Fine for blogger who claimed in video that Josephine Teo made offensive remarks against Malays
SINGAPORE: A blogger posted a video on TikTok claiming that Minister for Digital Development and Information Josephine Teo had made offensive remarks against Malays.
Manmeet Singh Bahadar Singh did so after he received a link from an unknown person to a WordPress blog with the alleged offensive content.
Singh, 57, then posted a commentary about the content without verifying its authenticity. He removed it once he realised that he had been "led on" by the unknown person, his lawyers S S Dhillon and Jasjeet Singh Harjindar Singh told the court.
Singh was fined S$6,000 (US$4,700) on Friday (Jun 6) after he pleaded guilty to one charge of knowingly committing an act which promoted disharmony between different racial groups.
Singh is a blogger who posts about socio-political issues on TikTok, among other social media platforms. He has been previously featured in the media as former presidential candidate Tan Kin Lian's bodyguard.
HOW THE OFFENCE HAPPENED
Before he posted the offending content on TikTok on Aug 12, 2024, he received a link to a WordPress blog post via WhatsApp from an unknown person.
The blog post alleged that Mrs Teo, when asked about racial progress during an interview with Chinese media on Singapore's 59-year development, had made an offensive remark against Malays.
Singh felt angry and offended.
On the morning of Aug 12, 2024, he posted a video on his TikTok account with a visible representation bearing the words "Minister Josephine Teo blurted 'Malays are i*****' in a Chinese interview".
He then repeated the blog post's allegations. Singh did not verify the authenticity of the claims on the blog post before making his video.
In the video, Singh repeats the allegations and tells viewers to "go look it up".
He then adds, "I have been voicing out for, you know, against racial discrimination in Singapore. And look what happened now? My prediction's right!"
He finishes the video with the phrase "bring them down", according to court documents.
At the time of the offences, Singh's TikTok account had around 9,054 followers. The video was available long enough for Mrs Teo's colleagues and a reporter to ask the minister about it.
Around four hours after the video was published, Mrs Teo told her press secretary about it. The press secretary then downloaded a copy of the video and lodged a police report.
Later that day, Singh suspected the allegations were false and removed the TikTok video by 1.40pm.
He then posted another video in which he apologised to Mrs Teo, noting that his previous allegation was probably false. By 3pm, however, TikTok removed this video.
Subsequently, Mrs Teo posted on social media platforms to state that the allegations were false.
The blog post that sparked the offences was not available as of 6.30pm on Aug 12, 2024.
Singh was arrested on Feb 4, 2025 and released on bail the next day.
In mitigation, Mr Dhillon told the court the circumstances under which his client had been "led on" by the unknown person who sent him the blog post.
Singh was on his way to work as a warehouse assistant when this person texted him and included the link to the offensive blog post. This person then encouraged Singh to do "what you need to do", said Mr Dhillon.
"At the time, Manmeet had just alighted from his bus and was walking to his then-workplace, which was about a 10-minute walk from the bus stop.
"Manmeet felt angry and offended and elected to take a snapshot of the blog post on his phone and proceeded to record a video of himself commenting on the alleged statement on his phone whilst walking," Mr Dhillon and Mr Singh said.
Singh then went about his work. As he was working, he started having second thoughts about his post, as he had a growing suspicion that its contents were fake.
However, as Singh's work involved sensitive information, he did not have access to his phone until lunch.
"To his surprise and shock, he realised that the unknown person who had sent him the WhatsApp message that morning had deleted his account as well as the said message," the defence lawyers said.
"This confirmed Manmeet's suspicions that he had been falsely led on."
Singh immediately removed his video and published an apology video on his TikTok account. Unbeknownst to him, TikTok removed this video by 3pm.
He subsequently posted a second video to apologise.
The defence lawyers said that Singh was "racked with guilt" over his actions.
"Manmeet is not in the business of making his videos for profit or clout. His content is akin to an extension of himself and his views, which he shares because he feels responsible to raise awareness," said the lawyers.
Singh has since "deliberately steered clear of associating with other politicians to avoid controversy", the lawyers said. He also actively vets his news sources.
The defence asked for a S$2,000 fine for Singh.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
Friendship knows no bounds? Sharing memes to stay in touch can only go so far when your friend lives overseas
Gift-giving need not occur only on significant occasions. Ms Zhai-McCartney said: 'I'm super old school – it feels really good to receive a physical piece of snail mail; a birthday card, a handwritten letter or a postcard from your travels is such a nice surprise in the era of convenience.' That said, Ms Tan pointed out that passively following your friend's social media feed does not qualify as staying connected. 'It tends to be a superficial exchange of information without full understanding of what the person may be going through,' she said. WHEN LETTING GO IS HEALTHIER Not every friendship, including long-distance ones, will last forever. As life goes on, people's priorities, needs and values change. If the relationship begins to feel one‑sided, or no longer reflects who both of you are, it may be time to let go. Ms Tan recommended working through a few self‑reflective points before making that decision: How do you feel when you think about this friendship? Does it lift you up or weigh you down? Have you genuinely tried to maintain it and what obstacles keep cropping up? Could extending the intervals between contact ease the pressure, or is it time to allow the friendship to rest? These guidelines can help with discerning if it is time to let the friendship go. Mr Spitalen said: 'Accepting this is part of growing up. Recognising that you have not done anything wrong will help you process it without guilt. You can still honour what the friendship meant without forcing it to remain the same.' IT'S RARELY TOO LATE TO RECONNECT If you miss someone, reaching out even after a long silence can rekindle old bonds. It can be easy to overthink, to want to avoid troubling others, but Ms Zhai‑McCartney has this reminder: 'It's almost never too late. We tend to assume people don't want to hear from us or we've offended someone, but what do you have to lose by being the one to break the ice?' Mr Spitalen agreed that there is no need for a grand gesture. 'A simple message like 'I was thinking about you, how are you doing?' or bringing up an old inside joke can open the door.' From her experience, Ms Foo who moved to Hong Kong found the above advice to be true. 'I feel that I can almost always pick up right where we left off. We always find ways to get back to each other in unexpected ways. 'The platonic love doesn't fade; it just takes a different shape.'
CNA
3 hours ago
- CNA
Thai PM Paetongtarn will not resign or dissolve parliament, ruling party official says
BANGKOK: Thailand's embattled prime minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra will not resign or dissolve parliament, a senior official from the ruling Pheu Thai party said on Saturday (Jun 21), risking a prolonged political crisis in Southeast Asia's second-largest economy. Sorawong Thienthong, who also serves as Thailand's tourism minister, said in a Facebook post that the prime minister would not quit, despite growing calls for her resignation after her apparent mishandling of a border dispute with neighbouring Cambodia. "The prime minister has clearly confirmed to us that she will continue to perform her duty to resolve various crises that the country is facing to the best of her ability," he said.
CNA
4 hours ago
- CNA
Certis auxiliary police officer, 47, dies after collapsing during NDP rehearsal at Padang
SINGAPORE: A 47-year-old Certis auxiliary police officer has died after collapsing during a National Day Parade (NDP) rehearsal at the Padang on Saturday (Jun 21). The man, was part of the OneChangi contingent for the Parade and Ceremony segment. He collapsed at 11.23am at the end of a component rehearsal, the Ministry of Defence (MINDEF) and Changi Airport Group (CAG) said in a joint media release. "He was immediately evacuated to the on-site medical post and arrived at 11.26am, where he was attended by the duty medical officer. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation was administered immediately," they added. The man remained unresponsive and was transferred to a standby Singapore Armed Forces ambulance at 11.42am. "Resuscitation efforts continued en route to hospital", said MINDEF and CAG. He arrived at Singapore General Hospital at 11.57am and was pronounced dead at 12.19pm. Certis confirmed in a statement that the man was one of its employees. CNA understands that he worked at Changi Airport. "We are currently working closely with MINDEF and Changi Airport Group to further provide the officer's family with the necessary support and assistance," Certis spokesperson Robin Goh said in response to CNA's queries. "Our thoughts and heartfelt condolences are with the officer's family and loved ones during this difficult time." The OneChangi contingent is made up of nine companies, including Certis and CAG. It is among the 18 civilian contingents participating in the NDP, which will be held on Aug 9 to mark Singapore's 60th birthday.
