Madras HC initiates suo motu proceedings against Ponmudy
The Madras high court on Wednesday initiated suo motu proceedings against Tamil Nadu minister K Ponmudy over his recent controversial remarks.
Justice N Anand Venkatesh said Ponmudy's comment was 'prima facie' akin to 'hate speech,' and directed the High Court Registry to place the suo motu case before chief justice K Sriram to decide on the further course of action in the matter.
On April 17, justice Venkatesh took serious note of the issue after an extract of the video containing Ponmudy's remarks was played in open court by a lawyer, during the hearing of a 2023 suo motu revision petition taken up by the court against the minister's acquittal in a case of disproportionate assets. This case was also initiated by justice Venkatesh.
At the time, the judge asked the state police to file an FIR against Ponmudi for his comments made on April 8 during a local meeting. Amid a public uproar over these comments, Ponmudy was also removed by the DMK from his post of the party deputy general secretary.
On Wednesday, when the 2023 revision petition was taken up for hearing, justice Venkatesh noted that the police remained 'motionless' and not taken any action against the minister despite a court order.
Justice Venkatesh said that it was the police's duty to ensure orders of the Supreme Court on curbing hate speech were complied with. The judge also took a strong exception to the submissions made by senior advocate and state's counsel P Wilson, in Ponmudy's defence.
Wilson told the court that several complaints were received by the police against the minister after his comment was circulated on social media. However, the police probed these complaints and closed them after concluding that no case was made against Ponmudy. Wilson also informed the court that the Madurai Bench of the Madras HC had already dismissed two petitions seeking action against Ponmudi over the said remarks.
Justice Venkatesh, however, said there cannot be any tolerance for hate speech. The judge then went on to translate Ponmudy's remarks made in Tamil to English and asked if anyone would speak in such a manner in front of their own families?
The court said that in the April 8 meeting, Ponmudi had narrated story in which a prostitute asked a man if he were a Shaivite or Vaishnavite, before telling him how much she expected to be paid for her services. The court went into further details of the story and Ponmudi's remarks and said it was evident that the minister had not only demeaned the 'moral worth of sex workers,' but he had also intended to 'subvert harmony and peace of various religious groups.'
Senior advocate Vikas Singh, who appeared Ponmudy in the suo motu revision case, argued that the comments had been made in a closed meeting and only a truncated version of the speech had been made public. He also pointed out that Ponmudy had merely been stating something that was part of a story from over 40 years ago.
The court however, underscored that there must be zero tolerance to hate speech, and ordered the Registry to record it had initiated suo motu proceedings against Ponmudi and place the matter before the Chief Justice for further action.
Previously, the Madras High Court had found Ponmudy guilty in December 2023 which had led to his immediate disqualification as a MLA and as minister for Tamil Nadu's higher education. But, in March 2024, the Supreme Court suspended his conviction and four-year jail sentence in a disproportionate assets (DA) case. Following this, he was inducted again into the Stalin-led cabinet.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
44 minutes ago
- The Hindu
More than 3,500 persons with disabilities to be nominated to local bodies in first phase: Chief Minister M.K. Stalin
Chief Minister M.K. Stalin on Saturday announced that under the two new legislations to nominate persons with disabilities to all local bodies in the State, a total of 13,357 members will be appointed to local governance roles. Of them, in the first phase, 650 individuals will be appointed to urban local bodies and 2,984 to rural local bodies, starting from July 1. Speaking at a felicitation function organised by the coordination committee of persons with disabilities to thank him for passing those legislations, Mr. Stalin said applications will be invited district-wise from July 1, and a committee led by the Collector will scrutinise them. A member from the district-level committee of persons with disabilities will also be part of the selection panel, he said. He added that the appointed members could participate in local council meetings and would receive honorariums on a par with elected members. 'I request all representatives of associations working for the welfare of persons with disabilities to continue close collaboration with the government. Let us move towards a truly inclusive society,' he said. 'Today, persons with disabilities are making strides in all sectors and achieving remarkable success by breaking societal barriers. You are proving that people facing challenges due to health conditions, or accidents can overcome them and succeed like anyone else. This is a government for all. That is what some divisive forces and those submissive to them find hard to accept. They cannot tolerate inclusive growth, social justice and equality. These are the very people who attack the DMK government. But the strength to defeat such forces politically comes from the support of the people,' Mr. Stalin said. In his speech, he also recalled at length the contributions of his father and former Chief Minister M. Karunanidhi towards the welfare of persons with disabilities and his efforts in honouring Thiruvalluvar and promoting the Thirukkural.. This was the first public event held at Valluvar Kottam after its recent renovation and infrastructure upgrade at a cost of ₹80 crore. Ministers, officials, representatives of associations for persons with disabilities and activists including Thangam, Jhansi Rani, Simmachandran, Gopinath, Manoharan, Deepak Nathan and Arman Ali were present.
India Gazette
2 hours ago
- India Gazette
DU calls 'Muslim' as language a clerical error after outrage over Urdu omission
New Delhi (India) June 21 (ANI) Delhi University on Saturday clarified that the listing of 'Muslim' as a 'mother tongue' and the omission of Urdu from its undergraduate admission form was a 'clerical error', after the move triggered widespread criticism from academics and civil society. In a statement, the university said, 'The University of Delhi sincerely regrets the inadvertent error in its admission form. We acknowledge your concerns and are committed to addressing them. However, attributing ulterior motives to this entirely unintentional oversight is unwarranted. We request all not to vitiate the University's diverse and harmonious environment.' The clarification came after screenshots of the application portal began circulating online, showing 'Muslim' in the list of languages under the 'mother tongue' section, while Urdu -- a constitutionally recognised language under the Eighth Schedule -- was missing. The university's admission portal was briefly taken down and restored later. While DU has not yet released a detailed explanation on how the error occurred, officials claimed that the form has since been corrected and Urdu reinstated. However, the issue has sparked strong academic and political pushback, with several teachers' groups calling it more than just a technical oversight. 'This is not an innocent mistake,' said Abha Dev Habib, former member of DU's Executive Council. 'The error reflects deep-seated biases -- conflating religion with language is not just ignorant, it's communal.' Faculty members across departments echoed concerns that the incident reflects a 'slippage in institutional integrity'. Dr Mithuraaj Dhusiya, a member of DU's Executive Council, said, 'Mistakes like these damage the university's inclusive image. Urdu is not just a language -- it is an essential part of India's cultural and literary legacy.' The issue has also prompted a wider discussion about linguistic representation in higher education institutions. Rudrashish Chakraborty, a professor at Kirori Mal College, said, 'The portrayal of 'Muslim' as a language suggests a worrying attempt to misrepresent India's largest minority community. Urdu is a secular language spoken by people of all faiths.' Teachers also questioned the language used in the form itself. 'The term 'mother tongue' is colloquial. Academic institutions should instead be using 'native language' or 'first language' for clarity,' said a professor from DU's English department. (ANI)
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
NPF, Nagaland Cong slam Shah remarks on English
Imphal/Dimpaur: The Naga People's Front ( NPF ) has termed the reported comment of Union home minister Amit Shah on English language as "unfortunate" and "disappointing". The Union minister on June 19 reportedly said those who speak English would be ashamed. NPF in a statement said Shah represents the aspirations and sentiments of a diverse and pluralistic nation, his words carry the weight of his office and reflect not only personal opinion but also shape public perception. "The people of India repose their trust in the nation's leaders, especially the Prime Minister and the home minister, as they hold important offices and are expected to uphold the dignity, unity, and inclusive spirit of the country with utmost responsibility and respect," the statement added. To suggest that speaking English is something to be ashamed of is to overlook the pivotal role that the language has played in uniting the diverse country, with 22 officially recognized languages and hundreds of dialects spoken across the nation. "India's linguistic landscape is among the most complex in the world," it added. In such a setting, English has functioned as a bridge language, helping people from different states, ethnicities, and linguistic groups to communicate, collaborate, and coexist, the NPF further added. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now It also pointed out that English has often helped maintain national coherence where linguistic fault lines, provided a neutral, common platform—especially in education, governance, and inter-state relations. NPF is in alliance with BJP in Manipur.
