France fines Apple €150 million over privacy feature

The watchdog said the way Apple implemented its App Tracking Transparency (ATT) software was "neither necessary nor proportionate to the company's stated goal to protect user data" and also penalised third-party publishers.
In addition to the fine, Apple will have to publish the decision on its website for seven days.
Authorities in Germany, Italy, Romania and Poland have opened similar probes over ATT, which Apple promotes as a privacy safeguard.
The feature, introduced by Apple in 2021, requires apps to obtain user consent through a pop-up window before tracking their activity across other apps and websites.
If they decline, the app loses access to the user's advertising identifier, which enables ad targeting.
Critics have accused Apple of using the system to promote its own advertising services while restricting competitors.
In its decision, France's Competition Authority said the ATT feature leads to an excessive number of consent windows for third-party apps on iPhones and iPads, making the experience more cumbersome.
Advertisement
It also found that Apple's system required users to opt out of ad tracking twice rather than once, "undermining the neutrality of the feature" and causing economic harm to app publishers and ad services providers.
The authority added that Apple's approach disproportionately affects smaller publishers, who rely heavily on third-party data collection to fund their businesses.
Following complaints from advertising industry players who claimed ATT hindered their ability to target users, France's competition watchdog initially declined to impose emergency measures in 2021 but continued its investigation.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

France 24

4 days ago

• France 24

Taiwan's entrepreneurs in China feel heat from cross-Strait tensions

But now those firms are feeling the strain from cross-Strait tensions that have stoked safety fears among companies. Taiwanese entrepreneurs -- known as "Taishang" in Mandarin -- poured billions into mainland China since ties began improving in the 1990s, playing an important role in its rise to become the world's second-largest economy. But their numbers have dwindled in recent years, with the number of Taiwanese working in China dropping from 409,000 in 2009 to 177,000 in 2022, according to estimates provided to AFP by the Straits Exchange Foundation, an unofficial intermediary between Taipei and Beijing. China's economic slowdown and mounting trade tensions with Washington are partially responsible, the organisation says. But James Lee, a 78-year-old Taiwanese industrialist who was forced to close his cable and electrical outlet factory in southern Guangdong province in 2022, blames "politics". "You have to be very careful when you speak," Lee told AFP. "We Taiwanese businessmen are afraid." Bolstered by their mastery of Mandarin and business acumen, Taishang have prospered as wily intermediaries between international markets and China's vast industrial manufacturing base. Perhaps the most famous of them is Terry Gou, the founder of Foxconn whose vast factories in China churn out iPhones that have helped make it the world's biggest contract electronics manufacturer. No guarantee of safety An hour's drive from economic powerhouse Shanghai, Kunshan has been a key hub for Taiwanese-owned industry in China since the 1990s. "Back then, it was a rice field," recalls Annie Wang, an industrialist from the island who arrived in Kunshan in 1996. "Taiwanese companies were fortunate to coincide with the 30 most glorious years of Chinese manufacturing," she said. Now, Wang heads an electronics subcontracting manufacturing plant, a small technology park and a coffee utensil brand. At the height of the boom, Kunshan was home to more than 100,000 Taiwanese, according to unofficial figures from local associations. But the number of Taiwanese companies in the city has shrunk from more than 10,000 a decade ago to fewer than 5,000 today, according to the data. And the Taishang have felt the squeeze as relations between Taipei and Beijing plunge to their lowest depths in years. The Chinese Communist Party -- which claims Taiwan as its territory but has never controlled it -- has hardened its stance against alleged "Taiwanese independence activists", even calling for the death penalty for alleged secessionism. New rules, which also encourage citizens to report alleged pro-independence activities, have had a chilling effect on Taiwanese businesses in mainland China. "We are not sending Taiwanese employees (to China) because we don't know how to guarantee their safety," said industrialist Lee. "The initial favourable conditions have disappeared, and now there are many additional risks," Luo Wen-jia, vice chairman of the Straits Exchange Foundation, told AFP. China's economic woes and rising production costs are adding to the problems. "When we first went there, we thought that China's economy would continue to improve because its market is so large and its population is so big," Leon Chen, a Taiwanese businessman who worked at a battery component factory in the southeastern province of Jiangxi, said. "But we haven't seen this materialise because there are some issues -- there is the US-China trade war and there was the pandemic," he added. Caught in crossfire In response, Taiwanese manufacturers are turning to new, more profitable -- and less politically sensitive -- locales. "Some went to Vietnam, and some went to Thailand, Indonesia and the Philippines, and some returned to Taiwan," Luo said. Between 2016 and 2024, Taiwanese investments in Vietnam approved by the Ministry of Economic Affairs in Taipei soared 129 percent, from US$451 million to more than US$1 billion. Over the same period, those to mainland China fell 62 percent, according to the same source. This decline could deal a blow to Beijing's "united front" strategy, which has seen it lean on Taishang communities to promote Taiwan's political integration and, ultimately, unification. And as Beijing launches military drills practising a blockade of Taiwan and Taipei cracks down on Chinese spies, Taishang risk being caught in the crossfire. In October 2023, Foxconn was placed under investigation by Chinese authorities -- a move widely seen as linked to a bid for the Taiwan presidency by its founder. "There is no way to compare it with the heyday but we can still make ends meet," said Chen. © 2025 AFP

France 24

7 days ago

• France 24

Big tech on a quest for ideal AI device

The ability to engage digital assistants as easily as speaking with friends is being built into eyewear, speakers, computers and smartphones, but some argue that the Age of AI calls for a transformational new gizmo. "The products that we're using to deliver and connect us to unimaginable technology are decades old," former Apple chief design officer Jony Ive said when his alliance with OpenAI was announced. "It's just common sense to at least think, surely there's something beyond these legacy products." Sharing no details, OpenAI chief executive Sam Altman said that a prototype Ive shared with him "is the coolest piece of technology that the world will have ever seen." According to several US media outlets, the device won't have a screen, nor will it be worn like a watch or broach. Kyle Li, a professor at The New School, said that since AI is not yet integrated into people's lives, there is room for a new product tailored to its use. The type of device won't be as important as whether the AI innovators like OpenAI make "pro-human" choices when building the software that will power them, said Rob Howard of consulting firm Innovating with AI Learning from flops The industry is well aware of the spectacular failure of the AI Pin, a square gadget worn like a badge packed with AI features but gone from the market less than a year after its debut in 2024 due to a dearth of buyers. The AI Pin marketed by startup Humane to incredible buzz was priced at $699. Now, Meta and OpenAI are making "big bets" on AI-infused hardware, according to CCS Insight analyst Ben Wood. OpenAI made a multi-billion-dollar deal to bring Ive's startup into the fold. Google announced early this year it is working on mixed-reality glasses with AI smarts, while Amazon continues to ramp up Alexa digital assistant capabilities in its Echo speakers and displays. Apple is being cautious embracing generative AI, slowly integrating it into iPhones even as rivals race ahead with the technology. Plans to soup up its Siri chatbot with generative AI have been indefinitely delayed. The quest for creating an AI interface that people love "is something Apple should have jumped on a long time ago," said Futurum research director Olivier Blanchard. Time to talk Blanchard envisions some kind of hub that lets users tap into AI, most likely by speaking to it and without being connected to the internet. "You can't push it all out in the cloud," Blanchard said, citing concerns about reliability, security, cost, and harm to the environment due to energy demand. "There is not enough energy in the world to do this, so we need to find local solutions," he added. Howard expects a fierce battle over what will be the must-have personal device for AI, since the number of things someone is willing to wear is limited and "people can feel overwhelmed." A new piece of hardware devoted to AI isn't the obvious solution, but OpenAI has the funding and the talent to deliver, according to Julien Codorniou, a partner at venture capital firm 20VC and a former Facebook executive. OpenAI recently hired former Facebook executive and Instacart chief Fidji Simo as head of applications, and her job will be to help answer the hardware question. Voice is expected by many to be a primary way people command AI. Google chief Sundar Pichai has long expressed a vision of "ambient computing" in which technology blends invisibly into the world, waiting to be called upon. "There's no longer any reason to type or touch if you can speak instead," Blanchard said. "Generative AI wants to be increasingly human" so spoken dialogues with the technology "make sense," he added.

France 24

13-06-2025

• France 24

Vivatech 2025: Is Europe lagging behind?

13:44 From the show This week, we take you to Vivatech in Paris. The event bills itself as the biggest tech and startup event in Europe. The tech industry is the driving force for growth in the world economy, but Europe only represents a small share of it. Is Europe lagging behind in the race for artificial intelligence? Why are there no tech giants the size of Google or Apple on the continent? Our Business Editor Charles Pellegrin meets with French and German startups, as well as with Estonian Energy and Environment Minister Andres Sutt, who was previously the country's minister for entrepreneurship and innovation.