Trump's Maga base divided on use of military might against Iran
'Anyone slobbering for the US to become fully involved in the Israel/Iran war is not America First/Maga ... We are sick and tired of foreign wars.'
Those are the words of congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene – normally regarded as one of
Donald Trum
p's most loyal followers. They highlight the deep split that has emerged inside the Maga movement as the US president warms to the idea of using America's military might against
Iran
.
For many of Trump's most ardent supporters that would be a deep betrayal. One of his most consistent campaign themes was his condemnation of 'forever wars'. In one typical outburst in 2019, he proclaimed: 'Going into the Middle East is the worst decision ever made.'
Many of the politicians and pundits who are most strongly associated with the Maga movement have now come out explicitly against deeper US involvement in the war on Iran. The critics include
Tucker Carlson
,
Steve Bannon
and former congressman
Matt Gaetz
. Carlson has used his newsletter to urge: 'Drop Israel. Let them fight their own wars', adding: 'What happens next will define Donald Trump's presidency.'
READ MORE
There are also signs that the anti-war right is linking up with the anti-war left. When Thomas Massie, a conservative Republican congressman, filed a House resolution seeking to block US involvement in the war this week, he swiftly got a host of co-sponsors from the Democratic left, including congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
Trump himself has already jabbed back at his critics from within the Maga movement, calling Carlson 'kooky' on social media. Meanwhile, supporters of America's traditional role as world policeman (sometimes referred to as neoconservatives) within the Republican party have rallied to back Trump's increasingly bellicose line on Iran. The supporters include senators Lindsey Graham and Mitch McConnell.
The split within Trump's base extends to the right-wing media scene. Greene has condemned Fox News and the New York Post for cheerleading for the war. Carlson, meanwhile, has used his own media platform to go after the neoconservatives – conducting a notably aggressive interview with Ted Cruz, in which he accused the Texas Republican senator of cheerleading for a war against a country that he knew nothing about.
Vice-president JD Vance is known to have been sceptical about the case for war with Iran for many months. Buckley Carlson, Tucker's son, is his deputy press secretary.
But Vance is now trying to act as peacemaker between the clashing factions within the Maga movement. In a post on X, he pleaded that Trump 'has earned some trust on this issue'. He also tried to reassure uneasy Maga supporters that the president is 'only interested in using the American military to accomplish the American people's goals'.
An Economist/YouGov poll taken a few days ago suggested that 53 per cent of Trump supporters opposed the US joining the war, with just 19 per cent supporting involvement. That could change, if and when American planes start flying sorties over Iran. The early days of a war often create a 'rally round the flag' effect.
But if the war goes wrong, there will be bitter recriminations. Iran could be the issue that breaks the Maga movement.
– Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Irish embassy in Tehran closed due to ‘deteriorating situation'
The Irish embassy in Tehran, Iran has been temporarily closed with staff being relocated to Ireland amid a 'deteriorating situation'. Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris said he had become 'increasingly concerned' about environment in which the embassy was functioning and the ability of diplomatic staff to work safely. 'It is in light of the deteriorating situation, following consultation with my officials and in very close consultation and co-ordination with EU partners, I have now decided to temporarily relocate our personnel from Tehran,' he said. Mr Harris said the relocation of staff was 'not a decision that I have taken lightly.' READ MORE 'Arrangements have been made for the embassy to continue its operations from our Dublin headquarters. Staff at my department's headquarters have now assumed the embassy's consular functions, and they remain in contact with the small number of Irish citizens remaining in Iran,' he said. The arrangements will continue until it is possible and safe for personnel to return to Iran, he said, and thanked ambassador to Iran, Laoise Moore and her staff for operating under 'very, very challenging circumstances.' Mr Harris reiterated advice that Irish citizens should not to travel to Iran or Israel. 'Citizens who live there and who wish to leave might consider departing through one of the land borders that is open as long as it is safe to do so,' he said. Mr Harris said he will continue to monitor the situation in the region and will be engaging with EU counterparts. 'My hope is that a diplomatic solution can be found to resolve this very dangerous conflict without further escalation or further loss of life in Iran or Israel,' he added.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Indications' Israel breached human rights obligations during Gaza war, EU review finds
A review by European Union officials has said there are 'indications' that Israel 's actions during the war in Gaza breached commitments to uphold human rights. The finding raises the prospect of the EU taking action against Israel for the first time since the start of the conflict. The review, a portion of which has been seen by The Irish Times, finds Israel's actions during its 20-month bombardment and invasion of Gaza constituted a failure to respect human rights. Focus will now likely turn to potential consequences for Israel, which EU states have to date been unable to find common ground on. READ MORE [ Israeli fire kills at least 44 Palestinians in Gaza Opens in new window ] The review examined whether Israel's actions in the Palestinian enclave had broken guarantees made about upholding human rights as part of the EU's 'association agreement' with Israel. The agreement governs relations between the two sides and includes a free trade deal, access to research funding and enhanced political dialogue. A majority of EU states last month supported a review taking place to determine whether Israel's military campaign in Gaza had broken human rights commitments signed up to as part of the agreement. The review was carried out by officials from the EU diplomatic corps, which is led by foreign affairs chief Kaja Kallas. It was shared with diplomats from EU states on Friday evening. It concluded: 'On the basis of the assessments made by the independent international institutions ... There are indications that Israel would be in breach of its human rights obligations under Article 2 of the EU-Israel association agreement'. The findings will be debated at a meeting of EU foreign affairs ministers in Brussels on Monday. Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris is expected to advocate for the EU to use what leverage it has, to put pressure on Israel to allow humanitarian aid into Gaza. It is expected ministers will ask Ms Kallas to come back to a further meeting next month, with a set of proposed actions the EU could take against Israel, such as possibly suspending parts of the EU-Israel association deal. A group of nine states, including Ireland, Spain, Belgium and Poland, have suggested the EU needs to do more to cut off trade with illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank and other occupied Palestinian territories. More than 55,000 Palestinians have been killed during Israel's military campaign in Gaza, which began after Hamas militants who control the enclave attacked southern Israel on October 7th, 2023. The governments of Ireland and Spain first called for a review of the EU-Israel deal in February of last year, but received little backing at the time. The worsening humanitarian situation in Gaza, exacerbated by Israel's recent blockade preventing food and aid getting into the territory for several weeks, saw growing support within the EU to exert political pressure on Israel to change course. It is understood the Israeli government has been lobbying EU states intensely behind the scenes through diplomatic and high-level political channels to push back on those efforts. Some of Israel's staunchest allies – Germany, Hungary and Czechia – had opposed the review taking place, as did the governments of Italy and Greece. 'We want to, through this process, up the pressure on Israel to change what they are doing,' a diplomat from one EU state said of the review. 'We want a broad agreement as possible on the outcome of the review.'
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Another week, another war: Trump pivots from America first to talk of a bunker buster
Story of the Week Another week. Another war. The prospect of carnage and thousands of deaths. Worrying questions about its impact on the region and beyond, the impacts on global stability. Israel 's launch of a war against Iran was not defensive or triggered by any attack. Rather it is a war of choice. Its stated aims at the start – eliminating Iran's nuclear threat – quickly pivoted into something else , regime change, or, more accurately, regime destruction. True to his make-it-up-as-you-go-along presidency, Donald Trump had pivoted within a day from his strict America first non-interventionist stance on international wars (a strong position with his MAGA base) to cheerleading the Israelis and threatening to deploy the only piece of arsenal the Israel Defense Forces do not have. That is, the 14-tonne so-called bunker-buster bomb which just might be able to penetrate into Fordo, the mountain where the Iranian regime has its main underground nuclear enrichment facility. [ Netanyahu's ruling party gets popularity boost in wake of Iran conflict Opens in new window ] True to form, Trump tells the whole of Tehran (population 10 million) to evacuate. Which, by all reports, most citizens have done. Meanwhile the Israelis and Iranians continue to pound each other. READ MORE The move has drawn attention away from Israel's continuing onslaught against the population of Gaza . The statement of the G7 was read by some as troubling as it seemed to give almost unconditional support for what Israel had done. Of course, a war between Israel and Iran is a different proposition than its siege of Gaza, as the Iranian regime is unsavoury by any yardstick. It seems that Israel's move to being an international pariah – even in the eyes of erstwhile supporters – has been modified, with some ambivalence expressed. Make no mistake it will employ the same ruthlessness and indifference to civilian casualties as it has done in Gaza and elsewhere. There is a long and sad history of intervention by big global powers in this region, where regime-change unfortunately leads to a new regime that is in some cases worse than the henchmen they replaced. Meanwhile Ireland continues to work to try to assist the few hundred citizens still in Iran and Israel. The Tánaiste has spoken to foreign affairs ministers in the region but, in truth, there is little our State can do bring influence to bear. Bust-up Row of this week. And every week. When you meet all the leaders outside the chamber they are all so civil. But there's something about the cauldron of the Dáil chamber that brings out the raspiness in Micheál Martin , Mary Lou McDonald , Simon Harris and Pearse Doherty . No matter what the issue it descends within seconds into a dogfight. If you want a perfect summary of what happened this week there no better place to start than these two (verbal) blow-by-blow accounts Miriam Lord. The first is here and the second is here . All very well but does it affect me? The story was almost missed given everything else that was happening this week but it was a significant moment in recent Irish political and financial history. AIB bought the very last part of its shareholdings back from the State making it a fully independent entity once more. After the financial crash, the State took shares in our two biggest pillar banks, Bank of Ireland and AIB, in order to make sure they survived. Bank of Ireland, which was less exposed to the property crash, came out of State ownership relatively quickly but it has been a long and slow process for AIB, taking almost a decade and a half. But the moment finally arrived this week. And Joe Brennan has a wonderful account of it , including that enticing line that at one stage the bank's art collection was worth more than the bank. Banana Skin When you go on a solo run as a Minister, just make sure the ball does not slip form your grasp. Minister for Arts and Media Patrick O'Donovan found out all about that this week, when he got a slap on the wrist from the bean counters in the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform (DPER). In recent months, O'Donovan brought two memos to Cabinet, 'under his arm', without informing DPER first. The memos related to the Arts Council 's half-abandoned ICT project as well as a plan to spend €10 million bringing an American football NFL game to Croke Park later this year. As Ellen Coyne reports , a senior DPER official said this practice 'makes it very difficult for this department, and indeed for Government generally, to thoroughly and properly consider issues and their implications, particularly regarding substantial expenditure implications and serious governance issues'. O'Donovan's spokespeople said there were time pressures involved which required him to bring both matters to Cabinet at short notice. He would not want to make a habit of it, as far as DPER is concerned. Winners and losers Winner: Colin Hunt, AIB's chief executive and former special adviser ministers for Finance. This week, the bank bought back the last of the shares held by the State since the banking collapse in 2010. Loser: Children's Hospital Ireland, which faced a grilling and dressing-down for its many failings at the Oireachtas Committee on Health. The Big Read Jack Horgan-Jones is on political column duty this week. Miriam Lord's Saturday column is a must-read. Martin Wall and Jack also have a big piece looking at the CHI in crisis. Hear here Sally Hayden joins Inside Politics on Friday from Beirut where missiles flying overhead have become a fact of daily life despite the ceasefire agreement Lebanon signed with Israel last November. The rising death toll and continuing aerial attacks from Iran and Israel show no signs of abating. And is the US on the verge of joining Israel's attack on Iran? Meanwhile, Children's Health Ireland appeared before the Oireachtas Health Committee this week with politicians eager to tear strips off the embattled group responsible for running children's hospital services in Dublin . Could the Israel-Iran war completely destabilise the Middle East? Listen | 49:01
