Pat Spillane: The stupidity of the GGA's biggest problem makes me channel the words of Margaret Thatcher
We are cutting off our nose to spite our face with too many matches
The French Open tennis finals were exceptional. Spain v France finished 5-4 in the Nations League. And that Munster hurling final – wow.
You might remember a couple of weeks ago I spoke about Rory McIroy's final round in the Masters as being my TV sporting highlight. Well, the Munster hurling final topped that, for sure.
That game in Limerick had everything: excitement, tension, drama, a rollercoaster ride of emotions. It had me glued to the TV from the first whistle to the last. I remember describing a football match on The Sunday Game as orgasmic. Well, that hurling game was orgasmic – no explanation required.
Neutrals who know nothing about Gaelic games were talking about the hurling final. The GAA is now hot and sexy, believe it or not. People talk about the new rules in Gaelic football and the exciting football championship. The magic of David Clifford. The Jim McGuinness factor. I should be happy. And yet I'm not.
Kerry's Paudie Clifford in action during their group game against Cork. Photo: David Fitzgerald/Sportsfile
This whole split season thing is bothering me, it is annoying me, it is angering me. The scheduling is wrong, wrong, wrong. For years, I railed against the state of football. Thankfully, enough important people came around to my way of thinking.
They got Jarlath Burns on board. He appointed Jim Gavin and his FRC colleagues. They rejigged, remodelled, and created a new game of Gaelic football.
And the rest is history. This championship has been the most exciting for many, many years. And, whisper it, despite that brilliant Munster hurling final, the football championship has been far better than its cousin. That is a first.
Thankfully, my crusade about the plague of Gaelic football has been, hopefully permanently, suspended. The crusade against the split season, however, will continue.
And a quick history lesson about the split season. Why did it come about? It was to give certainty to club players who went months without matches. And I have absolutely no problem with that.
But the reasons – and this is what people forget – that club players went months without games were down to two connected factors.
First was the incompetence of county boards who couldn't organise a piss-up in a brewery and couldn't put in place a proper fixtures structure for club players.
And secondly, subservient county board officers who bowed to the whims and demands of dictatorial inter-county managers, having an undue influence over when club matches should and should not be played.
There were many county boards, and Kerry was one, that had proper club fixtures in place. Where club players had a well-run schedule of games, played on the dates arranged.
I get the argument from Cork and Galway, they are against the split season being axed because they have so many competitions to run off. But here is the gas part. Cork's football championship started this week, involving the divisional and colleges sides. And guess what? Some of the divisional teams had to pull out because they couldn't field due to some players' club commitments.
Split season my arse.
Monaghan's Andrew Woods tries to get away from Miceál Rooney of Down. Photo: Philip Fitzpatrick/Sportsfile
Sadly, the GAA has taken a sledge-hammer to crack a nut with this split-season format. We had exclusive use of September to promote our games around our football and hurling finals. That is gone.
We have taken our two main products out of the shop window for six months – August to January – and given our rival sports, rugby and soccer, a free run. And they are making hay while the sun shines.
You can argue the pros and cons about club and inter-county competition, but the bottom line is that the inter-county competitions are those that generate the revenue for the GAA that can be ploughed back into games promotion and coaching. The inter-county senior football and hurling championships raise the profile of the GAA.
They provide the role models Irish youngsters aspire to emulate.
The split season in its present format is wrong in so many ways. We are cutting off our nose to spite our face with far too many matches, with too many competitions, too many games in too tight a time-frame.
The major competitions are not getting room to breathe and not getting the profile and publicity they deserve.
And let's not forget the club player now plays for 12 months of the year, so there is no split season in that sense.
Many club players start playing competitive games in February and some play All-Ireland club championships in January.
The inter-county players under this format are now training and playing all year round as well.
The only lads who are happy are the hundreds who fly to America for the summer to play football and hurling because they know their club championship won't start until August or September.
The final round of group games took place in the senior football championship on Saturday and Sunday. The second and third-placed teams will be into a preliminary quarter-final.
Those teams will have played four big matches in five weeks to reach the semi-finals. And if they want to play in the All-Ireland final, they must play five big matches in seven weeks. Now don't tell me that is fair.
All I can say is be careful what you wish for. I don't have a problem with the split season in theory, but it needs tweaking.
Here is a lesson from history and the greatest business blunder of all time. In 1985, after 99 years, Coca-Cola decided to change their formula for the most successful soft drink in the world.
The result was an avalanche of criticism and 79 days later they returned to the old formula. Lesson learned. Maybe the GAA will take that lesson on board as well and admit that there is a problem.
And don't get me started on having no replays. The last three Ulster football finals went to extra-time and two to penalties.
We saw an All-Ireland final last year going to extra-time and we had Munster hurling final going to penalties for the first time.
Christ, just think what replays would have done for the profile of those games in the provinces and nationally. And the money generated that could be spent by the provinces on coaching.
We should go back to replays for provincial finals and All-Ireland finals, with no extra-time the first day out.
But, of course, I know the GAA can turn to their usual sources, rugby, soccer, American football and concerts, to make up the shortfall in revenue. What a stupidly short-sighted approach.
Penalties to decide a football or hurling match are a joke. There may be plenty of drama, but it is a lottery and not a fair way to win or lose a game.
Can I just remind people that the FRC recommended last year that penalty shootouts should be replaced by an overtime showdown. A next score wins format. Or one where the conceding team has an opportunity to match their opponents' score and prolong the drama. That is a brilliant idea which the GAA has chosen, in its wisdom, not to go for.
I will not let up on this campaign. I will use the words of Margaret Thatcher – this lady is not for turning. Well, this man isn't either on the stupidity of the split season.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Palestine GAA club's planned tour of Ireland ‘under serious threat' due to visa delays
A West Bank GAA club's planned trip to Ireland 'is now under serious threat due to visa delays', representatives have said. At least 33 young Palestinian players are to arrive in Ireland in July to play a series of competitive matches against GAA clubs around the country and to take part in a cultural exchange. GAA Palestine, the organisation behind the tour, said it faced 'new requirements introduced during the [application] process', such as English-language birth certificates for Palestinian players and for coaches born in the West Bank. It further said the Irish embassy in Tel Aviv had closed its public office since Iranian missiles hit the Israeli capital and it was 'not prioritising visa applications ... halting all progress'. READ MORE A total of 46 people, including players, coaches, officials and one doctor, were due to arrive in Dublin on July 18th as part of planned trip by Ramallah-based Moataz Sarsour GAA club. GAA Palestine chairman Stephen Redmond said the new requirements in the visa application process had increased the expected processing time from four weeks to eight after, he said, it was given a 10 week pre-departure time frame to submit all necessary paperwork. It had officially submitted the visa applications on May 19th. Co-founder of GAA Palestine Claire Liddy said 'the embassy responded three weeks later, on Monday, June 9th, with a list of additional required documents'. She said the Irish Representative Office in Ramallah 'refused to accept the original documents' on June 13th. She said as local team members were Palestinian, they were 'banned from travelling to Tel Aviv', so club officials outside the region 'had to scan and send the original documents digitally on Monday, June 16th'. A spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs said: 'The department cannot comment on individual visa applications, but all visa applications are processed in line with established procedures for consideration by the Department of Justice.' The spokesperson said the Irish embassy's public office in Tel Aviv and representative office in Ramallah 'are presently closed due to the security situation and staff are working remotely. The public offices will reopen when circumstances permit'. Mr Redmond criticised what he labelled 'bureaucratic nonsense' and he called 'for common sense to prevail so these young people can step on to a GAA pitch'. He said the group had requested an expedited processing of their application, but that this had not taken place. 'With co-operation from the Department of Foreign Affairs, there is still a chance to issue these visas in time,' he said.
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Short border, long history: Storied Tipperary-Galway rivalry
It's not the longest border. Only 30km or so. And by land it measures just 12 metres, the width of the Portumna swing bridge. But there is no older inter-county hurling rivalry than Galway and Tipperary. The counties met in the very first All-Ireland final in April 1888 (actually the 1887 championship) when Tipp's representatives Thurles beat Galway's Meelick by 1-01 to no score in Birr, then known as Parsonstown. The teams had 21 players each and referee Patrick White presumably had little choice but to throw in the red sliotar and let the game flow. Though most reports reckon he sent off Meelick's John Lowry after an opponent retired injured, in the days before substitutes. The goal was scored by either Tommy Healy or Jim Healy. We salute & remember the Tipperary team (rep by Thurles) that defeated Galway (rep by Meelick) at Birr on this day, Easter Sunday, April 1st 1888 to win the 1st All Ireland Hurling Final which completed the 1887 Championship. Photo: Tipperary's GAA Story by Canon Philip Fogarty — Tipperary GAA (@TipperaryGAA) April 1, 2018 Travelling downriver from where Galway, Offaly and Tipperary meet – near Shannonbridge - Meelick-Eyrecourt, Killimor (authors of hurling's first rules in 1869) and Portumna GAA clubs all draw players just across the Shannon from Tipperary, until it widens into Lough Derg. On the east bank is Lorrha-Dorrha, home of Tony Reddin (actually a Galway man, who only transferred aged 28), Ken Hogan and Patrick 'Bonner' Maher. It was Galway's misfortune to be located in a province they dominated - Mayo (1909) and Roscommon (1913) won one Connacht SHC each when it was contested - and deprived of championship clashes with neighbours Clare and Offaly by those counties' lack of provincial success. Offaly didn't win Leinster until 1980. Galway's border with Clare is nearly three times as long as that with Tipperary but over the many decades that the Tribesmen played a maximum of two championship games per year, Clare didn't emerge from Munster too often. So both counties' 'anTippathy' grew stronger instead. It took the Tribesmen 36 years and nine (mostly semi-final) defeats before getting off the mark against Tipperary. Having lost the 1922 semi, delayed by the civil war until August 1923, Galway gained revenge at the same stage a year later (3-01 to 2-03), only to lose the 2024 final to Dublin, three months after beating Limerick for their first title. Tipp got their own back in the '25 decider, concluding what was to be the first epic trilogy between the counties on a 5-06 to 1-05 scoreline. There were only six more meetings over the subsequent 62 years and Tipperary won them all, including the All-Ireland of 1958, which was Galway's last final appearance until 1975, by which time the Premier had waned as a force in Munster. They also met in the 1961 Munster semi-final after what proved Galway's only victory (over Clare) in a decade-long relocation to the province. Leinster has proved a relatively happier hunting ground. If the Ulster hurling championship gets going again maybe they could make a guest appearance and complete the set? Galway had re-emerged as a force by the middle of the next decade and contested three All-Ireland finals in a row from 1979-81, bridging a 67-year gap in 1980, when the West was awoken. Tipp native Micheal 'Babs' Keating had been Galway coach to Farrell's trainer in '79 but was not part of the victorious setup the following year. The men in maroon were again runners-up in 1985-86, to Offaly and Cork, and were waiting hungrily after Tipperary captain Richie Stakelum declared 'The famine is over' in Babs' first championship season in '87. It was in Munster anyway. But though Nicky English scored the first point just nine seconds into the All-Ireland semi-final, Galway immediately hit back with a goal from Martin Naughton and led by four at half-time. Two majors from Pat Fox had Tipp ahead going into the closing stages but, following a contentiously disallowed English point, a goal from Éanna Ryan put Galway back in front and Noel Lane sealed the 3-20 to 2-17 victory. It was third time lucky on the big day as Galway beat Kilkenny by six, Lane again finding the net, and they defeated Offaly in the '88 semi-finals to seal a fourth consecutive final appearance. Their opponents were Tipp, playing their first final since 1971. Defences dominated this time, English and Fox being kept quiet as Galway edged it 1-15 to 0-14, and Lane scoring the sole goal in the final for the second year in a row. It remains the only time Galway have gone back to back. Closing stages of the 1988 All-Ireland Hurling final The rivalry had now been firmly rekindled. Babs felt his team had been roughed up in the final and publicly questioned Galway's tactics. Farrell bristled back. They met again in front of over 35,000 at Croke Park in the 1989 league final that April, Galway maintaining their superiority on a 2-16 to 4-08 scoreline. In Munster, the Premier then made it three in a row against surprise finalists Waterford but controversy overshadowed the All-Ireland semi-final rematch with the champions. The late Galway centre-back Tony Keady was the Hurler of the Year and had stayed on for a few weeks in New York after the All-Star tour in May. He played for the New York Laois club in a win over their Tipperary counterparts, and was reported and banned for two games in the Big Apple for playing under an assumed name - his brother Bernard's. When word reached Croke Park, however, the reigning Hurler of the Year was hit with a 12-month suspension for playing without clearance. Galway were scandalised as it seemed Keady was being made a rare example of for a common practice. It later emerged that Tipp defender Paul Delaney had done the same thing but escaped a ban. Farrell threatened to boycott the game if the ban wasn't lifted but the GAA's management committee voted 20-18 to uphold the decision, Tipperary's delegate voting in Keady's favour but some of Galway's Connacht neighbours opted to maintain the suspension. Keating described the subsequent match as "a nasty affair". Despite Keady's replacement Sean Tracey having a fine game, Galway were too fired up and referee John Denton sent off Sylvie Linnane and Michael 'Hopper' McGrath while John Leahy got away with a pull across Pete Finnerty, later admitting: "I was very lucky to stay on the field. I suppose the two of us bent the rules a small bit in our time. They were hard games." Finnerty reflected: "Nobody ever told John Leahy I didn't have a sister. Nowadays he might have been able to google it and find out' Tipp won 1-17 to 2-11, Éanna Ryan scoring both Galway goals but English hitting eight points. The Premier had 18 points to spare on Antrim in the final. There were further semi-final meetings in '91 and '93, Tipperary handing out a hammering on the way to regaining Liam MacCarthy in the former and a much-changed Galway getting revenge two years later. Then a seven-year gap to a first quarter-final and renewal of final hostilities in 2001: Tipp, managed by English, ended a 43-year wait for a final win against the Westerners, Mark O'Leary (2-01) and Eoin Kelly scoring seven apiece as they won 2-18 to 2-15, surviving a late, disallowed Kevin Broderick goal. There was only a point between them in 2003 (Tipperary), two in 2005 (Galway) and one again in the 2010 quarter-final when Tipperary went on to stop Kilkenny's five-in-a-row bid in the final after edging an electric contest 3-17 to 3-16. Tipperary did have nine to spare in a 2014 qualifier but that was only after a Seamus Callanan hat-trick spearheaded a late fightback from six down. Tipp were beaten by the Cats in a final replay. The next three years saw three classic All-Ireland semi-finals, each decided by a single point. Substitute Shane Maloney won it for Galway with his first touch in 2015, taking a Joe Canning pass to make it 0-26 to 3-16, Callanan scoring 3-09 for the losers. Anthony Cunningham's men lost the final to Kilkenny by four points. In 2016, Canning went off injured at half-time but Galway still led on the hour, before John McGrath set up sub John 'Bubbles' O'Dwyer for a goal and scored one himself as Tipp edged it 2-19 to 2-18. They beat Kilkenny by nine. Here's the moment that decided ANOTHER #GALvTIPP classic! Joe Canning's late point sent @Galway_GAA into the 2017 All-Ireland Hurling Final! — The GAA (@officialgaa) August 6, 2017 The following year was decided by a Canning wonder point (his 11th) five minutes into injury-time, Galway winning 0-22 to 1-18. They bridged a 29-year gap to All-Ireland glory in the final against Waterford. Galway have won both subsequent championship meetings. A quarter-final in 2020 – Aidan Harte the unlikely late goalscoring hero after reigning champions Tipperary had had Cathal Barrett sent off – and another in 2023, when the Tribesmen were on top throughout but had to survive a late scare to win by two points after hitting 18 wides. Their respective provincial displays to date make Tipperary favourites today but history tells us Galway will always raise their game at the sight of the blue and gold jersey.
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Kerry-Mayo TV info, throw-in time, date and more for All-Ireland MFC semi-final
Kerry face Mayo this weekend in the semi-final of the All-Ireland Minor Football Championship. Croker beckons for the winner with only two more wins needed for the eventual winner. Kerry captured their third successive Munster title so far in the campaign and will look to add to that with the All-Ireland. Mayo lost out to Roscommon in the Connacht final but rallied to progress past Cork with a good performance. Here's what you need to know: The match takes place at Páirc Chíosóg in Ennis, on Sunday June 22. The action is scheduled to get under way at 3:30pm. The match is being shown live on TG4 and you can follow updates with our live blog.
