How many Sooners made The Athletic's list of best CFB players since 2000? Who was snubbed?

How many Sooners made The Athletic's list of best CFB players since 2000? Who was snubbed?
The Oklahoma Sooners have had more success than just about every other college football program during the 21st century. With a few exceptions, very few teams have been better than OU since 1999.
Of course, it was after a dismal decade from 1989 to 1998, when the Sooners sunk to unprecedented lows, that new athletic director Joe Castiglione hired Florida defensive coordinator Bob Stoops to right the ship in Norman. When Stoops took the reins before the 1999 season, he set Oklahoma on a path that it's still on today.
The Sooners won the national championship in Year 2 for Stoops during the 2000 season, and they have captured a bevy of conference championships over the last 26 seasons. They've been one of college football's premier programs of the last quarter-century.
Bruce Feldman, who covers college football for The Athletic, took on the daunting task of ranking the 25 best college football players of the last 25 years. Narrowing down all of the sport's greats to only 25 since 2000 is extremely difficult, but Feldman took on the challenge.
Just two Sooners made Feldman's list, beginning with safety Roy Williams, who starred for Oklahoma in the early Stoops years. Feldman has him as the No. 18 player in college football since 2000. He totaled 287 tackles, 34 TFLs, 9 INTs and 44 PBUs overall in his career and was stellar during the 2001 season, racking up 107 tackles, 14 TFLs, 5 INTs and 22 PBUs.
"A standout on the Sooners' 2000 national title team, the 6-1, 220-pound California native set a BCS national title game record for most tackles by a defensive back with 12 as Oklahoma shut down Florida State 13-2," Feldman said. "The next season, as a junior, Williams became the first player to win both the Nagurski Trophy, as the nation's top defensive player, and the Thorpe Award, honoring the country's best defensive back. Williams' signature play happened in the 2001 Red River Rivalry game with Texas pinned deep near its goal with two minutes remaining and OU clinging to a 7-3 lead. Williams crowded the line before the snap, backed up, then blitzed, racing in and leaping over Longhorns running back Brett Robin, nearly swiping the ball out of Chris Simms' hand. The ball bounced into the hands of Teddy Lehman, who grabbed the fluttering ball and scored to propel Oklahoma to a 14-3 win."
The other OU player to make the list was quarterback Baker Mayfield, who led the Sooners for the final two years of the Stoops era and the first season under Lincoln Riley. Feldman has him as the No. 14 player in the sport since 2000. He totaled 14,607 passing yards, 131 passing TDs, 1,083 rushing yards and 21 rushing TDs in his career. He had an unbelievable 2017 season when he went off for 4,627 passing yards, 43 passing TDs, 311 rushing yards and 5 rushing TDs.
"Mayfield won the starting job as a walk-on freshman at Texas Tech in 2013 before transferring to Oklahoma, where he also initially walked on," Feldman said. "He flourished in Lincoln Riley's system, leading the Sooners to three Big 12 titles and two Playoff bids and finishing in the top four of the Heisman race three years in a row, including winning the award in 2017. Mayfield was at his best when the spotlight was brightest. In his return game to Lubbock, facing all sorts of animosity from the Red Raiders crowd, Mayfield passed for 545 yards and seven TDs (with no INTs) in a 66-59 win to outduel Patrick Mahomes. In 2017, he threw for 386 yards and three TDs, completing 77 percent of his passes in a blowout win at No. 5 Ohio State. He later shredded rival Oklahoma State for 598 passing yards and five TDs in a 62-52 win in Stillwater. He threw for seven TDs and zero picks in two games against top-10 TCU that season and had No. 2 Georgia on the ropes in a 54-48 loss in the CFP semifinal."
Both Williams and Mayfield have a good argument that they could be ranked higher, as Williams was the engine of one of college football's best defenses for multiple seasons and has a national championship ring. Mayfield pulled the program out of a lull in the later Stoops years and won more conference championships than he lost conference games. Both players are questionably ranked behind guys like DeVonta Smith, Andrew Luck, Larry Fitzgerald, Terrell Suggs, and Travis Hunter. In fact, Mayfield landed at No. 2 on a very similar list from ESPN last summer. His spot on Feldman's list feels far too low, especially considering a Heisman Trophy has his name on it and he was a finalist two other times.
While we're on the subject, plenty more OU players had to have been considered. Quarterbacks include Josh Heupel, Jason White, Sam Bradford, Landry Jones, Kyler Murray and Jalen Hurts. Running backs like Adrian Peterson and DeMarco Murray and pass catchers like Mark Clayton, Malcolm Kelly, Juaquin Iglesias, Jermaine Gresham, Ryan Broyles, Dede Westbrook, and CeeDee Lamb certainly have an argument.
Defensively, it's tough to argue against the likes of Torrance Marshall, Rocky Calmus, Teddy Lehman, Derrick Strait, Tommie Harris, Dusty Dvoracek, Curtis Lofton and Gerald McCoy. Those OU defenses, especially until Brent Venables left after the 2011 season, were feared across the Big 12 and college football.
Now, with Venables following Stoops and Riley as Oklahoma's third head coach over the last 26 seasons, it's time for the Sooners to put more players onto lists like these in the years to come. That starts with a pivotal 2025 season, the 27th season since Castiglione hired Stoops and thereby brought OU Football back to the top of college football.
Contact/Follow us @SoonersWire on X, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Oklahoma news, notes, and opinions. You can also follow Aaron on X @Aaron_Gelvin.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

New York Times

3 hours ago

• New York Times

404

Each NHL team's best and worst draft pick of the past decade The Athletic NHL Staff

New York Times

6 hours ago

• New York Times

All the FIFA Club World Cup permutations as final round of group games begin

The final set of group games at the FIFA Club World Cup get underway on Monday (June 23) and it's still all to play for across the tournament's first round. The top two teams in each of the eight groups will advance to the knockout stage, with the bottom two in each being eliminated. Here, The Athletic guides you through the state of play in each group and who needs to do what to reach the last 16. Teams level on points will be separated by their head-to-head records and then overall goal difference. Here is what the FIFA rulebook for the tournament says: If two or more teams in the same group are equal on points after the completion of the group stage, the following criteria, in the order below, shall be applied to determine the ranking: a) greatest number of points obtained in the group matches between the teams concerned b) superior goal difference resulting from the group matches between the teams concerned c) greatest number of goals scored in all group matches between the teams concerned If, after having applied criteria a) to c) above, teams still have an equal ranking, to determine their final rankings, criteria a) to c) above are applied to the matches between the remaining teams only. If no decision can be made through this procedure, criteria d) to f) below shall apply as follows to the two or more teams still equal on points: d) superior goal difference in all group matches e) greatest number of goals scored in all group matches f) highest team conduct score (players and team officials) relating to the number of yellow and red cards obtained: — yellow card: minus 1 point — indirect red card (as a result of two yellow cards): minus 3 points — direct red card: minus 4 points — yellow card and direct red card: minus 5 points Only one of the above deductions shall be applied to a player or team official in a single match. The team with the highest number of points shall be ranked highest. Advertisement g) finally, drawing of lots by FIFA How they stand: Results: Al Ahly 0-0 Inter Miami, Palmeiras 0-0 Porto, Palmeiras 2-0 Al Ahly, Inter Miami 2-1 Porto. Remaining fixtures: Inter Miami vs Palmeiras, Porto vs Al Ahly; both on June 23 (9pm ET; 2am on June 24 UK time). Palmeiras: The Brazilian club will advance to the knockout stage if they avoid defeat against Inter Miami. If they lose, they will still go through if Porto fail to win. If they do lose and Porto win, however, then whoever out of Palmeiras and the Portuguese side has the better overall goal difference in all group matches will advance. Inter Miami: Lionel Messi's side will advance to the knockout stage if they get at least a point against Palmeiras. If they lose, Inter Miami will still go through if Al Ahly fail to beat Porto. If Inter Miami do lose and Al Ahly win, then overall goal difference comes into play again. Porto: The Portuguese side must beat Al Ahly and hope Inter Miami win to have any chance. Porto would also need an overall superior goal difference to Palmeiras. Al Ahly: The team from Egypt must beat Porto and hope Palmeiras defeat Inter Miami. If these two results do materialise, then whoever out of Al Ahly and Inter Miami has the better goal difference from their three group games will advance. How they stand: Results: Paris Saint-Germain 4-0 Atletico Madrid, Botafogo 2-1 Seattle Sounders, Seattle Sounders 1-3 Atletico, PSG 0-1 Botafogo. Remaining fixtures: Seattle Sounders vs Paris Saint-Germain, Atletico Madrid vs Botafogo; both on June 23 (3pm ET; 8pm UK time). Botafogo: The club from Brazil will secure a place in the knockout stage if they avoid defeat against Atletico. If they lose to Diego Simeone's team, then they will still advance if PSG fail to beat Seattle Sounders. If they do lose to Atletico, and PSG win, then Botafogo need to have a better goal difference than Atletico from matches between Botafogo, Atletico and PSG to advance alongside PSG. Advertisement Paris Saint-Germain: If the European champions beat Seattle Sounders, they will advance. If PSG draw, they will go through if Atletico fail to beat Botafogo. If they lose, then they must hope that Atletico are defeated by Botafogo and then whoever advances in second place (behind Botafogo) will be determined by goal difference exclusively in matches between the other three sides. Atletico Madrid: Must avoid defeat. If they win, they will go through if PSG fail to beat Seattle Sounders. If PSG also win, then the two teams that advance out of Botafogo, Atletico and PSG will be determined by goal difference in their head-to-heads. If Atletico draw, they can only go through if PSG lose. Seattle Sounders: Must win and hope Atletico lose, then have the best goal difference in matches between themselves, Atletico and PSG. How they stand: Results: Bayern Munich 10-0 Auckland City, Boca Juniors 2-2 Benfica, Benfica 6-0 Auckland, Bayern 2-1 Boca. Remaining fixtures: Auckland vs Boca, Benfica vs Bayern; both on June 24 (3pm ET; 8pm UK time). Bayern Munich: The German champions have advanced to the last 16. Benfica: Will advance if they avoid losing to Bayern or if Boca Juniors fail to beat Auckland City. If Benfica lose and Boca win, then overall goal difference in all group matches will determine which of the two teams goes through. Boca Juniors: Must beat Auckland City and hope Bayern win, then rack up a superior overall goal difference to Benfica. Auckland City: The club from New Zealand have been eliminated. How they stand: Results: Chelsea 2-0 Los Angeles FC, Flamengo 2-0 Esperance Tunis, Flamengo 3-1 Chelsea, LAFC 0-1 Tunis. Remaining fixtures: LAFC vs Flamengo, Tunis vs Chelsea; both on June 24 (9pm ET; 2am on June 25 UK time). Flamengo: The Brazilian side have qualified for the last 16. Chelsea: Simple: avoid defeat against Tunis and the London club will go through. Lose, and Enzo Maresca's side will be eliminated. Advertisement Esperance Tunis: Anything other than a win against Chelsea will see them knocked out. Los Angeles FC: The side from California have been eliminated. How they stand: Results: River Plate 3-1 Urawa Red Diamonds, Monterrey 1-1 Inter, Inter 2-1 Urawa Reds, River 0-0 Monterrey. Remaining fixtures: Inter v River, Urawa Reds vs Monterrey; both on June 25 (9pm ET; 2am on June 26 UK time). River Plate: The Argentine club will go through if they beat Inter. If they draw, they will advance if Monterrey fail to beat Urawa Red Diamonds. If Monterrey do win, and River draw, the Argentinians will go through if they draw by a scoreline of 2-2 or higher. If it is 0-0 they will be eliminated and if it is 1-1 then whoever has the better overall goal difference in all group matches out of River and Monterrey will advance alongside Inter. If River lose they will be knocked out only if Monterrey win. Inter: Will go through if they avoid defeat against River. If they lose, they will still advance providing Monterrey fail to beat Urawa Reds. If Monterrey win, and Inter lose, then the Italian club will be eliminated. Monterrey: The Mexican side must beat Urawa Reds to have any chance of going through. If Monterrey do win and the game between Inter and River isn't a draw, then they will advance. If they pick up three points but the Inter-River match finishes level, then whichever of Monterrey and River Plate scored more goals in matches between themselves and Inter will advance alongside the Italian club. This means that if it is 0-0 in the Inter-River match, then Monterrey will advance. If it is 2-2 or higher, River Plate will go through. If it is 1-1, then whoever out of River and Monterrey has the higher overall goal difference in all group matches will advance alongside Inter. Urawa Red Diamonds: The club from Japan have been eliminated. How they stand: Results: Fluminense 0-0 Borussia Dortmund, Ulsan HD 0-1 Mamelodi Sundowns, Sundowns 3-4 Dortmund, Fluminense 4-2 Ulsan. Remaining fixtures: Dortmund vs Ulsan, Sundowns vs Fluminense; both on June 25 (3pm ET; 8pm UK time). Fluminense: Will go through if they avoid defeat against Mamelodi Sundowns. If they lose, they will be knocked out if Borussia Dortmund avoid defeat against Ulsan HD. If Dortmund also lose, then Fluminense will have to hope their overall goal difference in all group matches is better than Dortmund's. Advertisement Borussia Dortmund: Draw or win against Ulsan HD and the German side will advance. If they lose, they will still go through providing Sundowns don't beat Fluminense. If the South African side win, and Dortmund lose, then whoever has the better overall goal difference in all group matches between the German club and Fluminense will advance alongside the South African side. Mamelodi Sundowns: If they win they go through. Fail to pick up three points and they will be knocked out. Ulsan HD: The South Korean side have been eliminated. How they stand: Results: Manchester City 2-0 Wydad AC, Al Ain 0-5 Juventus, Juventus 4-1 Wydad, City 6-0 Al Ain. Remaining fixtures: Juventus v Manchester City & Wydad AC v Al Ain; both on June 26 (3pm ET; 8pm UK time). Juventus: The Italian side have qualified for the last 16. Avoid defeat to City and they will finish top of the group. Manchester City: The English club have qualified for the last 16. Wydad AC: The Moroccan side have been eliminated. Al Ain: The club from the United Arab Emirates have been eliminated. How they stand: Results: Real Madrid 1-1 Al Hilal, Pachuca 1-2 Red Bull Salzburg, Madrid 3-1 Pachuca, Salzburg 0-0 Al Hilal. Remaining fixtures: Al Hilal vs Pachuca, Salzburg vs Madrid; both on June 26 (9pm ET; 2am on June 27 UK time). Real Madrid: If the Spanish club avoid defeat, they will qualify for the knockout stage. If they lose, they will still go through if Al Hilal fail to win, but would be eliminated if the Saudi Arabian club beat Pachuca. Red Bull Salzburg: Will go through if they beat Madrid. If they draw, they will advance if Al Hilal fail to win. If Al Hilal do win, and Salzburg draw, the Austrians will go through if they draw by a scoreline of 2-2 or higher. If it is 0-0, and Al Hilal win, they will be eliminated but if it is 1-1, whoever out of Salzburg and Al Hilal has the better overall goal difference in all group matches will advance alongside Madrid. This means that if Al Hilal were to win by two goals or more, and Salzburg-Madrid finishes 1-1, then Salzburg will be eliminated. If the Saudi Arabian win by one goal, and Salzburg-Madrid finishes 1-1, then whoever out of Salzburg and Al Hilal has scored more goals in all group matches will advance alongside Madrid. If Red Bull Salzburg lose they will be knocked out only if Al Hilal win. Advertisement Al Hilal: Must beat Pachuca to have any chance of going through. If Al Hilal win and the game between Salzburg and Madrid isn't a draw, then they will advance. If they pick up three points and Salzburg-Madrid finishes level, then whichever of Al Hilal and Salzburg scored more goals in matches between themselves and Madrid will advance alongside the Spanish club. This means that if it is 0-0 in the Salzburg-Madrid match, then Al Hilal will go through and if it is 2-2 or higher, Salzburg will advance. If it is 1-1, then whoever out of Al Hilal and Salzburg has the higher overall goal difference in all group matches will advance alongside Madrid, meaning a two-goal win would send the Saudi Arabian side through. A one-goal win for Al Hilal, in the event of Salzburg-Madrid being 1-1, would mean that whoever out of Al Hilal and Salzburg has scored more goals in all group matches will advance alongside Madrid. Pachuca: The club from Mexico have been eliminated. Match 49: June 28, 12pm ET Lincoln Financial Field, Philadelphia Match 50: June 28, 4pm ET Bank of America Stadium, Charlotte Match 53: June 30, 3pm ET Bank of America Stadium, Charlotte Match 54: June 30, 9pm ET Camping World Stadium, Orlando Match 51: June 29, 12pm ET Mercedes-Benz Stadium, Atlanta Match 52: June 29, 4pm ET Hard Rock Stadium, Miami Match 55: July 1, 3pm ET Hard Rock Stadium, Miami Match 56: July 1, 9pm ET Mercedes-Benz Stadium, Atlanta Match 58: July 4, 9pm ET Lincoln Financial Field, Philadelphia Match 57: July 4, 3pm ET Camping World Stadium, Orlando Match 59: July 5, 12pm ET Mercedes-Benz Stadium, Atlanta Match 60: July 5, 4pm ET MetLife Stadium, New Jersey Match 61: July 8, 3pm ET MetLife Stadium, New Jersey Match 62: July 9, 3pm ET MetLife Stadium, New Jersey Match 63: July 13, 3pm ET MetLife Stadium, New Jersey

USA Today

7 hours ago

• USA Today

Sooners react on social media to Oklahoma City Thunder NBA Championship

THUNDER UP! 🏆 @okcthunder The Oklahoma City Thunder are the champions of the NBA. It is the first title in their short history in OKC, and it took a battle in game seven against a feisty Indiana Pacers team. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander led the Thunder in scoring for the win and earned NBA Finals Most Valuable Player. The whole run was incredible, but their performance in the finals solidified them among the greats of the sport. It was a performance that had all of Oklahoma tuned in to see if the team Sam Presti built. Along the way the Thunder had to win a game seven against the Denver Nuggets and two-time MVP Nikola Jokic. They had to beat another rising star in Anthony Edwards. And finally, the Thunder had to overcome a challenge from a Pacers team led by star guard Tyrese Halliburton and a coach in Rick Carlisle, who won an NBA title with the Dallas Mavericks. The Thunder mesmerized the state of Oklahoma, and Sooners legends, coaches, and players took note, reacting on social media to OKC's title win. OU legend Lane Johnson Linebackers coach Nate Dreiling - Why not OU? OU….. why not us next???? Offensive Coordinator Ben Arbuckle Let em know Coach 🗣️ OU GM Jim Nagy to OKC GM Sam Presti 𝐑𝐄𝐒𝐏𝐄𝐂𝐓🫡#ThunderUp OU Guard Daniel Akinkunmi OKCCCCC Sooner state native turned Dallas Sports Radio Host All we had in OKC growing up were the minor league baseball 89ers and hockey Blazers, and they never won anything. Now, that town has an NBA title. OKC is all grown up. Great for the State We Oklahomans have so many scars. OU fans. OSU fans. Thunder fans. Oklahomans in can never be taken away from us. SEC Network's Dari Nowkah feeling it Thunder the Everliving Heck UPPPPP!!!!!!!!!! 👏🏼👏🏼 Voice of OU Softball The OKC Thunder just won a a team... What a run... and it's just getting startedLet's gooooo A beautiful sight The Devon Tower is gold. #Thunder #OKC An Incredible Run The OKC Thunder just set four notable NBA records:1) +259, best home point differential in a single playoffs2) +131, best turnover differential in a single playoffs3) 19-2, best record following a loss in a single season4) +1247, best point differential in a single season Oklahoma sports fans know how to bring the Thunder Noise meter hit 111 decibelsLoudest of any game this postseasonThunder fans are ready Sooner Dad Reacts Oklahoma vs everybody!!!!!!!! #Boomer #OUDNA Former Oklahoma State star We just witnessed City has climbed the just a win — the birth of a is only the beginning.#ThunderUp 🌩🏆