Federal Judge Certifies Class Action for Transgender People Seeking Passports

A federal judge in Boston granted class-action status to transgender and nonbinary Americans on Tuesday in a lawsuit challenging a U.S. State Department policy that requires passports to reflect only the holder's sex recorded on their original birth certificate.
The order extends a preliminary injunction blocking the State Department from enforcing the policy against six plaintiffs to apply to all class members who apply for or update passports while the case proceeds. In the earlier order from April, U.S. District Judge Julia E. Kobick concluded that the passport policy likely violates the Fifth Amendment's equal protection guarantee because it discriminates based on sex and is 'rooted in irrational prejudice toward transgender Americans.'
The State Department filed an appeal of the preliminary injunction last week.
The government maintains that it has a strong interest in passports that accurately reflect the holder's sex. The State Department adopted the new policy earlier this year to comply with an executive order from President Trump directing all government agencies to limit official recognition of transgender identity and mandating that federal documents reflect what it termed the 'immutable biological classification as either male or female.'
In court documents, plaintiffs argued that a mismatch between the sex listed on their passport and their gender identity puts them at risk of suspicion and hostility that other Americans do not face. During the first weeks of Mr. Trump's administration, several plaintiffs received passports with an 'F' or 'M' marker contrary to the one they had requested. Another learned that selecting an 'X' marker, indicating a nonbinary gender identity, was no longer an option, though it had been allowed since 2022.
The government argued against certifying trans and nonbinary passport holders as a legal class in the case, contending that gender identity is subjective and that a class-wide injunction would create an undue administrative burden.
Judge Kobick, who was nominated by former President Joseph R. Biden Jr., found that those claims did not outweigh significant harm faced by transgender and nonbinary passport holders. She noted that plaintiffs in the case had described being forced to 'effectively 'out' themselves every time they presented their passports,' leading to anxiety and fear safety fears.
'These are the types of injuries that cannot adequately be measured or compensated by money damages or a later-issued remedy,'' she wrote.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

29 minutes ago

• Yahoo

Oil Market Get Fresh Injection of Uncertainty After US Strikes Iran

(Bloomberg) -- US strikes on Iran over the weekend have added to risks for global oil supply, which has so far been unaffected by some of the most extreme military actions in the Middle East in years. Bezos Wedding Draws Protests, Soul-Searching Over Tourism in Venice One Architect's Quest to Save Mumbai's Heritage From Disappearing NYC Congestion Toll Cuts Manhattan Gridlock by 25%, RPA Reports Brent crude jumped early on Monday to trade above $80 a barrel for the first time since mid-January after US President Donald Trump said air attacks had 'obliterated' Iran's three main nuclear sites. Prices then pared much of that gain, as the vital Strait of Hormuz remained open to tankers. Analysts are now trying to weigh the increased geopolitical risk against previous fears that strong production and a lukewarm global economy could result in a supply glut. Here's what oil watchers are saying: Rapidan Energy Group Iran will likely be very cautious about disrupting Hormuz, the narrow passage separating Iran and the Arabian peninsula through which about 25% of the world's oil and 20% of global liquefied natural gas must pass, said Bob McNally, president and founder of Rapidan Energy Group and a former White House energy official. 'Traders are holding their breath, waiting to see if Israel or Iran expand this conflict beyond military and political targets into traded energy,' McNally said on Bloomberg Television. 'So far, no one has pulled that trigger. And if they don't, I can see the price reversing.' Kpler Iran has other options for retaliation, including using its regional proxies to disrupt global trade flows more indirectly, according to Kpler Ltd. senior crude analyst Muyu Xu . That's what happened after Israel's invasion of the Gaza strip in 2023, when Houthi rebels in Yemen began attacking ships in the Red Sea. A direct move to disrupt Middle East oil flows would have severe consequences for prices, she said. 'If Iran blocks the Strait of Hormuz, even for one day, oil can temporarily hit $120 or even $150 a barrel,' she said. 'And if it attacks major oil production or export facilities in neighboring countries, it may drive up prices higher for longer.' Vanda Insights Oil markets have been incredibly choppy since Israel began strikes on Iranian nuclear infrastructure earlier this month, with some trading sessions beginning with price spikes before they retreated into daily losses. Traders need to look past the surprise of the news and analyze whether the underlying risks have actually changed, said Vandana Hari, founder of consultancy Vanda Insights. 'Beyond the knee-jerk reaction to the shock US attacks, the market needs to assess if the risk of the worst-case supply disruption scenarios has risen,' Hari said. 'I don't see a material increase.' Onyx Commodities Long-time oil market hand Harry Tchilinguirian said he's particularly watching whether Iran risks pulling the US deeper into the conflict by responding with strikes on American military assets or energy infrastructure in the region, which could drive prices higher. If the response is confined to Israel, that could reduce fears of escalation. 'Basically, the ball is now in Iran's court to respond, and while it says all options are on the table, some are more consequential than others,' said Tchilinguirian, head of oil research and analytics for Onyx Commodities Ltd. Sparta Commodities It's not just crude oil that faces risk. The Strait of Hormuz is also a major chokepoint for LNG and refined products including diesel and jet fuel. Some fuel markets may see the biggest price responses to the latest development, said June Goh, senior oil market analyst with Sparta Commodities. Diesel and jet fuel supply chains are most exposed to the Middle East as oil products from the Arab Gulf flow through Hormuz to feed the main demand hub in Europe, Goh said. 'The east-west spread for middle distillates is expected to widen further to incentivize barrels to flow into Western markets.' Saxo Bank Even without a full-scale disruption, the threat of Iranian action in the strait could hamper shipments, said Ole Hansen, head of commodity strategy for Saxo Bank A/S. Such delays could lead to short-term price spikes, but gains would be capped after countries released strategic reserves, and Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates redirected some crude to facilities outside Hormuz. 'The current geopolitical risk premium — now exceeding $10 a barrel — cannot be sustained for long without a tangible supply disruption,' Hansen said. 'Absent that, price gains may struggle to hold.' RBC Capital Markets Iran has options for retaliation beyond attempting to fully shut the strait, such as strikes on tankers or the port of Fujairah in the UAE, or exerting pressure on remaining allied groups in Iraq and Yemen to assist, said RBC Capital Markets LLC analysts including Helima Croft. It may take days or even weeks to comprehend the nation's full response. 'Above all, we would caution against the knee-jerk 'the worst is behind us' hot take at this stage,' Croft said. 'President Trump may indeed have successfully executed an 'escalate to de-escalate' move, but a wider expansion cannot still be ruled out at this juncture.' (Updates with comments from Saxo and RBC. A previous version was corrected to remove a reference to Indian product flows.) Luxury Counterfeiters Keep Outsmarting the Makers of $10,000 Handbags Is Mark Cuban the Loudmouth Billionaire that Democrats Need for 2028? Ken Griffin on Trump, Harvard and Why Novice Investors Won't Beat the Pros The US Has More Copper Than China But No Way to Refine All of It Can 'MAMUWT' Be to Musk What 'TACO' Is to Trump? ©2025 Bloomberg L.P. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Black America Web

29 minutes ago

• Black America Web

Trump Complains About Juneteenth, X Shows Off His Hypocrisy

Source: Sean Rayford / Getty President Donald Trump's complaint about federal holidays on Juneteenth prompted social media to show his past support for it while campaigning. As the nation observed Juneteenth on Thursday (June 19), the most noticable action — or inaction — was in the federal government save for a Truth Social post by President Donald Trump. He stated that he would get rid of 'non-working holidays', complaining that 'Soon we'll end up having a holiday for every once working day of the year,' without acknowledging Juneteenth by name, concluding 'It must change if we are going to, MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!' Juneteenth observes June 19th, 1865, the day when those Black Americans enslaved in Galveston, Texas were informed by a Union Army general that the Civil War had ended and that they had been freed by President Abraham Lincoln's signing of the Emancipation Proclamation two and a half years before. It was made a federal holiday by President Joe Biden in 2021, and it cannot be revoked without an act of Congress. Trump's stance was echoed by White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt during her press conference. After answering a question concerning a potential proclamation for Juneteenth, she replied: 'I'm not tracking his signature on a proclamation today. I want to thank all of you for showing up to work. We are certainly here.' Trump had signed up to eleven proclamations in the past week alone for Father's Day, Flag Day as well as the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army, which are not among the 11 annual federal holidays. According to reporting from The Guardian, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth requested a 'passive approach to Juneteenth messaging' in an email sent out earlier this week. The news comes after Hegseth has obeyed orders from Trump to carry out his elimination of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI), seen in renaming military installations like Fort Bragg and warships such as one named after the slain Civil Rights leader Medgar Evers. But Trump's social media post was swiftly called out by many on social media who noted that during his presidential campaign in 2020, he promoted Juneteenth becoming a federal holiday as part of his 'Platinum Plan' geared towards earning votes among the Black community. Former President Joe Biden spent the day on Galveston Island, attending the Juneteenth Emancipation March and Service held at Reedy Chapel AME, where he also paid homage to the late Texas Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee who worked to make Juneteenth a federal holiday. Trump Complains About Juneteenth, X Shows Off His Hypocrisy was originally published on Black America Web Featured Video CLOSE

Yahoo

33 minutes ago

• Yahoo

Trump admin live updates: Trump to meet with national security team on Monday

President Donald Trump on Sunday pushed Republicans to get behind his taxation bill that will fund his agenda as the self-imposed Fourth of July deadline approaches. "Great unity in the Republican Party, perhaps unity like we have never seen before. Now let's get the Great, Big, Beautiful Bill done," Trump wrote on social media. Trump addressed the nation on Saturday night after the U.S. carried out airstrikes on Iran's nuclear facility, which he called "a spectacular military success."Jun 23, 2:44 AMTrump to meet with national security team on Monday President Donald Trump is scheduled to host a closed meeting with his national security team on Monday as the administration prepares for possible Iranian retaliation following this weekend's U.S. attacks on Tehran's nuclear meeting will take place in the Oval Office at 1 p.m. ET, according to the president's public schedule. -ABC News Michelle Stoddart Jun 22, 12:13 PMAfter Iran strike, Trump sets sights on his 'big, beautiful bill' Following the U.S. military strike on Iran, Trump publicly praised what he called "great unity" within the Republican Party and shifted his focus to the administration's next legislative priority.'Great unity in the Republican Party, perhaps unity like we have never seen before. Now let's get the Great, Big, Beautiful Bill done,' Trump wrote on social media. 'Our Country is doing GREAT. MAGA!' The post was the president's first public comment since his address to the nation about the Iran attack on Saturday evening. The administration is aiming to pass the president's tax legislation ahead of the self-imposed July Fourth deadline.-ABC News' Kelsey Walsh Click here to read the rest of the blog.