PARC faces legal challenge over hiring process
To facilitate cooperation, Pakistan and Kuwait should establish a dedicated entity similar to PKIC. A proposed Pak-Kuwait Food and Agriculture Co could attract investment in agricultural development and boost Pakistan's food exports . photo: file
Pakistan Agricultural Research Council (PARC) has received a legal notice seeking to bar its Board of Governors (BOG) from approving revised criteria for hiring employees against various posts.
It is also interesting to note that the BOG has scheduled a meeting today (Tuesday) to approve the revised criteria for hiring employees, a process that started a year ago. Meanwhile, the government is already conducting a performance audit of PARC to determine whether it should be dissolved or merged with another department.
According to the legal notice, the appointment and extension of Dr Ghulam Muhammad Ali as Chairman of PARC have been challenged in Writ Petition No 2240/2024 before the Islamabad High Court (IHC). The court, in its judgment dated January 15, 2025, ruled that the chairman of PARC is not holding his office legally. The PARC BOG is advised to await the Division Bench's ruling on the legality of Ali's appointment/extension before proceeding with any key policy decisions in its upcoming 48th meeting of the Board scheduled for March 11, 2025. The appeal is set for hearing on March 12, 2025, as per the legal notice.
The management of PARC, led by Dr Ghulam Muhammad Ali, is accused of acting in bad faith. On March 5, 2024, and May 9, 2024, they advertised hundreds of regular positions, including Principal Scientific Officer (SPS-10/BS-19), Senior Scientific Officer (SPS-09/BS-18), Scientific Officer (SPS-08/BS-17), and Assistant Scientific Officer (SPS-07/BS-16) in the national press.
The recruitment criteria were allegedly tailored to favour ineligible candidates, violating PARC's Recruitment Criteria-2017, Regulation 8(3) of the PARC Employees (Service) Regulations, 1984, and the Federal Government's recruitment policy guidelines. The advertised recruitment criteria deviated from established standards as the requirement of post-qualification experience was omitted for the posts of Principal Scientific Officer (SPS-10/BS-19) and Senior Scientific Officer (SPS-09/BS-18). The stipulated number of years of experience required of the Principal Scientific Officer (SPS-10/BS-19) was reduced from 12 to 10 years. The maximum age limit for Scientific Officer (SPS-08/BS-17) was lowered from 35 to 32 years, limiting the pool of qualified candidates. The introduction of the Assistant Scientific Officer (SPS-07/BS-16) position was done with newly defined recruitment criteria in violation of established norms.
This recruitment process and tailored advertisements have been challenged in the Islamabad High Court, which has passed an injunctive order against the said recruitment process. During the last hearing in WP No 2094/2024, PARC presented a proposed Recruitment Criteria-2024, admitting that it had already been published in March and May 2024, including application solicitation, followed by written tests and interviews, despite still being pending approval by the BOG in its forthcoming 48th meeting.
The proposed Recruitment Criteria-2024, formulated by a lower-level committee, was advertised without prior review and approval by the Executive Committee (EC), a mandatory step before submission to the BOG under Regulation 8(3) of the PARC Employees (Service) Regulations, 1984. Even if approved by the BOG in its forthcoming meeting scheduled for March 11, 2025, the said criteria would have significant legal implications for the ongoing recruitment process already initiated and conducted using unapproved criteria.
During the period 2022-23, PARC made 332 illegal appointments against 164 advertised positions through tailored advertisements. Allegations of nepotism and favouritism include the recruitment of blood relatives as well as manipulation of written test results.
The audit concluded that appointments made in excess of advertised posts and without observing provincial/regional quotas were irregular and unauthorised. The audit has recommended a fact-finding inquiry to probe the matter.
Questions were sent to chairman PARC and secretary food, but no response was received.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan's ‘first operator-led angel investing network' launched
A private, invite-only angel investing network called Dastak has been launched by entrepreneur Saif Ali, designed to support high-growth Pakistani startups across tech, direct-to-consumer (D2C) brands, and services businesses. According to a statement, Dastak brings together seasoned operators, corporate executives, and investors from Pakistan and the diaspora to back 'ambitious founders with more than just capital.' Pakistan's startups face capital crunch, need urgent reforms: i2i report 'I'm not here to chase unicorns. I'm here to help a generation of Pakistanis build companies that put food on the table, pride in the product, and power back in the hands of young people,' Ali told Business Recorder. 'Pakistan will continue to face economic headwinds in the years ahead. The only way our youth can create real change is by building new companies, hundreds or even thousands of them,' he said, adding: 'this can only happen if we mobilize both local capital and local experience.' As per the release announcing the statement, Dastak is built on a premise that has talent but needs 'deeper backing' and it wants to curate a network of strategic angels, thereby simplifying the path to early-stage investment. The network is sector-agnostic with a focus on tech and SaaS; direct-to-consumer brands and modern services - margin-rich services businesses which it said are often overlooked by traditional venture capital investors. Rather than functioning as a fund or platform, Dastak says it facilitates direct investments. Startups gain exposure to operator-angels who have built and scaled companies themselves, while angels get access to vetted deals, legal coordination, and a streamlined investment process. The current group includes founders, C-level operators, and investment professionals spanning fintech, logistics, consumer technology, SaaS, and IT services, both within Pakistan and the diaspora abroad. While individual names are not being disclosed publicly at this stage, access to the network is currently limited to those who bring deep operational experience alongside capital. To ensure regulatory clarity, Dastak says it does not offer investment advice, manage funds, or guarantee returns. It facilitates access to vetted startup opportunities and provides advisory support where helpful. Investment decisions are made solely by individual angels. The initiative's aim is to lowers the barrier to angel investing while helping startups benefit from the mentorship and expertise of experienced professionals.
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Russia's attack on Kyiv kills five, sparks fires, Ukraine says
KYIV: Russian drone and missile attacks in and around Kyiv overnight killed five people, injured scores, sparked fires in residential areas and damaged an entrance to a metro station that serves as a bomb shelter, Ukrainian officials said on Monday. 'The Russians' style is unchanged - to hit where there may be people,' Timur Tkachenko, head of Kyiv's military administration, said on the Telegram messaging app. 'Residential buildings, exits from shelters - this is the Russian style.' Russia has not commented on the strikes. Both sides deny targeting civilians in the war that Russia launched in February 2022, but thousands of civilians have been killed in the conflict - the vast majority of them Ukrainian. At least four people were killed in Kyiv's busy Shevchenkivskyi district where the entire entrance of a residential high-rise building was destroyed, Ukraine's Interior Minister Ihor Klymenko said on Telegram. 'There are still people under the rubble,' Klymenko said. The attack caused damage in six of the city's 10 districts, including in several apartment buildings, and wounded at least 10 people, Klymenko said. Ukraine army chief vows to expand strikes on Russia A 68-year-old woman was killed and at least eight people were injured in the attack on the broader Kyiv region that surrounds the Ukrainian capital, its governor Mykola Kalashnik said on Telegram. Photos posted by Ukraine's State Emergency Service showed rescuers leading people to safety from several buildings and structures on fire in the dark. The Service said a pregnant woman was among those rescued. An exit to the metro station in Kyiv's Sviatoshynskyi district was also damaged, as well as an adjacent bus stop, Kyiv's officials said. Kyiv's deep metro stations have been used throughout the war as some of the city's safest bomb shelters. Russia's deadliest attack on Kyiv last week with hundreds of drones killed 28 people and injured more than 150, with Ukrainian officials saying that nearly 30 sites were hit during the multi-wave attack.
Business Recorder
11 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Russia's attack on Kyiv region kills one, sparks fires, Ukraine says
KYIV: An overnight Russian drone and missile attack in and around Kyiv killed one person, sparked fires in residential areas and damaged an entrance to a metro station that serves as a bomb shelter, Ukrainian authorities said on Monday. 'The Russians' style is unchanged - to hit where there may be people,' Timur Tkachenko, head of Kyiv's military administration said on the Telegram messaging app. 'Residential buildings, exits from shelters - this is the Russian style.' Russia has not commented on the strikes. Both sides deny targeting civilians in the war that Russia launched in February 2022, but thousands of civilians have been killed in the conflict - the vast majority of them Ukrainian. A 68-year-old woman was killed and at least two people were injured in the attack on the broader Kyiv region that surrounds the Ukrainian capital, its governor Mykola Kalashnik said on Telegram. In the capital itself, at least five people were injured, Mayor Vitali Klitschko said on Telegram. Photos posted by Ukraine's State Emergency Service showed rescuers leading people to safety from several buildings and structures on fire in the dark. The Service said a pregnant woman was among those rescued. The attack caused damage in three of the city's 10 districts, including in several apartment buildings, Klitschko said. An exit to the metro station in Kyiv's Sviatoshynskyi districts was also damaged, as well as an adjacent bus stop, Kyiv's officials said. Ukraine army chief vows to expand strikes on Russia Kyiv's deep metro stations have been used throughout the war as some of the city's safest bomb shelters. Russia's deadliest attack on Kyiv last week with hundreds of drones killed 28 people and injured more than 150, with Ukrainian officials saying that nearly 30 sites were hit during the multi-wave attack.
