Trump attorneys argue for hush-money appeal to move to federal court
Attorneys for Donald Trump on Wednesday argued that the appeal of his felony conviction in New York should be moved to federal court because the case related to official acts as president, while the state said it was too late to make the change.Trump was convicted last May of lying in relation to a hush-money payment to adult-film star Stormy Daniels, which he appealed. Then, in July, the US Supreme Court granted the president immunity for official acts. For Trump's legal team, the goal of moving to federal court is for the conviction to be overturned on immunity grounds.Both sides made their case during a one-hour hearing before a three-judge panel of the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals.
Trump's attorney, Jeffrey Wall, argued that the president's appeal belonged in federal court because the Manhattan District Attorney's Office chose to include evidence that they say relates to Trump's official acts as president, including testimony from former White House Communications Director Hope Hicks."Everything about this cries out for federal court," Mr Wall told the three-judge panel. The Manhattan District Attorney's Office, meanwhile, argued Trump's legal team took too long to ask for the case to be moved, after his sentencing. "After sentencing, removal is no longer available," said Steven Wu of the Manhattan District Attorney's Office. "Even if it were technically available, there are compelling reasons not to permit it."Mr Wu also disagreed with Trump's attorneys that some of the evidence presented in the hush-money trial related to his official acts. He gave an example of a postal worker who robbed someone while not at work, but then chose to confess his crimes in the postal office. The confession in the office, he argued, would not be related to the postal worker's official duties. Trump's crime, Mr Wu argued, "was completed before the White House evidence". During the hearing, the three judges pressed both sides, noting the case was "extraordinary" and "highly unusual". One judge told Mr Wall it would be "quite anomalous" for an appeal to be moved to federal court.But another noted that the Supreme Court in their immunity ruling used "broad" language to describe which evidence is related to "official acts" as president. The panel is expected to issue a written opinion at a later date. Trump's attorneys argued last September to move his New York case to the federal courts, but that request was denied by US District Judge Alvin Hellerstein. The 2nd US Circuit court is now hearing the appeal of that decision. Trump was sentenced in the hush-money case ten days before taking office in January. He was given an unconditional discharge, meaning he received no fines, probation or jail time, but the conviction will stay on his record. Trump was indicted in several criminal state and federal cases before his latest run for office, but the New York case was the only one to go to trial before he won the presidency. Trump's defence lawyers in the New York case, including Todd Blanche and Emil Bove, have since been promoted to positions in the justice department.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
22 minutes ago
- The Independent
The ‘inappropriate' post over Iran that led the LA County Sheriff's Department to apologize
The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department (LASD) apologized for an "offensive and inappropriate" social media post regarding recent U.S. strikes in Iran. The initial post, published hours after U.S. bombings, referenced "victims and families impacted" despite no reported fatalities. The LASD faced significant public backlash, with social media users criticizing the statement as a "slap in the face" to the U.S. military. The department first edited the post, then issued a formal apology, stating the original message was "unacceptable, made in error, and does not reflect the views of Sheriff Robert G. Luna or the Department." The LASD is conducting an internal review into the post's creation and publication, and is reviewing its social media oversight protocols.
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
WNBA commentator Rebecca Lobo forced into bizarre on-air U-turn after praising Donald Trump
WNBA legend and ESPN commentator Rebecca Lobo issued a bizarre apology on air for calling America 'great' during the Las Vegas Aces' win over the Indiana Fever. Lobo, who was named a WNBA All-Star back in 1999, was debating a foul call in Sunday's game with play-by-play announcer Pam Ward when she used a term vaguely similar to Donald Trump 's MAGA catchphrase. 'So they disagree with you?' Ward asked her colleague about the decision made by officials on court. 'They do, and I disagree with them. And that's fine,' Lobo responded before adding, 'that's what makes America great, right Pam Ward?' After seemingly being left uncomfortable with her choice of wording, Ward stayed silent before Lobo backtracked on the comment in strange fashion. 'I should rephrase that,' the former New York Liberty star said. Ward then replied: 'Yeah, I did think differences of opinion are perfectly fine.' WNBA legend and ESPN commentator Rebecca Lobo (left) issued a bizarre apology on air for calling America 'great' during the Las Vegas Aces' win over the Indiana Fever (right) "I should rephrase that" — CJ Fogler 🫡 (@cjzero) June 22, 2025 'Yes, that's a better way to say it. Sorry about that,' Lobo added. Fans quickly took to social media to slam Lobo, Ward and ESPN over the awkward moment, which many felt was unnecessary. 'Clearly not political. Just a general statement,' one user posted on X. 'Disgraceful! There is too long a pause after Rebecca said it. Someone in the booth told her rephrase it. There is nothing wrong with what she said, get over yourself woke ESPN. Not everything is political,' wrote another. A third put: 'Imagine being offended about saying America is great. F***in losers'. While another simply commented: 'Pathetic moment.' Lobo has spent over two decades as a commentator for ESPN after joining the network back in 2004, a year after she retired from basketball. As well as playing for the Liberty, Houston Comets, Springfield Spirit and the Connecticut Sun, the iconic center also won a gold medal at the 1996 Olympic Games in Atlanta with Team USA.
Daily Mail
40 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
See inside climate controlled room where Diddy stored baby oil: Live trial updates
A trove of new evidence photos in the ongoing Diddy trial, including pictures of 200 bottles of baby oil and 900 bottles of Astroglide lubricant, were released by federal prosecutors last week in court. The items were collected by Homeland Security officials during the March 2024 raid at the disgraced Bad Boy mogul's mansion in the exclusive Holmby Hills area of Los Angeles. The baby oil bottles were found stored inside a luxury, humidity controlled container akin to a cigar humidor. The prosecution claims Combs used his fame and power, as well as violence, to force his girlfriends into his 'freak-off' sex marathons. The defense, which will present its case this week, says prosecutors are trying to criminalize sexual activity between consenting adults. They admit their client was involved in domestic abuse, but argue he has not committed the federal crimes of sex trafficking and racketeering conspiracy. Combs, 55, has pleaded not guilty to the charges. Diddy stored bottles of baby oil in a temperature controlled box Over 200 bottles of baby oil and 900 bottles of astroglide lubricant were shown in evidence photos that came to light in court last week in the Diddy trial. The items were collected by Homeland Security officials during the March 2024 raid at the disgraced Bad Boy mogul's mansion in the exclusive Holmby Hills area of Los Angeles. It appeared the baby oil was kept in a luxury humidor designed to maintain humidity levels for cigars. Throughout the course of the trial, jurors have heard how the mogul used baby oil in marathon sex sessions called 'freak offs' or 'king nights' involving ex-girlfriends and escorts. All the explosive testimony from inside Diddy courtroom on Daily Mail's podcast The Trial To hear all the explosive testimony from singer Cassie Ventura and the other witnesses in Sean ' Diddy ' Combs' trial, tune in to Daily Mail's hit podcast The Trial. From sworn testimony to video evidence and the rapper's every subtle move, our team of journalists take you inside the courtroom of the world's biggest celebrity case. Daily Mail has been following Diddy's downfall from the very beginning. Join us as we hear from experts involved in the case, and members of the rapper's inside circle. All the explosive testimony from inside Diddy courtroom From sworn testimony to video evidence and the rapper's every subtle move, our team of journalists take you inside the courtroom of the world's biggest celebrity case.
