Gilgo Beach murders tied to Rex Heuermann by DNA software that needed ‘updates' due to glitches, expert testifies
The DNA software that linked Rex Heuermann to the Gilgo Beach murders was so glitchy that it was updated multiple times after it tied the accused serial killer to the grisly murders, a defense expert testified Tuesday.
Nathaniel Adams, a biotechnology expert for Heuermann's defense team, testified at a fiery court hearing that the IDBGEM program was prone to misreading genotype data that was used to link the suspected killer to six of the seven sex workers butchered and dumped on Long Island over more than 30 years.
'It's unreliable,' Adams, a 27-year-old graduate student and systems engineer for Forensic Bioinformantics in Ohio, testified in Suffolk County court. 'The software has been updated multiple times since the DNA in this case has been tested.'
5 Rex Heuermann, in court with lawyer Michael Brown, is charged with seven Long Island cold case killings.
Newsday
He said the software bugs would require a 'risk and hazard analysis' to avoid a 'catastrophic failure' that could lead to 'a miscarriage of justice.'
But Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney scoffed at Adams' qualifications as an expert on DNA — maintaining his testimony in about 30 other court cases have often been deemed 'inadmissible.'
'You've been in school for 10 years and have only obtained a bachelor's degree in all this time?' Tierney said as he grilled Adams on the stand. 'You're supposed to be an expert, but you don't even know who your adviser was or if you graduated summa cum laude or not.'
DNA is crucial to the prosecution's case as the most direct link to Heuermann and the killings.
5 Expert DNA witness Nathaniel Adams testified that DNA software used in the Gilgo Beach killings is unreliable.
James Messerschmidt
5 The seven sex workers allegedly killed by Long Island serial killer Rex Heuermann between 1993 and 2010.
Suffolk County Police Department
Suffolk prosecutors said they have linked Heuermann, a 61-year-old Manhattan architect from Massapequa Park, through hairs found on the seven victims. They were all sex workers who disappeared between 1993 and 2010 and were later found along desolate stretches of Long Island.
The deaths of the victims — Valerie Mack, 24, Taylor, 20, Megan Waterman, 22, Melissa Barthelemy, 24, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, Sandra Costilla, 28, and Amber Lynn Costello, 27 — remained unsolved until authorities reopened the cold case in 2022.
Heuermann, a married father of two, was arrested in July 2023 for three of the murders and was later tied to the other four through the DNA matches.
Investigators matched some of the victims through DNA links to Heuermann's wife, Asa Ellerup, and his adult daughter, Victoria Heuermann, authorities said.
5 Authorities have searched Rex Heuermann's Massapequa Park home twice searching for evidence in the killings.
New York Post
5 Suffolk County DA Ray Tierney scoffed at the credentials of the DNA witness called by Rex Heuermann's lawyer.
Dennis A. Clark
Authorities have twice executed search warrants at the Heuermann home, combing through the property, digging up the back yard and testing a basement gun bunker prosecutors believed was a 'kill room' — but have not revealed finding any physical evidence.
The DA did uncover a sick computer file, described as a 'how to' record on some of the killings and notes that appear to provide tips on how to improve the slayings.
The high-profile serial murder case has captured the nation's imagination, and is the subject of a newly released three-part Peacock docu-series that features first-ever interviews with Heuermann's family.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
Driver who mowed down beloved real estate agent Sara Burack in Hamptons hit-and-run arrested after manhunt
A 32-year-old Virginia woman was busted Friday in the Hamptons hit-and-run death of a hot-shot real estate agent who starred on Netflix's popular 'Million Dollar Beach House.' Amanda Kempton was charged with leaving the scene of a motor vehicle accident, a class D felony punishable by up to four years in prison, according to the Southampton Town Police Department. The arrest followed a manhunt for the motorist who mowed down 40-year-old Sara Burack in Hampton Bays. The prominent real estate agent, who specialized in high-end properties, was found unconscious by cops on the Montauk Highway near Villa Paul restaurant early Thursday, police said. It was unclear what type of vehicle struck Burack, leaving her to die on the side of the road. Kempton was set to be arraigned on the charges Saturday. Police are looking for the driver who struck Sara Burack, 40, and killed her in a hit-and-run incident in the Hamptons. Brian Zak/NY Post The department and the New York State Police Accident Reconstruction Unit were investigating the scene, local outlet Dan's Paper reported. Burack competed against other ritzy real estate agents on the Netflix reality show 'Million Dollar Beach House' in 2022. She previously worked for Nest Seekers International, a real estate agency for upscale properties in Manhattan and the Hamptons, but left the agency more than a year ago, Newsday reported. The beloved agent had a generous spirit and was known for her fundraising in New York City, close family friend and fellow realtor Paulette Corsair told Newsday. 'I want people to remember she was an amazing person who really cared for people. She was a hardworking real estate agent who was there for others. She was loved greatly by her friends and a close family.' Burack cut her teeth in her family's commercial construction and material sales business for years before jumping into the competitive luxury real estate market. 'I have always been intrigued by real estate projects and decided to become a broker after my experience as a summer property manager in the summer house I would rent,' she told Before the show's release, Burack promised that 'Million Dollar Beach House' would take viewers inside the lavish life of the rich-and-aspiring famous in the seaside enclave. 'Viewers will be taken into the world of the Hamptons where they will see not only beautiful multimillion-dollar beach homes and estates, but will be shown summer in the Hamptons,' she told 'With scenes from broker open houses, polo games, yacht life and more, there is sure to be an awww from viewers!'
New York Post
2 days ago
- New York Post
Real estate agent who appeared on Netflix's ‘Million Dollar Beach House' killed in Hamptons hit-and-run
A prominent real estate agent who specialized in high-end properties and was featured on the popular Netflix show 'Million Dollar Beach House' was killed by a hit-and-run driver in the Hamptons on Thursday afternoon, according to police and reports. Sara Burack, 40, was found unconscious by police on a Hampton Bays road shortly before 3 p.m. and the motorist who struck and killed her remains at large, police said, according to Newsday. Police are looking for the driver who struck Sara Burack, 40, and killed her in a hit-and-run incident in the Hamptons. Brian Zak/NY Post Southampton Town Police Detectives and a New York State Police Accident Reconstruction Unit investigated the scene, according to Dan's Papers. Police have not spoken to witnesses nor do they have any information detailing what type of vehicle that hit Burack and left her to die in the street, according to Dan's papers. Burack appeared in a Netflix reality show pitting hotshot real estate agents against each other. 'The competition is fierce — and the drama undeniable — as a group of young and hungry agents try to seal the deal on luxury listings in the Hamptons,' according to the show's description on Netflix's website. Burack used to work as a real estate agent for Nest Seekers International, a real estate agency for upscale properties in Manhattan and the Hamptons, according to Newsday. She left the agency more than a year ago but stayed in touch, Geoff Gifkins, the Hamptons regional manager for Nest Seekers, told Newsday. 'Our thoughts and prayers are with family and friends,' Gifkins said in a message. 'Please be kind and respectful as this is a tremendous loss to her parents and close friends.' Paulette Corsair, a real estate agent and close family friend, told Newsday that Burack will be remembered for her generous spirit and for fundraising in New York City. 'I want people to remember she was an amazing person who really cared for people,' Corsair told Newsday. 'She was a hardworking real estate agent who was there for others. She was loved greatly by her friends and a close family.' Burack told an interviewer that her family ran a commercial construction and material sales business that she spent years working for before moving into the elite luxury real estate market. 'I have always been intrigued by real estate projects and decided to become a broker after my experience as a summer property manager in the summer house I would rent,' she told Sara Burack, who appeared in a Netflix show about luxury real estate brokers, was killed in a hit-and-run incident. Brian Zak/NY Post Before the show's release, Burack described 'Million Dollar Beach House' as a peek into the lavish life of the rich-and-aspiring famous in the seaside redoubt. 'Viewers will be taken into the world of the Hamptons where they will see not only beautiful multimillion-dollar beach homes and estates, but will be shown summer in the Hamptons,' she told 'With scenes from broker open houses, polo games, yacht life and more, there is sure to be an awww from viewers!'
Newsweek
4 days ago
- Newsweek
Gilgo Beach Trial: What Rex Heuermann Was Overheard Telling Lawyer in Court
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Rex Heuermann told his defense attorney she did a "good job" during a hearing on DNA evidence on Tuesday. The comment came after defense attorney Danielle Coysh finished her direct questioning of Nathaniel Adams, a systems engineer at Forensic Bioinformatic Services Inc., Newsday reported. The Context Heuermann, 61, is facing murder charges for the deaths of seven women between 1993 and 2010. He was arrested in 2023 in connection with remains found over a decade prior near Gilgo Beach on Long Island, New York. The defense is challenging DNA evidence prosecutors say links Heuermann to six of the seven killings he's charged with. The judge is expected to rule on whether the evidence will be admissible at Heuermann's trial. Alleged Gilgo Beach killer Rex Heuermann appears for a hearing at Suffolk County Court in Riverhead, New York, on April 3, 2025. Alleged Gilgo Beach killer Rex Heuermann appears for a hearing at Suffolk County Court in Riverhead, New York, on April 3, 2025. James Carbone/Newsday via AP What To Know Adams said that California-based lab Astrea Forensics failed to follow some of the nationally accepted verification and validation standards. He also said the developers of the software used in Heuermann's case, IBDGem, have identified data errors and other defects in the system. The software has been updated since testing finished in Heuermann's case, Adams said. Adams said system errors would require a "risk and hazard analysis" to avoid "a miscarriage of justice," the New York Post reported. The prosecution has maintained that the DNA testing used in the case is widely accepted in the scientific community. Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney challenged Adams' qualifications, claiming that his testimony has not been admissible in about 30 court cases. Heuermann's ex-wife, Asa Ellerup, and daughter, Victoria Heuermann, did not attend the hearing on Tuesday. They have previously attended several of Heuermann's court appearances. Ellerup and Victoria were recently interviewed in the new Peacock documentary series The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets. What People Are Saying Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney, questioning Nathaniel Adams on Tuesday: "You've been in school for 10 years and have only obtained a bachelor's degree in all this time? You're supposed to be an expert, but you don't even know who your adviser was or if you graduated summa cum laude or not." Nathaniel Adams, discussing DNA testing in court on Tuesday: "It's unreliable. The software has been updated multiple times since the DNA in this case has been tested." What Happens Next The judge has yet to rule on the permissibility of DNA evidence. A date for Heuermann's trial has not been set yet. The defense has requested that the charges be split into five separate trials. Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@
