Whoopi Goldberg's claim that Iran and America are ‘the same' is offensive to Iranians suffering and dying — like my family
On Wednesday's 'The View,' Whoopi Goldberg said Iran and America are 'the same.' In a heated exchange, Alyssa Farah Griffin disagreed, at one point saying, 'It's very different to live in the United States in 2025 than it is to live in Iran.' Whoopi retorted, 'Not if you're black!' Here, an Iranian who fled the country and lives in America responds.
There is absolutely no comparison between life in the United States and life under the Islamic Republic of Iran. The worst situation of any American citizen — regardless of race, gender or background — is still infinitely better than the daily fear, oppression and brutality people endure in Iran.
I lived there. I know the fear firsthand. I've seen it.
Advertisement
In Iran, you're constantly watched. You can be arrested for a word, for a haircut, for listening to the wrong music, for refusing to conform.
They torture people. They execute dissidents. They even assassinate critics abroad.
So to hear someone on American TV, with total freedom of speech and legal protection, equate the United States with Iran is not only factually wrong — it's offensive to those who are truly suffering and dying in silence.
4 Whoopi Goldberg (left) sparred with Alyssa Farah Griffin (right) on Wednesday's episode of 'The View.'
ABC
Advertisement
In America, you can protest, sue, criticize the president and still go home safely at night. In Iran, that same act could get you killed. So no — they are not the same. Not even close.
Daily life in Iran is a prison — just not always with visible bars.
Every detail of your life is controlled: what you wear, what you say, who you associate with, what music you listen to, what you post online.
You're constantly afraid. Your phone is tapped. You speak in whispers. You look over your shoulder. Every sentence can be used against you.
Advertisement
Women are beaten and arrested for how they dress. Students are tortured for speaking out.
There is no due process, no transparency, no protection.
They can arrest you without reason, torture you without trial, and your family may never know where you are. They force televised confessions, and then they hang people — publicly.
4 The author, Majid Rafizadeh, speaks out about the Iranian regime — despite threats to him and his family.
Courtesy of Majid Rafizadeh
Advertisement
I've had family members tortured, detained. Some never came back.
So again, this is not something people in America, even in the worst circumstances, can fully grasp. It's not struggle — it's terror.
Iranians would generally rather be in the United States a thousand times over, even on its worst day. An Iranian would dream of having the problems Americans complain about.
In the United States, you have the right to speak, to challenge authority, to protest, to live your life.
In Iran, you have no such rights. You're not even a person in the eyes of the regime. You're property. And if you step out of line, they break you — and your family.
Here in America, even if someone disagrees with you, you still have the freedom to speak, to work, to achieve. People of all races have become billionaires, senators, even president.
4 Massive crowds make their way to the 2022 funeral of Mahsa Amini, who was murdered by Iranian officials for the way she wore her hijab.
UGC/AFP via Getty Images
So when someone in the West claims to be a victim while having access to courts, media, education and full legal protections, it feels like drama. It feels manufactured. Because in Iran, you're not a victim — you're a hostage.
Advertisement
Every single person in Iran knows someone who has been arrested, tortured or killed by the regime. It is not an exaggeration. It's reality. Political imprisonment is so widespread that it touches every family.
My own family has lived through this nightmare. They tortured my father. They monitored us. They interrogated relatives.
And these stories never make the news — because they don't allow journalists, they don't allow truth.
People disappear. Mothers never find their children. Executions happen without trials.
Advertisement
It's not a government — it's a mafia that rules through fear, pain and violence. Everyone knows someone. Everyone lives in fear that he or she might be next.
4 Iranian dissidents are executed in public — sending a lesson to the rest of the suffering population.
AP
I left Iran because of the oppression, the fear and the constant threat to my life and to my family. We were being watched. My father was tortured. My relatives were interrogated.
And I knew that if I stayed, I could disappear like so many others.
Advertisement
I still have family there — and they are constantly targeted. They are harassed, intimidated and punished, simply because I speak out. My elderly mother, who can barely walk, has been threatened.
They want to instill fear — to silence me. Most likely, they do it to stop me from writing and exposing the regime. And yes, I carry guilt every day because of that. I feel responsible for the pain they endure.
But I also know that silence helps the oppressor. I have to speak up. I have to write.
Advertisement
I have to expose the truth — even if it costs me everything. Even if it costs me my life.
Because what they are doing to the people of Iran is not just wrong — it is evil.
Majid Rafizadeh is a political scientist and advisory board member of the Harvard International Review.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
25 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Anti-Trump Protests Update: 'National Day of Action' Planned for July 17
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Another round of national anti-Trump demonstrations is being planned across the U.S. for July 17 under the banner of Good Trouble Lives On, a reference to the late civil rights icon, Congressman John Lewis. Newsweek contacted Good Trouble Lives On for comment via email on Friday outside of regular office hours. Why It Matters On June 14,anti-Trump "No Kings" protests took place in cities across the United States on Trump's 79th birthday, which also saw the president attend a military parade in Washington D.C. to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army. The protests took place in hundreds of U.S. cities, with large-scale gatherings reported in major hubs such as Philadelphia; Los Angeles; Austin, Texas; Portland, Oregon; and New York. According to analysis by pollster G. Elliott Morris, they were attended by an estimated 4 to 6 million people. What To Know Good Trouble Lives On demonstrations are being planned for dozens of American cities on July 17 including the likes of New York, Washington D.C, Chicago, Los Angeles and San Francisco with attendees invited to "March in Peace, Act in Power." The name is a reference to Lewis, a Georgia Democrat and an advocate of peaceful protests, who famously called for "good trouble" during the civil rights era. Anti-Trump "No Kings" demonstrators pictured in Los Angeles on June 14. Anti-Trump "No Kings" demonstrators pictured in Los Angeles on June 14. Jay L Clendenin/GETTY According to its downloadable "Host Toolkit" for organizers, the protests have three main goals. These are demanding an end to "the extreme crackdown on civil rights by the Trump administration," "the attacks on Black and brown Americans, immigrants, trans people, and other communities," and "the slashing of programs that working people rely on, including Medicaid, SNAP, and Social Security." Good Trouble Lives On is being supported by a range of other groups including the 50501 Movement, which also helped organize the "No Kings" demonstrations. The 50501 Movement, short for "50 protests, 50 states, 1 movement" was formed in January 2025 to protest Trump and has been involved in organizing a series of national demonstrations beginning on February 5. A series of "No Kings on Presidents Day" rallies took place on February 17 followed by "Hands Off" demonstrations in April and May criticizing federal layoffs and immigration crackdowns. What People Are Saying Speaking to Newsweek, Lorella Praeli, co-president of Community Change Action, which has backed anti-Trump demonstrations, said: "Look around—Trump and his allies are deploying the tools of authoritarianism: silencing dissent, targeting immigrants, punishing oversight, and even staging military displays for personal glorification. These aren't isolated incidents; they're part of a broader effort to delegitimize democratic norms." On its website, Good Trouble Lives On, which "is a national day of action to respond to the attacks on our civil and human rights by the Trump administration," wrote: "We are facing the most brazen rollback of civil rights in generations. Whether you're outraged by attacks on voting rights, the gutting of essential services, disappearance of our neighbors, or the assault on free speech and our right to protest—this movement is for you. "Trump is trying to divide us but we know the power of coming together." What Happens Next It remains to be seen how many people will turn out for the "Good Trouble Lives On" demonstrations and what the organizers plan next.
Newsweek
30 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Russia 'On the Brink Of' Recession Says Economy Minister
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Russia's economy, buoyed for months by wartime spending, may now be teetering toward recession, Minister of Economic Development of the Russian Federation Maxim Reshetnikov said on Thursday, according to Russian media reports. Speaking at the annual St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, Reshetnikov said: "The numbers indicate cooling, but all our numbers are [like] a rearview mirror." "Judging by the way businesses currently feel and the indicators, we are already, it seems to me, on the brink of going into a recession, he added, according to business news outlet RBC. Minister of Economic Development of the Russian Federation Maxim Reshetnikov attends a plenary session of the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum in St. Petersburg, Russia, on June 19, 2025. Minister of Economic Development of the Russian Federation Maxim Reshetnikov attends a plenary session of the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum in St. Petersburg, Russia, on June 19, 2025. Roscongress Foundation via AP Why It Matters The warning marks a significant shift as Russia faces the consequences of prolonged war-related spending, global sanctions and continued international isolation. For American policymakers and businesses, economic instability in Russia carries potential implications for global markets, energy prices, and ongoing geopolitical tensions, especially as sanctions and Russia's military operations in Ukraine continue to reshape the international economic landscape. What To Know Since sanctions were imposed following the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Russia's economy had outperformed early predictions. High levels of defense spending supported growth and kept unemployment rates low even as inflation worsened. Wages rose with inflation, benefiting many workers in the short term. Large signing bonuses for military recruits and death benefits for soldiers killed in Ukraine put additional money into poorer regions of Russia. However, economists have warned that the prolonged focus on military sectors, inflation, and a lack of foreign investment are increasing long-term risks and stagnation in other economic sectors. At Thursday's event in Russia's second-largest city, intended to showcase the country's economic achievements and court foreign investors, Reshetnikov addressed Central Bank Governor Elvira Nabiullina, saying he wanted to give "the economy some love," according to Reuters. Nabiullina downplayed fears, claiming Russia's economy was "coming out of overheating," according to RBC. Finance Minister Anton Siluanov also offered a more optimistic view, stating the economy was "cooling" but adding, "after any cooling, the summer always comes." What People Are Saying Russian Economy Minister Maxim Reshetnikov said, according to Reuters: "I didn't predict a recession. I said we're on the brink. From here on out, everything will depend on our decisions." Russia's Center for Macroeconomic Analysis and Short-Term Forecasting said in a statement this week: "It seems that an 'an economy of stagnation' has formed." What Happens Next The trajectory of Russia's economy will depend on forthcoming government and central bank actions as officials weigh responses to the cooling economic environment. Further policy announcements or economic data are expected to clarify whether Russia can avoid a formal recession designation in the coming months. This article includes reporting by The Associated Press
Newsweek
32 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Iran Rules Out US Talks Unless Israel Halts Strikes
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said on Friday that Tehran has ruled out any possibility of negotiations with the United States while Israeli strikes continue. His remarks came just hours before he was scheduled to meet European counterparts in Geneva. "We are not ready to engage in negotiations with any side while the Israeli aggression continues," Araghchi said, according to state media. He noted that Washington has sent messages seeking direct talks with Tehran, but said Iran has rejected the overtures. "We told the Americans clearly: as long as the attacks persist, there can be no negotiations. We are exercising our legitimate right to self-defense," he added. This is a developing story. Updates to follow.
