has been reported by the BBC that Eastwood is considering a bid for Áras an Uachtaráin. Eastwood is currently an MP for Northern Ireland's Foyle constituency, which takes in Derry. He resigned as SDLP party leader in October last year , having announced his intention to step down a couple of months prior. The BBC today reported that Eastwood is 'considering' a bid because 'people have asked and we'll see where it goes'. 'There's very few candidates in the field right now. It's something that needs a lot of consideration.' He added: 'I'm going to take the time to think about it, but it's a long summer and there's enough to be getting on with before any decisions around that would have to be made.' Aged 42, Eastwood has previously served as the youngest mayor of Derry between 2010 and 2011. He became an MLA in 2011 and became party leader in 2015. Advertisement Eastwood was then voted in as an MP in 2019 and was return to Westminister in 2024, though with a much smaller majority. Rumours have swirled in recent days that Eastwood is being considered as a potential nominee by Fianna Fáil. Asked to confirm if Eastwood had indeed been approached by the Fianna Fáil party, Martin questioned the basis for the question, adding: 'There's been no contact with me, there's been no engagement that I am aware of from the Fianna Fail party and it hasn't been on the agenda at all.' Speaking at a North South Ministerial Council meeting today in Co Armagh, Martin said he was 'surprised' to hear Eastwood was considering a run but said 'it's open to everybody to put themselves forward'. He said Eastwood was a 'very effective parliamentarian' but Fianna Fáil had not concluded on deliberations 'at all'. The SDLP and Fianna Fáil entered into a 'policy partnership' in 2019 but this was ended in 2022. Talks of a possible merger between the two parties had been ongoing at the time, however, rather than a full-on merger, the parties instead agreed to the 'policy partnership'. Eastwood told a meeting of his party delegates in September 2022 that the time had come for the SDLP to 'stand on its own two feet'. Meanwhile, Northern Ireland First Minister and Sinn Féin vice president Michelle O'Neill has not ruled out a run for the Irish presidential election. Asked at the North South Ministerial Council if she was considering putting her name forward, O'Neill said Sinn Féin is working its way through deliberations on putting forward a candidate. -With additional reporting from Diarmuid Pepper and Press Association Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Post
an hour ago
- Irish Post
Varadkar says Farage as PM could accelerate Irish unification
FORMER Taoiseach Leo Varadkar has said Irish unification could come about much more quickly if Nigel Farage were to become prime minister. Varadkar said Farage's rise to power could significantly shift public opinion in Northern Ireland and Scotland on remaining part of the UK. Describing British politics as 'very volatile' in a BBC interview, Varadkar said it's plausible that Farage could lead Britain within the next decade. While Reform won only five seats in the 2024 general election, it made notable gains in local elections across Britain. However, critics argue that Farage's popularity in parts of England may not translate into immediate political upheaval across the UK. 'There are people from both communities in Northern Ireland who value liberal and European ideals,' he said. 'If a future UK government contrasts sharply with one in Dublin, that could push more people toward voting for unification.' He also believes a Farage premiership could bolster support for Scottish independence. Regarding the possibility of a united Ireland, Varadkar stated that it is time to begin planning, although holding a referendum is not immediately necessary. 'We're not there yet in terms of numbers, but the direction is clear—demographics and polling show growing support, particularly among younger voters.' Later on the Red Lines podcast, Varadkar said he would trade two years of economic growth for Irish unity, arguing that the long-term benefits would outweigh any short-term costs. A 2024 report estimated the cost of unification at €20 billion over 20 years. He stressed that unity won't happen by accident: 'It must be worked towards. Those of us who believe in it have a duty to make the case.' See More: Irish Unification, Leo Varadkar, Nigel Farage, Northern Ireland
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood considers run for Presidential election as Sinn Fein plays down O'Neill bid for Aras
FORMER SDLP leader Colum Eastwood is considering throwing his hat in the ring for the Aras after being approached by people who want him as a candidate. It comes as Sinn Fein sources played down the chances of Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill becoming the party's candidate for the Irish Presidential race. 2 The Sinn Fein Vice President did not rule herself out of running for the Aras when asked about the possibility Credit: Getty Images - Getty 2 Former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood is said to be considering a run for the job Credit: PA:Press Association Opposition parties have held discussions about coming together to back one candidate with names like Senator Frances Black or Independent TD Catherine Connolly in the mix. An opinion poll last year found that the party's First Minister in the North READ MORE ON IRISH NEWS The Sinn Fein Vice President did not rule herself out of running for the Aras when asked about the possibility at a press conference following the North South Ministerial Council in Armagh. Asked about Sinn Fein's plan for the election, she said: 'We haven't concluded our own deliberations in terms of the presidential race itself. 'I think I have plenty to do being First Minister. But I think the fact remains that I could stand for election, be elected Uachtarain na hEireann but I can't vote in that election. 'That is where there is a deficit and what we need to see is Presidential voting rights extended to the North so that Irish citizens in the North can vote for their Uachtarain.' Most read in Irish News Pressed on whether she was considering putting her name forward, Michelle O'Neill said: 'I am working our way through our deliberations as we speak.' However, Sinn Fein sources told the Irish Sun that there is no chance that the First Minister will be the party's candidate for the election due to her position in the North. ARAS RACE RUMOURS One senior party figure said: 'She's too busy being a fantastic First Minister' while another said: 'No. That's not being discussed.' Another Northern Ireland politician who does want to put his name in the race for the Aras is former Social Democratic and Labour Party leader Colum Eastwood. The popular Northern politician told the BBC that he has been approached by people who want him to run in the election and he is seriously considering throwing his hat in the ring. Some reports had claimed that Eastwood was going to be Fianna Fail's candidate of choice for the Aras race but He said: 'There's been no contact with me and no engagement that I am aware of with the Fianna Fail party and that hasn't been on the agenda at all in terms of Colum. 'I was surprised when I heard that this morning that he was considering it but of course it is open to everybody to put themselves forward. 'Colum is a very effective parliamentarian and has been a political leader in Northern Ireland for quite some time."
