Plans to create 'holiday village' near Edinburgh Pentland Hills refused by council
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
Plans to create a holiday site on the fringe of the Pentland Hills have been thrown out for a second time this year
Lucy Crombie lodged an application to build 20 wooden holiday lodges on a site known as the Paddocks.
The area of open countryside borders Leyden Road, a narrow, winding rural road bounded by open farmland and woodlands which climbs from Kirknewton up to the main A70 road which skirts the Pentland Hills regional park.
The same application was rejected by the Development Management Committee in January last year and an appeal later dismissed by the Local Review Body.
One objector called for the council to refuse to decide on the latest filing of the proposals saying they had not changed since the council rejected the same plans last year.
And a lawyer suggested the proposal may have come back "to wear down" resistance.
Planning officers said the applicant had now supplied supplementary reports which validated councillors hearing the plans again.
The latest application attracted 22 objections including one from the local community council and a neighbour Juliet Bentley who lives in the B- listed Ormiston Castle immediately adjacent to the site.
(Image: West Lothian Council)
Ewan MacLeod of legal firm Shepherd and Wedderburn, acting as agents for Ms Bentley told councillors: 'Both we and our client are surprised that the application has been made to the council. It is identical in all material respects to [the previous] application.
'The application has clearly been submitted within the 5 year window and there has been no change in the development plan or in any other material consideration. The council must therefore consider whether to exercise its discretion to refuse to determine the application.'
In its written objection the firm said ' [the] applicant's failure to address the well-founded planning issues raised by local residents and the council's reasons for refusal, we submit that it would be irrational for the council to determine the application.'
Mr MacLeod said that if the application was refused ' the applicant can appeal to Scottish ministers and an unelected Scottish Government official can then take a decision which may overturn the democratic will of this committee… If you decline to determine the application the applicant has no appeal.'
He said such a decision would also save the council the expenses of defending its decision at an appeal.
An agent for the applicant denied planner's criticism of the proposals being "too urban" in appearance, saying that the cabins on the site occupied less than a third of the area.
Suggestions that the site would be too visible on the landscape were also questioned.
He added that his client was prepared to explore road widening and passing spaces outlined in concerns highlighted by the planners.
Planners outlined their objections stating: 'The proposals for the holiday chalets at this location would create a sense of urbanisation within a countryside setting. The Roads Officer would require works to be undertaken in order to improve road safety, including access works, road widening works at five points on the public road and application of a speed limit, to support the proposals.
'Mitigation measures can potentially address road safety concerns (although it is unclear if this will require agreement with third party landowners in respect of road widening works)'
Councillor Damian Doran-Timson asked planning officers what had changed in the plans since they were rejected by the LRB in August last year.
Planning officer Gillian Cyphus said there had been a lack of information when the proposals had gone to the review body; the slight change now was that drainage reports had been made available. That was why planners had recommended the proposals come before councillors for determination, with the recommendation for refusal.
Councillor Pauline Clark said: 'I think we should be encouraging tourists to come here. However I do think access is a big problem. I think the lack of being able to walk to the train station is a problem. I don't know if paths are something that could be sorted. It's major stumbling block
She defended the planning appeal procedures of the Scottish Government as democratic.
Councillor Doran-Timson agreed with her objections: He said ' We need to do more for tourism and economic development has been a failure, but I think the amount of non conformities we have with the application, not just the paths there's a number of different issues that have me going toward officers' recommendations.'
He added: 'Unlike Councillor Clark I share Mr MacLeods concerns about the Scottish Reporter overturns in recent years in West Lothian.'
Councillor Pauline Stafford said she had concerns about families with children walking the main road to Kirknewton. 'The nature of the site would encourage people to drive to and from it,' she added.
Councillor Willie Boyle said: 'My concern is that this looks like a caravan holiday park rather than holiday cabins you see in rural areas. I think the design is wrong.
Councillor Doran Timson's motion to refuse planning permission was backed by Willie Boyle.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
12 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Internationally renowned estate agency, Fine & Country, expands across Scotland
Premium estate agency, Fine & Country, has expanded to cover the whole of Scotland as it builds on success achieved in the south of the country. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Property entrepreneurs Louisa Thomson and Andrew Jack will spearhead the ambitious growth plans, with both drawing upon significant market experience. Louisa will build upon the success of her Fine & Country operation in Dumfries and Galloway to oversee 10 additional areas of Scotland. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Meanwhile, experienced estate agent Andrew, who has operated in the luxury property market for more than 20 years, will lead Fine & Country's operations in Edinburgh. Andrew Jack and Louisa Thomson will lead Fine & Country's expansion across Scotland. Louisa took on Fine & Country's only licence north of the Border four years ago, and she and her South Scotland team were recently declared one of Scotland's best single office estate agents in the prestigious UK Property Awards. She said: 'Fine & Country has a great reputation internationally for the sale and marketing of beautiful homes in the upper quartile of the market, and we are excited to be extending the premium services our customers receive to the whole of Scotland. 'There's been a genuine appetite in the south of the country for a high-quality, internationally renowned estate agency specialising in luxury homes and underpinned by true local knowledge - and we're already receiving positive feedback from other parts of the Scotland eager for Fine & Country to come their way.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scotland's high-end property market has shown remarkable resilience and growth. The Fine & Country Scotland team. In Q1 2025, net agreed sales of prime - upwards of £500k - properties surged 11 per cent year-on-year, compared to just three per cent across the wider Scottish market, highlighting a renewed push from cash-rich buyers in the very highest price brackets. In 2024, Scotland's ultra‐prime segment - homes priced over £1 million - recorded 466 residential transactions - up from 454 the previous year - underscoring steady demand at the very top end of the market. Regarded as one of the UK's most sought-after property markets, Edinburgh has its own dedicated Fine & Country licence. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Andrew is a long-term franchisee of Belvoir, which is part of The Property Franchise Group, as is Fine & Country, and he is excited to bring his experience and knowledge to the country's capital city. He said: 'Edinburgh is arguably the jewel in Scotland's crown and is one of the most desirable places to live and work. Its unique mix of historic charm, modern living, and excellent transport links makes it a prime location for both local and international buyers. 'Fine & Country brings a level of service and a fresh approach to the premium market that will offer sellers and buyers something different from what's currently available. Many of our target clients already engage with the brand through national publications and property sections, so we expect strong interest from the outset. 'Louisa and I have a great working relationship, and we are both extremely experienced at what we do, so it's going to be great to work together to make sure Fine & Country is as successful in Scotland as it is elsewhere in the world.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Jonathan Handford, the Interim Managing Director at Fine & Country, said: "We are thrilled to expand Fine & Country across Scotland and in Edinburgh, and we have no doubt that Louisa, Andrew and their teams will make a significant impact across the country.' Fine & Country Scotland can be contacted on 01738 354110 or scotland@
Edinburgh Live
33 minutes ago
- Edinburgh Live
Senior Edinburgh councillors to get £4k pay rise despite pledge to freeze wages
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Senior Edinburgh councillors have backed giving themselves a pay hike, with only one member speaking out in opposition. In February, Edinburgh Council agreed to freeze pay for senior councillors – including political group leaders and committee conveners – at the previous year's levels. But at Thursday's meeting all political groups except the SNP voted in favour of raising pay for senior councillors, with most getting an uplift of £4,637 to their annual pay packets – an 11.6% jump. Council committee conveners, as well as the SNP, Conservative and Liberal Democrat group leaders, will all get £4,637 added to their annual pay, bringing them to £44,644 per year, up from £40,027 from the previous year. And the depute council leader, Labour's Mandy Watt, will also get a £4,637 pay hike, bringing her total compensation to £52,669, up from £48,032 before. A council spokesperson said the increase in pay for senior councillors was intended to match the pay hike given to non-senior councillors by the Scottish Government. While local authorities have the power to set the pay of senior councillors, the rates for all other councillors are set by the Scottish Government, including the council's leader and Lord Provost, based on the fidings of the Scottish Local Authorities Remuneration Committee (SLARC). Earlier this year, it mandated that the salary for most councillors be raised to £25,982 per year, up £4,637 from their previous pay of £21,345, which stood unchanged for several years. Labour councillor and council leader Jane Meagher is paid £71,519 per year, while Lord Provost Robert Aldridge is paid £53,640. Depute council leader, Labour councillor Mandy Watt, said: 'I sat down and read the guidance, and it does say that in your approach to this, you should be doing councillor remuneration from the bottom up, not the top down. 'I very much appreciate the support that I've had [from officers] to get all this together.' An SNP source said: 'Councillors have been chronically underpaid for decades, and normally I'd take the view that we remunerate the position held, rather than the individual holding it. 'But the current crop of administration conveners are so inept that we could not support them getting a pay hike.' A council spokesperson said: 'While we don't set the rates of pay for non-senior councillor roles it's appropriate that we publish them and provide elected members with the opportunity to scrutinise rates for full transparency. 'The increase in Senior Councillors' remuneration was agreed by Council yesterday, and now includes the increase to the Councillor basic pay set by the Scottish Government.' Only one member, Labour councillor Katrina Faccenda, spoke out against the pay hikes. She said: 'I think you should take note of which councillors are getting extra money, and you should work out whether you are getting value for money from those councillors. 'Since this is public money, and I don't think anyone in here would support the misuse of public money, I'd ask the public to have a look at that, and work out if they think that in Edinburgh Council, the extra money they have to spend to subsidise councillors is being used in the right way.' Cllr Faccenda, who will not financially benefit from the pay increase for senior councillors, voted to support the hike. Meanwhile, independent councillor Ross McKenzie voted with the SNP to oppose the pay hike. Green co-convener, councillor Chas Booth, said: "Greens think it is right that people are paid appropriately for the work they do, and we welcomed the recommendations of the Scottish Local Authority Remuneration Committee around councillors' salaries. 'Pay is a significant barrier to people from marginalised groups entering politics, and if we want to see more diversity in our councillors to reflect the rich diversity of the communities we serve, then we need to ensure people without independent income can become elected representatives. 'However, we acknowledge that while so many people in Edinburgh continue to face a cost-of-living crisis caused by years of austerity which is now being continued by the Labour government at Westminster, the Labour council administration doesn't feel that big increases in senior councillor pay were not appropriate. 'Therefore Green councillors were happy to support their proposals around this."
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Scots businesses caught ‘deliberately' tax dodging named and shamed
The lengthy list of offending UK firms includes convenience stores, internet sales businesses, wholesalers and takeaways north of the border PAY UP Scots businesses caught 'deliberately' tax dodging named and shamed Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SCOTTISH firms caught owing hundreds of thousands of pounds after tax dodging have been named and shamed. HM Revenue and Customs has released a list of companies that have been caught out not paying their dues. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 HMRC has penalised several Scottish-based companies deliberately tax defaulting Credit: PA 2 Day-to-Day Scotland Ltd was one of several firms caught dodging tax payments Credit: Google Maps The lengthy list of offending UK firms includes convenience stores, internet sales businesses, wholesalers and takeaways north of the border. The operator of Day-to-Day Scotland Ltd was caught swerving £131,759 worth of tax between January 1, 2020 and June 30, 2023. The firm, based at 47 Hope Street in Glasgow, was hit with a £79,055 penalty. Internet sales company SK and SA Limited dodged paying £139,184 in tax between February 1, 2015 and January 31, 2018. The business on Ness Street in Glasgow was fined £80,031.19 but HMRC. Mohammad Qasim Umar Nagora, who formerly traded as 7 Star Spices, dodged paying £97,195 in tax between April 6, 2013 and April 5, 2020. The takeaway firm, previously based on Mosspark Drive in Glasgow, was penalised £47,382. Kai Xin Street Limited, which operates as Kai Xin, was snared after evading paying a whopping £299,701 in tax between February 1, 2018 and January 31, 2022. The fast food business, based on King Street in Rutherglen, near Glasgow, was fined £177,568. In Edinburgh, capital gain operator Wai Man Lo was found to have failed to pay £290,450 in tax between April 6, 2018 and April 5, 2019. Five 50ps that could earn you thousands The firm, based on March Road in the capital, has been billed £215,281. Wholesaler Ellol Limited was caught swerving £63,902 in tax payments between August 30, 2022 and February 28, 2023. The company, based on Colinton Road in Glasgow, has been fined £44,731. Mohammed Zaheer Anwar, who previously traded as Lochend Fry, dodged £27,630 in tax between April 6, 2015 and April 5, 2021. The businessman, formerly based on Lochend Road South in Edinburgh, has been hit penalised £13,796. In Perth, Baran Melisa Limited, formerly trading as Marini's, failed to pay a staggering £797,177 in tax between June 1, 2012 and August 31, 2018. The takeaway and restaurant, previously based on St Catherine's Road, has been billed £691,132. If HMRC finds that a firm has deliberately evaded paying, tax evasion penalties can be imposed, amounting to 70 per cent of the tax owed. If businesses or individuals fail to pay tax, HMRC can take further enforcement, including prosecution and seizure of possessions. In rare cases, offenders have been sent to prison for tax evasion. Kevin Hubbard, HMRC's director of individuals and small business compliance, said: "The overwhelming majority pay the tax they owe, but for those who refuse, we use a range of tools to take firm action. 'This includes publishing the names of those penalised for deliberate defaults to influence taxpayer behaviour and encourage defaulters to engage with HMRC." HMRC's full list of deliberate tax defaulters can be viewed here.
