Fabiano Caruana latest top-rated chess player to question D Gukesh: 'Not playing close to his best...'

D Gukesh is yet to win a tournament since being crowned the youngest world champion in chess history in December. And even though the teenager has shown flashes of brilliance, the lack of success has led to growing criticism, including from world No 4 Fabiano Caruana. read more
D Gukesh has had quite the few detractors ever since he became the youngest world champion in chess history last December following his victory over China's Ding Liren in Singapore. The biggest among them were five-time world champion Magnus Carlsen and Hikaru Nakamura, ranked first and second respectively in the world with the former counted among the greatest of all time.
There's another member of chess' elite who has been questioning whether Gukesh, who has been making headlines globally before even turning 20, truly deserves to be mentioned in the same breath as Carlsen or not.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
American Grandmaster Fabiano Caruana, who had finished runner-up at the Norway Chess recently – behind Carlsen but ahead of Gukesh – isn't just playing down Gukesh's as a threat for chess' old order, but is also describing the new generation of Indian players as youngsters who aren't as scary as they are made to be .
'Gukesh has been ambitiously fighting for first place'
And speaking on the C Squared Podcast, Caruana added that even though Gukesh is close to playing his best Classical chess, the titles aren't coming as frequently as they were last year.
'I don't think for the last two events (Superbet Chess Classic and Norway Chess) you can say that Gukesh is not playing close to his best classical chess. That would be a big stretch, not even a stretch I think that would just be dishonest,' Caruana, who overtook Gukesh on the FIDE Rating after Norway Chess, said on the podcast.
'But overall if you look at the last year and a half, then Budapest Chess Olympiad and FIDE Candidates and then Wijk aan Zee twice… Gukesh has had good performances. Obviously he's been one of the players who is ambitiously fighting for first place in many events,' he added.
Gukesh is yet to win a tournament since he was crowned world champion, having finished runner-up at the Tata Steel Chess behind compatriot R Praggnanandhaa and third at Norway Chess.
The Chennai lad has also struggled to make an impact in other Classical events such as the Superbet Classic that took place in Bucharest, Romania before the trip to Norway, and his struggle with the Freestyle format has been well-documented in the ongoing Grand Slam Tour.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Gukesh, however, has had his moments, especially in Norway where he pulled off a stunning victory over Carlsen – beating the world No 1 in the Classical format for the first time in his career.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

India Today

29 minutes ago

• India Today

ENG vs IND: Michael Vaughan slams Ben Stokes's decision to bowl in Leeds Test

Former England captain Michael Vaughan has questioned Ben Stokes's call to bowl first on a sun-drenched opening day at Headingley, expressing disbelief at the decision that allowed India to pile on 359 for 3 on Day 1 of the Leeds Test. Ben Stokes' decision seemed ill-advised, as centuries from opener Yashasvi Jaiswal and captain Shubman Gill—his first as skipper—powered India to a commanding position in their series opener against who knows the Leeds venue intimately, having played 51 first-class matches there-including four as England captain-said he was "staggered" by Stokes's decision at the toss. "I am an old-school traditionalist here at Leeds that when the sun is shining, with dry weather, you bat," Vaughan told BBC Test Match Special. "I was staggered when he said he was going to bowl. Traditions are out the window. You have to pick your decisions on that moment, and not things that you did here years ago."England's strategy to field first has become a familiar pattern since Stokes took over the captaincy in 2022. In the nine home Tests where England won the toss during his tenure, they have opted to bowl first eight times, winning six of those matches. Vaughan, however, cautioned against relying too heavily on recent trends or historical ENG vs IND 1st Test Day 1 Highlights"You always have to pick your decisions on that moment," Vaughan reiterated. "And not things that you did here years ago or at other times. It can't affect what the decision is today. You look at the England side and their strength is in the batting. And there is inexperience in the bowling at the moment. Ben clearly had a gut feeling, and sometimes it has worked."While recent history at Headingley might have supported England's approach-the last six Tests at the venue were all won by teams bowling first-conditions on the day seemed to favour batting. The pitch flattened out quickly, allowing Yashasvi Jaiswal and newly-appointed Indian captain Shubman Gill to each bring up superb fast-bowling consultant, Tim Southee, shed some light on the rationale behind the toss decision, citing the green tinge and early morning moisture as potential sources of assistance for the bowlers."With the colour of the wicket yesterday, and a little bit of moisture left in it, if there was a little bit of help in it, it was probably going to be this morning," said Southee. "That was the thinking behind the decision. You look at the surface and make the decision on what you think will give you the best chance. Not all the time do you get it right." You May Also Like

India Today

29 minutes ago

• India Today

ENG vs IND: Southee defends England's decision to bowl after India's Leeds show

England bowling coach Tim Southee has defended captain Ben Stokes's decision to bowl first after India piled on a commanding 359 for 3 on the opening day of the first Test at Headingley. Centuries from Yashasvi Jaiswal and new captain Shubman Gill put India in complete control on a surface that offered little assistance once the early morning moisture dried decision to field raised eyebrows, especially given the nature of the pitch and India's response with the bat. However, Southee, who is part of England's coaching staff as a consultant for the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy, insisted the call was made based on Thursday's pitch vs IND 1st Test Day 1 Highlights "I think with the colour of the wicket yesterday and a little bit of, I guess, moisture left in it. There was gonna be a little bit of probably this morning, so, yeah, I think that's the thinking behind the decision," Southee explained. "I think the Indian openers sort of negotiated that first hour relatively well. KL Rahul left well and, and Jaiswal played his hand as well throughout. So I think there was a little bit of assistance there, but for the rest of that it was a pretty good surface I guess is encouraging for our guys when we get an opportunity to bat as well."advertisementJaiswal (101) and Gill (127 not out) showcased composure and class as they stitched together a 129-run stand for the third wicket, lifting India from a shaky 92 for 2 after KL Rahul (42) and debutant B Sai Sudharsan (0) had fallen in quick succession. Rishabh Pant (65 not out) added further impetus in the final session, helping India finish with a flourish, scoring at 4.22 runs per over, to reach 359 for 3 at the close of play on Day was playing his first Test in England, Gill his fourth, and Sai Sudharsan was on debut - a fact that may have played into England's thinking at the toss. The last six Tests at Headingley had all seen the team bowling first emerge victorious, but critics suggested England were too focused on past results rather than current conditions."Don't think you think too much. You look at the surface and you make a decision on what you think is gonna give you the best chance. Not all the time you get it right," Southee admitted. "But I think, you look at the weather around and I guess there's a little bit of moisture left in that wicket this morning. I think the first hour or so there's gonna be potentially a little bit, but historically with this weather around it's gonna be turned into a pretty, pretty good surface at some stage."advertisementWhile England's bowlers toiled for long spells, India's performance marked a significant shift in their batting era, with Jaiswal and Gill making a strong statement in the absence of senior figures like Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma. Their innings not only laid a strong platform for India but also set the tone for the newly established five-Test Anderson-Tendulkar challenge for England now is to respond with the bat - and hope the surface, as Southee suggested, remains good enough for them to claw their way back into the contest. You May Also Like

First Post

38 minutes ago

• First Post

Challenger to champion: How R Praggnanandhaa learnt to play for victory, not just experience

R Praggnanandhaa emerged as India's leading chess prodigy in 2023 but had a subdued 2024 as world champion D Gukesh took the spotlight. In 2025, however, he's back in form. In an exclusive chat, Praggnanandhaa explains the changes he made to achieve consistent success. read more Before D Gukesh became the youngest chess world champion in 2024, R Praggnanandhaa emerged as India's breakout star in 2023. The then-18-year-old held Magnus Carlsen to two draws in the classical games of the FIDE Chess World Cup . Although he eventually lost to the five-time world champion in the tie-breaks, Praggnanandhaa had already made a significant impact on the global chess stage. Then came 2024. Praggnanandhaa finally secured his first win over Carlsen, the highest-rated chess player of all time, at Norway Chess and also helped India win a historic gold at the 45th Chess Olympiad. But at an individual level, the big trophies were missing. He finished fifth at the Candidates as Gukesh won the tournament at 17 and then went on to beat Ding Liren in December to become the world champion at 18. At the World Rapid Championship, Praggnanandhaa was in joint lead till the penultimate round before a blunder against teenager and eventual winner Volodar Murzin brought everything crashing down for the Indian. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Pure ecstasy and brutal agony, all within the span of a few months. Praggnanandhaa stood at a crossroads. Talent wasn't the issue; the challenge was using it to cross the finish line. Something was off. Something had to change. But what, exactly? That's when Praggnanandhaa turned to his most trusted ally in the chess world: his coach, R Ramesh. 'I think Ramesh knows me the best regarding chess. I've been working with Ramesh for the last 11 years,' Praggnanandhaa told Firstpost. 'We had a camp towards the end of the year. We were discussing all these issues in my game. And then we tried to go into details and try to find what is causing those issues and tried to find a solution to it. 'And I think all this work is paying off. In this regard, I think credit should be given to him.' Mental adjustments make Praggnanandhaa a winner But what was the solution? It was something seemingly minor, yet profound enough to be a life lesson. Praggnanandhaa was already beating top players, including Carlsen, but deep down, even he wasn't entirely sure of what he was capable of. In that camp at the end of 2024, Praggnanandhaa realised the fault was not in his game, but in his thinking. You can't beat the best players in the world if you don't think of yourself as the best. Since then, he has been a different player, winning the prestigious Tata Steel Masters at the start of the 2025 by beating Gukesh in a tie-breaker , clinching the Grand Chess Tour Superbet Chess Classic Romania last month and currently leading the FIDE Circuit 2025 standings, which can earn him a spot in the 2026 Candidates. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'I think it's mostly about mental changes, like being more confident in my abilities and trying to be more ambitious in games and not backing down against anyone,' Praggnanandhaa said while explaining what has changed in his game from 2024. 'You know, just fight, fight it out till the end. And as I said, I think once you believe in your abilities, you will fight in every game. Sometimes last year, especially in some tournaments, I was not feeling confident. So I think that was lacking. And once you regain that, you can be more ambitious. And I think now I'm more ambitious and fighting in every game.' A big support in his journey has also been his sponsors, who have made travel and training easy for the teenage chess star. 'Chess is expensive, especially when you travel to Europe for a tournament. You need to have trainers to help you during the tournaments. Apart from the tournament as well,' he said. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'It's difficult when you prepare for tournaments like the Candidates. This is where the Adani Group, coming in and supporting players, is essential. This happened just before the Candidates, so I could prepare my best. I am also able to train with the best facilities. That's showing in my result. I don't need to worry about anything, just focus on the game and keep improving.' With the key to winning decoded and sponsors onboard, Praggnanandhaa appears to be on the right path — grounded, yet ambitious. The teenager is well aware that Magnus Carlsen and elite players like Hikaru Nakamura and Fabiano Caruana aren't going anywhere. And the competition is rising back home too, with the likes of D Gukesh and Arjun Erigaisi. Praggnanandhaa is pleased with the progress he has made, but he knows there's still a long way to go. 'Yeah, I wouldn't really say I've been progressing rapidly,' Praggnanandhaa said. 'There have been some hiccups in between, like last year just didn't go my way. This year has been good for me so far, and I hope to continue that way. If you compare just these six months, then it's been good. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'But if you like, take into account the last year, then I think it's just normal progress and considering our last few months, definitely happy with my games and I want to continue playing this way,' he signed off.