Europe leads global defence spending rise, awakening to security deficit
Europe led a record international rise in defence spending last year, according to a report from the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI).
European expenses rose in real terms by 17 percent to $693m, spearheading a global rise of 9.4 percent to $2.7 trillion, marking the highest level of defence spending since the fall of communism in Europe.
Russia's war in Ukraine was the principal driver of the new trend, SIPRI said on Monday.
'The rapid spending increases among European NATO members were driven mainly by the ongoing Russian threat and concerns about possible US disengagement within the alliance,' said Jade Guiberteau Ricard, a researcher with SIPRI.
The protagonists in that war still bore the brunt of its expense.
Russia saw the biggest annual rise of any single country at 38 percent, as it suffered devastating material losses in its war in Ukraine. It spent $149bn, more than 7 percent of its economic output.
Ukraine spent its entire tax income of $64.7bn on its defence, and was the country devoting the biggest proportion of its economy – 34 percent – to the military.
But apparent US reluctance to continue to fund Ukraine's defence means more of the burden may fall on Europe.
That might not be as onerous as it sounds. The size of the European Union economy meant that it needed to spend only 0.12 percent more of its gross domestic product (GDP) to replace US military support for Ukraine, the think tank Bruegel estimated last February.
Most of Europe's defence spending increase, experts told Al Jazeera, addressed the need to rebuild defunct European militaries.
'The increase was expected, though it was still somewhat shocking to see it unfold,' retired US colonel Seth Krummrich said, as it reflected the end of US supremacy on the global stage.
Krummrich, who is now vice president of Global Guardian, a security consultant, believed this was the start of a new trend.
'I do believe we will see further increases in the years ahead. Europe recognises the need to stand on its own and not rely as heavily on the United States,' he said. 'That's not to say the US will not support Europe, but the 'guaranteed certainty' of US support is no longer felt.'
The EU last month relaxed deficit rules, allowing national budgets to spend an additional 650 billion euros ($740bn) on defence off the books.
Greece became the first member to announce a multiyear rearmament under the new rules on April 3.
Within Europe, Germany rose most steeply of all (by 28 percent), as an extraordinary 100-billion-euro ($113.5bn) fund announced in 2022 finally swung into action. However, every EU member state except Malta raised its defence budget, reflecting an increasingly widespread Russian threat perception.
The relaxed EU deficit rules, known as Rearm Europe, along with a 150-billion-euro ($170bn) fund to boost EU defence products and a German parliament decision last month to devote up to 1 trillion euros ($1.14 trillion) to infrastructure and defence all advocated in favour of what Krummrich predicted.
Experts cautioned that expenditure would take a long time to translate into force projection.
'Major military capability takes years to develop,' said Lukas Milevski, a lecturer in international studies at Leiden University. 'It takes time to train people, to buy the stuff, to build the stuff, to deliver the stuff,' he told Al Jazeera.
Germany, for example, promised Lithuania a brigade in 2022. Its barracks are built in southwest Lithuania, but the brigade is not expected to be manned, trained, equipped and operational until the end of 2027.
Milevski also cautioned that the money would have to be sustained over many years. 'By the time you actually need to pay for the stuff, all those exemptions that came with Rearm Europe have expired, and the year-by-year continuation doesn't provide the stability that defence policy needs,' he said.
Another concern is what the money is spent on. The staggering US defence budget of $997bn, for example, is often described as bloated with pork-barrel procurements rather than what a modern military needs.
Europe suffers from a similar problem of redundancy, with different states competing to have their tank or rocket launch system adopted as the EU standard and funded to great heights.
Krummrich believed the EU now enjoys a 'significant opportunity' to avoid squabbling about which older systems to preserve, and 'leap forward technologically through military innovation and investment'. It was enough, he said, to observe how 'the dirt laboratory of Ukraine has revealed a new evolution in warfare, especially regarding drones and unmanned vehicles'.
Others expressed concern about Europe's go-it-alone approach.
'It's capabilities that matter, and how those capabilities are built and controlled,' said Hugo Bromley, an economy and geopolitical expert at Cambridge University's Centre for Geopolitics.
The US and Europe should not be decoupling, but working together to provide specific needs in both Europe and the Asia Pacific, Bromley told Al Jazeera.
'The scarce assets America needs, particularly in an Indo-Pacific focus, are the very high-end [air]lift, missiles – capabilities that the current focus of European expenditure is not designed to create … because these are the capabilities that nation states wish most to keep to themselves,' he said.
'So we need to have an honest conversation about which countries are prepared to work together on these issues … and if you look at where our natural partners are to develop those high end capabilities, it is East Asia, Germany, to a lesser extent France and Britain, and what I think of as Commonwealth – so Australia, Canada.'
This internationalist approach is currently out of favour on the continent, where the concept of strategic autonomy now drives renewed European defence resolve.
Finally, there is concern that money, even if effectively spent over sufficient time to deliver force, is going to lead to tragedy in the Ukrainian theatre, which is largely depleted of its professional militaries.
'The operational map remains largely stagnant,' said Krummrich.
'Gone are the highly trained troops and great campaign plans. This is now a conscript war with negligible front-line movement,' he said, calling it a 'meat grinder'.
'In my opinion, high spending will not turn the war decisively for either side; it will only result in further death.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Iran detains 22 people suspected of links to Israeli intelligence
TehrancTypeface:> Iran has detained 22 people on suspicion of links to Israeli intelligence services. The suspects were held in the province of Qom, the pro-government ISNA news agency reported, citing local intelligence police. The detainees are suspected of having been in contact with the espionage services of the 'Zionist regime,' according to the news agency. They are also accused of 'unsettling public opinion' and 'supporting the criminal regime' of Israel. Details of the specific charges or the identities of those arrested have not been released. Iranian authorities have initiated a wave of arrests in the midst of the war with Israel, with media reporting dozens of people having been taken into custody across the country in recent days. Strikes between Israel and Iran are continuing for a second week, with a round of diplomatic talks between European foreign ministers and their Iranian counterpart on Friday having failed to produce results towards an end to the attacks. Israel says it launched its attack on June 13 because Iran was on the cusp of producing a nuclear weapon - something Tehran has consistently denied, saying its nuclear programme is for civilian use only. (DPA)
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Qatar committed to working with partners for sustainable Libya peace: Special envoy
QNA Berlin Qatar participated in the meeting of the International Follow-up Committee on Libya, which was held in the German capital, Berlin. Special Envoy of the Minister of Foreign Affairs HE Ambassador Faisal bin Abdullah Al Hanzab represented Qatar at the meeting. In his speech at the meeting, Al Hanzab reaffirmed Qatar's steadfast commitment to continue to work with regional and international partners to achieve sustainable peace in Libya and support Libyan national institutions in a manner that serves the aspirations of the Libyan people, achieve national reconciliation, and build the Libyan state. He also emphasised Qatar's full support for Libya's sovereignty, independence, and territorial integrity, along with the importance of creating appropriate conditions for holding fair and transparent parliamentary and presidential elections based on a consensual constitutional framework. He added that Qatar values the United Nations-led process, the efforts of the United Nations Support Mission in Libya, and the role of the Special Representative of the Secretary General.
Qatar Tribune
2 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
QC participates in St Petersburg economic forum
Tribune News Network Doha Qatar Chamber participated in the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum (SPIEF), held in St. Petersburg, Russia, from June 18 to 21. Qatar Chamber was represented at the event by Eng. Ali bin Abdullatif Al-Misnad, Board Member of Qatar Chamber and Chairman of the Qatari side of the Qatari-Russian Joint Business Council. On the sidelines of the forum, Al-Misnad held several meetings with Russian business leaders and economic officials to discuss trade and economic cooperation between the two friendly countries and explore ways to strengthen these ties. The discussions also highlighted the pivotal role played by the Qatari-Russian Joint Business Council in fostering business relations, enhancing communication between Qatari and Russian entrepreneurs, and promoting mutual partnerships and investment opportunities in both countries. Al-Misnad reaffirmed Qatar Chamber's commitment to enhancing trade relations and increasing bilateral trade. He emphasized the Qatari private sector's interest in expanding cooperation with its Russian counterpart, aiming to elevate collaboration to new levels and position Qatar as a key hub for Russian trade in the region. He further noted the Chamber's support for fostering partnerships between Qatari and Russian companies, as well as creating a conducive environment for building mutually beneficial business and investment alliances. He highlighted the strong interest of Qatari businessmen in investing in Russia, describing it as a prime destination for foreign investment. Al-Misnad also called on Russian investors to explore Qatar's attractive investment climate and the numerous opportunities available in the country.
