Platense who? Club World Cup is another step on the road to a global super league

Last Sunday, in the northern Argentinian city of Santiago del Estero, Platense beat Huracán 1-0 to win Argentina's Apertura, the decisive goal a beautiful dipping effort struck at the top of the bounce by Guido Mainero. It was the first title in the club's 120‑year history and provoked scenes of extraordinary emotion.
Platense are one of Argentina's quirkier clubs. They are nicknamed the Squid because their original ground was built on a marsh and the story grew that they played better in wet conditions when, as the journalist Antonio Palacio Zino put it, 'the boys moved like squid in their ink'. The boggy conditions are also supposedly why they wear brown after an early director thought it would help to hide mud stains; the real reason is probably that their first members agreed to wear the colours of a jockey who won a particular race.
None of their fans expected anything like this. Just as it has been for the rash of other rare winners across the world in recent months, for Newcastle, for Crystal Palace, for Aberdeen, for Union Saint-Gilloise, for VfB Stuttgart, it was a time for reflection, to remember friends and family long since passed who would have loved to have been there. 'At a time like this,' one of their joint managers, Favio Orsi, said, 'I think of my old man. I owe football to my old man. I thank life for everything I shared with him.'
If asked by a sceptic why football matters, this is what you would point to, its capacity to foster community, reflection and a stirring nostalgia: 'It is so sad to know that those days, win or lose, can't return. Nor those remember faces be gathered in one place again,' as JL Carr's narrator has it in his remarkable novel How Steeple Sinderby Wanderers Won the FA Cup.
Now, imagine you are a supervillain. You sit in your sinister mountain lair, all gleaming black stone and discreet lighting, stroking a cat and occasionally cackling manically. You care nothing for this euphoric purity. What you care about is power. You recognise the appeal of the smaller clubs and their fairytales, but that only obstructs your grand plans. You need to destabilise and destroy, and you decide the best way to do that is to create a cadre of super-clubs so wealthy that they render their domestic leagues farcical, drawing them ultimately towards a global super league.
Nobody is saying that's what Fifa is doing. Quite apart from anything else it would require a degree of organisational competence that has not been obviously apparent in the planning of the Club World Cup. But if that were what our supervillain were doing, how different would it look to the Club World Cup?
The financial stratification of the game is already a major problem. Over the past decade it has become standard for European leagues to be dominated by one or two clubs. The evidence of last season suggested the Premier League may have stumbled into a more equitable situation by dint of the combination of extremely high broadcast deals and profit and sustainability rules (at significant cost to the Championship and the rest of the world), but even that would be challenged by the impact of the Club World Cup, most of it funded by Saudi Arabia and Qatar.
The Saudi Public Investment Fund had already invested in DAZN, which bought the broadcast rights for the Club World Cup, when on Thursday it became an official partner of the competition. Qatar Airways had been named as a partner 48 hours earlier. It's not usual for major sponsorship deals such as this to be concluded less than a fortnight before the opening game.
Were Chelsea, say, to win the Club World Cup, they would receive around £100m in prize money and participation fees, a month's work for what a lower mid-table side would make in Premier League prize money for an entire season.
The Premier League isn't really the problem here. It is big enough and rich enough that it can just about absorb one club suddenly being handed £100m. But other leagues are not. Auckland City play in the Dettol Northern League, an amateur competition in New Zealand's North Island. Even if they lose every game in the group stage, they will receive £2.64m for participation. The Northern League caps player expenses at £70 a week. It's been widely reported that clubs circumvent that so some players might be making as much as £350 a week. In that environment, £2.64m goes a very long way.
Or take the example of Platense. Their prize money for winning the Apertura last week was £370,000. There are two Argentinian representatives in the Club World Cup: Boca Juniors and River Plate. Even if they lose every game, they will each get £11.25m for participation. Turn up, and they get 30 times as much as the winners of the domestic championship (albeit there are two champions every season in Argentina). Imagine Boca beat Auckland City: there's another £1.5m. Say, Boca or River progress to the last 16: there's £5m more.
Sign up to Football Daily
Kick off your evenings with the Guardian's take on the world of football
after newsletter promotion
Even given the complicated financial situations at most clubs in Argentina, it would be an extraordinary dereliction to fail to convert that into domination, particularly given the advantages the big two already enjoy.
Even if it remains as a competition held every four years – and rumours swirl of aspirations to make it biennial – for most sides, participation in the Club World Cup should become self‑perpetuating, a couple of dozen clubs almost infinitely wealthier than their domestic rivals. What then would the future be?
Our cat-stroking supervillain is thinking of a global super league that would diminish the domination of Uefa and the Champions League, which would suit Fifa very nicely. Coincidentally the Fifa president, Gianni Infantino, did try, with limited success, to establish an African super league that risked upsetting the delicate balance of local leagues and destroying the rivalries that have sustained the game there for decades.
It's worth reiterating that nobody is saying that is Fifa's grand plan. But that the financial distortion of leagues does feel like the sort of thing that an effective global governing body should be considering, perhaps even guarding against.
As it is, Fifa is engineering it.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Telegraph

32 minutes ago

• Telegraph

The Lions gaffes that must be eradicated in Australia

Tom Curry and Fin Smith joined Andy Farrell, their British and Irish Lions head coach, in delivering scathing assessments of Friday evening's 28-24 loss to Argentina, stressing that wastefulness cannot continue in Australia. The Lions' defeat was characterised by inaccurate offloads that coughed up possession and Farrell slammed his team's 'error rate' in Dublin, suggesting that they 'lost enough ball for a full tour'. Curry, who played 80 minutes at blindside flanker, was particularly frustrated. 'The biggest point is that we need to be more clinical with the ball,' he said. 'The exciting thing is that we have got people in position, people are running, but, f---, we can't score points if we are dropping it and giving it away that easily. That comes first and foremost.' "Not acceptable... dissapointed" ‼️ Andy Farrell's scathing assessment of the Lions defeat 🗣️ — Sky Sports (@SkySports) June 20, 2025 Like Farrell, the 27-year-old refused to point to a lack of familiarity – either between players or with a new attacking system – as justification. On his second Lions tour to follow 2021, Curry is hoping to eradicate sloppiness as quickly as possible with the Test series set to get under way on July 19. 'I have been on these things before and you can wait until Monday before you say this stuff, but you can get to the sixth week and still make the same excuse,' he added. 'Six weeks is not a long time so we can't make that excuse the whole way through [the tour]. We nipped that in the bud straight away. We need to take personal responsibility for our own performances and how excited we get on the ball. 'That is the really annoying thing, because on the flip side it's really exciting because we do have our hands on the ball and are in great spots. But come on, we need to take personal responsibility when we have it.' Forcing passes out of contact became a recurring and debilitating feature of the Lions performance. On the half-hour mark, Tommy Freeman arced off his wing behind the run of Bundee Aki and freed his arms, only for Sione Tuipulotu to drop a deft pass: Freeman should not shoulder all the blame for this, given he had a clear line of sight to Tuipulotu and lifted the ball into the path of his centre. It could probably be categorised as a constructive mistake. Around four minutes later, though, came a riskier effort. Having roamed across from the Lions' right wing and stepped up at first receiver, Freeman fixed two defenders and attempted to flip the ball to Marcus Smith. The latter seemed to call for a pass, but has overrun his team-mate by the time the ball is released: Other mix-ups in the second half were even less excusable and will have caused Farrell even more angst. Luke Cowan-Dickie spun through a tackle but was intercepted by Lucio Cinti as he aimed to link up with Fin Smith: Tadhg Furlong made ground around the fringes of a ruck before an aimless offload went to Gonzalo García, the Argentina scrum-half: Tuipulotu had a tumbling pass snaffled by Tomás Albornoz as well, and Curry admitted that the Lions had gone against the principles Farrell had outlined in training. 'Andy's been hot on [how] you've got to see your pass and know someone is there,' he said. 'There were key moments today when that didn't happen. That's what I'm saying – we can't say it in training and not do it in a game.' Successful offloads, such as one from Marcus Smith to Freeman in the first half as well as the interplay between Tuipulotu and Fin Smith that led to Aki's try, can carve open defences. As he urges greater caution, Farrell will not want to stifle creativity. The line-out was another scruffy area for the Lions and Curry pinpointed a gaffe with nine minutes remaining – when Ronan Kelleher's throw sailed over the top without the Lions even hoisting a jumper into the air – as another costly mistake. 'It's either a body language thing or we didn't communicate to the hooker well enough,' he explained. 'It's one of those two.' After spending 80 minutes at fly-half, Fin Smith was equally disheartened. 'I'm gutted, pretty deflated,' he said. 'It's probably not how I saw my first Lions cap going. I'm sure once I take the emotion out of it, the sun will come up tomorrow and we'll review it. Hopefully we can take stuff out of it but, yeah, it's incredibly disappointing.' Amid encouraging flashes, the Lions suffered from clunky moments in which a lack of cohesion derailed them. One such lapse occurred in the 76th minute after a scrum had earned the Lions a penalty advantage. Fin Smith fed Tuipulotu and wrapped around his centre, only for a pull-back pass to drop on to the turf: The Lions' hope is that execution matches up with their ambition and Fin Smith admitted that he might have reviewed the footage as soon as the early hours of Saturday morning. 'We don't feel too far away but I might watch that back and it will feel miles away,' said the Northampton Saints playmaker. 'We're not where we need to be, which is the main thing.' 'I'm sure it's not the first time the Lions have not played particularly well in their first outing,' Smith added. 'The main thing is how quickly we can respond and how quickly we can stop feeling sorry for ourselves. We need to get back on the training pitch and get better as quickly as possible.' Farrell's message has been for the tourists to refrain from moping or sulking, even if the long-haul flight to Perth, where the Lions face Western Force on Saturday in their first game on Australian soil, will present ample opportunity to study video clips of hasty offloads and other technical hitches. As the Lions all acknowledge, Argentina have handed them a wake-up call. Actions, not words, are required to regain impetus.

The Independent

42 minutes ago

• The Independent

Tom Curry urges Lions to make most of Australia tour after Argentina setback

Tom Curry has warned his British and Irish team-mates they can not afford to waste a moment in their search for respect as they target an immediate response to their defeat by Argentina. The Lions arrived in Perth on Sunday smarting from the 28-24 loss at the Aviva Stadium that drew a scathing assessment from head coach Andy Farrell, who refused to blame the squad's lack of familiarity for the setback. Western Force provide the first opportunity to make amends for the error-strewn opener and Curry, a tourist with the elite of British and Irish rugby in 2021, knows time is of the essence if the team are to be ready to face Australia. 'The thing with this sport and this tour is that it comes and goes so quickly. You've got to make the most of it,' the England flanker said. 'Every meeting and every session. Before you know it we'll be playing in Australia so we can't let moments pass us by. 'We speak a lot about respect with our own team-mates. We've only got six weeks together. Respect is so hard to earn but so easy to lose. 'It's really important that every session and meeting we turn up and push in the right direction. 'We have got to pull tighter, it's the only way. I feel like this group has taken so many steps off the field. I haven't got a bad word to say about anyone.' Against Argentina the Lions showed ambition in attack and dominated at the scrum, but the vast number of handling errors, malfunctioning line-out and vulnerability in the air are areas of pressing concern. Curry, who impressed outside of his own dropped passes, echoed Farrell's warning that a lack of time together must not be seen as a barrier to success on the tour. 'We've nipped that in the bud straight away. You can get to the sixth week and still make the same excuse. Six weeks is not a long time so we can't make that excuse the whole way through,' he said. 'We need to take personal responsibility for our own performances and how excited we get on the ball. 'On the flip side, it's really exciting because we got our hands on the ball and got into great spots. But come on, we need to take personal responsibility for the ball when we have it.' Fin Smith made his Lions debut in Dublin and the England fly-half feels the need to rally as quickly as possible following the disappointment against Argentina. 'I'm sure it's not the first time the Lions have not played particularly well in their first outing,' Smith said. 'The main thing is how quickly we can respond and how quickly we can stop feeling sorry for ourselves. We need to get back on the training pitch and get better as quickly as possible. 'No moping about, no sulking. We need to get back on the horse straight away and have conversations that are going to make us better. That's definitely the aim.'

BBC News

2 hours ago

• BBC News

Wales enjoy 'unreal' send-off for Euro 2025

"The hard work starts now with a week in Portugal."Excitement ahead of Euro 2025 reached new heights as Wales set off from Cardiff Airport to Portugal on Sunday afternoon, but the message from captain Angharad James was simple.'Good luck Wales' and 'C'mon Cymru' (come on Wales) were among the messages plastered across cards and banners as fans got the chance to bid farewell to those who are set to embark on what they hope will be the summer of a lifetime.A steel band played in front of the terminal entrance as players, along with head coach Rhian Wilkinson, posed for photographs with supporters and signed the dream will have started to feel even more real, with Wales holding a week-long training camp in the Algarve in preparation for their tournament opener against Netherlands in Lucerne on 5 midfielder James feels Wales are fully deserving of their place on the grandest stage."This group of players deserve this. We work so hard," she added. Having announced her 23-player squad for the Euros from the summit of Yr Wyddfa, also known as Snowdon last week, Wilkinson was eager to follow in the footsteps of Craig Bellamy's men's side who also used the training facilities in the south of Portugal in preparation for their recent World Cup qualifiers with Liechtenstein and Canada-born manager, 43, has regularly stated her desire to see Wales enjoy themselves in Switzerland next month, while also wanting her side to compete with the was a message typified by Hannah Cain - scorer of the opener in Wales' crucial 2-1 victory over Republic of Ireland on 3 December, a result that earned Wilkinson's side their place at the upcoming tournament."It's unreal," the Leicester City forward said of the welcome at the airport."We didn't know this was all going to be here, it's amazing."But focusing on the task ahead, Cain said: "We just want to win as many games as possible and have the best time ever." At 38 years of age, Jess Fishlock is the most senior member of the travelling Wales Seattle Reign midfielder - whose tally of 162 caps and 47 goals for her country are records - is perhaps the most deserving of a place on the plane given her remarkable contributions in the Welsh jersey since making her senior debut against the Swiss in Fishlock paid a touching tribute to those who had made their way to Rhoose to deliver the perfect send off for the history-making Welsh squad."This is beautiful and it means so much to local clubs. It's everything we've ever wanted," she 23 squad players and boss Wilkinson posed together for one final photograph for the assembled media from the aeroplane's staircase prior to boarding the Boeing aircraft itself was given one last send off prior to leaving the Welsh tarmac as it rolled between two fire and rescue trucks spraying water to give a cannon salute - traditionally reserved for a plane's first is undoubtedly aware of the scale of the task that lies ahead for Wales - who face France on 9 July and England on 13 July after their opener against the the 31-year-old issued something of a warning to those who are underestimating Wilkinson's team."We're excited for the challenge. People think Wales will be easy, but we won't, we always give 100%," concluded the 132-cap international.