MLA says marriage can weather Bill 15. What of Eby's relationship with First Nations?
VICTORIA - Grand Chief Stewart Phillip is among the fiercest critics of the British Columbia government's planned legislation to fast track infrastructure projects, saying their development 'flouted First Nations' basic human rights.'
His wife, Joan Phillip, says she'll be voting for the bills on Wednesday as a member of Premier David Eby's government.
She said Monday that she doesn't talk too much 'shop' with her husband.
'We have been married for 40 years, going on 41 years, and we have known each other longer,' she said.
'So I think we will weather this.'
The bigger question is if the government's relationship with First Nations is just as sturdy, amid condemnation of bills 14 and 15, which the government says are needed to respond to the threat of United States tariffs.
Surrounded by reporters at the legislature, Joan Phillip, MLA for Vancouver-Strathcona, said she would support both bills, which critics including her husband say undermine the government's obligation to consult First Nations under the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act.
'I have every confidence in our government and their ongoing commitment to DRIPA,' she said. 'So I support the bill and I have read it.'
The government says Bill 15 is to speed up public and private infrastructure projects, while Bill 14 would streamline permitting for renewable energy projects, such as wind farms.
Stewart Phillip, of the Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs, isn't convinced.
'If the (province) wants to fast-track projects, these (bills) are not going to do that, they are setting the stage for bigger fights,' he said on May 15 after a meeting with Eby as part of a delegation from the First Nations Leadership Council.
Chief Don Tom of the Tsartlip First Nation in Greater Victoria said at a protest in downtown Victoria on Monday, steps away from the legislature, that the 'era of trust' with Eby's government is over if the two bills pass this week.
Tom added that First Nations would do everything in their legal power to kill both bills, adding that First Nations would remember the actions of the government at the next election.
Tom said that this won't just apply to the premier, but every MLA who voted for the bills.
'It's the people who care about the environment, and the well-being of British Columbia, who voted for the B.C. NDP,' Tom said. '(We) are going to remember the next election, where they stood on issues and how they used their power and what they used their power for.'
Tom, who also attended the May 15 meeting with Eby, said First Nations have 'a good record in the court system' when it comes to protecting their constitutional rights for consultation.
Tom added that he has made these points to Eby himself, only to be met with 'silence' or a 'simple thank you,' but nothing to indicate a change in course.
'I don't find them (meetings with government) beneficial,' he said. 'They are just government telling us what they are going to do,' Tom said.
Joan Phillip said the government would 'weather this storm' and continue to seek and receive 'informed consent' from Indigenous titleholders.
'I think it's unfortunate and I can understand them feeling that way,' she said of Tom's comments.
'We have been trampled on by many former governments,' she said of First Nations people. 'But since 2017, we have done so much in terms of honouring the United Nations Declaration on Indigenous Peoples. We have got our action plan, and we are going to continue to honour those relationships that we have.'
First Nations want both bills withdrawn or revised, saying they undermine environmental standards and the constitutional rights of consultation for First Nations.
They have also been opposed by the Union of B.C. Municipalities and other critics.
The government wants both Bill 14 and Bill 15 to pass Wednesday after invoking closure on the bills.
Wednesday's vote will be a confidence vote with Speaker Raj Chouhan expected to cast the deciding vote.
Conservative Party of B.C. Leader John Rustad said his party would take every opportunity to bring down Eby's government with five confidence votes scheduled this week.
'I challenge him,' Rustad said. 'Go to the lieutenant-governor's house (and) drop the writ,' he said.
Speaking at a mining announcement in Vancouver, Eby said he was confident bills 14 and 15 would pass.
Tom said he had been talking with New Democrat MLAs to convince them to drop their support for the bills, but declined to reveal their names. However, Joan Phillip wasn't one of them, he said.
Tom said he admires the relationship between Joan and Stewart Phillip.
'They have stood with each other through thick and thin, and if any relationship can handle this, it is theirs,' Tom said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 26, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
5 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Under budget and ahead of schedule, Indigenous battery project shows how Canada could become an energy superpower
NANTICOKE, Ont. — The strong winds that once blew toxic pollution from North America's biggest coal plant over to the nearby Six Nations reserve now turn a forest of wind turbines owned by Indigenous People. With the smoke stacks at Nanticoke long gone , row upon row of solar panels blanket the areas where mountainous piles of coal used to sit. And as of April this year, Canada's largest grid-scale battery project operates a stone's throw away — planned, developed, constructed and owned with First Nations partners. At a time when Indigenous groups across the country are up in arms over federal Bill C-5 and Ontario Bill 5 , which they say bulldoze through their treaty rights to impose high priority development projects, Oneida Energy Storage shows, in the eyes of some, that another way is possible — one where Indigenous communities lead and development is delivered under budget and ahead of schedule . 'Conflict attracts attention. But progress like this is quiet,' said Matt Jamieson, president and CEO of Six Nations of the Grand River Development Corp. Matt Jamieson, president and CEO of Six Nations of the Grand River Development Corporation at the Oneida Energy Storage project in Nanticoke, Ont. Walking amid dozens of rows of colossal white batteries Friday, his words were both figurative and literal. Despite being able to provide 250 megawatts of electricity into the provincial grid — the equivalent of a mid-sized gas plant — the project is virtually silent. And, unlike the natural gas peaker plants they can replace, the batteries produce no emissions. 'It fits within our mandate for environmental conservation, protection and stewardship,' said Warren Sault, president and CEO of Mississaugas of the Credit Business Corporation. Warren Sault, president and CEO of Mississaugas of the Credit Business Corporation at the Oneida Energy Storage project in Nanticoke, Ont. Premier Doug Ford was first elected in 2018 after campaigning against renewable energy, cancelling hundreds of projects and stopping all new investment dead in its tracks. But his government has since seemingly had a change of heart, signing contracts for nearly one gigawatt of wind power and soliciting proposals for more. First Nations such as the Six Nations and the Mississaugas of the Credit River, which partnered on this project, have long been investors in renewable energy, and their experience put them ahead of the curve on recognizing that wind and solar power, because they don't produce electricity around the clock, need to be paired with batteries to achieve their full potential . The batteries charge up on excess power when it isn't needed, like the middle of the night, and pump that electricity back into the grid when demand is high, like on a hot afternoon when people crank up the A/C. 'The hotter it gets, the more the grid needs the power — and it's going to be a hot summer,' said Nick Zsofcsin, head of energy storage at Northland Power, which operates the project. 'We don't charge and discharge fully everyday, but the power is there when you need it.' When Six Nations approached the province to pitch the battery project in 2017, they were met with skepticism, said Jamieson. But after some patient explanation and negotiation, Six Nations and their development partners at Northland and NRStor were able to strike a deal to have the province's first large-scale battery project built, paving the way for an additional 2,800 megawatts of batteries the province contracted last year. 'It took a hell of a long time to convince the province to do this,' Jamieson said. 'But once we did, they turned around and said, 'We need a lot more of it.'' Grid-scale batteries are being installed at a rapid pace around the world, with 11,000 megawatts installed globally in 2022, a 75 per cent increase over the previous year. With all the batteries in the pipeline, Ontario is set to become a leader, though it still trails California, which has the world's most battery storage with more than 15,000 megawatts online. The Oneida project has a 20-year contract, guaranteeing a long-term stable revenue stream for the nearby community on the Six Nations reserve. The Mississaugas of the Credit were brought in so they could benefit, as well. The gleaming rows of batteries resemble an oversized outdoor change room, with little brass locks hanging off locker doors. Behind each door, there are 336 battery packs. With 24 lockers to a megapack and 278 megapacks on site, that's more than 2.2 million batteries all together, each one individually monitored and isolated for safety. The project has more storage capacity than 13,000 Tesla Model Ys, which is a good measure because the batteries themselves are manufactured by Tesla. Strategically located to feed power into the high-voltage transmission lines that used to connect the Nanticoke coal plant to the grid, the batteries also power the nearby Imperial Oil refinery and the Stelco steel mill, two of the province's largest users of electricity. About 40 of the 180 construction jobs were filled by members of the Six Nations, who were able to take their expertise up the road as soon as they were done to start work on an even bigger battery project in Hagersville, which is slated to open before the end of the year. At a time when legislation is being passed at the provincial and federal levels that assumes Indigenous people will be an impediment to development, Jamieson says the Oneida battery project shows how First Nations-led projects can be the key to achieving the goal of making Canada an energy superpower. 'I understand why government actors want to accelerate these large infrastructure projects, but they can't simply do it at the expense of Indigenous voices,' he said. 'Interestingly enough, we were the ones pushing them to move forward on this infrastructure project and now it's become a key component of the energy market in Ontario.'
Hamilton Spectator
a day ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Bill C-5 passes in the House, as Carney vows to consult Indigenous groups
OTTAWA — Facing concerns and warnings of Indigenous resistance against a key part of his governing agenda, Prime Minister Mark Carney acknowledged Friday that 'more fulsome conversations are needed' to choose the development projects his government wants to fast-track through controversial new legislation, Bill C-5. Speaking moments after the bill passed third reading in the House of Commons, Carney pledged to hold meetings in the coming weeks with First Nations, Inuit and Métis leaders and experts in a series of summits to 'launch the implementation of this legislation in the right way' in 'full partnership' with Indigenous communities. This will be the 'first step' in the process to choose which projects will be chosen through the new legislation for the fast-track to approval within the government's goal of two years. The Liberal government's major projects bill has passed the House of Commons thanks to help from the Conservative Party. Prime Minister Mark Carney calls the legislation the core of his government's domestic economic response to U.S. tariffs (June 20, 2025 / The Canadian Press) Carney also repeated pledges earlier this week, as the Liberal government rammed the bill through the House over the objections of some Indigenous , environmental groups and opposition parties, that the new process will respect Indigenous rights to consultation and 'free, prior and informed consent' under the United Nations Declaration to the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. The government House Leader said this week they expect the bill to pass in the Senate next week. 'These projects will be built with Indigenous nations and communities. This is not an aspiration. It is the plan embedded in the bill itself,' Carney said Friday. 'We all agree that more fulsome conversations are needed to select the nation-building projects and to determine the conditions that they must fulfil. In other words, the real work begins now.' In the April 28 election, Carney's Liberals won a minority government while promising to fast-track development projects like mines, pipelines and ports to boost economic growth, make Canada a 'superpower' in clean power and fossil fuels, and reduce reliance on the United States that has imposed a series of tariffs on Canadian goods. Carney acknowledged the bill sailed through the Commons quickly, but argued Friday that speed was needed to confront the 'crisis' of the American trade war. 'This is the response. This is us being in charge of our destiny. That's why we pushed it,' Carney said. Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty — a former grand chief of Eeyou Istchee in Quebec — said the promised summits are a 'serious signal' that Indigenous communities are going to be 'at the table' in deciding how projects will be chosen under the new process. 'There have been more projects selected. It is something that we will define together,' she said. The bill passed through the House of Commons Friday in two votes, after House Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia ruled to split the legislation into two parts. All parties supported a less contentious section to lift federal barriers to trade and labour movement inside Canada. The other, more controversial part dealing with major projects also passed with Liberals and Conservatives voting en masse in favour, and Bloc Québécois, NDP and Green MPs voting against. Toronto Liberal and former cabinet minister MP Nate Erskine-Smith also voted against the national projects part of the legislation . The version of the bill now moving to the Senate came with a suite of amendments, including some that the government supported, aimed at increasing transparency and restricting some of the powers the legislation would create. This includes a provision to obtain the written consent of affected provinces and territories before the government chooses to fast-track a given project, and to ensure the new process that the law would create respects ethics rules and can't override legislation like the Indian Act. The changes also created a new requirement for the government to publish a suite of information about the projects — from the contents of any studies and assessments about their impacts, to all recommendations about them from the civil service — at least 30 days before it officially puts them into the fast-track process. Business groups like the Canadian Chamber of Commerce have also supported the legislation, arguing that a thicket of government regulations has delayed major projects, and that there is now an urgent need to build new infrastructure for energy, critical minerals and other sectors. But Bill C-5 remains controversial, including with predictions this week from some Indigenous leaders that it could inspire resistance and protest like the 2012 'Idle No More' movement because of a lack of consultation on the new powers. MPs have also condemned the national projects part of the legislation as a troubling expansion of power that risks trampling environmental protections and Indigenous rights. After the amendments Friday, the bill retained its proposal to allow the cabinet to choose projects to fast-track based on 'any factor' it considers relevant, and to skirt laws like the Canadian Environmental Protection Act and Species at Risk Act when reviewing projects to speed up. 'This legislation is an abomination and one that will be a stain on the reputation of this government and of our prime minister. As a first effort to lead this country, it's a bad effort,' said Green Leader Elizabeth May. Bloc MP Sébastien Lemire accused the government of reproducing the 'condescending and colonialist spirit' of the last century towards Canada's Indigenous Peoples. And Don Davies, the NDP's interim leader, alleged the bill creates 'Henry VIII' powers that allow the government 'to override laws by decree. 'It guts environmental protections, undermines workers and threatens Indigenous rights,' Davies said. 'This bill will end up in court.'
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Message from the Governor General of Canada on National Indigenous Peoples Day
OTTAWA, ON, June 21, 2025 /CNW/ - National Indigenous Peoples Day is an opportunity to honour the vibrant traditions, languages and contributions of First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities in Canada. It is also an opportunity to celebrate the progress towards reconciliation that we make day after day, while reflecting on the work that lies ahead. Every day, Indigenous Peoples are enriching and redefining every field of endeavour: education, the arts, the environment, entrepreneurship, social programming and many more. I feel tremendous hope and pride when I see Indigenous peoples of all ages forging brilliant new paths to success while proudly embracing their identity. These steps forward are proof of the tangible progress we are making on the path to reconciliation. On this National Indigenous Peoples Day, let us celebrate and take pride in the countless achievements of First Nations, Inuit and Métis peoples in Canada. Mary Simon Stay connected:Follow GovernorGeneralCanada on Facebook, Instagram, X and YouTube. SOURCE Governor General of Canada View original content:
