Climate challenge as a development opportunity
https://arab.news/5fj7y
When climate change is framed as a global problem requiring collective regulation of greenhouse gas emissions, developing country governments see little reason to prioritize the issue over others. After all, the rich, industrialized countries that contributed disproportionately to the problem are themselves backing away from decarbonization and climate finance commitments, while low-income countries bear the brunt of the costs of climate change. Decision-makers in developing countries understandably conclude it may be more rational to hunker down and focus on climate resilience rather than emissions reductions.
But this is not the only way to frame the problem. While climate change undoubtedly poses a global collective action problem, in practice, climate outcomes are shaped by myriad decisions concerning development objectives such as industrial development, urbanization, job creation and local pollution management. Because late developers often have not entirely locked into energy systems, transport infrastructure, urbanization plans and energy consumption patterns, they have greater flexibility to steer investment and consumption choices toward lower-carbon and climate-resilient options.
In other words, the climate challenge can be framed as a choice among alternative development pathways. In many cases, development choices are also climate choices and, in a world where being a low-carbon economy confers a competitive edge, the absence of structural lock-in could be turned into an advantage.
Pursuing a climate-as-development approach is not easy or foolproof: it requires considerable state capacity, strategy-setting capabilities and full mobilization of the necessary technologies and finance. Importantly, it does not negate concerns about climate equity. Developing countries may opt to pursue the climate-as-development opportunity, but rich countries that disproportionately caused the problem remain on the hook to support this transition. Yet, this perspective offers an alternative to the zero-sum framing of climate policy and a basis for nationally specific visions.
An important starting point is that elites internalize and support low-carbon development as a potential opportunity, with climate resilience as a necessary component. Climate objectives cannot trump development goals but, equally, development innocent of climate considerations is no longer viable. To be politically feasible, any strategy must be rooted in the national context. Low-carbon development pathways are not easily replicable and need to be tailored to geography, local capacities and other variables. And, as with any long-term structural change, a durable, widely shared national narrative is needed (South Korea's 'green growth' in the 2010s is a useful example).
Shifting from narrative and vision to policy and implementation requires high levels of state capacity. Technical capabilities, along with the ability to identify climate-as-development opportunities and sources of climate vulnerability, are necessary, but by no means sufficient. In addition, as sociologist Peter Evans' analysis of East Asian industrial policy reminds us, the state must be simultaneously 'embedded' to engage and support private sector players and maintain sufficient 'autonomy' to avoid capture.
Developing countries, in particular, will have to be strategic and nimble in finding a niche for themselves.
Navroz K. Dubash
In practice, this means building institutions that can set the strategy, coordinate across sectors and at different scales, and provide trusted platforms to mediate conflict, ideally enshrined in law. All too often, climate policymaking is entrusted to relatively weak or siloed environmental ministries that cannot organize or enforce an all-of-government approach.
Moreover, because broad structural changes can introduce distributional concerns and leave some communities behind, deliberative bodies — such as South Africa's Presidential Climate Commission — can help to entrench low-carbon options by mediating social frictions and maintaining broad-based political buy-in.
Another major challenge for developing and emerging economies facing high capital costs is mobilizing adequate finance for capital-intensive low-carbon development. There are no easy answers here. According to BloombergNEF, global investment in the low-carbon energy transition in 2024 was only about a third of the annual amount required through 2030 and there were wide disparities in spending.
Developing countries have experienced few tangible gains from multilateral initiatives to scale up climate finance and reform the international financial architecture. Holding advanced economies to their financing commitments should remain a priority; but developing countries also need to mobilize more domestic finance and develop credible investment programs to attract global capital.
Recent efforts to create 'country platforms' — government-led coordination mechanisms that articulate a vision and identify financing pathways to achieve it — suggest one way forward. In preparing to host this year's COP30 UN climate change conference, Brazil is seeking to lead the way with a comprehensive multisectoral development program to mobilize investment.
Independent research suggests that Brazil has all the ingredients for a successful green industrial transformation: a strong resource base, a legacy of advanced manufacturing and a large market. Such models are worth exploring elsewhere, provided that they reflect a national vision, not donor-driven objectives.
One common criticism of nationally led, multi-objective development strategies is that the urgency of the climate crisis demands more direct action focused on emissions reduction, rather than on the indirect pathways suggested here. But this view ignores political reality. If climate action is seen to be at odds with other development objectives, it will lose. The only option is to devise strategies that can realize both sets of goals. The most effective climate policy over the long term might be one that shapes structural choices regarding urbanization and industrialization, rather than one that focuses narrowly on regulating emissions.
With the scope for global cooperation receding in today's fraught geopolitical environment, these arguments should not be interpreted as a call for atomization. On the contrary, developing national visions for low-carbon, resilient economies would benefit from mutual learning and enhanced coordination rooted in attention to local contexts.
Moreover, deploying low-carbon technologies will require investment in stable value chains, which depends on political and economic predictability. Developing countries, in particular, will have to be strategic and nimble in finding a niche for themselves. And the provision of finance at the necessary scale will still depend on a threshold degree of global cooperation.
But there is only one foundation that can support all these elements: a domestically developed vision of a low-carbon, competitive and resilient economy.
• Navroz K. Dubash is Professor of Public and International Affairs at the High Meadows Environmental Institute at Princeton University.
©Project Syndicate
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
13 hours ago
- Arab News
Water levels plummet at drought-hit Iraqi reservoir
DUKAN: Water levels at Iraq's vast Dukan Dam reservoir have plummeted as a result of dwindling rains and further damming upstream, hitting millions of inhabitants already impacted by drought with stricter water rationing. Amid these conditions, visible cracks have emerged in the retreating shoreline of the artificial lake, which lies in northern Iraq's autonomous Kurdistan region and was created in the 1950s. Dukan Lake has been left three quarters empty, with its director Kochar Jamal Tawfeeq explaining its reserves currently stand at around 1.6 billion cubic meters of water out of a possible seven billion. That is 'about 24 percent' of its capacity, the official said, adding that the level of water in the lake had not been so low in roughly 20 years. Satellite imagery analyzed by AFP shows the lake's surface area shrank by 56 percent between the end of May 2019, the last year it was completely full, and the beginning of June 2025. Tawfeeq blamed climate change and a 'shortage of rainfall' explaining that the timing of the rains had also become irregular. Over the winter season, Tawfeeq said the Dukan region received 220 millimeters (8.7 inches) of rain, compared to a typical 600 millimeters. Upstream damming of the Little Zab River, which flows through Iran and feeds Dukan, was a secondary cause of the falling water levels, Tawfeeq explained. Also buffeted by drought, Iran has built dozens of structures on the river to increase its own water reserves. Baghdad has criticized these kinds of dams, built both by Iran and neighboring Turkiye, accusing them of significantly restricting water flow into Iraq via the Tigris and Euphrates rivers. Iraq, and its 46 million inhabitants, have been intensely impacted by the effects of climate change, experiencing rising temperatures, year-on-year droughts and rampant desertification. At the end of May, the country's total water reserves were at their lowest level in 80 years. On the slopes above Dukan lies the village of Sarsian, where Hussein Khader Sheikhah, 57, was planting a summer crop on a hectare of land. The farmer said he hoped a short-term summer crop of the kind typically planted in the area for an autumn harvest — cucumbers, melons, chickpeas, sunflower seeds and beans — would help him offset some of the losses over the winter caused by drought. In winter, in another area near the village, he planted 13 hectares mainly of wheat. 'The harvest failed because of the lack of rain,' he explained, adding that he lost an equivalent of almost $5,700 to the poor yield. 'I can't make up for the loss of 13 hectares with just one hectare near the river,' he added. The water shortage at Dukan has affected around four million people downstream in the neighboring Sulaimaniyah and Kirkuk governorates, including their access to drinking water. For more than a month, water treatment plants in Kirkuk have been trying to mitigate a sudden, 40 percent drop in the supplies reaching them, according to local water resource official Zaki Karim. In a country ravaged by decades of conflict, with crumbling infrastructure and floundering public policies, residents already receive water intermittently. The latest shortages are forcing even 'stricter rationing' and more infrequent water distributions, Karim said. In addition to going door-to-door to raise awareness about water waste, the authorities were also cracking down on illegal access to the water network. In the province of roughly two million inhabitants, the aim is to minimize the impact on the provincial capital of Kirkuk. 'If some treatment plants experience supply difficulties, we will ensure that there are no total interruptions, so everyone can receive their share,' Karim said.
Arab News
2 days ago
- Arab News
Pakistan unveils new EV policy with over $353 million in subsidies for electric bikes, rickshaws
ISLAMABAD: The government on Thursday unveiled Pakistan's new Electric Vehicle (EV) Policy 2025-30, announcing a five-year subsidy of over Rs100 billion ($353 million) for electric bikes and rickshaws. The move comes amid a steady rise in electric vehicle adoption in a market traditionally dominated by Japanese automakers. Pakistan's urban areas exhibit some of the world's highest levels of air pollution, with road transport being a major contributor. Chinese and Korean EV brands are increasingly entering the local market, making these vehicles a more frequent sight in cities such as Islamabad, Lahore and Karachi. 'Total subsidy over five years will be over Rs100 billion and it will basically be focused on the two-and-three wheelers,' Haroon Akhtar Khan, a close aide to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, told a news conference. 'We will have subsidized financing for 116,053 electric bikes, 3,171 rickshaws.' 'A Rs9 billion [$31 million] subsidy will be allocated, and it is already there in the 2025-26 budget,' he continued. Khan added the government also allocated a 25 percent quota for women to increase their mobility. He projected the initiative will help with the annual savings of Rs283 billion ($1 billion) in fuel costs and a reduction of 4.5 million tons of carbon emissions. Khan said Pakistan's new EV policy was aimed at disincentivizing internal combustion engine vehicles and promoting electric mobility to help cut greenhouse gas emissions that damage the earth's ozone layer. He informed Pakistan has around 70,000 electric motorcycles, 5,200 electric cars and 450 electric buses, adding the government issued 61 manufacturing licenses for electric two- and three-wheelers including motorcycles and rickshaws. Khan also acknowledged the country lacks adequate EV charging infrastructure and faces challenges related to the absence of safety and quality standards. He said the government aims for 30 percent of all new vehicles produced over the next five years to be electric. 'So, we are establishing new electric vehicle testing rules, safety and emission standards,' he said. 'We have to make sure that if anybody is manufacturing an electric vehicle there are no emissions,' he continued. 'Another thing is battery disposal. We don't want to create any environmental problem that the battery is not disposed properly.' The country previously approved an ambitious National Electric Vehicles Policy (NEVP) in 2019, aiming for electric vehicles to make up 30 percent of all passenger car and heavy-duty truck sales by 2030. The policy set an even more ambitious target of making 90 percent of all vehicle sales electric by 2040.
Arab News
5 days ago
- Arab News
PIF earns perfect score on Global SWF Index
RIYADH: Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund earned a perfect score in the 2025 Global SWF Index, ranking it among just nine sovereign wealth funds worldwide for top governance, sustainability, and resilience. The report from the sovereign investor benchmarking firm evaluates 200 of the world's largest state-owned investment institutions across 25 indicators. PIF's flawless score this year marks a major milestone in its institutional development, following steady progress from 92 percent in 2023 to 96 percent in 2024. In contrast, the Saudi fund scored just 28 percent in 2020, according to Global SWF data. In 2025, only nine sovereign investors globally achieved a full 100 percent score. Of those, three were based in the Europe–Middle East–Africa region: PIF, Ireland's National Treasury Management Agency, and Nigeria's Sovereign Investment Authority. The Saudi fund led the group within EMEA and was the only Middle Eastern institution to reach a perfect score. The 2024 report described PIF as 'continuing to lead the charge,' highlighting that the fund voluntarily publishes an allocation and impact report as well as a self-assessment aligned with the Santiago Principles — despite not being a member of the International Forum of Sovereign Wealth Funds. PIF's sustainability strategy operates within the Kingdom's broader drive for spending efficiency, a theme highlighted in a March analysis by PwC and Consultancy ME. The report noted that public funds, anchored by institutions like PIF, are now being redirected toward high-impact sectors such as healthcare, tourism, and logistics, as well as artificial intelligence, combining fiscal prudence with strategic vision. Moreover, a Strategy& whitepaper outlined how the nation is investing heavily in its energy transition — targeting approximately $235 billion toward renewables by 2030 and embedding efficiency mandates for state utilities — to support its net-zero ambitions and long-term economic resilience. This alignment of sustainable investment and cost discipline reinforces PIF's role in delivering value-driven transformation in line with Vision 2030. The fund's elevation to the top tier was driven by enhanced climate-risk disclosures, the launch of a dedicated sustainability report, strengthened board oversight, and the implementation of comprehensive business continuity frameworks. These changes helped it secure full marks in all 25 areas of the GSR Scoreboard — 10 for governance, 10 for sustainability, and 5 for resilience. With over $925 billion in assets under management, PIF is a cornerstone of Saudi Arabia's Vision 2030, investing across strategic sectors, including tourism and logistics, as well as AI and renewable energy. Its strong transparency credentials and environmental, social and governance alignment have helped it build trust with global partners and signal its readiness for large-scale cross-border investment. According to the 2024 PIF Effect report, the fund's strategic projects, ranging from green bond issuances to renewable energy infrastructure, have generated a significant impact throughout Saudi Arabia and the world, enhancing local job creation, technology transfer, and environmental outcomes. A February analysis by Consultancy ME underscored how the Kingdom's broader focus on 'spending efficiency is driving growth and building resilience,' with PIF playing a central role by prioritizing cost-effective, high-impact initiatives aligned with Vision 2030 objectives. The full 2025 GSR report will be released on July 1.
