House price rise in holiday home crackdown county sparks 'not going to plan' claim
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
North Wales Live readers have been discussing the effects of Gwynedd's housing policies on local property prices, following reports that values have recovered after concerns that a clampdown on holiday homes had caused a "plunge". Cyngor Gwynedd is at the forefront of councils taking action to control second home numbers.
The council has imposed a 150% council tax premium on second homes and pioneered the use of Article 4 directives, requiring planning permission to convert residential properties into holiday lets or second homes.
These steps are intended to safeguard community balance in areas popular with holidaymakers and to help more local people afford homes in their area.
The council has taken these actions in response to the fact that approximately two-thirds of the county's residents were being priced out of the market, particularly in areas with high concentrations of holiday homes.
Ofcourseitis says: "12% down and 4.9% up isn't a bounce back, its still massively down on where it started, all as a result of Gwynedd council policies."
SCATHINGPEN writes: "Oops! Things not exactly going to plan. At least for Plaid. Wasn't the 'let's make it difficult for anyone to own or keep owning a second home' plan supposed to make homes cheaper for locals while driving those pesky second home owners away? Not having the desired effect? Well, at least the councils are happy. All that extra dosh to play with."
Lee77 believes: "Put the second home council tax up higher. Squeeze them until the pips squeak. It's extra coffers in the pot for the Council, which is good for permanent residents."
Tomosb81 states: "This should not be looked at in isolation. People may want to or need to sell a house in Gwynedd and buy a house elsewhere in the UK for work reasons, family reasons, etc. So it is also important to consider how house prices in Gwynedd have moved relative to house prices elsewhere.
"To illustrate: In Q4 2024 Principality reported that while Gwynedd prices fell by 12.4%, Carmarthenshire prices rose by 9.2%. In Q1 2025 Principality reported that while Gwynedd prices rose by 4.9%, Carmarthenshire prices also rose by 2.7%. So across the last 2 quarters, Gwynedd prices have fallen 7.5% while Carmarthenshire prices have risen by 11.9%. That is a massive divergence of 19.4%.
"Good luck to anyone who may need to move from here to there. This is an extreme example, but it is not unrepresentative of the general pattern. If someone never intends to move away then this may not be an issue. But for everyone else, it is. Consider a nurse at Ysbyty Gwynedd who gets a fantastic promotion to work in a hospital elsewhere and can't afford to move."
Indigodebz adds: "Surely this is proof the concept isn't working? Isn't the whole point supposed to be to make homes cheaper?"
Tomosb81 writes: "Prices are not up year on year. They are up in the first quarter of 2025, following a much larger fall in 2024. Year on year Gwynedd house prices are significantly down."
Ofcourseitis replies: "House prices in Gwynedd that dropped by 12% would need to rise by 14% to get back to where they were before."
Morpick says: "Houses will still not be 'affordable' as there are not the jobs available to support mortgages. But all the fuss diverts attention away from the inadequacies of the council to provide such housing and the premiums help to fund the gold plated pensions of council staff."
Do you feel that the council's policy is working? Join in the conversation HERE or in the comments below.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
'Essential' Llandudno phone mast plan approved
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Plans to install mobile phone antennas on the roof of Venue Cymru have been approved by Conwy 's planning committee - despite objections from planning officers. The application, submitted by Cornerstone, was granted conditional planning permission at a meeting held at the council's Coed Pella HQ last week. The telecoms company sought permission to install six new antennas on two steel frames on the roof of the council-owned Venue Cymru building in Llandudno. But planning officers had recommended the application be refused, citing concerns from the council's conservation officer. The committee heard how residents had contacted Aberconwy MS Janet Finch-Saunders as part of a campaign supporting the plans, while others said the bad reception was turning tourists away. Speaking at the meeting, Cllr Mandy Hawkins proposed councillors voted against officers' advice and said: 'It will improve the connectivity, as it is essential for digital inclusion and supports local commerce, tourism, and daily communications. Sign up for the North Wales Live newslettersent twice daily to your inbox. 'A reliable mobile service is crucial for businesses operating in the area, particularly those reliant on digital transactions and online engagement. This facilitates economic resilience and supports growth across multiple sectors.' Cllr Kay Redhead seconded Cllr Hawkins' proposal to go against the officers' recommendation. 'We pride Llandudno on being a Victorian resort, but that doesn't mean we have to live in the Victorian ages when it comes to technology,' she said. 'I disagree with what the conservation officer has said about it being a blot on the landscape and the visual impact. I think Venue Cymru itself is a blot on the landscape; it sticks out like a sore thumb. It goes against the rest of the promenade. You can see it from every angle driving into Llandudno. 'To put some antennas on that for the betterment of the community, I think, is a good thing. We've got an ageing population in Conwy and are slowly doing away with house phones, and everybody needs a better phone signal.' The site already hosts two existing antennas but is located within the Llandudno Conservation Area and the Creuddyn and Conwy Historic Landscape. Before the vote, the planning committee heard how the maximum heights of the new masts would be between 4.01 and 4.42 metres - exceeding the existing 3m equipment. Planning officer Elizabeth Wood reiterated the conservation officers' concerns. 'We agree with the conservation officer that it shouldn't be at the expense of the heritage,' she said. 'That site is clearly visible on approach to the town and adds too much to the visual clutter. With quite extensive changes, the proposed mast is going to have significant detrimental impact on the conservation area, which is our premier conservation area for the whole of the county.' Cllr David Carr also supported the application, pointing to the practical problems residents and visitors experience. 'The council's parking meters are affected by this because there are queues on the front (promenade) and people are not able to pay,' he said. 'They keep presenting their (debit or credit) card, and it doesn't work. I spoke to the relevant officer, and he said it is the connectivity; the signal is not coming through. I can't believe that 10 years ago you couldn't get a signal on Mostyn Street, and if I go with my phone now - and I've changed from O2 to EE - I still can't get a signal on Mostyn Street. 'I can go to the retail park and suddenly you can get a signal, but we don't have the phone boxes we had now, so people coming into Llandudno can't contact people, can they? I saw a few years ago a lady fell, and we wanted to ring, but the phones wouldn't work. It took about five or ten minutes to go into somewhere and ask them to phone. It is 2025 and we haven't got connectivity. People can't use their mobile phones.' Despite officer objections, members voted in favour of granting conditional planning permission. The plans include an electric meter cabinet, an equipment cabinet, two transmission dishes, and associated equipment such as Remote Radio Units. The equipment is intended to improve 2G, 4G and 5G coverage in the area. The planning committee will have to reaffirm their decision at the next planning committee meeting after going against officers' advice. Public notices in your area
North Wales Live
7 hours ago
- North Wales Live
'Essential' Llandudno phone mast plan approved
Plans to install mobile phone antennas on the roof of Venue Cymru have been approved by Conwy 's planning committee - despite objections from planning officers. The application, submitted by Cornerstone, was granted conditional planning permission at a meeting held at the council's Coed Pella HQ last week. The telecoms company sought permission to install six new antennas on two steel frames on the roof of the council-owned Venue Cymru building in Llandudno. But planning officers had recommended the application be refused, citing concerns from the council's conservation officer. The committee heard how residents had contacted Aberconwy MS Janet Finch-Saunders as part of a campaign supporting the plans, while others said the bad reception was turning tourists away. Speaking at the meeting, Cllr Mandy Hawkins proposed councillors voted against officers' advice and said: 'It will improve the connectivity, as it is essential for digital inclusion and supports local commerce, tourism, and daily communications. Sign up for the North Wales Live newsletter sent twice daily to your inbox. 'A reliable mobile service is crucial for businesses operating in the area, particularly those reliant on digital transactions and online engagement. This facilitates economic resilience and supports growth across multiple sectors.' Cllr Kay Redhead seconded Cllr Hawkins' proposal to go against the officers' recommendation. 'We pride Llandudno on being a Victorian resort, but that doesn't mean we have to live in the Victorian ages when it comes to technology,' she said. 'I disagree with what the conservation officer has said about it being a blot on the landscape and the visual impact. I think Venue Cymru itself is a blot on the landscape; it sticks out like a sore thumb. It goes against the rest of the promenade. You can see it from every angle driving into Llandudno. 'To put some antennas on that for the betterment of the community, I think, is a good thing. We've got an ageing population in Conwy and are slowly doing away with house phones, and everybody needs a better phone signal.' The site already hosts two existing antennas but is located within the Llandudno Conservation Area and the Creuddyn and Conwy Historic Landscape. Before the vote, the planning committee heard how the maximum heights of the new masts would be between 4.01 and 4.42 metres - exceeding the existing 3m equipment. Planning officer Elizabeth Wood reiterated the conservation officers' concerns. 'We agree with the conservation officer that it shouldn't be at the expense of the heritage,' she said. 'That site is clearly visible on approach to the town and adds too much to the visual clutter. With quite extensive changes, the proposed mast is going to have significant detrimental impact on the conservation area, which is our premier conservation area for the whole of the county.' Cllr David Carr also supported the application, pointing to the practical problems residents and visitors experience. 'The council's parking meters are affected by this because there are queues on the front (promenade) and people are not able to pay,' he said. 'They keep presenting their (debit or credit) card, and it doesn't work. I spoke to the relevant officer, and he said it is the connectivity; the signal is not coming through. I can't believe that 10 years ago you couldn't get a signal on Mostyn Street, and if I go with my phone now - and I've changed from O2 to EE - I still can't get a signal on Mostyn Street. 'I can go to the retail park and suddenly you can get a signal, but we don't have the phone boxes we had now, so people coming into Llandudno can't contact people, can they? I saw a few years ago a lady fell, and we wanted to ring, but the phones wouldn't work. It took about five or ten minutes to go into somewhere and ask them to phone. It is 2025 and we haven't got connectivity. People can't use their mobile phones.' Despite officer objections, members voted in favour of granting conditional planning permission. The plans include an electric meter cabinet, an equipment cabinet, two transmission dishes, and associated equipment such as Remote Radio Units. The equipment is intended to improve 2G, 4G and 5G coverage in the area. The planning committee will have to reaffirm their decision at the next planning committee meeting after going against officers' advice. Public notices in your area
North Wales Live
a day ago
- North Wales Live
Two housing 'sweet spots' in North Wales now among UK's most expensive
The price of a typical house in Wales is currently around £230,000. In some parts of the country, location can push the value up three or four times. A survey of postcodes across revealed two of the most expensive are in North Wales. One is on Anglesey, the other in Gwynedd, and both are coastal spots said to be 'dominated by second homes'. Houses in some villages now average more than London, where properties typically fetch £545,000. One slight surprise was the omission from the list of Llandudno in Conwy, where Llys Helyg Drive ('Millioinaire's Row') and Nant Y Gamar Road regularly rate amongst the most costly in Wales. With property experts Yopa, the Daily Mail looked for Britain's 'prestige pockets' to compile a list of the most expensive postcodes. Those within London were excluded as otherwise the capital would dominate the list: in London's W1B postode alone, houses level at a cool £4.37m. Introducing its list, the Daily Mail said: 'Postcodes matter. Whether it's the company insuring your car or the home buyer you hope to impress, this simple jumble of letters and numbers is shorthand for where – and how – you live. 'And Britain is bristling with prestige postcodes - areas whose desirability is determined by factors such as location, amenities and the view from the window.' Outside London, which is home to nine out of ten of the UK's most expensive postcodes, five places in England headed the list. Next came Edinburgh followed by the LL53 postcode in Gwynedd. This postcode covers much of the Llŷn Peninsula from Afonwen to Ynys Enlli (Bardsey Island). Within it lies Pwllheli and the villages of Abersoch, Llanbedrog and Morfa Nefyn. According to the Daily Mail, Abersoch is often dubbed 'Cheshire-by-the-sea', having the highest house prices per square foot in Wales. 'It's a magnet for second homeowners, who are attracted by the Blue Flag beach, sailing club, chi chi shops and views of Snowdonia (Eryri),' said the newspaper. Here, one address is amongst the most exclusive in Wales, with Abersoch's Benar Headland offering stunning views and prices to match. Usually only one property on the street is sold each year, one fetching £2.6m in 2021. Across the LL53 postcode, house prices have averaged £290,460, according to Rightmove. In Abersoch, the average was £803,750, though prices here are reportedly under pressure from policy measures designed to curb holiday lets and second homes. Ranking 13th in Britain's postcode list was the LL64 area of Anglesey. This exclusively covers the seaside village of Rhosneigr. A popular centre for watersports, residents and visitors have access to three beaches and the first lake in Wales to be classified as a village green. Rhosneigr has good amenities and, like, Abersoch, a golf course. This postcode, noted the Daily Mail, is 'flooded with second homes and buy-to-lets'. Sign up for the North Wales Live newsletter sent twice daily to your inbox Over the last year, house prices here averaged £772,083, according to Rightmove. This was up 11% on the previous year, driven by extraordinary demand for semi-detached properties which levelled at £1.47m. Even terraced properties sold through Rightmove were averaging £690,000. Steve Anderson, Yopa's national franchise director, said every county has pockets of demand. 'These are real housing market sweet spots that people will pay a hefty premium to be part of,' he added. The most expensive postcodes in Britain This is the list acompiled by the Daily Mail. Bedfordshire - MK44 Berkshire - SL5 Bristol - BS8 Buckinghamshire - HP9 Cambridgeshire - CB3 Edinburgh - EH3 Gwynedd - LL53 Leicestershire - LE7 Cumbria - LA23 Derbyshire - S32 Devon - TQ8 Dorset - BH13 Anglesey - LL64 East Riding of Yorkshire - HU14 East Sussex - BN3 Essex - CM4 Gloucestershire - GL19 Greater London - W1 Greater Manchester - WA15 Hampshire - SO42 Cornwall - PL28 County Durham - DH1 Herefordshire - HR96 Kent - TN13 Lancashire - L40 Cheshire - SK9 Lincolnshire - LN2 Merseyside - CH60 Norfolk - NR25 North Somerset - BS21 North Yorkshire - HG2 Northamptonshire - NN4 Northumberland - NE20 Nottinghamshire - NG23 Oxfordshire - RG9 Rutland - LE15 Aberdeenshire - AB15 Angus - DD5 Stirling - FK9 South Yorkshire - S17 Staffordshire - WS7 Suffolk - IP18 Surrey - GU25 West Midlands - B15 West Sussex - BN18 West Yorkshire - LS22 Wiltshire - BA11 Worcestershire - WR7 Gloucestershire - GL9 Shropshire - SY9 Isle of Wight - PO35 Hertfordshire - WD7 Find properties for sale or let near you
