Sinn Féin MEP calls on EU commissioner to withdraw 'deeply inaccurate' remarks about Ireland
SINN FÉIN MEP Kathleen Funchion has called on the EU's foreign commissioner to her withdraw remarks on Ireland's neutrality.
During a debate at the European Parliament in Strasbourg on Tuesday on the upcoming Nato summit next week, Funchion criticised the EU's inaction on dealing with Israel's military operations in the Gaza, Iran and other parts of the Middle East.
The Ireland South MEP later noted the sovereign right of each member state to choose its own foreign policies and if they participate in military alliances such as Nato. She said that the EU hopes it recognises Ireland's right to maintain its historical neutral stance.
'We in Ireland have a proud history and tradition of UN peacekeeping, and long may that continue,' Funchion said, adding that it was 'important to reference the creeping militarisation into EU politics'.
'This debate has been a combination of maddening and depressing for the past two hours, listening to the vast majority of speakers. I would also remind people that, at its core, the EU is supposed to be a peace project, and we should not move away from this'
Other members also voiced concern over the fulfilment of international law obligations in the conflict during the debate and called for a renewed effort to achieve peace in the Middle East and in Ukraine.
'Peace does not mark end of suffering'
During her closing remarks, the European Commission Vice President and foreign affairs Commissioner Kaja Kallas said that peace can only be achieved in Ukraine when the aggressor, Russia, is willing to negotiate.
She addressed Funchion's remarks and claimed that Ireland had the chance for 'prosperity' in the years following the World War II, while the rest of Europe experienced 'atrocities'.
She said, in that context, that a negotiated peace through surrender would not benefit countries under siege by others.
Advertisement
'I want to address our Irish colleagues,' Kallas said. 'Peace doesn't mean the human suffering will stop. If you surrender, you [still] have the aggressor. [If] you say, 'Take all that you want', it doesn't mean that human suffering will stop.
'In our experience behind the Iron Curtain [the border between the Soviet Union and Europe during the Cold War] after World War II, countries like Ireland got to build up their prosperity, but for us, it meant atrocities, mass deportations, suppression of our culture and language.
'This is what happens, it is peace – but not freedom. It's not freedom of choice for people. And that is what the EU is all about and that's what we're fighting for.'
'Ill-advised remarks should be withdrawn'
The remarks have been criticised as 'deeply inaccurate' by MEP Funchion, who said the vice-president was dismissive of the post-war experience of people on the island of Ireland.
Funchion said Kallas' comments were 'ill-advised and deeply insensitive to the experiences of Irish communities still seeking justice to this day'.
She added: 'Ireland too endured atrocities, from the Ballymurphy massacre to Bloody Sunday, where innocent civilians were shot and killed by British soldiers. Our people suffered internment without trial, and widespread discrimination in housing and employment, particularly in the North.
'Furthermore, the suppression of Irish language and culture has been an ongoing battle, as evidenced by the decades-long campaign for an Irish Language Act in the North.
She added: 'I have written to the vice-president asking her to withdraw her remarks and to acknowledge the reality of Ireland's past.'
Kallas' office has been contacted for comment.
Includes reporting by Press Association
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
‘Lit up like a Christmas tree' – Calls for vape shop restrictions in south Dublin
The motion, brought by Sinn Féin councillor William Casey, said that the 'proliferation of vape shops" in the centre of villages and near schools was an 'undesirable development' that should be tackled with a ban. During the Clondalkin, Newcastle, Rathcoole, Saggart and Brittas Area Committee meeting, Mr Casey said the growing number of vape shops were targeted at school-going children. "It's our children that they're aiming at. They're no longer aiming them at the adults who have taken to vaping because they couldn't get off cigarettes, they're being aimed directly as a first-choice product for children,' he said. Other councillors agreed, with Independent Francis Timmins saying that he wasn't only worried about the number of vape shops, but also their lengthy opening hours. "At 11 or 12 at night, a vape shop open in the middle of Clondalkin is a bit bizarre to me. I don't get it, I don't understand it,' he said. "I'm concerned about the opening times, I'm concerned about the litter of the vapes around the shops, we've had an issue with that, we've had an issue with signage, particularly the signage around the ACA (architectural conservation area). 'One of the vape shops is lit up like a Christmas tree, and it's lit up from early morning to late at night, and it's just diabolical to be quite honest with you for a heritage village,' he added. Mr Timmins said he thought there were four or five such shops in Clondalkin village, with several selling vapes and sweets alongside one another, a tactic that 'really worries' him. Independent Ireland councillor Linda de Courcy said 'nothing good is going to come' from the number of vape shops now open in Clondalkin, and said she had seen children buying sweets in them. A response from SDCC given to Mr Casey said that no policy on vape shops existed in the County Development Plan 2022-2028. ADVERTISEMENT Even if it were in the plan, the council said it would have a 'very limited effect' on the ground because shops benefit from significant exemptions under the Planning and Development Act 2001. "This means a wide range of commercial and retail premises in our villages and communities could be changed to vape shops without planning permission. This makes the planning system unsuited to the management of vape shops.'
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Sinn Fein's Michelle O'Neill doesn't rule herself out of Áras bid
Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill has declined to rule herself out of being Sinn Féin's candidate in the upcoming Irish Presidential election. Despite saying that she was busy as First Minister, she did not rule herself out of being the candidate in the election. President Michael D Higgins will leave Áras an Uachtaráin in November, with the election likely to take place in October. Parties have been slow out of the traps to announce whether they will run a candidate and who that candidate will be. When asked at the North South Ministerial Council in Armagh on Friday, if she would be running for Sinn Féin, Ms O'Neill did not directly say no, despite being asked twice. She said: 'We [in Sinn Féin] haven't completed our own deliberations in terms of the presidential race itself. 'I think I have plenty to do being First Minister here. 'But I think that the fact remains that I could stand for election. I could be elected as Uachtarán na hÉireann, but I can't vote in that election. 'That's where there's a deficit of what we need to see is presidential voting rights extended to the north, so that Irish citizens can vote for their Uachtarán.' When asked if she was considering putting her name forward, Ms O'Neill said: 'I am currently working our way through our deliberations as we speak.' Meanwhile, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said that there has been no communication between Fianna Fáil and former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood about the prospect of him being Fianna Fáil's candidate. In an interview with the BBC, Mr Eastwood, who resigned as SDLP leader in October, stated that he was considering entering the race. The Taoiseach, however, denied suggestions that the MP for Foyle would be the Fianna Fáil candidate. He said: 'There's been no contact with me, and there's been engagement that I am aware of with the Fianna Fáil party.. That hasn't been on the agenda at all, in terms of Colum. 'I was surprised when I heard that this morning that he was considering it. But of course, it's open to everyone to put themselves forward. 'Colum is a very effective parliamentarian, has been a political leader in Northern Ireland for quite some time. 'But we will make our choices as a party, and we haven't concluded deliberations at all.'The Taoiseach stated that previous experiences from Presidential elections, that later in the summer would be a 'more optimal time' to announce who is running for the party. The Irish Mirror understands that the Fine Gael nomination process for the presidential election campaign will open in July. Other parties, including the Social Democrats and Labour, are still mulling over whether to run a unity candidate in October's election.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood considers running for Irish Presidency
The Foyle MP stepped down as leader in October 2024. Mr Eastwood said he was considering because 'people have asked'. "We'll see where it goes," he told the BBC. "There's very few candidates in the field right now. It's something that needs a lot of consideration. "I'm going to take the time to think about it, but it's a long summer and there's enough to be getting on with before any decisions around that would have to be made.' Incumbent President Michael D Higgins is not eligible to stand again as he will have completed two full seven-year terms. Taoiseach Micheál Martin said he is not aware of any engagement with former SDLP leader Colum Eastwood over becoming the Fianna Fáil candidate for the Irish presidency. It has been reported that Mr Eastwood is considering a bid for Áras an Uachtaráin. Asked to confirm if Mr Eastwood had been approached by the Fianna Fáil party, Mr Martin questioned the basis for the question, adding: 'There's been no contact with me, there's been no engagement that I am aware of from the Fianna Fáil party and it hasn't been on the agenda at all.' Mr Martin said he was 'surprised' to hear Mr Eastwood was considering a run but said 'it's open to everybody to put themselves forward'. He said Mr Eastwood was a 'very effective parliamentarian' but Fianna Fáil had not concluded on deliberations 'at all'. Meanwhile, Northern Ireland First Minister Michelle O'Neill has not ruled out a run for the Irish presidential election. Asked if she was considering putting her name forward, Ms O'Neill said Sinn Féin is working its way through deliberations on putting forward a candidate.
