Is seat 11A the safest on a plane? Not really, experts say
LONDON: The survival of a passenger who escaped through an exit door seconds after his Air India flight crashed killing everyone else on board has prompted speculation over whether his seat, 11A, is the safest.
Aviation experts say it is not so straightforward because aircraft vary widely in seat configurations, crashes are unique and survival often hinges on a complex interplay of factors.
"Each accident is different, and it is impossible to predict survivability based on seat location," said Mitchell Fox, a director at Flight Safety Foundation, a US-based nonprofit.
Viswashkumar Ramesh said his 11A seat was near an emergency exit on the London-bound Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner that crashed in Ahmedabad on Thursday and he managed to walk out.
Sitting next to an exit door might help you survive an accident but it would not always be 11A because aircraft can have dozens of different configurations.
"In this particular instance, because the passenger was sitting adjacent to the emergency exit, this was obviously the safest seat on the day," said Ron Bartsch, chairman at Sydney-based AvLaw Aviation Consulting.
"But it's not always 11A, it's just 11A on this configuration of the Boeing 787."
A 2007 Popular Mechanics study of crashes since 1971 found that passengers towards the back of the plane had better survival odds. Some experts suggest the wing section offers more stability.
Sitting next to an exit door, like Ramesh, gives you an opportunity to be one of the first out of the plane, although some exits do not function after a crash. The opposite side of the plane was blocked by the wall of a building it crashed into, he said.
In January of last year, a panel missing several bolts blew off the side of a Boeing 737 MAX mid-flight, creating a gaping hole and damaging the adjacent seat. Fortunately, no one was seated there at the time, and the incident resulted in no fatalities.
Sitting by the aisle might offer you a speedier escape but it increases the likelihood of being hit in the head by luggage falling out of the overhead bins - a much more common occurrence than major crashes.
SAFETY BRIEFINGS
Paying attention to the safety briefing at the start of your flight - often dismissed as routine - is likely the best way to improve your chances of survival, experts say.
Disciplined compliance with cabin crew evacuation advice, including leaving bags behind, was a key factor in saving the lives of all 379 passengers and crew aboard a Japan Airlines flight in January last year.
The Airbus A350 aircraft had collided with a Coast Guard plane at Tokyo's Haneda Airport, killing five of the six crew members on the smaller aircraft.
Safety briefings typically cover critical instructions such as how to fasten your seatbelt securely, adopt the correct brace position and plan your evacuation route.
A common tip is to count the number of rows between your seat and the nearest exit - vital knowledge if the cabin fills with smoke and visibility is low.
Despite disasters such as the Air India crash, plane designs have evolved to increase the likelihood of passengers walking away from a rare plane accident, Fox said.
These include floor path lighting, fire detection and extinguishers, less flammable cabin materials and improved access to emergency exits.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Air India cuts international flights after crash causes chaos
Air India's decision came a day after Indian authorities directed the airline to improve its operations. PHOTO: REUTERS NEW DELHI – Air India, India's flagship carrier, said it would temporarily reduce the number of international flights it operates, after the deadly crash of one of its flights last week unleashed plane delays, unnerved passengers and prompted technical inspections of its fleet. The airline, which is grappling with the aftermath of the June 12 crash that killed at least 270 people, said late on June 18 in a post on the social media platform X that it was cutting international services on certain planes by 15 per cent at least until mid-July. The move, which applies to wide-body jets – planes with two aisles that are typically used for long-haul flights – is meant to 'ensure stability of operations, better efficiency and minimise inconvenience to passengers,' it said. Air India's decision came a day after Indian authorities directed the airline to improve its operations. The airline has been inundated by complaints from passengers about cancelled flights, faulty cabin devices and inadequate information being given to travelers. On June 17, India's Directorate General of Civil Aviation, the country's main civil flight regulator, said in a statement that it found no 'major safety concerns' as it conducted technical inspections of Air India's fleet of 33 Boeing 787 Dreamliner planes, the model of plane that crashed. So far, 26 of the airline's planes have been cleared, Air India said. However, the regulator did find 'maintenance-related issues' and directed the carrier to 'strengthen internal coordination across engineering, operations, ground handling units'. Air India has a fleet of 190 planes, a company spokesperson said late on June 19, though its website lists 128. Air India Group, including Air India Express, operates about 1,000 flights daily, including to dozens of overseas destinations. The carrier has cancelled more than 80 flights since the crash. NYTIMES Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
3 days ago
- Straits Times
Boeing keeps low profile at Paris Air Show as Airbus hits $27 billion orders
An Airbus A350-1000 passenger aircraft performs during an exhibition flight demonstration as the Paris Air Show on June 18. PHOTO: AFP PARIS – Every other year, thousands of visitors flock to a Paris suburb for the Paris Air Show, one of the aerospace industry's biggest events. The atmosphere is typically celebratory, but the recent deadly crash of an Air India flight cast a shadow over the show this week. The contrasting moods were apparent in the rivalry between two of the show's most prominent aircraft manufacturers: Airbus and Boeing. Airbus said it had withheld some announcements, but still secured US$21 billion (S$27 billion) of orders for new commercial jets, while rival Boeing opted not to announce new sales following last week's Air India 787 crash. The cause of the crash, in which at least 270 people died in the plane and on the ground, has yet to be determined. But it happened at a delicate moment for Boeing, which had appeared to be moving past a series of setbacks in recent years. The company reported nearly 350 orders in May, some of which were part of a trade deal between the United States and Britain. That made May Boeing's best month for sales in a year and a half. Boeing also reached a crucial production target in May for its most popular plane, the 737 Max. Boeing's chief executive, Kelly Ortberg, and the head of its commercial plane unit, Stephanie Pope, were scheduled to attend the air show, but cancelled their plans after the Air India crash. The sober atmosphere for Boeing was a contrast to Airbus, which boasted major orders for its most popular jets, including 40 A220 single-aisle jets for LOT Polish Airlines and a deal with VietJet for up to 150 single-aisle jets. Airbus also scored big wins in Saudi Arabia, which wants to become an international air travel hub: Riyadh Air ordered 25 A350 wide-body aircraft, while AviLease, a Saudi jet leasing company, ordered 40 commercial and cargo jets. Still, Airbus said it had chosen to hold back some announcements. 'The cold shower we all had was the Air India accident, so we've actually scaled back,' said Christian Scherer, the CEO of Airbus' commercial aircraft business. He added that although aerospace was extremely competitive, Airbus never used safety to its advantage: 'You don't go there.' Boeing has been in catch-up mode the past few years as its rival has pulled ahead in orders. Even if it does see any slowdown in business because of the crash, it will probably be temporary if the investigation clears the plane itself, said Richard Aboulafia, a managing director at AeroDynamic Advisory, a consulting firm. 'If there's any pullback from orders in the aftermath of this tragedy, it's purely for optics,' he said. Airlines remain confident in Boeing's planes and have only one major alternative in Airbus. It could take months to determine the cause of the crash. The plane's flight data recorder and cockpit voice recorder, both of which have been recovered, should yield a wealth of information, experts said. It was the first fatal crash involving a Dreamliner, a popular choice for long-distance routes because of its range, fuel efficiency and other factors. More than 1,100 are in service today, according to Cirium, an aviation data firm. India's aviation authority, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation, said on June 17 that a review of Air India's remaining Dreamliner planes 'did not reveal any major safety concerns.' NYTIMES Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Business Times
4 days ago
- Business Times
Airbus hits US$21 billion orders at Paris Air Show as Boeing focuses on India crash
[PARIS] Airbus secured more aircraft orders on Wednesday, raising its total to US$21 billion at this week's subdued Paris Air Show, while rival Boeing opted not to announce new sales following last week's Air India 787 crash. Airbus firmed up an order for 10 long-haul jets from Taiwan's Starlux Airlines in a boost for the European planemaker after one of its biggest customers, AirAsia, dashed expectations of another grand finale matching its earlier expansion. Airbus won a total of 148 firm orders worth US$14.2 billion including six previous ones disclosed publicly for the time, plus 102 provisional orders worth US$6.7 billion, according to estimated delivery prices from UK-based Cirium Ascend. Delegates had been bracing for a more muted show than usual after Boeing struck huge deals during US President Donald Trump's recent trip to the Middle East. The US jetmaker then scaled back its presence at the show to focus on the probe into last week's deadly crash of an Air India Boeing 787. But Europe's Airbus has been steadily racking up business, and underscored confidence about growing demand by holding out the prospect of higher dividends. It prefaced each show announcement with sympathies for India victims, however. 'It is an air show with a regrettable tragedy that has affected all of us,' Airbus planemaking CEO Christian Scherer told Reuters. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Despite the sombre tone, talk was rife before and during the event at Le Bourget outside Paris that Airbus might seal a major deal with AirAsia to add a final flourish to the gathering. Airline entrepreneur Tony Fernandes, the CEO of AirAsia owner Capital A Group, told Reuters that it was in talks to buy 50 to 70 A321XLR jetliners, and 100 A220s or competing E2 regional jets from Brazil's Embraer. But he played down the chances of a deal in Paris, saying the first priority was to complete the group's restructuring. 'We're still doing a lot of work with Airbus and other (manufacturers) .... I think we'll look to do something imminently, in the next 1-3 months,' he said in an interview. Two industry sources said Airbus had made an 'aggressive' offer to boost A220 orders and win a launch customer for a new 160-seat version but that talks stalled over financing. Another said it would be natural to resume discussions around July when the company expects to exit its financial troubles. 'Different show' Embraer said on Wednesday it had secured an order for 60 of its E175 regional jets from SkyWest Airlines, which also agreed purchase rights for a further 50 of the aircraft. Airbus announced an order for two A350 freighters from logistics company MNG Airlines, and EgyptAir was unveiled as the previously-undisclosed buyer of six A350-900 long-haul jets. Planemakers have been struggling to keep up with demand for new, more fuel-efficient aircraft since the end of pandemic-era travel restrictions, with supply chain problems - particularly with engines - delaying some deliveries. Airbus said on Wednesday, however, that since early 2025 it had experienced 40 per cent fewer disruptions caused by delayed components at its production facilities. 'It has been a very different air show from those we have seen in the past, which have tended to be wall-to-wall aircraft orders,' Agency Partners analyst Sash Tusa said. 'Civil orders have been affected by .... Boeing being very careful about how they announce or don't announce things,' he said. In another shift, he said, Airbus focused on securing public backing for planes that could benefit from more orders like the A220, rather than its heavily sold-out A320neo family. On the defence side of the show, US drone maker Anduril and Germany's Rheinmetall said they would partner to build aerial drones for European markets, in a sign of Europe leveraging US technology to boost military capabilities. REUTERS
