England's Stokes criticised for ‘staggering' decision to put India into bat
Michael Vaughan, the former Yorkshire and England batter, said he was 'staggered' that Ben Stokes chose to bowl first after winning the toss on the opening day of the Test series against India. The tourists proceeded to plunder 359 runs for the loss of three wickets on a flat pitch with Yashasvi Jaiswal and the new captain, Shubman Gill, both scoring centuries.
Sign up to The Spin
Subscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week's action
after newsletter promotion
The last six Tests played at Headingley had all ended in victory for the side that bowled first, and Vaughan accused England of making their decision based on the history books rather than the conditions on the day. 'I am an old-school traditionalist here at Leeds that when the sun is shining, with dry weather, you bat,' said Vaughan, who played 51 first-class matches at Headingley including four as England captain. 'I was staggered when [Stokes] said he was going to bowl. Traditions are out the window. You have to pick your decisions on that moment, and not things that you did here years ago.'
Tim Southee, the former New Zealand seamer working as England's bowling consultant, said they had been swayed by the green tinge to the surface on Thursday, before it received its final trim overnight. 'With the colour of the wicket yesterday and a little bit of moisture left in it, there was going to be a little bit in it this morning. That was the thinking behind the decision,' he said.
'I think there was a little bit of assistance there [in the first hour], but for the rest of the day it was a pretty good surface, which is encouraging for our guys when we get an opportunity to bat. I guess when you win the toss and bowl you expect to make early inroads, but they negotiated that first hour or so pretty well. We've got a new ball still, so hopefully tomorrow morning we can make the most of that and make some early inroads.'
England's decision at the toss may have been intended to expose the relative inexperience in these conditions of India's top order: of the five players to bat on Friday Jaiswal was playing his first Test in this country, Gill his fourth, and Sai Sudharsan – who got a four-ball duck – was making his Test debut. 'Credit to the Indian batsmen – Jaiswal and Gill played a couple of great hands there,' Southee said. 'They've not played a lot of cricket but they're certainly talented cricketers.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
44 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ollie Pope century silences critics as England fight back against India
Ollie Pope repaid England's faith and banished further questions over his place as his fine century helped turn the tables on day two of the first Test against India. Pope's grip on the number three spot looked shaky at the start of the summer as Jacob Bethell pushed hard for the shirt, but having shored up his position with 171 against Zimbabwe last month he put the debate to bed with 100 not out against the might of Jasprit Bumrah and company. Ben Stokes had claimed it would be 'remarkable' to dispense with his vice-captain and those words chimed as Pope led England to 209 for three in response to India's 471 at Headingley. The tourists had earlier missed the opportunity to bat their opponents out of the game, losing seven for 41 as Josh Tongue and Ben Stokes finished with four wickets apiece. Their combined efforts rebalanced the game after India's serene progress on day one but the presence of Bumrah cast a long shadow. The world's best bowler lived up to the billing, ripping out Zak Crawley with the new ball and returning for Ben Duckett and Joe Root, but his best was not quite enough to remove Pope. Twice he saw genuine edges sail through gaps in the cordon and when one did go to hand at gully, Yashasvi Jaiswal spilled him on 60. Pope dealt admirably with the interrogation, never losing his composure and scoring 13 fours in a 125-ball ton boasting plenty of character. The milestone may have arrived with a scratchy single into the leg-side but it was fitting that it came off the relentless Bumrah. The day began ominously for England, who took the field at 359 for three and soon began dancing to Rishabh Pant's tune. Resuming on 65 he became the third centurion of the innings with some outrageous hitting. He ramped Shoaib Bashir's first ball over slip, rang up the 400 with a fierce pull for six and flogged the spinner one-handed over the ropes to bring up his hundred. He marked the occasion with an extravagant front flip to delight the crowd but as soon as his stand of 209 with captain Shubman Gill was over, it was England making the big moves. Karun Nair bagged a duck on his first appearance in seven years, Pope snatching a smart one-handed catch, then Pant paid for a moment of indecision as he squared up then offered no stroke as Tongue attacked from round the wicket. The Nottinghamshire seamer had waited an hour and 40 minutes to get his hands on the ball but he made up for the wait, clean bowling Ravindra Jadeja, Bumrah and Prasidh Krishna in a four-over spell of four for 11. A rain shower delayed the start of the England innings, which began with clouds above, floodlights on and Bumrah licking his lips. He picked off Crawley with menacing efficiency in the first over, prying around the outside edge twice before having him caught at slip with a cracker. The rest of his spell was edge-of-the-seat viewing – hitting Ben Duckett on the toe for a tight lbw shout and twice coming close to having the left-hander caught at backward point. Pope also had a stroke of luck on 10, saved only by the yawning gap where fourth slip should have been. But whenever Bumrah was not bowling it was a different game. Runs came easier at the other end, with England's natural aggression meaning a regular supply of boundaries. At one stage Bumrah even proved his fallibility by fumbling the ball over the rope at fine leg. Pope has a reputation as a skittish starter but he looked calmer than usual, his footwork less erratic and his drives a little crisper as England took tea at 107 for one from just 24 overs. Duckett reached 50 with a classic sweep but when Pope followed after the break it was another moral victory for Bumrah. Tearing back in from the Pavilion End he drew a thick edge and was let down again, with no third slip in place. Pope's luck was in once more when Jaiswal put him down and Bumrah eventually took the catchers out of the equation as he finally got a second scalp, flattening Duckett's middle stump via a drag-on. Pope was made to work for his century, trading blows with the seamers until he finally reached the landmark and erupted in celebration. Root succumbed to Bumrah's very next delivery and Harry Brook was caught off a no-ball in a dramatic finish, leaving Pope standing tallest at stumps.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Pope makes gutsy century before Bumrah late show
First Rothesay Test, Headingley (day two of five)India 471: Gill 147, Pant 134, Jaiswal 101; Stokes 2-66, Tongue 4-86England 209-3: Pope 100*, Duckett 62; Bumrah 3-48England are 262 runs behindScorecard Ollie Pope's gutsy century led England's resurgence only for Jasprit Bumrah to give India the crucial wicket of Joe Root late on day two of the first preferred to rising star Jacob Bethell at number three, repaid England's faith with 100 not out at ball after Pope completed his century, Bumrah had Root caught at first slip to leave England 209-3 - all three wickets falling to the pace are 262 adrift of India's 471, a total that should have been much greater. Despite Rishabh Pant completing a thrilling century, the tourists lost their last seven wicket for 41 runs. Captain Ben Stokes and Josh Tongue claimed four wickets a brooding sky - play was held up for 40 minutes by rain - England were faced with the threat of Bumrah, who promptly had Zak Crawley caught at was electrifying, but England dug in through a stand of 122 between Ben Duckett and Pope. Duckett was dropped off Bumrah, Pope edged the same bowler through the fell for 62 to Bumrah's second spell, in which Pope was dropped at third slip by Yashasvi Jaiswal on the evening sunshine, Root overturned being given lbw. Bumrah was summoned for one more spell. Though he could not prevent Pope's milestone, he snatched the bigger prize of there was still time for Harry Brook to be caught off a Bumrah no-ball. It was a heart-stopping end to an engrossing day. England fightback has makings of Headingley classic England were flattened on the opening day, forced to chase leather after gifting away the advantage of winning the on 359-3, India should have batted England out of the contest and then unleashed Bumrah late the tourists offered a route back in with loose dismissals and dropped catches, and England, chiefly Pope, played well enough to grab the opportunity. Their batting was sensible, rather than cavalier, yet the hosts stills scored in excess of four an conditions in which England had to start their innings, ideal for bowling, further highlighted just how good Friday had been for batting. When Bumrah had the ball, every delivery was an event and on another day he could have had an even bigger all the talk of the toss and Bumrah's brilliance, England have a foothold in the match. On a sluggish pitch that looks full of runs, the home side may be vindicated in a fourth-innings now India retain the upper hand through their lead and the presence of Bumrah. It could turn into a classic.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
England stage fightback against India after Rishabh Pant's stylish century
Rishabh Pant and Jasprit Bumrah lived up to their box office billings but England battled back with ball and bat against India in the first Rothesay Test. Pant became India's third centurion of the innings with a swashbuckling 135 – following first-day tons from Yashasvi Jaiswal and Shubman Gill – but India collapsed from 430 for three to 471 all out. A clatter of wickets either side of lunch on day two was followed by a near hour-long rain delay, after which Bumrah lit up a gloomy Headingley with an astonishing new-ball burst under the floodlights. Zak Crawley perished in the first over of the reply, looking to play to leg but dumbfounded by late movement as he edged to slip, while Bumrah might also have accounted for Ben Duckett and Ollie Pope. As it was, the pair weathered the onslaught – in which nigh-on every Bumrah delivery was an event – and tucked into India's other bowlers to lift England to 107 for one at tea, trailing by 364. Duckett was dropped on 15 by the usually dependable Ravindra Jadeja at backward point while both the left-handed opener and Pope edged between third slip and gully. At the other end Mohammed Siraj was ransacked for 23 from his first three overs while Prasidh Krishna was ineffective, with Duckett and Pope pressing the accelerator in Bumrah's absence. Siraj had a much better second spell and might have had Pope on 34, but an lbw appeal was turned down and a review showed the ball was only trimming the top of the stumps as luck went England's way. Duckett won the race to fifty, ending the session on 53 not out, with the under-fire Pope unbeaten on 48. India held sway on 359 for three overnight after being asked to bat first and Chris Woakes and Brydon Carse again struggled to make an impact as Gill and Pant stretched the tourists' lead. While Gill bedded in, Pant went through the gears and went after Shoaib Bashir, greeting his first ball of the day with a paddle for four then a huge hit for six in the same over to move into the 90s. Pant brought up a seventh Test ton in style with a one-handed six off Bashir before removing his helmet and gloves and celebrating the achievement with a somersault. Gill sought to get to 150 in similarly buccaneering fashion but found only Josh Tongue in the deep to depart for 147, setting in motion England's recovery. Nair's first Test innings for India since 2017 was a brief affair as a drive off England captain Ben Stokes was excellently pouched by his deputy Pope, diving full length to his left. Tongue then took centre stage. Having been curiously overlooked up until 20 minutes before lunch, he jagged one back into Pant, who shuffled across his crease but offered no stroke and was pinned leg-before. After Shardul Thakur nicked off to give Stokes his fourth wicket, Tongue made short work of the tail. Having leaked 75 off 16 wicketless overs on Friday, he claimed four for 11 from overs on Saturday.
