PAC unearths Rs3.4b graft by 195 cotton mills
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on Wednesday revealed that Rs3.4 billion in taxes had not been recovered from 195 cotton mills across Punjab, Sindh, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan from 2012 to 2023.
The revelation came during a PAC meeting chaired by Junaid Akbar. The Ministry of National Food Security and Research came under sharp scrutiny for failing to collect the cotton tax for over a decade.
The secretary for food security informed the committee that the mills had taken the matter to court, but settlements were now in the works. "We hope the entire amount will be recovered in the coming months," he added.
However, committee members expressed frustration over why the matter had reached this point. Senator Saleem Mandviwala questioned, "Why did it even come to this. Why wasn't the tax collected in the first place?"
The secretary responded that the ministry lacked a clear mechanism for upfront tax recovery. Chairman Junaid Akbar instructed the ministry to ensure full recovery by June.
PAC member Aamir Dogar lamented the deteriorating state of cotton production, asking, "Cotton is disappearing from this country... what is being done about it?"
In response, the secretary said the Central Cotton Committee (CCC) was being merged into the Pakistan Agricultural Research Council (PARC), and that efforts were underway to revive the cotton sector.
The committee also raised serious concerns about the frequent reshuffling of top bureaucrats in the ministry.
PAC member Hussain Tariq pointed out that four secretaries had been changed within the past eight months. The current secretary, he noted, was previously serving in the Ministry of Kashmir Affairs and Gilgit-Baltistan.
"It takes six months to even understand the workings of the ministry, and by that time the secretary is changed," Tariq said, urging PAC to issue guidelines discouraging such premature transfers.
Shazia Marri endorsed the proposal, urging PAC to formally advise the government against frequent administrative transfers. The committee agreed to write a letter to the prime minister on the issue.
Moreover, PAC members also expressed alarm over the declining cotton yield. The food security secretary assured the committee that improvement efforts were underway and that a special committee had been formed by the prime minister to address the issue.
However, the committee was informed of a Rs52.3 million loss due to the CCC's failure to invest Rs90 million. "This amount has now been invested," said the secretary, but the PAC directed the ministry to submit investment verification within 15 days.
Even more concerning was the revelation that the CCC hired 155 employees without Ministry of Finance approval, leading to a loss of Rs21.6 million, according to audit officials.
"These 155 employees have now been terminated," the secretary claimed. When Aminul Haque asked why the staff were fired after eleven years, the secretary clarified, "These workers were not continuously employedthey were recruited for 89-day terms during each cotton season."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Streetlight meters: Punjab seeks functionality verification survey
ISLAMABAD: The government of Punjab has requested a comprehensive survey to verify the functionality of existing streetlight meters and to ensure the installation of separate energy meters for all unmetered streetlight connections maintained by local governments. The province has also called for a special electricity tariff for streetlights, citing inflated billing practices by distribution companies (Discos). According to the Secretary for Local Governments, Punjab, there are currently 229 Local Governments providing municipal services across the province. Under Section 21(1)(s)(iii) of the Punjab Local Government Act, 2022, the responsibility for the installation and maintenance of street lighting lies with these Local Governments. Despite facing limited financial resources, Local Governments have been striving to maintain street lighting infrastructure. However, the rising cost of electricity—exacerbated by inflated bills—has made it increasingly difficult to sustain these essential services. A major contributing factor to these high bills is the prevalence of unmetered streetlight connections. Currently, Punjab has a total of 177,495 streetlights, of which 99,288 are metered while 78,207 remain unmetered. Due to the lack of proper metering, Discos often bill Local Governments based on average consumption or lump-sum estimates. This results in payments for electricity that is not actually consumed, placing a heavy financial burden on already stretched municipal budgets. Audit reports from the Municipal Corporations of Rawalpindi and Sialkot, presented before the Public Accounts Committee-III (PAC-III) of the Punjab Assembly, flagged significant overpayments. The audit cited unjustified payments of Rs. 69.048 million in Rawalpindi and Rs. 70.667 million in Sialkot for streetlight electricity bills. After reviewing the audit findings and the responses of the concerned departments, PAC-III issued the following directive to the Local Government and Community Development Department: 'The Committee directed the Administrative Department to prepare a comprehensive reference for submission to the Federal Government, emphasizing the rationalization of electricity tariffs, installation of separate meters, and exploration of alternate solutions.' In a letter addressed to the Secretary of the Power Division, the Secretary for Local Governments, Punjab, requested that in light of the PAC directions, necessary instructions be issued to all relevant Discos in Punjab to: (i) conduct a comprehensive survey to verify the functionality of all already-installed streetlight meters and ;(ii) expedite the installation of separate energy meters for all unmetered streetlight connections maintained by Local Governments. The letter also urges to take up the matter with the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) to introduce a special electricity tariff for streetlights, given that these services constitute a vital public utility. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
NA panel reviews FBR powers
The National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance on Thursday directed the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to incorporate safeguards before closing bank accounts of unregistered businesses, amid widespread tax evasion and underreporting by businesspeople. The committee, which met here with its chairman Syed Naveed Qamar in the chair, reviewed the FBR's proposed measures to enforce sales tax compliance, including the disconnection of utilities and temporary freezing of bank accounts for non-filers. During the meeting, FBR Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial gave a briefing to the committee. He said that unregistered businessmen would not be able to operate a bank account under sales tax laws, adding that such a person would be served a notice prior to the closure of the bank account. "The bank account of an unregistered person will be reactivated within two days after registration," he said. He revealed that out of 300,000 industrial units in Pakistan, only 30,000 to 35,000 were registered with the authorities. Explaining reasons, he acknowledged that the tax rate in Pakistan was high. "One-third of manufacturers are not registered in sales tax. People who even come under the tax net do not file returns," Langrial said. "Those who pay taxes underreport their incomes," he told the committee. "Electricity theft alone costs Rs500 to 600 billion every year." When asked how the FBR would identify businesses not paying sales tax, the FBR chairman explained that the income declared for income tax purposes would be used to estimate the volume of sales, supplies and overall business activity. Action would then be taken against individuals who fail to register, he added. Committee member Javed Hanif supported the FBR's proposals but the committee chair cautioned against enacting a law aimed at catching tax evaders if it also adversely affects compliant businesses. Another Committee member, Sharmila Farooqi, suggested that instead of making the penalties more stringent, the taxpayers should be given incentives. "Reduce the tax rate. It will broaden the tax net and encourage the people to get them registered. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb replied that the tax threshold and process would be improved. however, he made it clear that tax exemptions and amnesties would not be given anymore. "The time for tax exemptions and amnesties has passed. People have to be brought into the tax net." Langrial urged the committee to allow the FBR to temporarily deactivate the bank account of unregistered businessmen. The committee, however, directed for including safeguards in the process. Petroleum levy Meanwhile, the committee approved a proposal to increase the rate of petroleum development levy (PDL) to Rs90 and impose carbon levy on petrol, diesel and furnace oil. Finance Ministry officials told the committee that there was a proposal to impose the PDL on furnace oil as well. The officials said Rs100 billion in revenue was expected from the PDL on furnace oil. They added that 1.2 million tons of furnace oil was imported for 1,000MW Independent Power Producers (IPPs). The Power Ministry secretary said that the target of PDL recovery in fiscal 2025-26 was set at Rs1,468 billion. The Finance Ministry officials said that the government expected Rs45 billion in revenue through the carbon levy. The committee chair asked how much amount the Centre would get if the levy was turned into a carbon tax. On that the officials said that the amount in that case would be Rs18 billion. The committee was informed that the entire amount of a levy went to the federal government, but in taxes, provinces also get share. The chair stressed that the committee was not taking any decision regarding a levy or a tax on petroleum products. The industries secretary told the committee that Rs10 billion from carbon levy would be spent of the promotion of electric vehicles. He added that 30% of the vehicles would be shifted to electric vehicles by 2030. The production of all types of vehicles in the country is around 150,000, the officials said, adding that there were 76,000 electric vehicles in the country at present. "In the next five years, the production of electric vehicles will be increased to 2.2 million," the secretary said.
Business Recorder
3 days ago
- Business Recorder
PD tells NA body Rs2.50/litre carbon levy to apply from July 1
ISLAMABAD: Petroleum Division Thursday informed National Assembly's Standing Committee on Finance that the carbon levy of Rs2.50 per litre will be imposed on petroleum products from July 1, 2025. Senior officials from the Petroleum Division informed that at present, petroleum levy stands at Rs77/litre on high-speed diesel (HSD) and Rs78.02/litre on petrol. The government plans to cap it at Rs90/litre. Furnace oil, while phased out from public power plants, continues to be used by IPPs (Independent Power Producers). The government plans to borrow Rs1.275 trillion from commercial banks at a rate 0.9 per cent below the three-month KIBOR to retire existing power-related debts. Rs77 per litre PL on furnace oil likely 'This will eliminate IPPs and Power Holding Company liabilities in six years,' the secretary power division said, adding that Rs683 billion will go toward Power Holding Company dues alone, with Rs323 billion repaid annually. The surcharge of Rs3.23/unit will not apply to lifeline consumers, who continue to receive subsidised rates, he stated. The Committee considered the Amendments in the Petroleum Products (Petroleum Levy) Ordinance,1961. The Committee approved the proposed amendments in principle, with the observation that the Ministry shall brief the Committee on the issue of whether the proposed measure should be classified as a levy or a tax. Committee Chairman Naveed Qamar clarified the recommendation for solar taxation originated from the National Assembly panel, not the Senate, refuting member Mubeen Arif's claim. 'It was our recommendation, not the Senate's,' he asserted. Earlier, Qamar recalled, the committee had suggested avoiding any tax on solar to promote renewable energy. The committee also discussed plans to boost electric vehicle (EV) production as per global climate commitments. While Pakistan currently has 76,000 EVs, officials aim to raise production to 2.2 million in five years, mostly comprising electric motorcycles. However, concerns arose as officials revealed the government plans to finance EV subsidies by levying new taxes on vehicle buyers. According to the Industries Secretary, a 1pc levy will apply to cars up to 1300cc, 2pc for cars between 1301cc–1800cc, and 3pc for cars above 1800cc. Committee members were surprised to learn that these levies were not mentioned in the Finance Bill 2025-26. The Committee considered the amendments in the enactment of the New Energy Vehicle Adoption Levy Act, 2025. During detailed deliberations, the Committee observed that there is no comprehensive plan in place for the transition to Electric Vehicles (EVs), particularly due to the inadequate availability of recharging stations. Accordingly, the proposed shift to EVs and the corresponding imposition of tax were deemed unsatisfactory and lacking a proper implementation framework. It was further noted that hybrid vehicles have not been included in the proposed measures. Given these concerns, the Committee decided to defer consideration of the matter until the next meeting, with directions to the Ministry to present a comprehensive and actionable plan for the implementation of the objectives outlined in the proposed bill. The Committee considered the amendments in the Sales Tax Act, 1990. The Committee undertook a clause-by-clause examination of the proposed amendments to the Sales Tax Act, 1990. Following detailed deliberations, the Committee approved the majority of the clauses. However, it proposed amendments to certain provisions where deemed necessary. Provisions relating to fraud were deferred for further consideration, and the Bill was accordingly deferred for reconsideration in the next meeting. Furthermore, the Committee recommended a review of the Export Finance Scheme (EFS) concerning raw cotton, and suggested that tax imposition on local production be brought at parity with that on imported cotton. It was further recommended that these observations be forwarded to the Secretary of Commerce and Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), for necessary action and compliance. The Committee considered the amendments in the Regulation of Generation, Transmission and Distribution of Electric Power Act, 1997 (XL of 1997). After detailed deliberations, the Committee recommended that the revised amended draft, as submitted by the Ministry, be approved. The Committee considered the proposed amendments to the Stamp Act. During detailed deliberations, it was observed that the term non-filer is being used in the proposed amendment, even though this category has been removed from the applicable laws. In light of this inconsistency, the Committee decided to defer consideration of the amendment until the next meeting. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
