IHC ruling favours FBR: Leading telecom co to pay Rs22bn
ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has issued a judgement against a leading telecom operator, which would result in payment of Rs22 billion (US$78 million) to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR).
In this regard, a Division Bench of the Islamabad High Court, led by Justice Babar Sattar, has delivered a significant ruling in favor of revenue in a tax reference filed by a major Telecom operator. This ruling upholds the powers and jurisdiction of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) in assessing tax liability on a high-value intra-group transaction involving the transfer of Telecom Operator's tower assets. As a result, the Telecom Operator is now liable to pay taxes amounting to approximately Rs. 22 billion (USD 78 million) on its gain from the transaction.
The landmark case focused on 2018 internal asset reorganization, where the Telecom Operator transferred its nationwide tower infrastructure to its wholly owned subsidiary. The disposal of these assets for Rs. 98.5 billion (USD 940 million) by the Telecom Operator was recorded in its financial statements as an accounting gain of approximately Rs. 75.9 billion. However, the Telecom Operator contended that the transaction was not taxable because the asset was disposed of to its wholly owned subsidiary, according to section 97(1) of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 (ITO) concerning intra-group transfers.
The high court dismissed the petitioner's argument, stating that the provision permits a tax-neutral event only if all conditions of section 97 of the ITO are met. This includes ensuring that the written-down value of the transferred asset remains unchanged in the hands of the transferee compared to the transferor, meaning the transaction should not generate any economic value leading to taxable income. The Court determined that the transaction was conducted at a fair market value of USD 940 million, accepted by the petitioner as consideration, thereby violating section 97 of the ITO.
Consequently, the Court concluded that the gain from the transaction was clearly a taxable event since nothing remained to defer taxation to a later date. Additionally, the Court ruled that the Commissioner had the authority to consider accounting income when evaluating taxable income.
This remarkable success of the FBR on judicial front is another step toward accomplishment of vision of the Hon'ble Prime Minister for expeditious liquidation of state revenue involved in the cases pending before the various appellate fora.
Under the guidance of Rashid Mehmood, Chairman, FBR, Legal Wing of the FBR headed by Mir Badshah Khan Wazir, Member (Legal IR) in association with Director General (Law) has already taken a number of initiatives to actively pursue the pending cases by providing proper assistance to the courts. These collective efforts have resulted in resolution of large number of pending tax disputes at various legal fora involving revenue in billions of rupees. Asma Hamid, ASC, and Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed Khan (DG Law) effectively represented the Federal Board of Revenue in this case.
While dismissing another petition of the same telecom operator filed against a show cause notice issued under the Federal Excise Act, 2005, the court-imposed cost of Rs. 100,000 upon the petitioner to be paid to Deputy Commissioner-IR, LTO, Islamabad within four weeks.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Dost Steels to raise Rs4.45bn via rights issue to fund billet production
Dost Steels Limited, a Pakistani steel manufacturer, plans to raise Rs4.45 billion (USD 15.6 million) through a rights issue to fund the installation of a melting furnace. The listed company disclosed the development in its filing to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) on Monday. The quantum of the right issue is approximately 100% of the existing paid-up capital of the company, i.e. approximately 100 right shares for every 100 ordinary shares held by the company's shareholders. As per the filing, the company shall issue 444,695,577 ordinary shares, at par, that is at a price of Rs 10/- per right share, aggregating to Rs4.45 billion. The steel maker said that the purpose of the rights issue is to raise funds for the installation and commissioning of a melting furnace to produce billets. Additionally, the funds will be used to meet the company's working capital requirements. Dost Steels secures Rs2.08bn investment DSL shared that by setting up the melting furnace, the company will be producing billets, which are essential raw materials for producing the end product. 'This will significantly reduce raw material costs, leading to improved profit margins,' it said. Moreover, the project will boost operational efficiency, provide enhanced supply chain control, and support the business's long-term sustainability. 'These improvements are anticipated to result in increased profitability and shareholder value, thereby strengthening the company's financial position and competitive standing in the market,' it said. The company was of the view that the right issue is being carried out at a price, which is near the current market price, and hence, there is no major risk associated with it. However, normal risks associated with the business will remain. On Monday, the share price of DSL settled at Rs7.24, a decrease of Re0.18 or 2.43%.
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Aurangzeb unveils new tax measures, targets poultry, mutual funds & govt securities
Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb unveiled new taxation measures, including levies on income generated from mutual funds and government securities, at the National Assembly on Monday. Addressing the lower house, the finance minister presented three more budget proposals. 'The first of these is to increase the tax rate on income derived from the debt portion of mutual funds issued to companies from 25% to 29%. Secondly, it is proposed to impose a 20% tax on profits made by corporations and companies on investments in government securities,' he said. The government has also proposed to tax the poultry sector, said Aurangzeb. 'It is proposed that a Federal Excise Duty (FED) of Rs10 per day-old chick should be imposed on hatchery chicks, so that this sector can also contribute to the national exchequer,' he said. The finance minister maintained that the government has presented a balanced budget for the fiscal year 2025-26. 'On one hand, we have kept government expenditure under control, while on the other, much emphasis has been laid towards increasing tax base and its compliance,' said Aurangzeb. Imported cotton yarn: APTMA hails 18pc sales tax imposition Aurangzeb said that tariff rationalisation is vital, stating: 'By lowering import duties, our business unit cost would decrease, which will facilitate exports.' He said that the government will soon announce an industrial policy, whereas consultation on EV policy has already been initiated. Moreover, the government, in collaboration with British Asian Trust, would soon launch Pakistan's first Skill Impact Bond (SIB). The SIB links funding to the achievement of outcomes, he said. Affordable Housing The government, in its bid to promote affordable housing, would launch a 20-year loan scheme for the low-income segment, informed Auranzgeb. He clarified: 'Only those dams will be pursued that are already approved.' On Saturday, Aurangzeb, in his address to the Senate, announced key relief measures in the federal budget for FY2025-26, including a significant income tax cut for the salaried class and a reduction in General Sales Tax (GST) on imported solar panels. The finance minister, on Monday, reiterated that individuals earning between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million annually will now be taxed at just 1%, down from 2.5% proposed in the budget for FY2025-26. He said that tax has been imposed on individuals receiving an annual pension of over Rs10 million, while, on the special instructions of the Prime Minister of Pakistan, pensioners over the age of 75 are exempt from all types of taxes. Aurangzeb added that the proposed 18% GST on solar panel imports has been lowered to 10%. Powers of FBR Aurangzeb informed the lower house that on the special instructions of the Prime Minister, the existing powers of the FBR regarding tax fraud and the amendments made through the Finance Bill were reviewed once again, under which tax fraud has been categorised into cognizable and non-cognizable offences. 'In cases involving up to Rs50 million, the FBR will not be able to arrest without a court warrant,' he said. In addition, any one of the following conditions must be fulfilled for arrest: 1) the accused deliberately did not become a part of the inquiry despite three notices; 2) the accused tries to escape; and 3) tampers with the record. 'Despite this, the approval for arrest will be given by a high-level three-member committee of the FBR, instead of an officer, and it will be necessary to present the arrested persons before the court of a special judge within 24 hours,' he said. In addition, it will be ensured that no citizen is abused in this process, he added. Real estate sector In the real estate sector, Aurangzeb noted that in the past, people used to buy large properties beyond their declared financial means. Under Section 114C of the Income Tax Ordinance, the Finance Bill proposed to prohibit such people from engaging in large financial activities. 'On the instructions of the prime minister, this new law will not apply to the purchase of residential plots or houses worth up to Rs50 million, commercial plots or properties worth up to Rs100 million and vehicles worth up to Rs7 million,' said the finance minister. Aurangzeb said that the ongoing tensions between Iran Israel are expected to disturb the region's economic situation. However, the government is prepared to deal with any situation, he assured the lower house.
Business Recorder
7 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Yuan slips to 3-week low on Iran tensions, HK dollar hits weaker end of band
SHANGHAI: China's yuan slipped to a three-week low against the dollar on Monday as investors rushed to perceived safe haven assets and awaited Iran's response to US attacks on its nuclear sites that dramatically exacerbated Middle East tensions. The yuan's weakness mirrored other emerging market currencies, which fell across the board to reflect the dollar's strength. But the losses were limited by the central bank's firmer-than-expected official midpoint guidance fix. Meanwhile, the Hong Kong dollar, which is pegged to the greenback, again hit the weaker end of its trading band again, with markets cautiously watching to see if the Hong Kong Monetary Authority would step in to defend the local currency. The onshore yuan fell to a trough of 7.1950 per dollar, the weakest level since June 3, before changing hands at 7.1877 as of 0350 GMT. Its offshore counterpart was down about 0.13% in Asian trade to 7.1880 per dollar. The dollar/yuan pair 'seems to have formed a rounding bottom, potentially rising on the back of broad dollar gains,' Maybank analysts said in a note. 'The Israel-Iran-US conflict are keeping investors nervous but (an) upmove of the USD/CNH seems to be limited still. China has thus far condemned the attacks on Iran but did not indicate any sign of direct support or involvement.' China's yuan rises on stronger fixing, weaker dollar outlook Prior to the market opening, the People's Bank of China (PBOC) set the midpoint rate at 7.1710 per dollar and 204 pips firmer than a Reuters' estimate of 7.1914. The spot yuan is allowed to trade 2% either side of the fixed midpoint each day. Market participants closely watch the central bank's daily guidance for any clues on changes to FX policy. 'The daily PBOC fixing continued to signal a preference for stability, even as external risks rise,' said Marco Sun, chief financial markets analyst at MUFG Bank (China). Apart from Middle East tensions, some market watchers also expect the yuan to weaken in the second half of this year due largely to uncertainty in trade relations between the world's two largest economies. 'We see a moderate yuan depreciation in the second half on potential export pressure and material rate differentials,' economists at Standard Chartered said in a note. 'China's authorities have started to relax outbound investment since June, likely leading to more capital outflows. Sharp devaluation remains unlikely as the yuan is already highly competitive at its current valuation.'
