Islamophobia : French Ministers seek control over Muslim bodies [Opinion]

France, the birthplace of the Declaration of the Rights of Man, claims to be a model of universality, yet it excludes a portion of its female citizens. Its strict stance against the veil in sports highlights how selectively its humanistic principles are applied. Under the guise of neutrality and equality, the state is actually upholding a narrow vision of secularism, which leads to intentional discrimination.
For years, this policy has drawn significant international criticism. In October 2024, UN experts called the ban on the veil in sports «discriminatory» and a violation of fundamental freedoms, accusing France of failing to justify these restrictions with clear legal imperatives. Despite these warnings, the government persists, gradually institutionalizing this exclusion.
Sports federations are following suit. The French Football Federation (FFF) and the French Rugby Federation have already banned the veil in their competitions. In January, the French Rugby Federation (FRR) prohibited conspicuous religious symbols, effectively barring veiled players from Saint-Denis Rugby 93 from pursuing their passion. This decision extends the 2021 law that allows federations to impose strict religious neutrality.
But the push doesn't stop there. In February 2025, the Senate examined a bill aimed at explicitly banning all religious symbols in sports. Officially, it seeks to resolve a «legal gray area». Unofficially, the goal is clear: to permanently exclude veiled athletes from high-level competitions, making them invisible.
A Governmental Cacophony
This ideological escalation has caused division within the government. Marie Barsacq, the Minister Delegate for Sports, publicly opposed the blanket ban. «We must not exclude women from sports», she declared, emphasizing that sports should be a space for freedom and empowerment. She was supported by Minister of National Education Élisabeth Borne. However, both women faced opposition from Gérald Darmanin, Minister of Justice, and Bruno Retailleau, Minister of the Interior, who are strong advocates for a total ban in the name of a rigid interpretation of secularism.
Yes, I want all religious symbols, including the wearing of the veil, to be permanently banned in sports competitions. pic.twitter.com/KVWak8d936
— Bruno Retailleau (@BrunoRetailleau) March 19, 2025
This governmental discord highlights the ideological deadlock in France. Should the country defend an inclusive version of secularism that allows all women to participate in sports, or a coercive secularism that excludes them based on a dogmatic vision? At present, the latter approach prevails, disregarding the very principles of liberty, equality, and fraternity that France claims to uphold.
The State on the Sidelines
After the veil, the issue of breaks for fasting footballers has become a new point of contention. Every year, the question resurfaces: should Muslim players be allowed to pause briefly to hydrate after sunset during Ramadan? In France, the choice has been made to avoid tolerance.
The French Football Federation (FFF) decided in 2023 to reject these game breaks, unlike other European leagues such as the Premier League in England or the Bundesliga in Germany, which have taken a more pragmatic approach. What could have remained a purely sporting decision has instead turned into a political issue, revealing a distinctly French obsession: regulating every detail of sports, even at the cost of creating problems where none existed.
This regulatory zeal becomes even more absurd when it specifically targets certain religious practices. Professional footballers, assisted by medical teams, manage their diet and hydration based on their physiological needs. So why ban a brief pause that doesn't disrupt the game and is accepted elsewhere in Europe? This artificial debate distracts from a more worrying reality: a desire to control bodies, with the state seeking to dictate even how an athlete should eat or dress.
French Contradictions
By legislating every detail, France finds itself trapped in its own contradictions. Should all accommodations be banned in the name of neutrality, or should we recognize that sports can adjust to cultural and religious practices without betraying their core values?
Some voices, though still too rare in the French political landscape, advocate for a more pragmatic approach: returning to the true essence of secularism, which guarantees everyone freedom of conscience, without discrimination. In other words, it's time for France to stop stigmatizing part of its population under the guise of neutrality and reconcile with its own principles of liberty, equality, and fraternity.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Morocco World

16 hours ago

• Morocco World

France's Gender Equality Minister Visits Morocco to Help Boost Women's Empowerment

Rabat – France's Minister for Gender Equality and the Fight Against Discrimination, Aurore Bergé, will visit Morocco from June 23-25. The trip aims to strengthen bilateral cooperation on feminist diplomacy, human rights, and social issues, building on the strategic dialogue launched after President Emmanuel Macron's state visit in October of 2024. Central to the visit is the goal of promoting economic empowerment for women. In Rabat, Bergé is scheduled to meet with Naïma Ben Yahia, Morocco's Minister of Solidarity, Social Inclusion, and Family, to discuss joint initiatives aimed at preventing violence against women. A joint declaration of intent is planned to outline the shared objective of integrating women's rights into public policy. In Nouaceur – a province near Casablanca known for its industrial zones and home to the Mohammed V International Airport – the minister will visit the Safran Nacelles industrial site along with the Institute of Aeronautics Trades to examine the role of women in the Moroccan industrial sector, focusing on vocational training and professional integration programs. Bergé will also meet with Nadia Fettah Alaoui, Minister of Economy and Finance, Amina Bouayach, President of the National Human Rights Council (CNDH), and Ahmed Abbadi, Secretary General of the Rabita of the Ulemas – Muslim scholars – to discuss gender-related issues across governmental and institutional levels. The visit will include a review of field projects supported by the French Development Agency, such as the 'Ajyal Égalité' program, which provides support for women affected by violence. The trip may also facilitate Morocco's participation in the international conference on feminist diplomacy scheduled in Paris in October 2025. In Marrakech, Minister Bergé will visit social institutions including the Lalla Amina Center for children deprived of family care and facilities focused on women's economic empowerment. The visit aims to promote coordination among institutional, economic, and associative actors related to social inclusion and gender equality. The visit comes as Morocco ranks 137th out of 148 countries in the World Economic Forum's 2025 Global Gender Gap Report—second in the Maghreb and tenth in the Arab world. Despite slight gains in education and political representation, Morocco remains near the bottom globally in economic participation and health. By contrast, ​​France ranks 35th and holds fourth place among G7 nations. The visit's focus on feminist diplomacy and women's empowerment reflects an official effort to advance gender equality on an international level. However, some of Bergé's previous statements expose deeper tensions within white Western feminism—where orientalist biases and selective political narratives can undermine solidarity and inclusivity. Following the murder of a Muslim man at the Khadija mosque in La Grand-Combe, southern France, Minister Aurore Bergé sparked controversy by dismissing the use of the term 'islamophobia' to describe the attack. 'I understand those who might spontaneously use it, because they see it as a way (…) to express support and empathy. But I believe it is not an appropriate term,' Bergé said. 'I also discussed this with the Prime Minister. Sometimes, we must allow for nuance. This nuance is crucial to me because I know those pushing to impose this term today do so with questionable intentions,' she added. Simultaneously, Bergé demanded a firm break from the left-wing party La France Insoumise (LFI) over allegations of antisemitism. Yet, these accusations are less about hostility toward Jewish people and more about LFI's outspoken condemnation of the Israeli state and its ongoing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza—a pressing feminist issue and a litmus test of genuine political and social commitment to justice.

Morocco World

2 days ago

• Morocco World

Morocco's Bouayach Meets UN Chief to Call for Rights-Based Global Reform

Rabat – UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres met with Amina Bouayach, head of Morocco's National Human Rights Council (CNDH) and current president of the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions (GANHRI), to discuss how national institutions could claim a stronger voice in shaping the global agenda. The meeting, held yesterday at the UN headquarters in New York, reflects a growing push from Bouayach and the GANHRI network to ensure that institutions rooted in local realities help guide international decisions, especially as the world confronts overlapping crises. Bouayach spoke on behalf of more than 120 national institutions across the globe. She thanked Guterres for placing rights at the core of the UN's work and called his 'Call to Action' and the 'Pact for the Future' crucial reference points for those working to defend dignity on the ground. 'Human rights are not a decorative element of global diplomacy,' she said. 'They form the very core of justice. National institutions speak with the voices of those who often go unheard, victims, citizens, activists, and carry their realities from the field to decision-making halls.' During the meeting, Bouayach laid out two key proposals to Guterres. First, she called for national institutions to be granted formal participation in key UN platforms held in New York, such as the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC), the High-Level Political Forum (HLPF), and the Commission on the Status of Women (CSW). These forums shape the UN's long-term goals, and Bouayach argued that national institutions, with their direct knowledge of conditions on the ground, would bring valuable contributions. Second, she urged for a greater role for GANHRI in the upcoming 'UN80' initiative, a UN-wide reflection ahead of its 80th anniversary. With growing mistrust in global systems and widening gaps between people and power, Bouayach urged the UN to restore the balance between its three founding pillars: peace and security, development, and human rights. 'This moment calls for courage,' she said. 'Rights must return to the center of international reform.' Bouayach also pointed to the existing partnership between GANHRI, the UN Human Rights Office, and UNDP as a model of collaboration that supports national institutions in bolstering their work and independence. This tripartite effort held its annual gathering in New York earlier this week, just before she met with Guterres. 'The challenges we face today are not abstract. They touch lives,' Bouayach lamented. 'GANHRI will remain fully engaged in defending rights across borders. We ask the United Nations to stand with us, so that every country has an institution that protects the dignity of its people, with independence and real impact,' she added. Bouayach was elected president of GANHRI by unanimous vote in March. The election followed strong backing from the African regional group, NANHRI, which officially nominated Bouayach in January 2025. Tags: Amina BouayachCNDHGuterreshuman rightsMorocco

Morocco World

4 days ago

• Morocco World

UN Commends Morocco for Advancing Peace, Justice in Central African Republic

​​Morocco has emerged as a key player in the reconstruction of the Central African Republic (CAR), with the United Nations recognizing its leading role in advancing the rule of law and institutional reform in the conflict-affected nation. In its 2024 report on peacebuilding, the UN Secretary-General commended Morocco for its sustained diplomatic efforts and strategic leadership as chair of the Central African Republic (CAR) configuration within the UN Peacebuilding Commission. Since assuming this role in 2019, Morocco has mobilized critical political and financial backing for judicial and security reforms in CAR. Its initiatives have helped stabilize the country's fragile institutions and secure international commitment for long-term peacebuilding. The report credits Morocco's diplomacy with enhancing support for the Special Criminal Court — a hybrid tribunal mandated to prosecute serious crimes — and for backing grassroots reconciliation mechanisms. These actions, in coordination with the UN Multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in the Central African Republic (MINUSCA) and the UN Development Program (UNDP), have been funded through the Peacebuilding Fund (PBF), ensuring close collaboration with national authorities in Bangui. UN leadership stresses that building the rule of law is essential for preventing future conflicts. The report calls for tighter coordination between agencies like the Global Focal Point for the Rule of Law (GFP), the Peacebuilding Commission, and the Peacebuilding Support Office. It also recommends greater integration of GFP partners — including OHCHR, UN Women, UNICEF, and UNODC — early in the planning stages of peacebuilding programs. Cautioning against institutional setbacks during the withdrawal of peacekeeping missions, the report warns of the dangers of losing momentum in judicial reforms, transitional justice, and prison system improvements. It advocates for expanded use of adaptable PBF funding to sustain essential programs even after missions end. To reinforce these goals, the UN urges stronger communication between the GFP and the Peacebuilding Support Office (PBSO), and more frequent deployment of joint teams, including from the UN's logistical hub in Brindisi, Italy. Above all, the report underlines that the success of rule of law initiatives hinges on lasting political will, both domestically and internationally. In this context, Morocco is held up as a model of commitment and vision, with the report framing its leadership as emblematic of Africa's growing voice in shaping international peacebuilding efforts. Morocco's actions, the UN concludes, are helping to embed justice as a foundation for sustainable peace, and reinforcing its reputation as a key diplomatic actor within the UN's multilateral system. In parallel to its diplomatic leadership, Morocco remains one of the UN's most active troop-contributing countries, with over 1,700 Moroccan peacekeepers currently deployed across missions.