Japan's top court expected to rule excluding sex industry from COVID grants constitutional
TOKYO -- Japan's Supreme Court is expected to finalize a decision upholding the constitutionality of government regulations excluding a business in the sex industry from eligibility for COVID-19 grants, which the plaintiff argue violates Article 14 of the Constitution guaranteeing equality under the law.
The Supreme Court's First Petty Bench, overseen by Justice Mitsuko Miyagawa, decided May 26 to set June 16 as the date for its ruling on an appeal by a sex business operator. Because the court will not hold the oral arguments necessary to review the high court's decision, the two lower court rulings -- which found the exclusion constitutional and rejected the business operator's claims -- are expected to stand.
The plaintiff is a so-called "delivery health" company in the Kansai region that dispatches sex workers. In September 2020, the company applied to the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency for a 2-million-yen (about $14,000) sustainability grant and about 1 million yen in rent support, citing decreased sales due to the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the applications were denied under the exclusion regulations. The company then sued the government for a total of about 4.5 million yen ($31,600), including 1.5 million yen ($10,500) in damages in addition to the two grants.
In the lawsuit, the government argued that sex industry businesses, which provide temporary sexual gratification for a fee from customers, "contradict the sexual moral standards shared by the majority of citizens," and that it was inappropriate to support such businesses with public funds. In June 2022, the Tokyo District Court ruled that the exclusion "is based on reasonable grounds and does not constitute discrimination, and thus does not violate the Constitution," dismissing the business's claim.
The Tokyo High Court's October 2023 appeal verdict acknowledged that while public values regarding sexuality are diversifying, there remains a negative mindset toward publicly recognizing sex-related entertainment businesses. It concluded that the government's decision to exclude such businesses from eligibility for grants because of the difficulty in gaining the understanding of taxpayers was "not unreasonable and did not exceed the discretion of the administrative agency," upholding the district court ruling.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yomiuri Shimbun
13 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Housing Problems: Prevent Real Estate Firms from Targeting Elderly, Forcing Home Sales
With real estate prices soaring, unscrupulous businesses have in many instances forced elderly people to sell their homes. The government must quickly take measures to address this issue. There have been many disputes due to leaseback contracts, under which homeowners sell their property to real estate companies and use the proceeds as rent to continue living in their home. According to the National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan, it received 239 requests for consultation on this issue last fiscal year, 10 times more requests than it saw five years ago. In one case, a woman in her 70s, facing financial difficulties, sold her condominium unit to a real estate agent for ¥16 million on the condition that she could continue living there for ¥60,000 per month in rent. However, the rent was suddenly raised to ¥110,000, and she said she was pressured to move out if she could not pay. In another instance, a person was persistently pushed to sign a contract and charged a ¥6 million penalty when they sought to cancel the contract later. In other cases, homeowners were forced to sell their homes at prices far below the market rate. Most of the people who sought consultations at the center were elderly people with a diminished ability to make judgments. Real estate prices are rising, particularly in urban areas. Businesses seem to be using slick words to purchase homes and resell them at higher prices for a profit. Such unscrupulous business practices targeting the vulnerable cannot be overlooked. The leaseback system itself is not inherently problematic. Use of the system has been expanding, such as in cases in which homeowners looking to move into care facilities want to sell off their homes to raise the funds they need while continuing to live at home until a spot for them opens up. The problem lies in how some companies repeatedly make aggressive solicitation. During the COVID-19 pandemic, it seems there was an increase in cases in which companies approached isolated elderly people and proposed buying their home. It is said that these unscrupulous companies often do not properly explain the terms of the contracts, such as the duration of the lease after the sale, rent increases and penalties for canceling. It is not uncommon for elderly people sign contracts without fully understanding these terms. In some cases, relatives living elsewhere have trouble detecting the sale because the elderly individual continues to live in the same home. The government needs to establish specific guidelines on what companies need to explain before a contract is signed and how to prevent disputes over the way in which firms understand customer intentions. Real estate industry groups should also create rules proscribing unscrupulous solicitation. In the insurance industry, the Financial Services Agency has presented guidelines for when companies sell to elderly people, requiring that family members be present, discussions be recorded and sufficient time be given for consideration. Such measures could serve as a reference. For an elderly person, it is a major blow to lose the home they have grown accustomed to. Family members and others around the elderly should be on the lookout for any unusual changes. (From The Yomiuri Shimbun, June 22, 2025)
Kyodo News
21 hours ago
- Kyodo News
U.S. asked Japan to raise defense spending to 3.5% of GDP
KYODO NEWS - 12 hours ago - 20:15 | All, Japan, World U.S. President Donald Trump's administration has asked Japan to raise its defense spending to 3.5 percent of gross domestic product, a request that will likely prompt Tokyo to call off a planned high-level meeting with Washington, a Japan-U.S. diplomatic source said Saturday. The request was made recently by Elbridge Colby, U.S. undersecretary of defense for policy, the Financial Times has reported, citing people familiar with the matter. Colby, a seasoned strategist, had previously pressed Japan to increase its defense spending to 3 percent of its GDP. The increased demand will likely lead Japan to cancel a planned meeting of the countries' foreign and defense chiefs, which was scheduled in Washington before Japan's House of Councillors election, expected on July 20. The meeting would have been the first since Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba and Trump took office in October and January, respectively. Kyodo News reported in late May that Japan and the United States were considering holding the so-called two-plus-two security talks in Washington this summer. Japan and the United States had not formally said such talks, as held in July last year in Tokyo, would take place. In 2022, after Trump's first term, Japan decided to double its annual defense budget to 2 percent of GDP by 2027, a dramatic move in postwar security policy under the country's war-renouncing Constitution. But Trump continues to complain that the U.S.-Japan security treaty is one-sided, with his administration apparently planning to ask Tokyo to pay more for American troops based in the Japanese archipelago once bilateral negotiations over his tariffs proceed.
Kyodo News
a day ago
- Kyodo News
U.S. asked Japan to raise defense spending to 3.5% of GDP
KYODO NEWS - 8 minutes ago - 20:15 | All, Japan, World U.S. President Donald Trump's administration has asked Japan to raise its defense spending to 3.5 percent of gross domestic product, a request that will likely prompt Tokyo to call off a planned high-level meeting with Washington, a Japan-U.S. diplomatic source said Saturday. The request was made recently by Elbridge Colby, U.S. undersecretary of defense for policy, the Financial Times has reported, citing people familiar with the matter. Colby, a seasoned strategist, had previously pressed Japan to increase its defense spending to 3 percent of its GDP. The increased demand will likely lead Japan to cancel a planned meeting of the countries' foreign and defense chiefs, which was scheduled in Washington before Japan's House of Councillors election, expected on July 20. The meeting would have been the first since Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba and Trump took office in October and January, respectively. Kyodo News reported in late May that Japan and the United States were considering holding the so-called two-plus-two security talks in Washington this summer. Japan and the United States had not formally said such talks, as held in July last year in Tokyo, would take place. In 2022, after Trump's first term, Japan decided to double its annual defense budget to 2 percent of GDP by 2027, a dramatic move in postwar security policy under the country's war-renouncing Constitution. But Trump continues to complain that the U.S.-Japan security treaty is one-sided, with his administration apparently planning to ask Tokyo to pay more for American troops based in the Japanese archipelago once bilateral negotiations over his tariffs proceed.
