Singapore casts tax shadow on India bets, shuns shell companies
Mumbai: Singapore is intensifying scrutiny of companies and investment entities, a move that could ignite new tax disputes. This development particularly impacts many MNCs and international funds that use the Asian financial hub as a base to invest in and acquire companies in India.
The catalyst for these potential disputes is a recent series of advance rulings by the
Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore
(IRAS), which define and endorse what constitutes '
economic substance
'. If a Singaporean entity fails to meet the conditions emphasized by the tax administrator and thus cannot prove it has adequate 'substance,' the Indian Income Tax (I-T) department could levy higher taxes. This could involve claiming tax on certain stock sale transactions or demanding increased tax on earnings from dividends and loan interest paid by an Indian company. Dealmakers and businesses are closely monitoring this situation.
"These advance rulings are the first to evaluate economic substance factors since their inclusion in 2024 as Section 10L of Singapore's Income Tax Act for taxing gains from the sale of foreign assets. These factors could be used by Indian tax authorities to determine whether a Singapore-based entity is merely a conduit, particularly when applying the
Principal Purpose Test
(PPT)," explained Ashish Karundia of the CA firm Ashish Karundia & Co. (A PPT is a provision that allows denial of treaty benefits).
According to Girish Vanvari, founder of the tax and regulatory advisory firm Transaction Square, the implications are far-reaching due to the change in law prioritizing substance and economic reality over legal form. "For tax professionals and business leaders, this means a necessary recalibration of how Singapore is used in cross-border structuring -especially in relation to Indian operations. So, if you're using Singapore as a holding or IP base for India-related investments, it's time to revisit the structure. The days of relying purely on treaty protection without operational presence are over," said Vanvari.
Many foreign investors betting on India utilize Singapore to leverage the tax treaty between the two countries. A common structure involves one of their arms in a tax-friendly jurisdiction setting up a company in Singapore (say, S1), which in turn owns another company in Singapore (say, S2). In this two-layered structure, S2 serves as a vehicle to invest in India. Typically, when exiting an Indian investment, S1 might sell the shares of S2, which holds shares in an Indian company; alternatively, S2 would directly sell its interest in the Indian company.
THE PARAMETERS
The IRAS underscored that economic substance would require: (a) a company to have adequate human resources with the necessary qualifications and experience; (b) have a premise in Singapore; (c) take key business decisions there; and (d) incurs expenditure.
If S1 or S2 does not fulfil these criteria, they would come under the lens of the tax authorities in either Singapore or India. How? Here are the possible situations:
· Say, S1 sells shares of S2 (both local entities) and if India demands tax on the 'indirect transfer' by invoking India's domestic tax regulations, companies like S1 have till now argued that under the treaty India has no right to tax gains from indirect transfers. However, in future, the I-T department could assert that the treaty holds only if S1 has substance. But if it doesn't (as per Singapore's terms), S1 cannot avail treaty benefits and must pay tax to India. Here, I-T would challenge that S1 was formed primarily to escape tax.
· If S2 directly sells shares of the Indian company, there's no capital gains tax if the shares were bought before 2017 (under a grandfathering provision introduced when the treaty was amended). However, if S2 lacks substance, I-T may demand tax on the grounds that treaty relief can be denied to a shell outfit.
· Suppose, S1 sells stocks it directly holds of another company in a third country. S1 can avoid tax in Singapore if it can demonstrate substance. However, if S1 fails the substance test (and is taxed by Singapore), then India would also have strong grounds to demand tax from S1 when it sells shares of S2.
· Also, there's an increased risk of double taxation - with India taxing based on source and Singapore taxing based on substance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
26 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Indian rupee, bonds under pressure as US strike on Iran deepens Middle East conflict
The Indian rupee and government bonds are poised to face pressure this week following a U.S. strike on Iran, raising concerns of higher oil prices and potential retaliation that could deepen the conflict in the Middle East. ADVERTISEMENT The rupee had closed at 86.5850 against the U.S. dollar on Friday, down 0.6% on the week. U.S. President Donald Trump said late on Saturday that the country had struck Iran's main nuclear sites, aligning with an Israeli offensive in a significant escalation of the ongoing Middle East tensions. Tehran called the attack a grave violation of international law and vowed to defend itself. In a televised address, Trump warned Iran against retaliating, stating that any response would trigger further attacks unless Iran agreed to pursue peace. Concerns over a potential escalation of the conflict had already driven oil prices higher this month, and analysts now anticipate an additional increase of $3 to $5 per barrel in reaction to the U.S. strikes. ADVERTISEMENT Brent crude oil futures closed at $77 per barrel on Friday, up nearly 4% on week. Elevated energy prices are a pain point for the Indian rupee and government bonds, as oil is a major component of India's import bill. ADVERTISEMENT A "flight to safety is likely to reinforce the dollar's strength against the Indian rupee and other major currencies," said Dilip Parmar, a foreign exchange research analyst at HDFC Securities. The rupee could weaken towards 87.50 in the near-term, Parmar added. Traders reckon that the Reserve Bank of India would likely step in to curb excessive volatility. ADVERTISEMENT The rupee may find immediate support around 87.50-87.60 but will remain acutely sensitive to developments in the Middle East, said a trader at a state-run bank. Foreign portfolio flows related to a upcoming large IPO alongside remarks from U.S. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, scheduled for Tuesday, will be among other cues in focus for the rupee this week. ADVERTISEMENT Meanwhile, India's 10-year benchmark 6.33% 2035 bond yield ended at 6.3087% on Friday. Traders expect it to move in a range of 6.30% to 6.40% this week. "A $10 per barrel rise in crude could widen India's current account deficit by 0.3% of GDP and elevate inflation, eroding real yields," CR Forex said. Earlier this month, the RBI reduced its inflation forecast for the current fiscal year to 3.7% and cut its key lending rate by a steeper-than-expected 50 basis points. A big rate cut would assure stakeholders of India's focus on economic growth and aid in faster transmission, members of rate setting panel wrote in the June policy minutes. However, it reverted to a "neutral" stance from "accommodative", prompting analysts to forecast an end to the monetary easing cycle. "International uncertainties make RBI think it is necessary to front load the monetary easing to boost growth. But RBI may take longer to see the impact before implementing another cut going forward. Looking forward, we see RBI to stay on hold for next few months, said Alaa Bushehri, head of emerging market Debt, BNP Paribas Asset Management. KEY EVENTS: ** June HSBC India manufacturing, services and composite Flash PMI - June 23, Monday (10:30 a.m. IST) U.S. ** June S&P Global manufacturing, services and composite Flash PMI - June 23, Monday (7:15 p.m. IST) ** May existing home sales - June 23, Monday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** June consumer confidence - June 24, Tuesday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** May new home sales units - June 25, Wednesday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** May durable goods - June 26, Thursday (7:30 p.m. IST) ** January-March GDP final - June 26, Thursday (6:00 p.m. IST)(Reuters poll -0.2%) ** Initial weekly jobless claims for week to June 16 - June 26, Thursday (6:00 p.m. IST) ** May personal consumption expenditure index, core PCE index - June 27, Friday (6:00 p.m. IST) ** June U Mich sentiment final - June 27, Friday (7:30 p.m. IST)
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Rs 1 lakh crore FII selloff in 6 sectors! Are you still holding the wrong stocks?
Live Events Valuations at Tipping Point Earnings Under Pressure Where the Smart Money Is Moving Bottom Line: What Should Investors Do? (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) have gone on a selling spree, offloading nearly Rs 1 lakh crore worth of Indian equities in just six months across six key sectors of consumer durables FMCG , and IT . The sharp pullback, concentrated in segments once considered defensives or structural bets, underscores rising concerns around valuations, global macro uncertainty, and a shifting earnings biggest casualty is the IT sector, which alone has seen Rs 33,479 crore in net FII outflows, or a third of total selling. This is followed by FMCG (Rs 17,819 crore), auto (Rs 16,058 crore), consumer services (Rs 14,417 crore), power (Rs 12,231 crore), and consumer durables (Rs 11,296 crore).'We continue to maintain our underweight stance in the IT sector, as we foresee a slowdown in overall IT spending in the US market and a probable delay in discretionary spending,' said Neeraj Chadawar, Head of Fundamental and Quantitative Research at Axis Securities. 'Guidance and commentary remain critical for the sector going forward.'The broad-based nature of the selling suggests a structural de-risking rather than just profit-taking. Even construction (-Rs 9,322 crore) and healthcare (-Rs 9,048 crore) have witnessed sharp outflows. In contrast, only a handful of sectors have seen net FII inflows, including telecom (Rs 23,065 crore) and financials (Rs 9,456 crore).Despite the bounce-back in domestic equities since April, foreign investors remain wary. FIIs were net sellers in four of the six months this year, including massive outflows of Rs 78,027 crore in January and Rs 34,574 crore in February. Even June, so far, has seen a net selloff of Rs 5,404 crore (till June 15).'Export-facing sectors will be in a wait-and-watch mode… domestic-facing sectors will likely lead from here,' Chadawar added, highlighting the impact of reciprocal tax measures and global macro retreat comes amid a strong equity rally that has made valuations appear frothy, particularly in mid- and small-cap segments. According to Jefferies' Chris Wood, the Nifty Midcap 100 Index now trades at 27.1x forward earnings, even as the Nifty itself is at 22.2x—well above its historical median.'Valuations have become an issue again, particularly in the mid-cap space,' Wood wrote in his GREED & fear report. 'The equivalent of $7.2 billion of equity supply was raised last month and $6 billion so far in June. It is this supply which poses the main risk to the market.'Wood noted that domestic flows and sentiment remain strong, especially in consumer finance stocks. However, FII positioning indicates growing concern about over-valuation and saturation in parts of the valuation, earnings downgrades and growth moderation are another red flag. HSBC, in its Q4 review, flagged weak topline performance in consumer staples and slowing credit growth in banks.'Demand for consumer staples was subdued, while competitive intensity remains high… Growth for banks moderated to a single-digit rate amid margin pressures,' the HSBC note said, adding that 'a sustained recovery in earnings growth is still a few quarters away.'The IT sector, despite posting 6% net income growth, continues to suffer from poor visibility in US demand, weak discretionary spend, and macro uncertainty in export markets. This aligns with Chadawar's view that export-oriented sectors remain underweight, pending clarity on reciprocal trade not all foreign investors are pulling back entirely—they're simply rotating. FIIs have made significant investments in telecom (Rs 23,065 crore) and to a lesser extent in financials (Rs 9,456 crore), services (Rs 7,351 crore), and chemicals (Rs 4,863 crore).'From a long-term valuation and earnings visibility perspective, our portfolio is currently tilted towards cyclicals,' said Chirag Mehta, CIO, Quantum AMC. 'We believe the global macro challenges do not derail India's domestic cyclical recovery. Sectors like banking, consumer discretionary, materials, and utilities appear attractive.'While Mehta remains cautious on IT, he believes continued correction could create long-term entry opportunities, especially in high-quality names with consistent earnings Jefferies' GREED & fear India portfolio is shifting gears. Positions in L&T, Thermax, and Godrej Properties are being exited, replaced with TVS Motor, Home First Finance, and Manappuram Finance. Additional exposure is also being added to PolicyBazaar and Bharti Airtel, signaling a shift to consumption- and credit-focused domestic flows remain robust, the intensity and concentration of FII selling, especially in IT, FMCG, and auto, should not be ignored. With nearly ₹1 lakh crore of outflows in six months, the foreign money is clearly betting on earnings downgrades, valuation fatigue, and a global demand slowdown.'We seek out quality, high-integrity businesses at reasonable valuations… Our value-conscious approach often leads us to sectors that may be out of favour but possess strong fundamentals,' Mehta investors navigating this turbulent landscape, the data suggests a clear bifurcation: domestic-oriented sectors like telecom and financials are attracting foreign capital, while export-dependent sectors face sustained selling pressure. The challenge lies in timing entry points as valuations remain elevated despite the sectoral rotation.(Data: Ritesh Presswala): Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Nuvoco Vistas makes Rs 1,800 crore payment to complete Vadraj cement acquisition
Nirma Group's Nuvoco Vistas Corp has completed its acquisition of debt-ridden Vadraj Cement by making a payment of Rs 1800 crore to lenders, led by Punjab National Bank and Union Bank of India. This acquisition will boost Nuvoco Vistas' installed cement capacity by over 20%, reaching around 31 MTPA, marking its third acquisition after Lafarge Cement and Emami Cement. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Popular in Ind'l Goods/Svs 1. India Cements to sell its subsidiary Industrial Chemicals Nirma Group's Nuvoco Vistas Corp has made the Rs 1800 crore payment to lenders led by Punjab National Bank (PNB) and Union Bank of India completing its acquisition of the debt-ridden Vadraj Cement . The money was paid to lenders on Saturday, allowing them to write back their provisions this quarter, two people aware of the details said."The money came to lenders on Saturday and has been distributed. There were some delays due to some litigation but now that everything is settled, the company transferred the money well ahead of the June 24 deadline," said one of the persons cited with 25% of the more than Rs 8000 crore debt stands to gain Rs 431 crore, while Union Bank will get Rs 345 crore, calculations by ET acquisition will help Nuvoco Vistas boost its installed cement capacity by over 20% reaching around 31 MTPA and is the company's third acquisition after Lafarge Cement and Emami Cement. A Mumbai bench of the NCLT had approved the acquisition in Vadraj Cement, formerly owned by ABG Shipyard, has a 6 million tonne grinding unit in Surat and will add to Nuvoco Vistas' existing production capacity of 25 million tonne by more than 20%.The acquisition was undertaken through Vanya Corp, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Nuvoco Vistas. Subsequently, Vanya will be merged with Vadraj Cement, according to the resolution plan. Vadraj Cement will ultimately become the wholly-owned subsidiary of the Rs 1,800 crore offer outbid Adani Group at an auction under the court-monitored corporate insolvency, ET had reported in January this year. Adani group-backed Ambuja Cement had partnered with Prudent ARC-backed RKG Fund to acquire the Gujarat-based cement the Rs 1,800 crore offered by Nuvoco Vistas, Rs 1,725 crore will be used for repaying financial creditors' dues, and the balance is set aside for operational credit, dues to employees, an insolvency resolution process costs.
