logo
ENع
Married Student Loan Borrowers' Payments May Jump Under New GOP Plan

Married Student Loan Borrowers' Payments May Jump Under New GOP Plan

Forbes13-06-2025

WASHINGTON, DC - MARCH 11: U.S. Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) speaks to reporters following the weekly ... More Republican Senate policy luncheon at the U.S. Capitol on March 11, 2025 in Washington, DC. Cassidy was joined by Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY) (L) and Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD). Cassidy, as Chair of the Senate HELP Committee, released draft legislation on June 10 that would make substantial changes to the federal student loan system. (Photo by)
Senate Republicans released draft reconciliation legislation this week that builds on efforts by their House counterparts to reshape the federal student loan system. The Senate version of the bill is identical in many ways to the House legislation, which passed the chamber last month on a largely party-line vote. But there's a critical difference between the two versions. If the Senate version of the bill ultimately becomes law, it could cause monthly student loan payments to dramatically increase for many households, particularly for married borrowers.
The changes center on income-driven repayment. IDR plans are a type of federal student loan repayment plan that offers borrowers affordable payments based on a formula applied to their income. The bill would make significant changes to the IDR system by fully repealing three plans – ICR, PAYE, and the SAVE plan. The legislation would preserve the IBR plan in a modified form for current borrowers. But borrowers who take out new loans going forward would only be able to access a new IDR option created by the bill called the Repayment Assistance Plan, or RAP.
While the details of RAP are largely the same between the House and Senate, the Senate version of the bill appears to treat married couples differently than the House version does. Between that, and the more expensive repayment formula associated with IBR as compared to the other IDR options, many married borrowers may experience significant increases in their monthly payments if the bill passes. Here's a breakdown.
For all current income-driven repayment plans – ICR, IBR, PAYE, and SAVE – payments are calculated based on the combined income of married borrowers only if they file their taxes as married-filing-jointly. Borrowers who file their taxes as married-filing-separately would have their income-driven payments based on their individual income. Filing separately can cause some households to pay more in overall taxes, so it doesn't make sense for everyone. But for many married borrowers, filing as married-filing-separately is the only way to get an affordable monthly student loan payment, even if it means higher taxes.
Under the House version of the reconciliation bill that narrowly passed that chamber in May, this treatment of married borrowers would be extended to the new RAP plan.
'The term 'adjusted gross income', when used with respect to a borrower, means the adjusted gross income (as such term is defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) of the borrower (and the borrower's spouse, as applicable) for the most recent taxable year, except that, in the case of a married borrower who files a separate Federal income tax return, the term does not include the adjusted gross income of the borrower's spouse,' reads the text of the House bill.
But while the Senate version of the bill released this week is similar to the House version in almost every way, there's a notable difference in the bill's definition of Adjusted Gross Income for the RAP plan in the Senate bill.
'The term 'adjusted gross income', when used with respect to a borrower, means the adjusted gross income (as such term is defined in section 62 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986) of the borrower (and the borrower's spouse, as applicable) for the most recent taxable year,' reads the bill. The Senate's language completely omits the exception for separate federal tax returns outlined in the House version.
This could have dramatic ramifications for married borrowers. A borrower who has an Adjusted Gross Income of $50,000 who files taxes separately from their spouse would have a monthly RAP payment of around $208 per month. But if their spouse earns the same amount of income, so that their combined Adjusted Gross Income is $100,000 regardless of their marital tax filing filing status, the monthly RAP payment would jump to more than $830 per month – a four-fold increase.
The RAP plan would be the only income-driven repayment option for borrowers who take out federal student loans after July 1, 2026, under the terms of both the House and Senate bills. Borrowers already in repayment on their student loans prior to that date could maintain access to a modified version of Income-Based Repayment, or IBR. But they would lose access to more affordable options like the PAYE and SAVE plans. Borrowers who are enrolled in these plans would be moved into IBR, unless they opt to switch to RAP (but if they do that, they would be locked into RAP, with no option to change plans again in the future).
Both the House and Senate bills would appear to preserve the marital tax treatment of borrowers under IBR, meaning married borrowers enrolled in IBR should continue to be able to file separate federal tax returns to exclude a spouse's income from being factored into the monthly student loan payment calculation. But moving into IBR from PAYE or SAVE could also significantly increase a borrower's monthly student loan payment, even if they can continue filing taxes separately.
'A typical family of four headed by a borrower with a bachelor's degree would be forced to pay an additional $2,808 per year should Congress enact this proposal, when compared to the SAVE plan,' said the Student Borrower Protection Center in a letter to the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee Chair and Ranking Member on Wednesday. For SAVE plan borrowers in particular, who have been in forbearance for the last year due to ongoing legal challenges, 'Borrowers will experience an immediate and unprecedented payment shock as their monthly payments jump from $0 per month to $431 for a typical single student loan borrower with a college degree—an annual increase of more than $5,000' annually, said the group.
The bill would make other changes to the federal student loan system that could also impact married borrowers. The legislation would effectively eliminate income-driven repayment altogether for Parent PLUS borrowers, with the exception of those who have already consolidated their Parent PLUS loans and enrolled in Income-Contingent Repayment. This could push many parent borrowers, who would effectively have no affordable repayment option, into default. The bill would also limit Parent PLUS borrowing and phase out the Graduate PLUS program, which could force families to rely more heavily on private student loans, which which are generally costlier and riskier than their federal counterparts.
'The Senate reconciliation bill's higher education provisions would cause widespread harm to American families by making college more expensive, making student debt much harder to repay, unleashing an avalanche of student loan defaults, and rolling back basic protections for students who are defrauded by their college—all to fund tax cuts for the wealthy," said Sameer Gadkaree, president of The Institute for College Access & Success, in a statement earlier this week. 'The proposed overhaul of the student loan repayment system would take the unprecedented step of eliminating existing protections for borrowers. It would implement an overly complex plan that departs from decades of precedent by forcing the lowest-income borrowers to make unaffordable payments and extending the repayment term to 30 years. Taken together, this will likely drive many more borrowers into default."

Hashtags

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

What Do Employees Really Want Instead Of Pizza Parties?
What Do Employees Really Want Instead Of Pizza Parties?

Yahoo

time35 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

What Do Employees Really Want Instead Of Pizza Parties?

'Overworked and underpaid employees don't want pizza parties and team-building exercises,' he said. His eyes looked strained, and I couldn't tell if he had a headache or was exhausted… I guessed both. 'What's wrong with pizza?' I joked, trying to lighten the mood. 'Nothing. I like pizza. But when you're stressed about finances, have to fight for every penny you make, juggle more responsibilities than you have time, and doing everything you can to exceed expectations to the point of burnout… well, what you need is to feel valued, have opportunities for growth, a wage and a title that reflects everything that you're doing, some help, strong support and a good work culture… some freakin' hope… something that has more of a lasting impact than a slice of pizza.' I remained silent. I couldn't decide if I was allowing him more space to think or if I was thinking to myself how much I agreed with him. 'It's almost insulting,' he continued. '99.9% of the time, they act like they don't even recognize our existence, and now they want to throw us a party? No thanks. Having a party is great, but first, let's get your team healthy enough to enjoy it.' He paused. 'They're panhandling a superficial solution to a real problem.' 'And what's the real problem?' I asked. 'They aren't investing in people — they're investing in results. They don't realize that the results will exceed their expectations if you authentically invest in good, hardworking, talented people. Despite the lack of meaningful appreciation and resources, we have a great team. Think what it could be if they added the missing components.' He removed his glasses and wiped his eyes. He stared at me with a tiredness that went well beyond the moment. 'Wouldn't it be nice to have an environment where employees are invested in so much that they could find another job but don't because they love where they work?' he asked. 'That would be nice,' I said. 'What do you think is going to happen?' 'We are woefully under-supported, yet the expectations keep rising. Essentially, we're being set up to fail… either by failing to reach their unattainable bar or by failing our health and family in thinking that we must continue without setting realistic boundaries. Heck, it could end where I cannot meet their increasing expectations, get let go, and cannot even use them as a reference. That would be ridiculous, as I'm a great employee. I feel destined to fail, and that's a horrible feeling.' 'Sounds like fear is playing a role, too,' I said. 'You bet it does! They have me: I am too strapped for time and finances to even look for another job. By the end of the workday, I'm beyond exhausted, have headaches, can't sleep, and am barely present for my family. Yet, I'm doing this for my family. That's messed up. Worst, I actually like my job. Heck, I'm great at it. But who cares? They'd rather put money into hiring other positions and socials than caring for the few doing the bulk of the work. Where does that leave me? Seriously, where? It leaves me angry because I CARE.' I didn't say anything. 'Right… you're lack of response has been my answer for a long time. I can't do a damn thing, and they know it. But you know what?' 'What?' 'Even more than what I know about them, I know me,' he said. 'I've been in much worse situations than this one. I'm accustomed to survival mode. The difference was that I was fighting for something worth the sacrifice. Here, I am fighting to take care of my family in an environment that isn't fighting for me. The sacrifice, as it stands, is not supporting my why… if I am too sick or strained to be available to my family, why am I giving my limited energy to a job that would soon forget me the moment I'm gone?' 'Very true,' I said. 'I have two months of savings in my account. If I quit today, I would have two months to look for a job. Imagine what I could do with two months of actual rest and serenity. Granted, it would be stressful, especially since I'm already familiar with the devil I know. But, as it stands now, eventually, my body will force me to take two months off to recuperate from whatever condition I'm bringing upon myself. So, if I have to be down and out, wouldn't it be better to be down and out to find a job — rested and fed — than sick?' 'Sounds like you lack work-life balance because you fear losing your job if you speak up, fear failing their continued rising expectations, and fear of an eventual health prognosis of keeping your job if nothing changes,' I said. 'I'm afraid either way, I'm going to lose everything,' he said. 'Let's play that out. What if you lost your job today for whatever reason? What horrible thing could happen?' I asked. 'I could have a hard time finding another job due to the economy, I could be forced to sell our home, I would default on some loans, I would….' He stopped. 'I would fail my family.' 'Of all you just said, you didn't mention losing your family,' I said. 'Oh, I would never lose them. They are my life, and I know my wife and kids are always beside me,' he said. 'Always.' 'So, you'll never lose what is most important because you won't lose them, right?' I asked. 'Right,' he said. For the first time, his eyes looked like they had just read a hopeful line in a sad book. 'You're not letting your family down by acknowledging your worth, recognizing where you're most needed, and adjusting accordingly,' I said. 'What are you suggesting?' he asked. 'I would never tell you what to do, as that is between you and your family. I would recommend you take it to prayer with your wife. I would caution you not to allow this to continue for much longer, as you will eventually begin to harbor resentment and anger toward your employer and yourself for putting up with it. And I would stop having so many passive boundaries.' 'Passive boundaries?' he asked. 'Yes. You know you are a valuable employee. You mentioned to me earlier that you've been a stellar employee in every job you've had. Guess what? You will be again if you choose to get another job. Stop allowing others to pacify you with empty promises and pizza parties. Speak to what you want, whether a promotion or help … whatever you know to be true. If they don't see your requests as valid, that doesn't make them false. It just means they don't know your worth… make sure you do.' 'I know my worth, but I also know my responsibilities,' he said. 'That's fair. Often, we do things as adults because we 'have to' more than 'want to.' Responsibility isn't meant to be taken lightly or shirked. Over time, however, we must pay attention to patterns, noticing when individuals consistently demonstrate that they are not going to change and when it is upon us to change.' 'I get that. I'm just terrified of letting my family down,' he said. The weight upon him was suffocating, and I could tell he was carrying a burden that would eventually break him. 'That's speaking from a position of self-loathing and shame. Such thinking keeps you stagnant in areas where God has gifted you and given you talents to grow. There is nothing shameful about taking care of your health, not diminishing your value, and moving forward in full faith that God is opening doors you haven't even seen.' 'Opening doors I haven't even seen,' he repeated. 'I like the sound of that.' 'All I'm saying is keep your options open… you've convinced yourself that you're trapped. You're not. Even if things change for the better in your current job or it all falls away, the most important things will remain. And God will eventually position you on higher ground. He knows your needs. He knows you. Believe this. Trust God. And move forward, being okay with whatever outcome God provides.' 'Whatever outcome God provides. Yes,' he said. For the first time, he offered a faint smile. God, be with us as we make difficult decisions. Help us to simply be obedient to You, trusting that You will either change our situation or change us. May we use the skills and talents You have blessed us with to serve You with joy, knowing that You will provide for us and sustain us well beyond any earthly position. You are stronger than our greatest fears, and in Your strength, and in Your name, we move. Our true position is in You alone, Christ Jesus. Lead us, guide us, and take us from fear to faith in Your presence and peace. This column was initially published by CherryRoad Media. ©Tiffany Kaye Chartier.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store