10 years after Charleston church massacre, faith leaders lament that the country hasn't changed

People of faith gathered again at Mother Emanuel AME on Tuesday just like they did 10 years ago, searching for God's truth and His love in the church fellowship hall.
On that horrible night in 2015, nine Black church members were gunned down by a white man who hated them just for the color of their skin. He sat with them through their Bible study, then as they closed their eyes and bowed their heads, he started firing.
As survivors gathered in 2025, they invited another congregation that knows the pain of murderous hatred to join them. When a gunman killed 11 people at the Tree of Life synagogue in 2018, Mother Emanuel's pastor, the Rev. Eric Manning, flew to Pittsburgh to comfort another flock.
A lament about a world unchanged
It was up to Rabbi Jeff Myers to lament Tuesday that the world hasn't changed as much as was hoped by the congregation of the South's oldest African American church, which was founded by enslaved people, torn down after they rebelled and then rebuilt following the Civil War.
'Both of us were assaulted by Americans who did not want us to exist, who thought violence would solve their problems,' Myers said.
Then he read the portion of the U.S. Declaration of Independence that starts with 'we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.'
'Except for the Jews and the Blacks. That's how I feel in America right now,' Myers said.
A call to action and justice
Democratic U.S. Sen. Mark Kelly said American society combines hate and guns in a stew that threatens the country's existence.
'We know that hate is dangerous. But hate with a gun in its hand is deadly,' said Kelly, who was joined at the Mother Emanuel pulpit by his wife, former U.S. House member Gabby Giffords, who was gravely wounded in a January 2011 mass shooting in Arizona.
The Charleston church massacre did change the world in some ways.
The shooter, now on death row just like the killer at Tree of Life, posted selfie photos with a Confederate flag to hammer home his racist reasons for shooting Black parishioners. For many, this act made it impossible to keep defending the rebel banner as a symbol of southern heritage. South Carolina then took the flag down from the Statehouse grounds where it was installed as a rebuttal to federal desegregation orders.
A struggle with our racist past
But some things are the same. Mother Emanuel's sanctuary still has the same deep red carpet. The church continues its mission of empathy, empowerment, encouragement and equipping.
And the nation still struggles with the legacy of enslaving Black people for hundreds of years.
South Carolina remains one of only two states in the U.S. without a hate crime law even though survivors keep pushing for it. Months before the massacre at Mother Emanuel, a white North Charleston police officer shot and killed an unarmed Black man in the back about 10 miles (16 kilometers) away. Six years later, a white officer knelt on a Black man's neck in Minnesota for nine minutes, killing him.
'On paper, the concept of the United States is a wonderful one. In reality, it is not successful right now,' Rabbi Myers said.
A reminder of forgiveness
Mother Emanuel member Marvin Stewart has tried to emulate the love he saw in his nine friends killed that night.
'Unfortunately, the present time is very demoralizing and very challenging with the political divide. As I sat in church today, and I keep hearing the word forgiveness, I said, 'am I in that space?' I would use the word acceptance as the space I'm in,' Stewart said after the service.
One hymn was sung Tuesday. It was 'Amazing Grace' — the spiritual that Barack Obama, the nation's first Black president, began singing at the memorial service for the nine victims, held just blocks from Gadsden's Wharf, where an estimated 40% of enslaved Africans first touched U.S. soil.
Rapturous applause rained down when survivors of the shooting and relatives of the people killed were asked to stand and be seen.
And moments of joy
Chris Singleton, whose mother Sharonda Coleman-Singleton was killed, asked everyone to 'hug somebody who looks different than you,' and for several minutes the packed sanctuary was abuzz with smiling people, arms reaching over pews and hugs spilling into aisles.
Large photos of those killed were on display in the sanctuary — pillars of the community who included the church's pastor who was a state senator, a high school track coach, the church sexton, a librarian and an aspiring poet. The shooter sprayed more than 70 bullets to kill them — and told Polly Sheppard he was leaving her alive so that the world would know his motive: "You're taking over our country. And you have to go.'
He failed, the Rev. Manning said: People of faith are still here, working together for good through God.
'Let the memory of the Emanuel Nine be a light that guides us not only to remembrance, but also to renewal and change,' he said.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Independent

29 minutes ago

• The Independent

The ‘inappropriate' post over Iran that led the LA County Sheriff's Department to apologize

The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department (LASD) apologized for an "offensive and inappropriate" social media post regarding recent U.S. strikes in Iran. The initial post, published hours after U.S. bombings, referenced "victims and families impacted" despite no reported fatalities. The LASD faced significant public backlash, with social media users criticizing the statement as a "slap in the face" to the U.S. military. The department first edited the post, then issued a formal apology, stating the original message was "unacceptable, made in error, and does not reflect the views of Sheriff Robert G. Luna or the Department." The LASD is conducting an internal review into the post's creation and publication, and is reviewing its social media oversight protocols.

Daily Mail​

32 minutes ago

• Daily Mail​

WNBA commentator Rebecca Lobo forced into bizarre on-air U-turn after praising Donald Trump

WNBA legend and ESPN commentator Rebecca Lobo issued a bizarre apology on air for calling America 'great' during the Las Vegas Aces' win over the Indiana Fever. Lobo, who was named a WNBA All-Star back in 1999, was debating a foul call in Sunday's game with play-by-play announcer Pam Ward when she used a term vaguely similar to Donald Trump 's MAGA catchphrase. 'So they disagree with you?' Ward asked her colleague about the decision made by officials on court. 'They do, and I disagree with them. And that's fine,' Lobo responded before adding, 'that's what makes America great, right Pam Ward?' After seemingly being left uncomfortable with her choice of wording, Ward stayed silent before Lobo backtracked on the comment in strange fashion. 'I should rephrase that,' the former New York Liberty star said. Ward then replied: 'Yeah, I did think differences of opinion are perfectly fine.' WNBA legend and ESPN commentator Rebecca Lobo (left) issued a bizarre apology on air for calling America 'great' during the Las Vegas Aces' win over the Indiana Fever (right) "I should rephrase that" — CJ Fogler 🫡 (@cjzero) June 22, 2025 'Yes, that's a better way to say it. Sorry about that,' Lobo added. Fans quickly took to social media to slam Lobo, Ward and ESPN over the awkward moment, which many felt was unnecessary. 'Clearly not political. Just a general statement,' one user posted on X. 'Disgraceful! There is too long a pause after Rebecca said it. Someone in the booth told her rephrase it. There is nothing wrong with what she said, get over yourself woke ESPN. Not everything is political,' wrote another. A third put: 'Imagine being offended about saying America is great. F***in losers'. While another simply commented: 'Pathetic moment.' Lobo has spent over two decades as a commentator for ESPN after joining the network back in 2004, a year after she retired from basketball. As well as playing for the Liberty, Houston Comets, Springfield Spirit and the Connecticut Sun, the iconic center also won a gold medal at the 1996 Olympic Games in Atlanta with Team USA.

The Independent

an hour ago

• The Independent

Shocking video appears to show father of three US Marines being beaten by masked agents in parking lot

Graphic new video footage appears to show the moment multiple masked men in U.S. Border Patrol vests beat a father of three U.S. Marines in the street, before he was bundled into the back of an unmarked car. Narciso Barranco, 48, a landscaper from Tustin in Southern California, was left bloodied and visibly shaken after being violently detained by at least seven alleged immigration officers while working outside of an IHOP on Saturday. In one short video first posted by Santa Ana Councilman Johnathan Hernandez and the social Instagram account @Santaanaproblems, alleged Customs and Border Protection agents struck Barranco in the head at least six times, thrusting his face into the concrete and kneeling on his neck, before he was forced into the back of a light-colored Chevrolet SUV using a truncheon. Barranco's shoulder was left dislocated, his eldest son, Alejandro, a 25-year-old Marine veteran, told the Los Angeles Times. Councilman Hernandez's office has 'made themselves available to help with City resources,' according to the post. In a second, close-up recording shared by the social media account, alleged agents wrestled a string trimmer from Barranco's hands. Screams and high-pitched whines could be heard from Barranco as several alleged officers knelt on top of his body, pinning him to the floor as cars drove past honking their horns. 'Give me your hand,' one agent said to Barranco, which was returned with further squeals. 'Ey, leave him alone bro!,' a person filming from a nearby vehicle shouted. One of the alleged agents, sporting a balaclava and sunglasses, briefly unholstered what appears to be a pistol before placing it back on his hip. Barranco's arrest comes against the backdrop of the Trump administration's ongoing workplace raids across the nation. They sparked a wave of demonstrations that resulted in the president deploying the National Guard and U.S. Marines to LA in an attempt to end the unrest. Alejandro Barranco, who served with the Marine Cops in Afghanistan, told the Santanero that his father was transferred to a detention facility in LA. The younger Barranco, who said his two younger brothers are active serving with the Marines, said his father was able to make a call and asked him to 'finish the job he was doing when he got detained.' He confirmed to the newspaper that his father had already begun the process of establishing his citizenship before Saturday's arrest. 'I didn't really know what to say. I was still in shock and distress. I do believe my father was racially profiled – they didn't ask him anything,' Alejandro Barranco said. 'They just started chasing him, and he ran because he was scared. He didn't know who was after him.' The military veteran added that his father was a law-abiding person who was kind and courteous to those in his neighborhood. 'He has always worked hard to put food on the table for us and my mom,' he said. 'He was always careful and always did his taxes on time. He never caused any problems and he is known as a kind and helping person by everyone in our community.' The family has launched a GoFundMe campaign called 'Justice for Narciso: Assaulted and detained by CBP,' which had raised more than $64,500 by Monday morning to help cover Barranco's legal and medical costs. 'He was pepper sprayed and punched in the face multiple times by these masked and unidentified 'officers,'' the fundraiser organizer wrote. 'He is a good, hard working man. He has raised his family here and has established himself here. What we ALL saw today was disgusting and heart wrenching.'