Miguel Cabrera shockingly erased from quarter century list and here is why

Detroit Tigers legend and one of baseball's greatest hitters, Miguel Cabrera, was shockingly omitted from The Athletic's All-Quarter Century team announced on May 22. It was a Hall of Fame-worthy resume with more than 3,000 hits and 500 home runs that failed to include Cabrera among the 15 players.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Though Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer, two of the Tigers' former stars, were included, Cabrera's name was not on the list prompting many raised eyebrows in the baseball community. So why was this great player omitted?
Miguel Cabrera's career statistics were legendary, but positions kept holding him back
Miguel Cabrera's numbers at the plate position him as one of baseball's all-time greats. He was an All-Star twelve times and a power hitter in his prime years. But as for Jayson Stark's All-Quarter Century team which featured eight position players, five starters, a closer, and one designated hitter Cabrera wasn't included. Why not?
They constructed the team by position, and that hurt him.
Cabrera had more than 100 games at four positions: first base, third base, left field, and right field. He also spent a huge portion of his later years as a DH. That might serve a team well, but for a list such as this, it blurred where he mattered.
First base, initially, was won by Albert Pujols, arguably the best to occupy the position of his greatness at the position. Third base saw Adrian Beltre's excellent defense and similar offense usurp Cabrera's place.
As a DH, Cabrera's later stats were not good enough to compete with Edgar Martínez or David Ortiz types. Outfield? Not when legends like Mike Trout and Barry Bonds were in the mix.
Also Read:
Miguel Cabrera's defense played a role in snub
Another reason Miguel Cabrera probably was omitted? Defense. Although he played several different positions, Miguel Cabrera wasn't exactly revered for his glove. His defensive statistics, including Defensive Runs Saved (DRS), were well below average.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
At the same time, Beltre, winner of five Gold Gloves and owner of 200 career DRS played elite defense. Add to that 3,166 hits and 477 home runs, and the case for Beltré becomes overwhelming. If Miguel Cabrera was an elite fielder or decidedly superior at the plate, he might have had a more compelling case. But his all-around competition passed him by.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Time of India

an hour ago

• Time of India

James Harden stuns fans by dressing as WWE legend Hulk Hogan at Fanatics Fest showdown

James Harden. Image via: Christopher Creveling-Imagn Images | Fanatics/X James Harden is entering his 16th NBA season, and the 35-year-old superstar proved he's still full of surprises. During Fanatics Fest in New York City, the Los Angeles Clippers guard lit up the crowd by channeling none other than WWE icon Hulk Hogan . The 2018 MVP's unexpected entrance, complete with theme music, yellow feather boa, and signature red bandana, delivered a larger-than-life moment that perfectly matched the electric energy of the event. His iconic entrance gave fans a glimpse of Harden's showman side beyond the basketball court. James Harden brings Hulk Hogan energy to Fanatics Fest James Harden embraced the Hardenmania character. Striding into Fanatics Fest to Hulk Hogan's classic entrance anthem, 'Real American,' Harden owned the moment with the confidence of a wrestling headliner. His performance was met with cheers and laughter from the crowd. Later during the event, Harden joined a live talk session where he reflected on his journey and aspirations. As he was speaking, a fan interrupted from the audience with a message, 'Win a championship.' Without missing a beat, Harden looked over and responded with a calm, determined, 'I will, I'm trying,' drawing both applause and laughter from those in attendance. Coming off a season that revitalized his legacy, Harden has reason to be optimistic. He earned both All-Star and All-NBA Third Team honors while averaging 22.8 points and 8.7 assists over 79 games. Even though the Clippers were bounced in the first round of the playoffs, the team's 50-win campaign was considered a success. Still, the championship remains the missing piece for the 11-time All-Star, and that's something he hasn't given up on. Whether or not he achieves it, his appearance at Fanatics Fest reminded fans that James Harden is keeping his championship dream alive. Fans reacted to James Harden's epic Hulk Hogan tribute at Fanatics Fest Fans online were quick to react to the epic moment created by James Harden. 'Thank you James. See, it takes special people to move on from hard feelings. He knows Hogan is the GOAT. If he can't be there personally he can be there in spirit,' one fan wrote on X. 'To those wondering if he knows, he definitely knows. He just ignores it or possibly is just a fan of the Hulk Hogan character, not the person itself. Hulkamania is, and always will be running wild. HULKAMANIA, BROTHER!!' another wrote slamming the criticism of the moment. 'Hulk Hogan wouldn't like this soo Good work Harden,' another fan shared. 'It's hilarious he got more cheers than the REAL Hulk Hogan would've,' one fan claimed. While the moment has its criticism, Harden's offseason break outing has certainly delighted a log of fans. Of course, many are upset for the Clippers legend not getting anywhere near winning a championship this year, but he is optimistic to come back stronger. Also Read: Victor Wembanyama keeps a secret notebook for wisdom from NBA legends like Kevin Durant and LeBron James Follow all the live updates, scores, and highlights from the India vs England Test match here . Game On Season 1 kicks off with Sakshi Malik's inspiring story. Watch Episode 1 here

Time of India

2 hours ago

• Time of India

Victor Wembanyama keeps a secret notebook for wisdom from NBA legends like Kevin Durant and LeBron James

The San Antonio Spurs' centerpiece for the future, the 21-year-old French phenom Victor Wembanyama, has turned heads for how he approaches greatness. What's not often seen is his personal notebook, where he stores advice from legends. The Spuers superstar recently shared that he is willing to note wisdom from active NBA legends, including Kevin Durant and . Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Victor Wembanyama quietly records advice from NBA greats like LeBron and Kevin Durant in a notebook During a live taping of The Shop: Uninterrupted at Fanatics Fest in New York, Victor Wembanyama peeled back the curtain on a unique part of his process. 'I have a note on my phone with questions to ask the guys, KD [Kevin Durant], 'Bron [LeBron James],' he shared, sitting alongside LeBron James and NFL icon Tom Brady. 'I had the chance to talk to [Nikola] Jokić for 45 minutes at All-Star [weekend]. And I'm taking notes.' That moment gave fans a glimpse into how seriously the Spurs star studies the game and its greatest minds. Wembanyama's hunger to learn doesn't end with casual conversation. 'When I'm told something, I don't forget it. It's super precious, for sure,' he added. That philosophy, combined with his freakish 7-foot-3 frame and raw talent, is what makes his ceiling so terrifyingly high. Before a blood clot in his right shoulder ended his season prematurely, Wembanyama was averaging 24.3 points, 11.0 rebounds, 3.7 assists, and a league-leading 3.8 blocks per game. The setback raised concerns, but the support from peers like Durant has been heartfelt. 'I'm glad they caught this early,' Durant said after a Spurs win over his Suns. 'That can affect your overall health… I'm thinking about Vic… he's gonna put his best foot forward every day. ' That mutual respect isn't one-sided. On Kevin Hart's Cold as Balls podcast, when asked if he's a big Durant fan, Wembanyama didn't hesitate: 'That's right.' Tired of too many ads? go ad free now He later doubled down in an interview with M6 Info after the Paris Olympics, calling Durant his 'favorite childhood player.' Laughing, he added, 'I made it clear that I wanted to learn from him, perhaps only steal one or two of his secret techniques.' Also Read: If trade rumors surrounding Durant pan out, and the Spurs do become a landing spot, the student might soon train daily with the teacher. But regardless of what happens, Wembanyama's notebook will continue to grow, filled with hard-earned wisdom from legends who've already left their mark, and one who's just getting started.

First Post

11 hours ago

• First Post

Bumrah roars, Pant dazzles, but Pope keeps England in the fight as they reach 209/3 on Day 2

Rishabh Pant's century and Jasprit Bumrah's fiery spell lit up Day 2 of the 1st Test at Headingley. Ollie Pope countered with an unbeaten ton as England reached 209/3 in reply to India's 471. read more Leeds: Jasprit Bumrah displayed his spine-tingling genius after Rishabh Pant unfurled an audacious hundred, but England batters led by centurion Ollie Pope produced their own parade to reach 209 for three at the end of the second day of the first Test here Saturday. Pope (100 batting) and Harry Brook (0) were at crease when the stumps were drawn with England whittling down India's lead to 262 after the visitors made 471 in their first innings. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Brook would certainly thank his stars as a pull off Bumrah, which was caught by Mohammed Siraj, was adjudged no-ball in the last over of the day. It was a sliver of example how the Indian pacer tormented the hosts batters. England did not quite solve the Bumrah puzzle but they showed enough spunk to bat through the storm. Pope can be a lovely batter to watch in full flow, but here the Surrey man sussed up the conditions and the general quality of the attack to a nicety to tweak his batting. Once he survived a massive shout for leg-before perpetuated by Mohammed Siraj, relying mainly on his bottom hand to collect runs with cuts and dabs through point, gully regions. Pope came to the middle when Bumrah was bowling in a charged atmosphere after he consumed opener Zak Crawley in the first over itself with a peach in a wonderful exhibition of fast bowling. Crawley never looked settled, producing edges in his first three balls, and the fourth one proved lethal. The delivery took the outside edge of the right-hander's bat, grazed on his thigh pad and eventually nestled in Karun Nair's hands at first slip. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Pope's partner Ben Duckett (62 off 94 balls), with whom he added 122 runs for the second wicket, had big slices of fortunes too. He was dropped on 15 by Ravindra Jadeja at backward point off Bumrah, but the England batters were good enough to put those thorny moments behind them to cash in on the profligacy of Bumrah's colleagues in the pace department. Siraj and Prasidh Krishna, a hard length bowler, were eager to discover the mandatory fuller length England, but they overreached in their effort, often giving ample space and width for batters to make some risk-free runs. Just as the alliance was swelling, Bumrah, who was used in short, sharp bursts, returned for his third spell, and induced an inside edge off Duckett to halt England's free walk. It was also slightly perplexing to see India skipper Shubhman Gill delaying the introduction of Shardul Thakur into the attack, which eventually happened in the 34th over. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD It did not give any noticeable lift to India's bowling unit, and it also watched in dejection the leg-before decision against Joe Root off Siraj was getting overturned via DRS. But that did not deter Pope as he reached 9th Test hundred with a cheeky single off Bumrah as sun-washed Headingley greeted the fourth hundred-maker in two days. However, that irresistible force of nature Bumrah returned at the right time to nick off Root to end a threatening 80-run stand for the third wicket. But before Bumrah made an instant impression, another Indian player thrilled the Leeds crowd. Pant's seventh Test hundred was soaked in brilliance and impudence. Once India resumed from overnight 359 for three, they needed Pant and Gill to carry on from last day's point. They showed intent too as the Indian captain motored onto 147, his highest score in Tests, and milked 209 runs for the fourth wicket with his deputy. Pant was at his entertaining best, starting his cavalier ways with a stunning falling paddle off spinner Bashir behind stumper Jamie Smith, a la West Indian legend Rohan Kanhai. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD A six over mid-wicket off spinner Shoaib Bashir carried him to 94, and the 90s is a rather troubled territory for Pant as he was dismissed seven times in Tests on that score in his career. So, it was not really surprising to see him taking singles until he reached 99. Pant then decided not to waste too much time, and summoned that one-handed six off Bashir to go past the 100-run mark for the seventh time in his career, and the 27-year-celebrated the occasion with a perfect somersault. It was also a moment of redemption for Pant as Gavaskar had slammed his shot selection during the tour to Australia with the stinging remark 'stupid, stupid, stupid.' But on this day, the legendary batter atoned for it with the exclamation of 'superb, superb, superb!' on air. However, the dismissals of Pant and Gill gave England the opening and they crashed through, taking seven Indian wickets for 41 runs across two sessions. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD