Sabrina Carpenter draws criticism with new song and album announcement
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Pop star Sabrina Carpenter has sparked debate online with the release of her new song Manchild and the artwork for her upcoming album Man's Best Friend.
The 26-year-old singer is no stranger to turning heads with her playful lyrics and performances, and Manchild is no exception.
While some fans are praising her signature tongue-in-cheek provocativeness, others say she has crossed a line by using language that they interpret as ableist.
The country-pop tune, which was released Thursday, is a takedown of disappointing men and is widely expected to soar up the charts. Jason Hellerman, a film and TV writer, praised the western-style music video as an "homage to female empowerment cinema." But not all listeners agree.
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 03: Sabrina Carpenter attends the 'Moda Operandi' Pre-Met Gala cocktail party at The Twenty Two Hotel on May 03, 2025 in New York City.
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 03: Sabrina Carpenter attends the 'Moda Operandi' Pre-Met Gala cocktail party at The Twenty Two Hotel on May 03, 2025 in New York City.
Aeon / Contributor/GC Images
The song's pre-chorus includes the line: "Stupid, or is it slow? Maybe it's useless? But there's a cuter word for it, I know," before Carpenter lands the punchline: "Manchild."
That particular lyric has drawn some criticism. Blaire Wilson (@blairewilsonproject), a 33-year-old disability advocate and independent journalist from Ontario, Canada said in a TikTok post that, as an autistic woman, she found the choice of adjectives—particularly "slow"—deeply problematic. She suggested non-ableist alternatives, including "reckless" for "stupid," "complacent" for "slow," and "selfish" for "useless."
Newsweek reached out to Sabrina Carpenter's publicists for comment via email outside if working hours and will update this article if they respond.
"The casual use of the word 'slow' in her new song Manchild is especially concerning to me given its history as an ableist slur against neurodivergent and intellectually disabled people," Wilson told Newsweek. "Language matters, particularly when used by public figures with large platforms. When such terms are repurposed casually or as a joke, even unintentionally, they reinforce harmful stereotypes and contribute to the erasure of marginalized communities."
Wilson connected her concerns to other struggles within the autistic community, including opposition to U.S. health secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s proposed autism database.
"I think artists with significant influence need to consider how their work interacts with ongoing social struggles," she said. "Without that awareness, what may be intended as edgy or playful can unintentionally perpetuate harm and silence those who are already at risk."
She clarified that her suggested word alternatives were not meticulously chosen but meant to demonstrate how easy it is to describe someone acting immature or ridiculous without resorting to harmful language.
Wilson emphasized that as an autistic woman and the mother of a non-speaking autistic son, she sees firsthand the damaging impact words like "slow" can have. She argued that using such language, even ironically, reinforces harmful stereotypes that can have lasting consequences in education, healthcare, employment, and beyond.
Not everyone shared Wilson's point of view.
"Okay wait. I am autistic and I have personally no issue with these words being used, as the terms you provided on the screen are not synonymous with the lyrics," wrote a user named Em in the comments of the video.
"I get what you're saying but that's not what SHES saying. She's literally talking about a grown man that cheated on her," another commenter added.
Presley Cash (@hellomynameispresleycash), a 27-year-old artist from Missouri, also voiced concerns, calling the track "ableist – not feminist" in a TikTok video that garnered over 235,000 views and nearly 5,000 likes.
"The song stopped me in my tracks when I heard her mocking tone as she listed off different digs, the one in particular that made my stomach church was 'slow'," she told Newsweek.
Cash noted she was bullied throughout school for her learning disability.
"Especially followed by the word 'useless' I thought, 'this is 2025 right??' She's using a known slur for the disabled in her 'song of the summer' right now? My immediate thought was how many disabled children that look up to her and admire her are going to hear this song and be crushed that she is using verbiage that has been used against them time after time. To hear their favorite artist singing that slur in a mocking tone—on the radio no less! Hitting number 1 overnight. In my opinion the lyric in particular 'slow' should be taken off the radio," Cash told Newsweek.
Cash's video has comments switched off, but various other TikTokers have posted videos disagreeing with her argument, and pointing to a history of some male artists degrading women in their songs.
In addition to the lyrical critique, Carpenter's artwork for her upcoming album Man's Best Friend has also come under fire. The image, posted to her Instagram Wednesday, shows the singer being dragged across the floor by her hair—a choice some say promotes regressive gender stereotypes.
Kiera Dann (@ddiva444), a 21-year-old student from Brighton, UK, went viral with her commentary on the cover, racking up over 600,000 views.
@ddiva444
What do we think of the new album? I'm excited to hear the music! Just not so keen on the cover #sabrinacarpenter #dating ♬ original sound - Kiera
"I understand that Sabrina's music is often satirical and pokes fun at men's actions towards women, but without knowing her brand, it just paints women as an object used to serve men. If she had flipped the image so she was holding a man by his hair then that would be poking fun at the issue, but this just caters to the male gaze and normalises violence towards women," Dann told Newsweek.
According to the comments section, viewers of the video remain divided over both the song and the visuals. Some disagreed with Dann, interpreting the image as satireical and subversive, or urging viewers to wait to hear the album before forming an opinion.
Carpenter rose to prominence playing the starring role of Maya in the Disney Channel show Girl Meets World from 2014 to 2017. While she has been releasing music for 10 years, she found superstandom with her 2024 album, Short 'n' Sweet, which included the smash hits Espresso and Please, Please, Please.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
3 hours ago
- Newsweek
Woman Finds 1962 Barbie in Thrift Store—Can't Believe The Price Tag
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A Virginia woman was left stunned when she wandered into a thrift store, only to find a 1962 collector's item listed for just $10.99. For Grace Caroline, 29, thrifting has long been an exhilarating hobby, and she's found countless second-hand treasures in the past. But when she and a friend recently traveled further afield to some of the larger thrift stores in northern Virginia, she couldn't believe what she found in the Christmas decorations aisle. To her surprise, Caroline saw a vintage Barbie doll from 1962, still in her original box. It seemed too good to be true, as Caroline told Newsweek that she thought "it had to be a reproduction" at first. But as she looked closer, she realized what an amazing find this was. An original 1962 Barbie that was found in a Virginia thrift store. An original 1962 Barbie that was found in a Virginia thrift store. u/mewisme700 / Reddit "I just thought, there's no way this collector's item was just sitting out," Caroline said. She continued: "She is still in her original box from 1962 and looks mostly untouched. She does have a case of what Barbie collectors call green ear, where the original metal earrings she once wore oxidized into the vinyl of the face. She is missing her hand tag, but still luckily has the original booklet with her, still sealed." Caroline didn't hesitate to buy the Barbie, especially as it cost just $10.99. Indeed, the packaging even has the original sticker with the price on, showing that the doll was once sold for $2. When adjusted for inflation, this equates to around $21 in 2025. Although Caroline isn't a Barbie collector, she is a Pokémon collector and certainly knows the value of an original item. "Once the doll was confirmed not to be a reproduction, I immediately recognized the significance of this Barbie as one of the first releases. I wanted to ensure that it was saved from the thrift to be in the hands of a Barbie collector where it can be cherished and appreciated after 63 years in storage," Caroline told Newsweek. She shared her discovery in a Reddit post (posting as user u/mewisme700), and it's gone viral with over 12,000 votes and 270 comments in a matter of days. Amy McKune, a curator at the National Museum of Toys and Miniatures, believes that it's an amazing find, made even better by the near pristine condition it's been kept in. McKune told Newsweek: "She does appear to be in her original box, wearing her original swimsuit and red sandals. Often the thin strap on the tops of those sandals has split as the plastic has aged. I can't see her ears to know if she still has her original earrings. The pearl earrings often have left an area of green discoloration around the ears." It appears to be a #6 Barbie, introduced in 1962, McKune says. She noted that the #6 model was the first doll to wear the famous red swimsuit, with earlier versions sporting a black and white striped one instead. "Isn't it amazing that after only three years, Mattel had introduced six models? The model number on one end of the box (Model 850) was used for all of the Ponytail Barbie dolls," McKune continued. The box that the 1962 Barbie came in, showing the original $2 price tag. The box that the 1962 Barbie came in, showing the original $2 price tag. u/mewisme700 / Reddit The online reaction has been astonishing to see, as many social media users were just as bewildered as Caroline by her thrifting find. In fact, many didn't even believe that it could be real. Caroline said: "I have a lot of people calling it staged because thrift stores have become very adamant in making sure the good stuff goes behind the counter. But with the sheer amount of daily donations thrift stores get because of our hyper-consumeristic lifestyle, it doesn't surprise me that gems like this do slip past thrift employees." Among the hundreds of comments on the post, many Reddit users were amazed by the iconic vintage Barbie. One comment reads: "That's an impossible find! I'm so jealous!" Another Reddit user wrote: "Amazing find. Never even seen one in the original box!" While another person replied: "This is awesome! Think of all the hands it went through at the thrift store and nobody there thought enough to grab it. Congratulations!" Do you have any amazing thrifting finds that you want to share? We want to see the best ones! Send them in to life@ and they could appear on our site.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Millie Bobby Brown Debuts a Fresh Hair Look in a Sparkly Pink Push-Up Bra
Millie Bobby Brown has seemingly gone back to brown hair. In a new Instagram post, she wore her brunette hair in a low bun along with a sparkly pink bra. Brown has recently sported bleached blonde hair.I'll be perfectly honest, I can't always keep up with Millie Bobby Brown's hair. Remember when she seemingly went through four hair transformations in the space of one month earlier this year? Well, apparently she's still just as playful and experimental as ever. Earlier this week, she was sporting a cute wavy blonde bob. Two weeks ago, she had a brunette bob. Three weeks ago, her hair was long and blonde. Five weeks ago, it was a dark shade of brown. As of June 21, the short brunette hair seems to be back. In her latest post on Instagram, the Stranger Things actress wore her short brunette hair in a side part and a low bun, with a few pieces hanging by her face on one side. She captioned the post simply "oh boy," which I can't help but think is a reference to the opening of Sabrina Carpenter's new single, "Manchild." After all, the actress also posted a video of herself dancing to the song on her Stories around the same time. In the photo, Brown wore a silky pink top with a deep scoop neck, showing off a pink bra with cute lace, sequin, and bow details. She kept the pink theme going with baby pink nails, a pink ring, and a swipe of pink blush. It is, as they say, giving girlhood. Brown, who has posted several recent clips and images on social media with blonde hair, recently spoke about the bleached look on the Call Her Daddy podcast. "People are so shocked about it," she said, adding, "I just think I look really different to what people are usually seeing me as. It's so fun." Read the original article on InStyle
Newsweek
8 hours ago
- Newsweek
Gen Z Woman's Bizarre Pregnancy Craving Goes Viral—It's Cereal With a Twist
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A Gen Z mom to be is raising eyebrows online after sharing her latest pregnancy craving. London-based Lidia Mera (@lidiavmera) told TikTok viewers that it was the time of day where she needed her "current hyper fixation" snack now that she's in her third trimester. "It's a little bit... I wouldn't say weird, but let's just say interesting," Mera said in her clip. The 24-year-old then prepares a bowl of chocolate hazelnut cereal complete with milk and ice cubes and an unexpectedly generous splash of soy sauce. Mera told Newsweek that her pregnancy craving is a sweet and salty snack that "somehow" works perfectly. "The perfect fusion between refreshing ice cold milk, chocolate filled crunchy cereal for the sweetness and then finishing it off with soy sauce to add that salty element into it—the perfect combo," she said. As someone who's always had a sweet tooth, Mera explained that she's started to also crave salty foods since becoming pregnant. "I tried to find a way to incorporate that salty element into a snack I regularly have: a bowl of cereal, and soy sauce just sounded like the perfect solution," she told Newsweek. "The ice cubes came in to make the milk even colder because when you're pregnant anything ice cold is just immediately 10 times better." Mera's clip has been viewed over 228,000 times and asked TikTok users to "rate" her pregnancy craving in the comments. "Sweet and salty is a foolproof combo so I'm not entirely surprised that this works but damn that soy sauce came out of nowhere," one user wrote. "I have soy sauce on basically everything so I get it," another user added. "Soy sauce and milk? Hell nah," a third wrote. Dr. Shyamala Vishnumohan, an accredited practicing dietitian with a special interest in fertility and pregnancy nutrition, told Newsweek that there's a reason behind pregnancy cravings. "I've seen women crave everything from raw mango with salt to tamarind, amla or even green chilli," she said. "From a scientific standpoint, they're partly driven by hormonal shifts and partly by nutrient needs." Vishnumohan also pointed to research that shows up to 90 percent of women experience cravings during pregnancy, with most occurring during the first and second trimesters. "I also believe pregnant mothers carry this intuitive body wisdom—gently nudging them toward what they need," she said. "It's a beautiful mystery." As for other cravings, Mera said she's been all about "red meat, fries, ice cream—and even better when you pair it or dip it in soy sauce." The expectant mom told Newsweek her pregnancy craving elicited a mix of opinions. "Some people saying it's absolutely horrifying and some people agreeing that this could actually be a good combo, but not sure if anyone is actually keen enough to give it a go," she said.
