It would be some irony if the two parts of Ireland taught the UK lessons in devolution

Quality of life is much the same North and South, although we tend to arrive at our similar outcomes through different ways.
That is a rough summary of the first full research report from
the Shared Island Initiative
, launched by Taoiseach Micheál Martin on Monday.
Both parts of Ireland have similar figures on income inequality, for example, but
Northern Ireland
achieves this more through its benefit system and the Republic more through its tax system. Housing consumes around one-fifth of disposable income in both jurisdictions, representing a great cancelling out of multiple factors. Health services on either side of the Border deliver the same levels of primary and secondary care. However, unmet demand in the North is more about long waits, while in the South it is more about high costs.
Will there be a teacher's strike in the autumn?
Listen |
45:36
Headlines are made by dramatic differences, not similarities, on closer inspection, so the lack of interest in Monday's announcement is unsurprising. But the record of the Shared Island Initiative is that what starts off dry as dust and condemned by some nationalists for lacking ambition, can then slowly and subtly transform attitudes in ways nationalism has never managed.
READ MORE
When the initiative was established in 2020, it commissioned the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) to examine policy differences and the potential for co-operation across the island. Monday's report is an overarching summary of the programme so far.
A step change in this work was promised in last November's Fianna Fáil manifesto and adopted in the Coalition's programme for government. It mandates commissioning 'a North-South statistical series and publication to provide comparable data on economic activity, public expenditure and wider social and economic measures, including education, housing and health outcomes'.
Monday's report is the start of this new era of authoritative, comparative data. How much authority it acquires remains to be seen – none of this is a precise science – but it has been given the imprimatur of the Taoiseach's office.
The stated purpose of the data is not to support any constitutional argument, heaven forbid. It serves two official objectives: learning from policy differences either side of the border; and analysing the extent and potential of cross-Border co-operation.
Policy differences are to be studied for useful insight, rather than with any political goal of harmonisation. The ESRI report explains that there is more to learn from your immediate neighbours simply because their experience is more likely to be relevant. It mentions comparative studies between 'the four parts of the UK' as an example.
When the United Kingdom embarked on devolution three decades ago, there were hopes it would function as a policy laboratory, with regions learning from each other's different approaches to practical problems. Instead, devolution has become a platform for constitutional arguments, while public services are neglected. The devolved administrations pay scant attention to each other and Westminster believes it has little to learn from any of them. It would be quite an achievement, and quite an irony, if both parts of Ireland did better than the UK at making the policy laboratory work.
The clearest lessons to emerge from the ESRI report are that Northern Ireland needs to improve its further education and training. Although children reach the end of school with similar skill levels North and South, too many northerners then leave education with few or no qualifications. Comparison with the Republic reveals the extent to which a handful of poor policy choices are throwing human potential away.
[
Shared Island: Cross-Border co-operation should be expanded, ESRI report concludes
Opens in new window
]
On cross-Border co-operation, the second subject of the report's analysis, the revelation is how little of it takes place. Collaboration on healthcare is mainly confined to specialist initiatives in Border areas. Just 0.6 per cent of students at southern universities are from the North, with a 2.4 per cent figure in the opposite direction.
Tourism and energy are the only sectors where all-Ireland co-operation has developed at a significant, strategic level, yet only tourism has the benefit of dedicated North-South structures under the Belfast Agreement. The all-Ireland energy market owes its success to private investment in a highly regulated market. There are other cases where regulation gets in the way, such as the taxation of cross-Border workers. So, although there is plenty of potential for further co-operation, it is not as straightforward as tends to be imagined, or as the Belfast Agreement may appear to envisage.
While that will hardly be news to any informed observer, they are now better informed with official facts and figures. Taking ownership of the facts away from unreliable partisans is how a dry report can begin to slowly and subtly transform attitudes. It is easier to have a serious debate on where Northern Ireland and the Republic are going when there is agreement on where they are today. Not that the Shared Island Initiative has any particular destination in mind, of course. Heaven forbid.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Irish Examiner

38 minutes ago

• Irish Examiner

First Minister O'Neill remains vague about potential presidential candidacy

The North's First Minister Michelle O'Neill has failed to rule herself out as a potential candidate for the Irish presidential election. When asked to comment on speculation that she may throw her hat into the ring, Ms O'Neill was coy, only saying: "I think I have plenty to do as first minister." Asked whether or not she was considering it, she responded: "I am... working our way through deliberations as we speak." Sinn Féin is in the midst of a consultation process with members on how it will proceed in terms of the election. "It's a very important and significant role. Sinn Féin could have a candidate or support someone from outside of Sinn Féin. There are merits in both options," a party spokesperson said. While remaining vague on her own ambitions in terms of the presidency, Ms O'Neill was clear on wanting to see voting rights extended to citizens in the North. I could stand for election, I could be elected Uachtarán na hÉireann but I cannot vote in that election. "So that is where there is a deficit, and what we need to see is presidential voting rights extended to Irish citizens in the North," said Ms O'Neill. She was speaking at a meeting of the North South Ministerial Council in Armagh where Taoiseach Micheál Martin was also questioned about possible candidates to take on the role. Mr Martin appeared to be caught off-guard by a suggestion that former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood could be a possible Fianna Fáil candidate. "There has been no contact with me and there has been no engagement that I am aware of with the Fianna Fáil party and it has not been on the agenda," the Fianna Fáil leader said. The party has not yet concluded its deliberations with Mr Martin suggesting that it is likely to be later in the summer when they make an announcement on the matter.

Irish Independent

an hour ago

• Irish Independent

Impact of coastal erosion on Wexford beaches raised in the Dáil – ‘Courtown and Kilmichael are in serious danger'

Coastal erosion in Courtown beach in Gorey has had a significant effect with lifeguards moving northwards to cater for the crowd concentrations. 'Up to 25 per cent of Ireland's coastline is facing the serious problem of coastal erosion and the proportion in counties Wicklow and Wexford is higher. The Taoiseach will be aware that I represent an area that stretches from Brittas Bay to Morriscastle. We have some of the finest beaches in the country, but many of them, most notably Courtown and Kilmichael, are in serious danger,' he explained. "We need to look at addressing this from a climate point of view and at beach replenishment. There is the threat to adjoining lands and infrastructure, nesting areas and coastal biodiversity. We can learn from other countries such as the Netherlands.' Beach replenishment is a common practice in the Netherlands, and involves adding sand to the beaches and the seabed to counteract erosion. A popular method is the sand motor, which involves depositing a large amount of sand offshore, allowing natural forces like waves, wind, and currents to redistribute the sand over time. 'Of concern to me as well is that the Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment's own statistics show that, between 2017 and 2024, the number of homes at risk in our coastal areas grew from 1,445 to 2,279. I ask that this issue be a priority,' he added. Taoiseach Micheál Martin agreed that the situation was an important issue, following on after his attendance at the UN Ocean Summit in France recently. "Ireland is increasingly making a significant contribution to the international debate on the oceans. Regarding coastal erosion, I invite the Deputy to make a submission to the Minister for public expenditure.' He highlighted the climate change crisis and how the erosion of coasts will have a domino affect on food production if not addressed promptly. "Climate change is here and now; it is not something that is going to come in ten years' time. It is affecting flooding. It is eroding coastlines. It is putting homes in danger. It is affecting food production patterns and so on. I believe that, in the next national development plan, there has to be ring-fenced funding for the cost of climate change to enable us to adapt to protect,' he said.

RTÉ News​

2 hours ago

• RTÉ News​

Behind the Story: The most brutal political race of all

A small few have outlined their interest in running for the presidency later this year, but many more are tight-lipped. A lot of people have ruled themselves out, while others have been kicking official announcements down the path by insisting decisions have not been made. For the bigger parties there's a lot to consider - and for the rest of us there's a lot to speculate on. It seems Fine Gael have two strong options, while Sinn Féin's Michelle O'Neill raised eyebrows earlier when she neither said yes or no when directly asked if she will run. Fianna Fáil have a bit of a selection dilemma on their hands, and the spot for an expected joint-left candidate seems to be wide open. In the latest episode of Behind the Story, Katie Hannon, Fran McNulty and David McCullagh scan the field and tell the more dramatic stories of past campaigns. They go into how Albert Reynolds thought he had a nomination in 1997, only to be pipped by Mary McAleese. They also look at the infamous phone call that Brian Lenihan denied he ever made.