Waterford find that rough winds and championship structures do shake the darling buds of May
Peter Queally walked into the press conference room in Páirc Uí Chaoimh with his hands buried deep in his pockets. The blank look on his face was just a front. Eight months of training and more than 10 months of planning since his appointment last August had just gone up in smoke.
He spoke about refereeing decisions that reared up in their face and how proud he was of his players, but he didn't become animated until the conversation turned to the championship structure. At one time or another since its introduction in 2018, the provincial round-robin system has been good for every other county in hurling's established top nine, except
Waterford
.
Waterford selector Dan Shanahan and manager Peter Queally saw long months of efforts come to naught against Cork. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
For the GAA, for hurling, for the coffers of the Munster Council, for TV viewing figures, for attendances, for lovers of the game and rubber-neckers alike, for excitement that doesn't need to be spun, for shocks and other stuff that defy explanation, it has been good for everyone. Except Waterford.
In six seasons of the format, they have yet to emerge from the maze. In the two years of the pandemic, when that system was in cold storage, Waterford reached an All-Ireland final, a Munster final and an All-Ireland semi-final. In the year before the system was introduced, they also reached an All-Ireland final. All of that might be coincidental.
READ MORE
Queally's core point was about being habitually eliminated in May and how lunatic it was for intercounty teams to be finished before the summer has started. Long before now, he was familiar with that feeling: much of Queally's career as a Waterford player was in the era of straight knock-out when May was a lethal month all over the country, in football and hurling. In Queally's 14 years in a Waterford jersey he made just 20 appearances in the championship. That was a different kind of brutality.
It is a much-changed environment now. Because the demands are heavier, players who commit to intercounty teams are taking a far greater risk with their time. Queally said that he had conversations with players who couldn't face a winter of training and meaningless league matches, only for their year to be over in the last month of spring.
There was little consolation for Waterford and Shane Bennett after their defeat by Cork. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
He also made the point, which others have made before, that every football team is still alive in the championship. None of the teams that qualified for the Sam Maguire can be eliminated before the middle of June. The stragglers in the Tailteann Cup will be gone next weekend, but the rest will soldier on.
Queally's complaint is the function of an unresolved calendar. This year, the group stages of the hurling championship started before the end of Lent and finished before Gary Lineker. The general kindness of the weather was a miracle.
Consider this ridiculous anomaly. The Derry footballers played their first championship match in 48 days at the weekend. Yet the group stages of the provincial hurling championships were rattled off in 36 days: all 25 matches. It's like slugging a pint of stout in one swallow. Don't stop at the G.
Queally's suggestion for a change in the format, though, went beyond reservations about the calendar. He proposed that the provincial hurling championships should be run off on the same footing as the provincial football championships, followed by a round-robin phase in which – just like football – counties from different provinces would be grouped together.
'Imagine the crowds that would go to a Waterford-Wexford game,' he said, 'or a Waterford-Kilkenny game.'
Since the GAA started changing championship formats around the turn of the century, nothing has been off the table and maybe Queally's proposal will eventually get an airing.
This year's Leinster hurling championship lacked zest because the usual shock results were absent. The Munster hurling championship was deflated by a couple of blowouts and Clare's weary implosion. It was the first year in six when both round-robin championships failed to meet feverish expectations. Looking into the future, a five-out-of-six strike rate is unsustainable.
Is that a cause for worry? The Leinster football championship has survived, unaltered, on strike rate of about three or four out of 15 since 2010. Maybe that's being generous. I lost count. The Munster football championship has continued at a similar basement level of punter/player/pundit satisfaction over the same period. That's evidently safe from reform too.
Cork's Brian Hayes goes past Gavin Fives and goalkeeper Billy Nolan of Waterford to score his side's opening goal on Sunday. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
It is tough for Waterford to peer into Leinster where the scrap for third place is typically between Dublin and Wexford, both of whom operate around Waterford's level. In the round-robin format, Galway have not always been formidable either. Waterford would flourish among that set of teams.
But the attractiveness of the Munster championship is precisely that it is so cut-throat. Queally made that point too. 'We know how unforgiving the Munster championship is,' he said. 'That's the beauty of it.' In a later answer he said, 'We all want the cut and thrust of the Munster championship. We don't want to take from that.'
In that case, two teams must suffer every year. It is heartbreaking that Waterford have suffered so much, but there is no way of softening it. The current format has broken attendance records in Munster for the third year in a row. It is the suspense and the smell of blood that brings the crowds back, year after year.
But Queally is right about May. That is a scandal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
39 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Donegal power past Louth into quarter-finals
It took a while, but Donegal eventually put their experience to use in MacCumhaill Park, Ballybofey, as they eased through to the All-Ireland quarter-finals with a 16-point win over Louth. The Wee County put it up to Donegal in the opening half, but a second goal from Ciaran Thompson on 49 minutes put the home side on their way. Thompson, playing in his 50th championship game for the county, took a crossfield pass from Oisin Gallen to find the corner of the net. The score put Donegal 2-11 to 0-09 ahead and from there the Louth challenge faded and the home side were able to keep the scoreboard ticking, finishing with 12 different scorers. The large attendance of 15,369 were not give much to shout about in the opening half as both sides played it cagey. Donegal were really lacklustre in what was a very poor spectacle in the opening half. Peadar Mogan, as happens often, opened the scoring and Donegal looked to be in control after 15 minutes, leading by 0-5 to 0-1, Conor O'Donnell, Oisin Gallen, Michael Murphy and Finnbarr Roarty adding to their total. Paul Matthews had the lone Louth point. Craig Lennon added a second point while Donegal had a great goal opportunity which Oisin Gallen spurned. The miss seemed to inspire Louth and especially Ryan Burns as he hit three points in as many minutes to tie up the game on 24 minutes. Gallen and Dara McDonnell traded scores before Donegal got the goal they threatened. It came from a long kick-out by Shaun Patton which found Oisin Gallen and he sent Conor O'Donnell through to fire to the net. Donegal did have possession as the hooter sounded but Louth turned them over and Ryan Burns hit the last score of the half to leave just two between them - Donegal 1-06 Louth 0-07. Sam Mulroy opened the second half account for Louth with a free but they only managed one more score (Mulroy from play) until the 62nd minute and by that stage Donegal were able to substitute Michael Murphy, Ryan McHugh and Eoghan Bán Gallagher. There will be tougher tests ahead for Donegal, who had 11 wides, while several shots dropped short. Scorers Donegal: Oisin Gallen 0-5; Conor O'Donnell 1-2; Ciaran Thompson 1-0; Michael Langan 0-3, 1tp; Michael Murphy 0-3, 1tp 1f; Finnbarr Roarty, Daire Ó Baoill 0-2; Peadar Mogan, Shane O'Donnell, Niall O'Donnell, Caolan McColgan, Hugh McFadden 0-1 Louth: Ryan Burns 0-4; Sam Mulroy 0-3, 1f; Paul Matthews, Craig Lennon, Dara McDonnell, Peter Lynch, Ciaran Downey 0-1 Donegal: Shaun Patton, Finnbarr Roarty, Brendan McCole, Peadar Mogan; Ryan McHugh, Eoghan Bán Gallagher, Caolan McColgan; Jason McGee, Michael Langan; Ciaran Moore, Ciarán Thompson, Shane O'Donnell; Conor O'Donnell, Michael Murphy, Oisín Gallen. Subs: Hugh McFadden for McGee (half-time), Dare Ó Baoill for McHugh (49), Patrick McBrearty for Murphy (51); Niall O'Donnell and Odhrán McFadden Ferry for C O'Donnell and Gallagher (54) Louth: Niall McDonnell; Daire Nally, Dermot Campbell, Donal McKenny; Emmet Carolan, Peter Craig, Craig Lennon; Tommy Durnin, Dara McDonnell; Conall McKeever, Ciaran Downey, Paul Matthews; Dan Corcoran, Sam Mulroy, Ryan Burns. Subs: Conor Grimes for Carolan (half-time), Seán Callaghan for Durnin (48), Ryan Walsh for Matthews (51), Kieran McArdle for Lennon (53), Ciaran Byrne for R Burns (56)
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Relentless Down give Galway huge test but experience sees Pádraic Joyce's contenders through
All-Ireland SFC preliminary quarter-final: Down 3-21 Galway 2-26 Another Sunday, another stone-cold thriller. Down gave Galway their bellyful it here, chasing Padraic Joyce's side manfully and relentlessly right to the very last drop. They came up short, mostly because they'll be playing Division 3 football next year while Galway are a top table side and have been for a while. On the evidence of this summer, it won't be too long before Down grab themselves a seat too. Conor Laverty's team are a world removed from where they were when he took over in late 2002. Back then, they hadn't won a game for a year and the traffic at the dressingroom door was flowing out rather than in. A world where they would run a credible All-Ireland contender like Galway to two points must have seemed beyond fanciful back then. 'I wasn't coming here hoping that Down would play well,' Laverty said afterwards. 'I came here with a massive belief that these players could perform at this level and that this is the standard we want to be playing at. But what we did talk to the players about was, do you want to be coming here to Páirc Esler to be playing a preliminary quarter-final in front of 14,000 people? 'Or would you rather be playing ... I came to a league match here against Clare one year and there wasn't 150 people at it. Or Tailteann Cup games where there were only a couple of hundred people there. This is where players want to be. We would have felt that in games this year, it's been experience that has held us back slightly in key moments.' READ MORE Down's Pierce Laverty in action against Galway's John Maher. Photograph: James Lawlor/Inpho Ultimately, that was probably Galway's thumb on the scale here. When the stadium was bubbling midway through the second half as Down dominated midfield, Joyce was able to bring Peter Cooke in off the bench. Cooke has been a here-again-gone-again presence for Galway down the years but he made his debut in 2016 so he knows the road. He was able to steer Galway home. Cooke caught a world of ball, scored a point and laid on the sealing goal for Tomo Culhane. All of which meant that brave and all as Down had been, the home side were never able to cut the margin below two points. 'We were battle-hardened before today but we're battle-hardened again,' was Joyce's take on it all. And so they were. Though Cooke saw them through the endgame, Galway were in position thanks in the main to a couple of effervescent displays from Matthew Thompson and Shane Walsh. Thompson in particular looks like a nailed-on Young Footballer of the Year, pulling the strings out the pitch year like someone with a decade under his belt rather than just a few months. Walsh popped up with 1-7 in the first half, including three two-pointers and a goal that oozed class. In the space of two minutes just before half-time, he landed a two-pointer from play, laid on a goal for Rob Finnerty, skinned Ceilum Doherty for a one-pointer, then caught the kickout and drove on to draw a foul outside the arc, which he duly converted. Seán Fitzgerald in action for Galway. Photograph: James Lawlor/Inpho He got injured in the process, landing on his shoulder, and barely had a kick after half-time before being taken off. 'He got a nasty injury,' Joyce said. 'He fell forward and the Down player followed through with the knee on the shoulder so he's in a bit of a bother there with the shoulder.' That burst just before half-time looked like it had put the game out of reach for Down. They went from being just a point behind in the 28th minute to going in at the break on the thick end of a 1-16 to 1-6 scoreline. Even though there was a stiff breeze blowing straight down the ground, it still looked fairly insurmountable for Laverty's side. But Down didn't take a backward step. They had a couple of two-pointers on the board within 69 seconds of the restart. Odhran Murdock was phenomenal, the 22-year-old Down captain running in 1-2 from midfield and pushing his side forward at every opportunity. Caolan Mooney rolled back the years off the bench, whistling through for back-to-back points to make it 1-20 to 1-18 with a quarter-hour to go. Galway were rocking now, their kickout in such peril that Joyce had replacement goalkeeper Connor Gleeson warming up a couple of times. But gradually they got a foothold around the middle again, with Cooke and Cian Darcy settling them. When Cooke put Culhane away in the 65th minute, the Galway sub iced the game. It was tough on Down goalkeeper Ronan Burns who had made a string of brilliant saves but wasn't quite up to this one. Down's day in microcosm. They gave Galway a huge test here. Expect it to stand to both of them. DOWN: R Burns; P McCarthy, P Fegan, C Doherty (0-0-1); R Magill (1-0-0), P Laverty, M Rooney (0-1-0); D Guinness (0-2-0), R McEvoy (0-1-0); D Magill (0-0-2), O Murdock (1-0-2), A Crimmins (0-0-1, 1f); J Guinness (0-0-1), P Havern (0-0-2, 2f), J McGeough (1-0-1). Subs: E Branagan (0-0-1) for McCarthy (21-26 mins, blood); Branagan for McCarthy (h-t); C Mooney (0-0-2) for McGeough (55); O Savage for Doherty (57); C McCrickard for Crimmins (62); F Murdock for Rooney (66). GALWAY: C Flaherty; J McGrath, S Fitzgerald, L Silke; D McHugh, S Kelly, C Hernon; P Conroy, J Maher; C Darcy (0-0-1), M Tierney (0-0-2), C McDaid (0-0-2); R Finnerty (0-1-4, 1f), S Walsh (1-3-1, 2tpf), M Thompson (0-1-3). Subs: P Cooke (0-0-1) for Conroy (48 mins); D O'Flaherty (0-0-2) for Hernon (57); J Heaney for McDaid (61-69, temp); T Culhane (1-0-0) for Walsh (62); J Daly for Maher (67). Referee: D O'Mahoney (Tipperary).
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
'It looks a nasty injury': Shane Walsh a doubt for Galway's quarter-final
Shane Walsh is again an injury worry for Pádraic Joyce ahead of Galway's forthcoming All-Ireland quarter-final after damaging his shoulder in Newry. Walsh picked up the problem in winning a two-point free off Peter Fegan in the 30th minute of this preliminary quarter-final win over Down. He went down again in the 62nd minute before sending over a two-pointer off his left foot to bring his personal total to 1-7, his last act before being replaced. Joyce admitted it is a concern ahead of going to Croke Park. 'Yeah, he got a nasty injury, he fell forward and the Down player followed through with the knee on the shoulder so he's a bit of a bother there with the shoulder. 'We left him on there for 10 minutes just to see how he got on but he's getting no better so we'll assess him here, we'll go back and see what it is, it looks a nasty injury.' It is unfortunate for Galway as the 32-year-old delivered in spades for the second game in a row following a slow start in Páirc Esler. 'After 15 minutes, he got into the game and got the shackles off a bit but he kicked a couple of great twos, kicked the free and kicked the goal as well so yeah he was quite sharp,' said his manager. Joyce was delighted to see his players answer some of their critics with a win that displayed character in staving off Down at the end. 'People are saying we don't play for 70 minutes. I think we got a good performance there for the full 70 minutes overall. 'You're never going to get things your own way. There was two (teams) knocked out yesterday and two knocked out today, so we're down to the last eight. That's where we're at. We know where we are, we're happy enough to be there. 'We've work to do, and we just can't perform like that next week whoever we are playing in the quarter-finals. If we concede that kind of score, we're going to be in trouble.' Joyce hopes Galway will be afforded a Sunday quarter-final to give them a seven-day build-up in what will be their third game in 15 days but won't be seeking it. 'Look, we put ourselves in that situation so we're not going to be complaining. We'll get on with it. We'll get back down the road tonight but again the big thing for us is that we've had three long journeys. We've been in Celtic Park, we've been to Breffni Park and we're in Newry so they're huge journeys, they're two days travel and then trying to recover and get back down the road. 'We left Galway yesterday at 1pm and we won't get home until about 10pm tonight so that's part of it but it's a privilege to be playing for Galway, being involved in Galway we could be at worse things on the weekends, to be honest.' As Conor Flaherty struggled to find Galway men with his second half kick-outs, Joyce twice called for Connor Gleeson to get ready to enter the game but ultimately opted against it as Flaherty turned things around. 'We kicked away two, three, four but we've two good keepers in Galway. The wind was really, really strong as well and probably Connor Gleeson would have had a bit more distance but we didn't opt for it in the end. 'In fairness to Conor Flaherty, he gathered himself at the end there and the two or three last kick-outs were really, really good to our main guys. Cein Darcy caught some brilliant ball again and Peter Cooke made a huge impact when he came off the bench as well so yeah, happy enough with it.'
