River City didn't ‘pass value for money test,' BBC boss says

Bosses announced plans to cancel the show, which has been running since 2002, next year, claiming viewing patterns had shifted.
The decision has raised concerns about impacts on the screen sector in Scotland.
READ MORE: Campaigners under fire from BBC over River City 'mistruths'
But, appearing at Holyrood's Culture Committee on Thursday, BBC Scotland director Hayley Valentine said: 'I didn't take this lightly and I did think about the consequences for cast, for crew, for people who are impacted by the decision, of course I did.
'However, we have to put our audience's needs first, and the audience for River City has declined significantly over the past five years.'
Ms Valentine pointed to several new dramas set to be produced by the broadcaster, saying: 'What we'll do with these new dramas, which will absolutely cost more to make, but we'd expect them to deliver much bigger audiences than River City does.
'In terms of value for money for the audience, I'm afraid that River City didn't pass that test for us any longer, and the new dramas, we really hope will.'
READ MORE: Ex-Corrie star blasts BBC over plans to axe River City
The police drama, Shetland, Ms Valentine said, brings in about 700,000 viewers in Scotland and up to eight million elsewhere in the UK, compared to just 200,000 for River City.
Addressing concerns about the future of the sector, she said: 'River City is not the only game in town in terms of access to drama in Scotland, whether you're an actor, whether you're a director, whether you're a producer, whether you're a trainee.
'We offer these opportunities across a really wide range of content, it's not just River City that does that for us.'
READ MORE: Irvine Welsh calls for saving of 'big training ground' BBC River City
Ms Valentine also pointed to budgetary issues at the broadcaster, telling MSPs she doesn't 'have the money to do everything that I want to'.
'There are a million things that I'd like to do that aren't possible.
'So I have to make difficult decisions.
'This decision was made on the basis that the audience figures are not performing for us in the way that we need them to.'
Cast and crew, as well as the actors' union Equity, have already appeared before the committee to warn of the impact of the soap's cancellation.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mail​

an hour ago

• Daily Mail​

BBC and ITV broadcaster retires after 48-year career with tributes pouring in from sporting icons

A BBC and ITV broadcasting legend has retired after his 48-year career in the industry came to an end. Steve Rider, 75, bid farewell for the final time after being part of the presentation team on ITV4 for the British Touring Car Championship at Oulton Park. Ryder's contributions to Formula One were recognised in the form of a two-minute montage that featured tributes from the likes of Lando Norris, Jenson Button, Damon Hill, Nigel Mansell and David Coulthard. He became a familiar face on British TV screens after becoming a regular presenter on BBC's Grandstand. Ryder also led coverage for rugby, golf, motorsports and rowing events for the BBC, along with Sports Personality of the Year. He then left the BBC in 2005 to join ITV, where he became the anchor of their F1 and World Cup coverage. In an interview with Mail Sport in April, Ryder expressed his disappointment about how the BBC 'dismantled' its coverage of golf, a sport he was synonymous with during his time there. The broadcaster last had live coverage of The Open in 2015 and the Masters in 2019. 'It has been a bit of a surrender,' insists Rider. 'I really don't think there are too many hard-fought battles taking place with the BBC trying to defend their position. 'The one thing that they do have is that ability to deliver a sizeable audience, so why not offer that up for the last day of the Ryder Cup or the Masters? 'The whole landscape has changed hugely, but I do think BBC Sport went with a bit of a whimper, which is a shame.' After being diagnosed with prostate cancer in October 2023, Ryder underwent emergency surgery, which successfully stopped the tumour from spreading. He told BBC Breakfast: 'They took one look and said ''we're going to operate in two weeks''. 'No messing around. We did Brands Hatch for ITV on the Sunday and I had the operation on the Thursday. So it slotted into the schedule quite nicely!'

Scotsman

an hour ago

• Scotsman

The Gold ending explained: will there be a series 3?

The Gold to conclude its second series on BBC - but will it be back for a third season? 🕵️‍♀️ Sign up to our Arts and Culture newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The Gold is set to conclude with one last episode tonight. Fans have been delivered a disappointing verdict on its future. But how does series 2 of The Gold end? This article contains spoilers for The Gold up-to-and-including series 2 episode 6. Don't read further if you haven't watched the finale yet. The hunt for the villains involved in the Brink's-Mat robbery and its aftermath is set to come to an end on the BBC tonight. The second series of The Gold will come to a dramatic conclusion this evening. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad After two-years away, the hit historical drama returned for a fresh batch of episodes earlier this month. Over the space of three weeks, the show has charted the hunt for the other half of the stolen gold - taking the task force across the globe. But for viewers hoping for further episodes, a disappointing verdict has been delivered. Here's all you need to know: How did The Gold series 2 end? Charlotte Spencer as DI Nicki Jennings in The Gold series 2 | BBC Final warning: spoilers for The Gold series 2 episode 6 from this point on. Don't read further if you haven't watched it yet. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Having been caught by police again, John Palmer faces trial in the UK once again - this time for fraud over the timeshares he sold in Teneriefe that never materialised. Palmer defends himself and gets off to a strong start, seemingly connecting with the jury far more than the prosecution. However DI Nicki Jennings manages to get Palmer to show his true side by getting him worked up and angry when she takes to the stand. He is found guilty by the jury - in the end - and he is sentenced to eight years in prison and has a confiscation order of £33 million placed against him as well. Charlie Miller avoids being charged over the Brink's-Mat robbery, but is extradited to the US. In Fort Lauderdale, he faces a RICO suit (Racketter Influence and Corrupt Organisations Act) with hapless Douglas Baxter (Joshua McGuire) being one of the key witnesses - albeit he still faces having to pay millions of dollars in damages. Baxter takes to the stand - and the show continues one of the best running gags of series two with him getting upset over the mislabelling of the place he was caught taking drugs in the UK. Seemingly rattled by a threat from Miller, Baxter changes his testimony and does not identify him in court as a 'co-conspirator'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Miller is found guilty by the judge in America and she awards damages against him of $151 million (£112 million approximately). Police officers from Kent hunt for Kenneth Noye in Spain - after a sighting in Cadiz. He is hiding in the woods with Brian Reader - who has returned from season one - and a story is planted in the paper that he may have been killed in a gangland hit. After spotting him in town, the police follow him to his hideout in the woods - but are warned to be cautious by their boss back in the UK. Noye did kill a police officer back in season one, after all. Getting spooked, Noye prepares to flee from Cadiz but is arrested before he can leave. Bringing to an end a lengthy man-hunt. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The now-retired Boyce returns to catch up with what remains of the Brink's-Mat taskforce - Tony and Nicki. He tells them that between Miller, the Palmer trial and other results of the investigation over £200m has been recouped and it is 'the biggest financial result in the history of British policing'. He declares 'one day the country will know what we did' but warns that it is Brink's-Mat it is 'never over'. What else happened in The Gold series 2 finale? The show ended on quite the dramatic cliff-hanger last night (June 22), with John Palmer (Tom Cullen) being shot at by gunmen while Charlie Miller (Sam Spruce) attempted to escape from Tony Lundy (Stephen Campbell Moore) in Costa Rica. Kenneth Noye (Jack Lowden) had his trip to Teneriefe ruined after running into an old London villain - turned police informant - who gave him a 'nice day' before ratting him out to the police as he was wanted for murder. However the finale of The Gold series 2 picks up not in the immediate aftermath of the dramatic end to episode five and instead with the surprise return of a familiar face from season one. Crooked lawyer Edwyn Cooper (Dominic Cooper) is back and is appearing before a parole board, discussing the legacy of Brink's-Mat. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Tom Cullen (John Palmer) and Joshua Samuels (Jerren) in The Gold series 2 | BBC It is revealed that Miller was caught and arrested by Lundy in Costa Rica and is now in custody. He has been returned to England - and not banged up in the Americas. Palmer has also been arrested and has decided to 'defend himself' in his upcoming trial. Noye is still on the run, later revealed to be in Cadiz in Spain - back on the mainland and away from Tenerife. His face is soon plastered over the papers and is clocked by a person in a supermarket. Police are swamped with 'sightings' of Noye - after he calls up another old face from season one in the form of Brian Reader (James Nelson-Joyce). They attempt to watch Reader but he gives them the slip and reunites with Noye - although he warns him that his 'friends' at Scotland Yard will not be able to help him this time. Boyce is close to retirement and he is pressured into charging Miller with robbery - over Brink's-Mat - but warns his superiors that they do not have enough evidence. Lundy is accused of corruption in the paper. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Miller appears at the Old Bailey and the charges are dismissed for a lack of evidence - as Boyce had feared would be the case. But he is extradited to the US - so it is a short lived victory. Reaching his 30 years of service, Boyce informs the task force that it is time for him to go - and he warns that 'cases like this' don't 'end neatly'. He does tell Tony and Nicky that they have an 'ending in sight' before adding that it is hard to leave with the job 'half-done'. All of which leads into the ending of The Gold series 2 - see above for further explanation about what happened. Will there be a third series of The Gold? Joshua McGuire has fun as crooked lawyer Douglas Baxter in the new series of the BBC's Brinks-Mat drama The Gold (Picture: BBC/Tannadice Pictures/Des Willie) The Gold will not be returning for a third series - with those involved stating that it had 'always' been planned as a two-part show. Despite the second series ending with Boyce saying 'Brink's-Mat is never over', unfortunately for viewers hoping for more episodes - it is the case this time. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Prior to the show's return, Charlotte Spencer and Emun Elliott spoke to Radio Times and revealed that it had always been envisioned as a two season show by creator Neil Forsyth. Elliott explained: 'The way Neil writes often, because I've worked with him a couple of times, he always seems to know whether something's going to be a standalone thing, a two parter, a three parter. "So he has that kind of entire story arc in his head from episode 1, season 1. And obviously if the first season had been a disaster, there would be no season 2, but luckily, there was such a great response, that we got to continue chasing this gold." Are you disappointed that The Gold will not be back for season three? Let me know your thoughts by email: . Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad

Daily Record

an hour ago

• Daily Record

BBC Breakfast halts live segment over 'distressing' image as reporter left visibly concerned

BBC Breakfast was forced to abruptly pull a live feed from Stonehenge during their Summer Solstice coverage after airing a disturbing image which took horrified viewers by surprise. Reporter Peter Ruddick was on camera at the time of the incident interviewing revellers, as he told viewers: "For some this is a spiritual occasion. For others it's a party, or a rare chance to walk among history. "For everyone, it's special. Special indeed, and I've been asking everyone, 'What are you going to do with that extra bit of sunshine?' Because as Naga said, today is the day." However, his report was suddenly halted as it froze on the scene of a dog in a coat lying very still on the grass with Ruddick looking down at the creature with visible signs of concern on his face. Back at the studio, hosts Charlie Stayt and Naga Munchetty quickly filled in to reassure viewers. Charlie told the audience: "Okay, we should just explain - problems with the line there. "The dog that Peter was looking at there is all well and good, just a little tired. We saw it breathing earlier on, because it was wrapped up to keep warm. That's all." The incident takes place amid BBC Breakfast boss Richard Frediani's extended leave last week following claims of bullying, the Mirror reports. Frediani has been in charge of the programme, which is broadcast daily from Salford, since 2019, and is also editor of the News at One. Just last month, he accepted a Bafta Award when Breakfast won best TV news coverage for a special episode about the Post Office scandal. An insider disclosed to The Sun: "It's been an incredibly challenging past few months for everyone involved with BBC Breakfast - from crew to on-screen talent." "Fredi was already taking a break because obviously the allegations against him have been pretty damning, and he needed time to reflect. "He's devastated by some of the claims and has also had a lot of behind the scenes support from colleagues, many of whom think he's a brilliant boss." In a statement regarding Frediani, a BBC spokesperson shared: "While we do not comment on individual cases, we take all complaints about conduct at work extremely seriously and will not tolerate behaviour that is not in line with our values. "We have robust processes in place and would encourage any staff with concerns to raise them directly with us so they can be addressed." In a separate incident in April, the BBC published the findings of a review into its workplace culture which found that some stars and managers "behave unacceptably" at work, and bosses often fail to tackle them. In another development, The Sun is also reporting about two alleged incidents which it says caused BBC bosses to speak to presenter Naga Munchetty. The Beeb said it would not remark on individual cases but reassured all complaints about conduct at work are taken extremely seriously.