Peak private equity? Sector gets defensive about its ability to generate top returns
BERLIN — Private equity's biggest annual gathering is called SuperReturn, but its returns haven't been looking quite so super of late — leading the industry to urge investors to ride out the uncertainty.
At this year's conference in Berlin, Germany there was a clear acceptance that a previously forecast 2025 boom in M&A and initial public offering activity has not materialized. And that is putting private equity — which ballooned following the Great Financial Crisis as an alternative funding source to risk-averse banks, now rivaling many of them for size — under pressure.
But panels and sideline discussions at the event showed plenty of fighting spirit, with some attendees defending against the narrative that dealmaking is drying up or that the public markets might be a better bet for returns. Many enthused about growth areas ripe for private equity backing, including European defense firms, undervalued mid-caps and Middle Eastern data centers.
The event at the Intercontinental Hotel hosted nearly 6,000 attendees this week, with headline keynotes from Carlyle Group Co-chairman David Rubenstein and Blackstone Vice Chair Thomas Nides. Tennis superstar Serena Williams and U2 frontman Bono were also among the speakers.
"There is no doubt exits have slowed due to headwinds from geopolitical tension and volatility in public markets. As a result, we have seen companies stay private for longer," said Nalin Patel, lead private capital research analyst at PitchBook. An "exit" refers to when a private equity fund exits its investment in a firm, be it through a sale, IPO or process called a dividend recapitalization.
Pitchbook data for the first three months of 2025 showed exit values in Europe dropped 19% quarter-on-quarter, as exit count fell 25.2%.
The industry is, meanwhile, holding nearly 30,000 unsold companies worth about $3.6 trillion, according to a March report from Bain. That means limited partners (LPs) — investors in funds — can't realize returns or access cash, while general partners (GPs) — the managers of funds — are spread more thinly across their portfolio companies.
U.S. tariffs were repeatedly cited at SuperReturn as having reduced overall market risk appetite, coming just as the industry had been betting on some respite after being rocked by the Covid-19 pandemic, supply chain disruption and higher interest rates.
Yann Robard, managing partner at alternative asset manager Dawson Partners, told a packed crowd that private markets are going through a cyclical dip, but that "on average and over the long term, our analysis suggests that private equity outperforms public markets."
Assessing data since the start of 2000, Robard said a $1 investment in a Russell 3000 index would have generated a 6.6 times return versus a 19.9 times return in private equity. He added that the sector has better weathered volatility despite its higher leverage — illustrated by a flood of private capital, which has tripled in the last decade from $5 trillion to $17 trillion.
Private equity's surge was supported by more than a decade of ultra-low interest rates, with dealmaking hitting a peak in 2021 as low rates met a Covid rebound and fiscal support packages. A core issue hanging over buyout firms now is that many "just paid too much" during that period, said John Romeo, managing partner at management consultancy Oliver Wyman, on the sidelines of the event.
"It may have been for good companies, but they just paid too much, so they're not going to make the target returns on those, and that's blocked up the system a little bit. At some point that has to pass," Romeo told CNBC. "I'm still very bullish on private equity."
"If I compare how well prepared a private equity firm is in their monthly board meeting with a company, they know the ins and outs of that perfectly, compared to a public market investor who just doesn't have the same level of information or levers to control."
Recent years have seen new trends in the private equity world: the rise of continuation vehicles, in which firms essentially dispose of stakes in their companies to new funds they've created; Net Asset Value (NAV) lending, where loans are made against a portfolio's underlying value; and secondaries, in which existing interests or assets are bought from primary private equity investors as a way for LPs to access cash.
"The secondary market is hot, it's on fire," said Richard Hope, head of EMEA and global co-head of investments at Hamilton Lane.
While it may have arisen as a way to overcome challenges in the industry, Hope said: "Those investing into the secondary market really like it. It's short-duration, it gives you nearer-term liquidity, and it actually gives you an enhanced return. Some investors are looking at in a positive way and want to add it to their portfolio."
There has been a push toward getting retail investors involved in the space — traditionally the preserve of large institutional investors — including via an exchange-traded fund launched by State Street and Apollo Global Management in March.
Family office representatives were also a notable presence on the ground at SuperReturn.
Consolidation has been another consequence of the changing environment, which Rob Lucas, CEO of CVC Capital Partners, expects to continue.
He agreed the market sees stronger and weaker cycles, and was currently in the latter, but stressed that making the right investments during periods of volatility generates the strongest returns.
"What our LPs are looking for from us is more demanding, in returns, governance, compliance, sustainability, AI. All of these areas are hugely intensive and require depth and strength of platforms," he said during a panel.
"Groups coming together is a natural part of that," he said, adding that private equity was still a "super strong asset class" with tailwinds supporting it.o
One common refrain at SuperReturn in support of the outlook was the huge amount of "dry powder" — liquid assets — still available for many of the biggest names in the industry to deploy, estimated at over $1 trillion.
Despite making the defense case for private equity's future, SuperReturn attendees agreed that huge uncertainty remained regarding the macro environment, not least with the U.S. trade issue far from resolved. A lot is resting on the expectation that fingers are poised on buttons, ready to set deals in motion as soon as some stability returns.
Oliver Wyman's Romeo said that private equity has expanded into highly diversified financial institutions but will thrive by focusing on its bread-and-butter roots — finding companies at attractive prices and being laser-focused on improving profitability.
"Firms have never had, really, this much money... The entry price that you go in at really matters, but then you've also got to have a real clear plan how you're going to drive that value creation," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Life Time athletic club opening at 452 Fifth Ave.
The owners of 425 Fifth Avenue, aka 10 Bryant Park between East 39th and 40th streets, landed another big catch at their tower where Amazon recently signed for 330,000 square feet — and it all started with a game of pickleball. In one of Manhattan's largest retail-space deals this year, burgeoning 'athletic urban country club' Life Time signed for 52,000 square feet on four levels, including in the soon to be vacated, 17,000 square-foot Staples store. It will open in early 2027 behind a prominent Fifth Avenue entrance. The Life Time deal all but completes the leasing picture at the 865,000 address, which consists of three formerly separate structures that include the 10-story Knox Building. Advertisement 4 425 Fifth Avenue, aka 10 Bryant Park between East 39th and 40th streets, center. Google Maps Life Time has 180 clubs in the US and Canada. Chief property development officer Parham Javaheri said 10 Bryant Park checked all the boxes for what he wanted in Midtown. 'We want to serve both our residential and commercial cores,' he said. 'Although the location is obviously more commercial, there's a lot of residential growth nearby as well.' Advertisement Life Time, founded by chairman and CEO Bahram Akradi, has seven other Manhattan locations, two in Brooklyn, and another coming at the supertall Brooklyn Tower condo project. Javaheri said, 'We want to grow methodically. Meaning, we want destinations that let us stay true to what Life Time is, and they require a lot of space.' In fact, several others in the city are even larger than at 10 Bryant Park with 80,000 square feet each. The 10 Bryant Park edition will boast a luxurious, co-ed 'wet' suite with steam rooms, saunas, hot tubs and cold plunges; a workout floor with best-in-class cardio and resistance-training equipment; a recovery space with massage chairs and body-compression technology; and a half-dozen boutique-style studios for group fitness formats. 4 A rendering of the Life Time athletic club location at 10 Bryant Park, which is expected to open in early 2027. LIFE TIME Advertisement Eli Elefant, CEO of 10 Bryant Park landlord Property & Building Corp., said, 'We had the privilege or repositioning the building in a post-Covid world. It gave us the ability to reimagine what a commercial building can look like in a challenging environment.' Elefant said, 'When we lost our big bank tenant, HSBC, we got all their antiquated space back. Our thought was to lean heavily into the tech sphere and market the former bank space to big users and we were ultimately successful.' With the Amazon deal, the 30-story tower's office floors are 100% leased. What he called a 'blank slate' after HSBC decided to move to The Spiral in Hudson Yards also suggested the need to deliver what Amazon and many other 21st Century tenants want: a spectacular 'wellness' amenity. 'We didn't just want to build a gym,' Elefant chuckled. 4 Eli Elefant, center, the CEO of 10 Bryant Park owner Property & Building Corp., and Life Time chief property development officer Parham Javaheri, right, bonded over their vision during a pickleball game. LIFE TIME Advertisement Introduced by brokers, he and Javaheri first met on Oct. 17, 2023. 'We talked about a lifestyle-physical concept,' Elefant said. 'I said, 'Why don't we meet for a workout?'' Javaheri recalled, 'We played pickleball at 1 Penn and at Sky on West 42nd Street. Eli told us what his vision was for a strong amenity. We formed a good friendship.' 4 A rendering of the interior of the announced Life Time athletic club at 10 Bryant Park. LIFE TIME The competition 'was a great way for him to humiliate me,' Elefant laughed. 'But I'm a firm believed in personal synergies' in a changed real estate market that needs to be 'less sharp-elbows than collaborative, although I'm not sure everyone got the message.' Atlantic Retail's Joe Mastromonaco represented Life Time and JLL's Patrick Smith acted for the ownership. Property & Building's parent company owns 14 million square feet of buildings in Israel, but 10 Bryant Park is the only one in New York it wholly owns although it has discreet investments at others.
Business Upturn
5 hours ago
- Business Upturn
ELV FRAUD ALERT: Elevance Health, Inc. Investors are Reminded of Ongoing Securities Fraud Class Action — Contact BFA Law by July 11 Legal Deadline (NYSE:ELV)
NEW YORK, June 22, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Leading securities law firm Bleichmar Fonti & Auld LLP announces that a lawsuit has been filed against Elevance Health, Inc. (NYSE: ELV) and certain of the Company's senior executives for potential violations of the federal securities laws. If you invested in Elevance you are encouraged to obtain additional information by visiting Investors have until July 11, 2025, to ask the Court to be appointed to lead the case. The complaint asserts claims under Sections 10(b) and 20(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 on behalf of investors who purchased Elevance common stock. The case is pending in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana and is captioned Miller v. Elevance Health, Inc., et al. , No. 25-cv-0092. Why was Elevance Sued for Securities Fraud? Elevance provides health insurance plans. This includes contracting with states to administer Medicaid benefits. States routinely review Medicaid eligibility, but during COVID, the federal government paused this process. The pause ended in 2023, and states resumed redetermining Medicaid eligibility. During the relevant period, Elevance represented that it was closely monitoring the cost trends associated with the redetermination process and that the rates Elevance was negotiating were sufficient to address the risk profiles of those patients staying on Medicaid. As alleged, in truth, the redeterminations caused a significant increase in the acuity and utilization of Elevance's Medicaid members. What's more, the shift occurred to a degree that was not reflected in Elevance's rate negotiations or in its financial guidance for 2024. The Stock Declines as the Truth is Revealed On July 17, 2024, Elevance stated that it was now 'expecting second-half utilization to increase in Medicaid' and that it was 'seeing signs of increased utilization across the broader Medicaid population.' On this news, the price of Elevance stock declined $32.21 per share, or nearly 6%, from $553.14 per share on July 16, 2024, to $520.93 per share on July 17, 2024. Then, on October 17, 2024, Elevance announced its Q3 2024 financial results, revealing that its missed consensus earnings per share ('EPS') expectations by $1.33, or 13.7%, 'due to elevated medical costs in [its] Medicaid business.' On this news, the price of Elevance stock declined $52.61 per share, or nearly 11%, from $496.96 per share on October 16, 2024, to $444.35 per share on October 17, 2024. Click here if you suffered losses: What Can You Do? If you invested in Elevance you may have legal options and are encouraged to submit your information to the firm. All representation is on a contingency fee basis, there is no cost to you. Shareholders are not responsible for any court costs or expenses of litigation. The firm will seek court approval for any potential fees and expenses. Submit your information by visiting: Or contact:Ross Shikowitz [email protected] 212-789-3619
Business Insider
5 hours ago
- Business Insider
Women are getting wealthier — and they don't invest the same way as men
Women are becoming richer, and they're changing the face of wealth. According to a report by McKinsey published last month, women control about a third of all retail financial assets in the US and the European Union. By 2030, that proportion is expected to rise to between 40% to 45%, wrote Cristina Catania, global co-convener and European lead for the risk and resilience practice, and Jill Zucker, senior partner and co-leader of McKinsey's global growth transformation service line. The report is based on a survey of about 13,000 American and European investors, nearly half of whom were female financial decision makers. It found that between 2018 and 2023, global wealth rose by 43%, but jumped by 51% for women. Women's expanding control of assets is being driven by a combination of factors, including a continuing decline in marriage rates, the ongoing boost in women's average earnings, demographic trends like longer life expectancies, and a broad shift in attitudes about women managing their own finances. Risk doesn't equal reward As women become wealthier through investing, it's becoming clearer that they don't approach it the same way as men. "Women are much more risk-aware," Anna-Sophie Hartvigsen, cofounder of financial education and investment platform Female Invest, told Business Insider. "I would like to call it much more realistic in their own ability to invest." She said women are less likely than men to invest emotionally. "On average, men trade a lot more often than women because they believe they can beat the market or they read something in the news, and they get pumped up or afraid, and then they invest based on that," Hartvigsen said. Female investors, in her view, tend to be more calm, more realistic, and better at assessing risk. However, Katie Geery, an advisor at Rise Private Wealth Management, says being more cautious can also hold women back by leading them to miss out on opportunities to build wealth. "It is important to work with a trusted financial advisor who understands your risk tolerance and can walk you through making well-educated investment decisions based on your long-term goals," she told BI. Returns aren't everything The aims of investing also sometimes differ between men and women. "Women prefer to invest toward achieving specific goals rather than chasing the highest returns," said Avanti Shetye, financial planner at Wealthwyzr. Geery said female investors tend to be more focused on philanthropy and gifting. They often consider their values when buying stock and want their purchases to help make a better impact on the world. "Women often seek financial advisors who are empathetic and take the time to get to know them on a more personal level to gain a deeper understanding of their goals and values," she said. On Female Invest, Hartvigsen said the principles its members care about the most include climate, especially a firm's carbon footprint, and diversity in leadership, in terms of a board having a good gender balance. Start investing early For Shetye, it's important to start investing early. "Women tend to be primary caregivers for children or aging parents and often take unpaid time off," she said. "Not only that, women statistically live longer than men, which implies that women would need to invest as much as they can as early as possible so that their portfolios last them through retirement." Hartvigsen said long-term financial planning is vital: "When you do that, it doesn't matter what happens today." Both agree that this plan should be grounded in expert advice. "Working with a financial planner whose planning process is rooted in financial education can help provide comfort and security to stay consistent even in the roughest of markets," Shetye said. But she also believes that practice is more important than perfection. "You are never going to know everything there is to know about investing," Shetye said. "The key is consistency, and time will do the heavy lifting." Hartvigsen advises her clients to invest monthly on the same day and to diversify their investments. "If you do that, historically, it has been near impossible not to make money in the long run."
