THE DUHAN DILEMMA: Lions head coach Andy Farrell needs to see big improvement from van der Merwe if he's to make Test team after costly blunders against Argentina

Given that he had only played 11 minutes of rugby since the end of the Six Nations in March, it was always likely Duhan van der Merwe would have to overcome some ring-rust on his return to action.
Pitched in from the start as the British and Irish Lions began their campaign against Argentina in Dublin last Friday night, the Scotland international would have been hoping to blow off the cobwebs.
As one of the most explosive finishers in world rugby, he would no doubt have envisaged marking his comeback with a trademark try and a demonstration of his lethal running power.
While he didn't manage to score, Van der Merwe made a couple of powerful carries in the first half and was involved in most of the Lions' best moments in attack.
And yet, a lot of that good stuff was undone by his mistakes. By the end of a difficult night for Van der Merwe and the Lions as a whole, questions were already being asked. Such as whether his attacking brilliance and try-scoring prowess outweigh his defensive deficiencies. It's an issue which doesn't tend to be spoken about much with Scotland.
His place in Gregor Townsend 's team is pretty much guaranteed. With the Lions? Not so much. His selection will have been playing on Andy Farrell's mind as the squad travelled to Australia following their 28-24 defeat to the Pumas.
Van der Merwe was at fault for two Argentina tries in the first half. The first saw him miss a vital tackle as winger Ignacio Mendy stepped inside to score.
The second, right on the cusp of half-time, saw the South African-born 30-year-old lose the ball cheaply in contact as Argentina countered brilliantly and scored through fly-half Tomas Albornoz.
Having made a couple of high-profile errors which led directly to the concession of two tries, Van der Merwe was later seen on the sidelines with ice on the same ankle that had put him on the injury list for three months.
By all accounts, not a great night. Some critics even suggested that Van der Merwe may have played himself out of the Test team before the plane had even taken off.
That's probably a slightly premature assessment of his chances, but the Scotland star certainly didn't do himself any favours.
With the travelling party touching down in Perth on Sunday night, Van der Merwe will arrive in Australia as a player rapidly needing to find some form if he's to regain the trust of Farrell.
When the Lions squad was selected in early May, Van der Merwe was fretting over whether or not he would be part of Farrell's plans at all.
Speaking after his selection had been confirmed, he said: 'Since I've picked up the niggle, you have doubts and you start thinking: 'Is this going to have an effect on me going on the tour?'
'Then you start taking yourself back to the Six Nations. Did I have my best Six Nations? Good at times, but probably a wee bit average at times.
'Then you start thinking: 'Am I the type of winger Andy Farrell likes'? You think about that every single day. So I'm definitely a wee bit shocked, but at the same time, I'm absolutely buzzing.'
If Van der Merwe was fully fit and firing on all cylinders, most observers would have him in their starting XV for the three Tests against the Wallabies. At his best, he remains a force of nature.
In reality, his inclusion is not cut and dry. He is still working his way back to full fitness. Other wingers in the squad, most notably James Lowe and Mack Hansen, have Farrell's trust from Ireland duty.
Tommy Freeman finished the season as one of the form players on the planet, scoring a burst of 15 tries in 10 matches for England and Northampton.
Van der Merwe's problem that these defensive frailties are not especially new. They are not a one-off that can be brushed aside and forgotten
Over the past few years, for all we have marvelled at some of the brilliant tries he has scored for Scotland, he has often been a weak link in defence.
He misses too many tackles and, for a man of his physique, loses the ball far too often in contact. That kind of stuff can be forgiven when he's running the length of the field to score against England. But Farrell might not be so willing to overlook such deficiencies, especially with a player who is still working his way back to full fitness. Ultimately, it will be a case of does the head coach stick or twist with Van der Merwe?
Van Der Merwe attempts to make the breakthrough for Lions during a tough night in Dublin
Farrell was never going to be naive enough to single out any player for criticism on the back of the defeat to Argentina. It was scrappy and disjointed, but it wasn't a night to reach for the flamethrower.
'Some people will have done themselves proud,' he said. 'They'll be hurting for the team because they're all team players.
'Some players will be happy, others won't and will be dying to get another chance.'
It's fair to say that Van der Merwe fell into the latter of those two categories, although it should be said he was far from alone in that regard.
Especially under the high ball, he and a few of his team-mates in the backline looked decidedly shaky. You can bet your last Dingo dollar that Australia head coach Joe Schmidt will have taken note of that.
'We weren't as consistent as we would have liked to be,' said captain Maro Itoje. 'We only showed glimmers of what we can do.
'When we were on it, we looked good, we just need to do it more consistently. We want to be more aggressive but we are building. We will live, learn and get better.
'Argentina showed us where we are lacking. I am happy we had a hard-fought game. As we improve our relationships, and spend more time together in training and understanding each other's triggers, it will come.
Van der Merwe has been left with a point to prove after his performance against the Pumas
'There are no excuses. We should have been better today but, as with other areas of the game, we'll learn and get better together. This is only match one.'
It would be foolish to write off the Lions on the basis of what happened in Dublin. The same is true of Van der Merwe's chances of making the Test starting XV.
If he can prove his fitness and recapture his best form, it will be difficult for Farrell to leave him out. But, right now, he has landed in Australia as a player with a point to prove.
Van der Merwe started all three Tests on the tour of South Africa four years ago. The chances of him doing the same in Australia feel much less certain this time around.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Independent

an hour ago

• The Independent

Tributes paid to ‘giant' Celtic icon and Lisbon Lion

Former Celtic defender John Clark, a member of the legendary Lisbon Lions, has died at the age of 84. Clark was instrumental in Celtic's historic 1967 European Cup victory, where they became the first British club to lift the trophy. He made over 300 appearances for Celtic and won numerous domestic titles, including four Scottish league titles and four League Cups. Clark maintained a lifelong association with Celtic, serving the club for over 40 years in various capacities including player, coach, assistant manager, and kit man. Tributes from Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers and chairman Peter Lawwell highlighted his immense contribution and status as a club giant.

Daily Mail​

an hour ago

• Daily Mail​

SIR CLIVE WOODWARD: Australia head coach Joe Schmidt is playing mind games... but this is why it would be a huge mistake to keep his Wallaby stars out of the Lions warm-up matches

No one wins if Australia choose not to release their best players to feature in the warm-up matches of the British & Irish Lions tour. Such a scenario risks making the entire trip a non-event. The Lions need tough preparation fixtures Down Under to ensure they are ready for their Test series with the Wallabies.

The Guardian

an hour ago

• The Guardian

Immanuel Feyi-Waboso picked for England tour despite two-match ban

Immanuel Feyi-Waboso has been included in England's squad for the summer tour of Argentina and the US despite a suspension that rules him out of two of the three fixtures. Feyi-Waboso was sent off after 33 minutes of his first appearance in six months during an England XV's 26-24 defeat by France at Twickenham on Saturday. He endured a torrid comeback, twice dropping the ball before he was sent to the sin-bin for his clothesline tackle on the French fly-half Antoine Hastoy – his yellow card subsequently upgraded to red. On Sunday, Feyi-Waboso was handed a three-match ban, which will be reduced to two provided he completes 'tackle school'. As a result, the 22-year-old wing misses the two Tests against Argentina next month but is available to face USA in Washington. If his inclusion in the 36-man squad – co-captained by Jamie George and George Ford – is a surprise, it demonstrates just how important a player Steve Borthwick considers Feyi-Waboso. Before last Saturday, he had not played since December because of a shoulder injury after his return was delayed amid confusion as to whether he would undergo surgery. It is understood, however, that Borthwick sees value in having Feyi-Waboso with the squad in Argentina with an eye on the future as well as to provide competition to the other wings in training with Will Muir, Cadan Murley and Tom Roebuck selected. Feyi-Waboso's inclusion means he will stay fresh should the British & Irish Lions come calling but, as things stand, his ban does not expire until after Andy Farrell's side have played their first Test against Australia. Feyi-Waboso was handed an enhanced contract by the Rugby Football Union last October and is sure to be on the list that Borthwick names after the summer tour. That England do not have their usual week's training camp before their autumn Tests may also explain why the head coach believes Feyi-Waboso warrants a place in the summer squad. Forwards (20): F Baxter (Harlequins), A Clark (Gloucester), A Coles (Northampton), C Cunningham-South (Harlequins), B Curry (Sale), T Dan (Saracens), T Davison (Northampton), A Dombrandt (Harlequins), C Ewels (Bath), J George (Saracens, co-capt), J Heyes (Leicester), T Hill (Bath), N Isiekwe (Saracens), E Iyogun (Northampton) C Langdon (Northampton), A Opoku-Fordjour (Sale), G Pepper (Bath), B Rodd (Sale), S Underhill (Bath), T Willis (Saracens). Backs (16): C Atkinson (Gloucester), S Atkinson (Gloucester), O Beard (Harlequins), J Carpenter (Sale), I Feyi-Waboso (Exeter), G Ford (Sale, co-capt), W Muir (Bath), C Murley (Harlequins), L Northmore (Harlequins), M Ojomoh (Bath), H Randall (Bristol), T Roebuck (Sale), H Slade (Exeter), B Spencer (Bath), F Steward (Leicester), J van Poortvliet (Leicester). Elsewhere, Borthwick has made two changes to the squad that was announced last Monday to prepare for the fixture last weekend. Ben Curry comes in for Jack Kenningham while Raffi Quirke is replaced by Harry Randall. Both Curry and Randall were with the squad for rehabilitation last week but have been deemed fit to make the touring party. George Furbank and Fraser Dingwall were also rehabbing last week but have not been considered for selection. Sign up to The Breakdown The latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewed after newsletter promotion In total, Borthwick has selected 10 uncapped players with Muir joined by Bath teammates Max Ojomoh and Guy Pepper. The Gloucester trio of Seb Atkinson, Charlie Atkinson and Arthur Clark are also selected along with Oscar Beard, Joe Carpenter, Luke Northmore and Emmanuel Iyogun. 'The three-Test series is a huge challenge and a valuable opportunity for the continued development of this squad,' Borthwick said. 'For some of the younger players, this will be their first experience of touring overseas with England. Travelling together helps strengthen team bonds and offers a valuable chance for new players to integrate into our environment.'