Why is X suing the Indian government as Musk woos Modi?
When Elon Musk met Narendra Modi in Washington DC in February, the SpaceX and Tesla chief presented India's prime minister with a gift and introduced him to his family. Modi described the meeting as 'very good'.
Modi was in the United States to see President Donald Trump. In Modi's meeting with Musk, the two talked about collaborating in the fields of artificial intelligence (AI), space exploration, innovation and sustainable development, according to India's Ministry of External Affairs.
But almost a month later, Musk's social media platform X has filed a lawsuit against the Indian government, alleging that New Delhi is unlawfully censoring content online.
The lawsuit comes as Musk edges closer to launching both Starlink and Tesla in India.
So why is X suing India just as Musk is trying to charm Modi?
In a suit filed in the high court of the South Indian state of Karnataka on March 5, X has alleged that the government of India is using 'an impermissible parallel mechanism' which blocks content online and also empowers government officials and ministries to remove illegal online content, circumventing the legal process for content regulation laid out in the country's Information Technology Act.
Section 69A of the country's IT Act, which was passed in October 2000, gives India's IT ministry the right to remove online content deemed harmful to the country's national security and 'public decorum', but it must follow a judiciary process under which the ministry requests permission to remove online content from the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY). MeitY examines the content and then decides whether to censor it.
Now, the Indian government has introduced a new mechanism to delete content – Section 79 (3)(b) of the IT Act, which has a separate blocking process.
Section 79 (3)(b) allows online content to be removed following a simple notification from a government official. Notices to remove content can be sent via the government's 'Sahyog' (which means cooperation in English) portal without any form of judicial review.
The Indian government requires social media platforms like X to sign up to the Sahyog portal, but the social media platform claims doing so will subject it to 'arbitrary censorship'.
'The new legal censorship power they have created [through the Sahyog portal] does not have safeguards such as a requirement of a designated officer sending the censorship request to the central government. Now, it can be done by any government department by designating an officer which can send takedown requests, as was done by the country's railway ministry earlier this year, when it ordered X to take down over 200 videos concerning a stampede which occurred in New Delhi in February,' Apar Gupta, a lawyer and co-founder of the Internet Freedom Foundation, told Al Jazeera.
'Through the parallel censorship system, the government has taken an illegal step. There is merit to the claim being made by X in this instance,' Gupta added.
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) member and former IT minister Rajeev Chandrasekhar told Indian News Agency Asian News International: 'India is a country where the law applies to everybody. X is within its right to go to court.'
X's case against the government was made public by Indian media reports on March 20 and the next hearing is at the Karnataka High Court on March 27.
Al Jazeera has contacted India's IT ministry and the ruling BJP party for comment.
It does not seem so. While officials at MeitY have told local media that it is talking to X about content generated by the social media platform's in-built chatbot, Grok 3, the X lawsuit predates this.
In recent weeks Grok has caused a stir in India by generating content and responses to users' questions which are considered 'abusive and controversial' by the ruling BJP government.
When one X user 'asked' Grok if Prime Minister Modi's interview responses are scripted, the chatbot responded: 'Modi's interviews often seem scripted – his answers are polished, on-message and rarely stray from the narrative. He's a PR machine, using social media and controlled settings to shape his image, as seen with his heavy multimedia strategy since 2014. Real impromptu moments? Almost nonexistent.'
Gupta said: 'There has been a high level of self-censorship in India, as well as a rise in what is called digital authoritarianism, in which a lot of people don't feel free to say what they want to say. Grok gives them the chance to pose questions critical of the union government, particularly the prime minister and the chatbot has been responding on the basis of a data stream, which includes Wikipedia articles and journalistic articles in a chatting and engaging manner.'
'But at its very root, people need to understand that Grok is mostly AI which has been trained on public resources and what it is stating can also reflect misinformation and may suffer from biases,' he added.
'There is no correlation between filing the case and the Grok responses generating a viral trend. The only relationship is that the same ministry of the government [MeitY] is involved,' he added.
Gupta said it is too early to tell what the impact of the outcome of the case will be for X users in the country.
'For users in India, there has always been friction between the government and large social media platforms. The reason behind this is that the government often does not follow the constitutional limits placed on them and requires censorship for political reasons. So any pushback by platforms ends up supporting the cause of free expression, which is very well needed in closed societies where a very high level of censorship is present,' he said.
'But in this case, X also has a historic problem of not being more transparent with how it decides and determines its content moderation practices, and globally, X has stopped reporting government demands for takedowns, which used to be submitted prior to Musk's takeover. So X definitely is no model corporate actor in a way either,' he added.
It is unlikely, say experts. Michael Kugelman, South Asia Institute director at The Wilson Center, a Washington, DC-based think tank, told Al Jazeera that Musk operates with 'a lot of leverage' in India, thanks to his wealth and the investment capital he's prepared to deploy in high-growth industries such as telecoms and renewables.
Musk has also been appointed by Trump to lead the US government's new Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) and has announced swingeing cuts to federal jobs and claimed to have found billions of dollars of waste and fraud in government spending.
'His proximity to Trump ramps this leverage up even more. So he has great leeway to do as he wishes without the risk of alienating New Delhi. He can dangle Starlink and Tesla while also acting on his principle of 'free speech absolutism' on social media,' he said. He has already reached agreements with telecom companies in India to provide Starlink services and is in talks with others. Plans to introduce a Tesla manufacturing base in the country are also under way.
Similarly, the impact of this suit on overall US-India ties will be small, he said. 'Given all the different tracks of cooperation playing out in the relationship, and given all the goodwill that it enjoys, this X spat is a blip at best and a nuisance at worst. Not to mention, the massive Indian market is far too appealing to pull back from,' he added.
'So no matter how the legal process plays out, X will want to stick it out in India. That commitment to stay can also help fend off possible bilateral tensions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
8 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Tesla's robotaxi launch fuels next growth wave hopes
Agencies Electric vehicle pioneer Tesla was poised to finally begin offering its robotaxi service as of Sunday, with rollout expected to start in Austin, Texas. The long-awaited launch is seen as an initial step that Elon Musk's backers believe could lead to the company's next growth wave. The launchwhich comes as Musk refocuses on his business ventures following a controversial stint in Donald Trump's administrationwill employ the Model Y sport utility vehicle rather than Tesla's much-touted Cybercab, which is still under development. The long-awaited launch follows the dramatic meltdown earlier this month in relations between Musk and Trump, which saw a cascade of bitter attacks from both men. Since then, Musk has publicly expressed regret for some of his statements, while his company's Texas operation has readied the Austin push – part of a major drive on autonomous technology and artificial intelligence that Tesla bulls believe will yield huge profits. This group includes Wedbush analyst Daniel Ives, who said autonomous technology could be a catalyst for potentially $1 trillion in additional market value or more. 'There are countless skeptics of the Tesla robotaxi vision with many bears thinking this day would never come,' said Ives, who predicted that Trump's administration would clear roadblocks for Tesla and pivot from the recent 'soap opera.' 'The golden era of autonomous for Tesla officially kicks off on Sunday in Austin,' Ives said in a note Friday. But the unveiling in the Texas state capital comes amid questions about how Tesla will try to overcome criticism of Musk's activities for Trump. Tesla saw profits plunge 71% in the first quarter following poor sales in several markets. In picking Austin for the debut of the autonomous vehicle (AV) service, Musk is opting for a U.S. state known for its company-friendly approach to regulation. 'Texas law allows for AV testing and operations on Texas roadways as long as they meet the same safety and insurance requirements as every other vehicle on the road,' the Texas Department of Transportation told Agence France-Presse (AFP). An Austin website listed six autonomous vehicle companies at various stages of operation: ADMT (Volkswagen), AVRide, Tesla, Zoox (Amazon), Motional (Hyundai) and Waymo (Alphabet/Google). But the Texas legislature this year enacted a new bill that requires prior authorization from the state's Department of Motor Vehicles before companies can operate on a public street without human drivers, a group of seven Democratic lawmakers said in a June 18 letter to Tesla. Citing the enhanced system, the lawmakers asked Tesla to delay testing until after the law takes effect Sept. 1. If Tesla proceeds with the launch this weekend, 'we request that you respond to this letter with detailed information demonstrating that Tesla will be compliant with the new law,' the letter said. Musk had initially planned the launch for June 12, before pushing back, saying he was being 'super paranoid' about safety. 'We want to deliberately take it slow,' Musk said in a May 20 interview on CNBC, telling the network that Tesla would probably only operate 10 autonomous vehicles the first week. But that number will rise to perhaps 1,000 'within a few months,' Musk told CNBC. 'And then we will expand to other cities ... San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Antonio.' The service will be offered from 6 a.m. until midnight and will be available to 'early access' users on an invitation-only basis in a geofenced area, Tesla owner Sawyer Merritt said Friday on Musk's X platform, adding that Tesla had given him permission to release the information. Musk last fall unveiled the Cybercab, which has no steering wheel or pedals. But production is not expected to begin on the vehicle until 2026. Tesla's robotaxi launch comes well after Waymo's offering of commercial robotaxi service, with more US cities gradually added.
Qatar Tribune
8 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Indian Mango Festival concludes with resounding success in Doha
Tribune News Network Doha The Embassy of India, in collaboration with Souq Waqif and Indian Business & Professionals Council, successfully organised the second edition of the Indian Mango Festival from June 12– 21, 2025 in Doha. The 10-day cultural and commercial celebration of India's 'King of Fruits' showcased the rich diversity and flavor of Indian mangoes, drawing an enthusiastic response from the local and international visitors alike. The festival featured around 50 varieties of mangoes, including the famed Alphonso, Dasheri, Langra, Kesar, Rajapuri, Malgova, Neelam, Badami, Imam Pasand, Kalapadi, Totapuri, Chakkarakkutti, Sindoori, and Mallika, among others. Alongside fresh fruits, visitors indulged in a delectable range of mango-based sweets and savories like cakes, sweets, ice creams, pickles, juices, and other dishes, showcasing the versatility of the fruit in Indian culinary traditions. Over 150,000 visitors belonging to over 60 nationalities attended the festival, underscoring the popularity of Indian mangoes and the deep cultural appreciation shared between India, Qatar and other countries. A total of 130,000 kilograms of mangoes were sold, while the combined sales of mangoes and mango products exceeded 160,000 kilograms—a testimony to the fruit's universal appeal. The event brought together 31 Indian companies, reflecting the growing strength of India-Qatar economic ties, especially in the agro-produce sector. The festival served not only as a platform for trade and promotion of Indian produce but also as a vibrant celebration of India's cultural heritage and agricultural excellence. In addition to the mango showcase, the festival included a variety of interactive activities such as quizzes and competitions, engaging families and children and adding a festive flavor to the marketplace. The Embassy of India expresses its sincere appreciation to the authorities of Souq Waqif and the Private Engineering Office for their productive collaboration in successfully organising the second edition of the Indian Mango Festival.
Qatar Tribune
9 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Stock market futures on edge after US bombs Iran's nuclear sites
Agencies New York Dow Jones futures, the S&P 500, and Nasdaq futures are expected to open on a shaky note following President Donald Trump's announcement that the US had conducted airstrikes on three Iranian nuclear facilities. Additionally, Tesla's robotaxi programme launch is on the near horizon. The stock market displayed mixed results over the past week, showing resilience amid significant developments concerning Israel and Iran. Stocks like Viking, Dell, Super Micro, and Shake Shack are currently within theirbuy zones. On Friday, the S&P 500 declined as investors kept a close watch on the latest news from the Middle East. The broad market index dropped 0.22 percent, closing at 5,967.84, as Friday marked the S&P 500's third consecutivelosing session. Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist at CFRA Research, said earlier this week that the S&P 500 is currently trading approximately 3 percent below its recent52-week high. 'If there's a calming down of the geopolitical activities, then you know that could be helpful,' he stated. The strikes come as Tesla will launch its robotaxi service in Austin, Texas, this Sunday. The service features a 'safety monitor' in the passenger seat. Meanwhile, Uber Technologies, which may be impacted by the Tesla robotaxi updates, has established a new base and is preparing for an aggressive market entry.
