Growing rejection of PSIRA's draft firearm regulations sparks nationwide outcry
Private security industry is facing a crackdown on the weapons the security industry can have access to.
The wave of opposition to the proposed amendments to firearm regulations for the private security industry is gaining momentum, with nearly 30,000 formal objections submitted by the Foundation for Rights of Expression and Equality (Free SA) in a scathing rejection of the draft regulations under the Private Security Industry Regulation Act.
'This is not just about regulatory overreach; it's about people's lives. The draft regulations are disconnected from the realities of crime in our country. They disarm the very people who are protecting our communities while offering no credible alternative,' said Reuben Coetzer, Spokesperson for Free SA.
Free SA warns that the proposed regulations, tabled by the Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority (PSIRA) and Police Minister Senzo Mchunu, could have dire implications for public safety, community self-reliance, and the constitutional rights of citizens.
The proposed amendments to South Africa's Private Security Industry Regulation Act introduce significant changes to the management of firearms within the private security sector. These draft regulations aim to tighten control over the issuing, possession, and use of firearms and other weapons by security service providers.
Key provisions include mandating that security officers may only possess firearms lawfully provided by their employers, prohibiting them from using personally owned firearms while on duty.
Additionally, the regulations seek to impose stricter oversight on firearm usage, including requirements for detailed record-keeping and adherence to specified training standards.
Free SA has called for the immediate withdrawal of the draft, citing widespread concern from crime-affected communities. In its submission to PSIRA, Free SA revealed it had received 28,395 individual objections through its public participation platform. 'We don't see SAPS in our community. If you take away our security patrols' tools, who will protect us?' read one submission. Another asked: 'Private security came when my wife was attacked. SAPS came three hours later. If these rules pass, who do I call next time?'
Among the objections are concerns about legal vagueness, such as undefined terms like 'reasonable quantity of ammunition' and impractical proposals like mandating tracking devices on firearms. Free SA also criticised what it called a 'flawed and legally deficient' public consultation process and warned that the regulations ignore successful safety models, such as the Western Cape's LEAP programme.
The foundation's stance echoes industry-wide backlash. Just last week, six leading private security industry bodies—SANSEA, SASA, the National Security Forum, CEO, TAPSOSA, and LASA—announced their formal opposition to the proposed regulations.
'We urge the government to work collaboratively with the sector to find solutions that support both accountability and operational viability,' said Steve Conradie, National Chairperson of the National Security Forum. 'If these regulations are promulgated, it will result in massive job losses and will put the safety of the public at risk.'
The coalition has engaged firearm law expert Martin Hood of MJ Hood and Associates to spearhead their legal response.
THE MERCURY
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Ipid 14 000 case backlog sparks concern for police committee
Parliament's police committee urges Ipid to fix its massive backlog and staff shortages, warning that victims of police misconduct are left without justice. A backlog of more than 14 000 Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid) cases was carried over to this financial year, raising concerns for the portfolio committee on police. The committee said the backlog of 14 469 cases hampers Ipid's ability to fulfil its mandate effectively. It called for urgent strategies to remedy the concern. 'Ipid plays a critical role in ensuring accountability from the South African Police Service (Saps), and the backlog directly undermines this drive,' said Ian Cameron, the chairperson of the committee. Ipid struggles with 14 000-case backlog 'While the committee has noted various interventions to clear the backlog, the reality is that victims of police abuse of authority remain without recourse.' This comes after the committee met with both Ipid and the Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority (PSiRA) on Thursday to discuss the revised annual performance plan and strategic plan. The committee welcomed the R126.3 million additional funding over the medium term and hopes it will significantly contribute to reducing the case backlog. ALSO READ: Police officers charged with serious crimes remain on active duty It is, however, worried that the additional funding, without clear plans to address some of the internal systematic challenges, will not solve the issue. A significant obstacle to the Ipid is the disproportionately high case-per-investigator ratio, the committee said. It noted that a nominal staff increase—from 387 in the 2025-26 fiscal year to 421 in 2027-28 — will not sufficiently address the issue. 'In the context of the increasing cases reported to Ipid, it is necessary to ensure that the directorate is adequately capacitated to increasing demand,' the committee said. Plans to introduce digital case management system The portfolio committee on police acknowledged that the directorate plans to introduce a new digital case management system to help the organisation monitor cases more effectively and improve victim tracking and communication. It has, however, urged Ipid to effectively implement the plans, as a functional system may positively impact the backlog. The committee added that it was also concerned about the implementation of recommendations made by Ipid to the Saps. It stated that Thursday's meeting highlighted a trend of Saps seemingly ignoring strong recommendations made by the directorate. ALSO READ: Fatal shooting at Limpopo mine: Fraud suspect dies after trying to disarm officer 'This phenomenon erodes the effectiveness of Ipid and its mandate, and the committee resolved that there is a need for a laser focus on the rate of implementation of the recommendations,' Cameron said. The committee also expressed agreement with Police Minister Senzo Mchunu that Saps members must improve their conduct. 'The bottom line is that there is no place in the Saps for rogue police officers who engage in criminal activity. While the Ipid provides the necessary checks and balances, the Saps members must always be fit and proper for the service they must render to the people,' Cameron said. PSiRA's plans to implement digital strategy In terms of PSiRA, the committee acknowledged the plan to implement a digital strategy that will ensure a smooth user interaction process. The committee also welcomed the intention to increase PSiRA's footprint to make sure that private security companies in Limpopo, Northern Cape, and North West are able to access its services more easily. 'The committee has always emphasised the importance of the private security industry in efforts to combat crime in the country,' it said. NOW READ: Police sergeant abuses power, gets 20 years for raping victim inside police station
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
Julius Malema to honour fallen EFF members at mass funeral following tragic bus accident
Julius Malema is expected to return to KwaZulu-Natal for a mass funeral of party supporters who died in a bus and truck accident recently. Image: EFF EFF leader Julius Malema and the top leadership of the party are expected to return to KwaZulu-Natal to attend the mass funeral of the party members that died in a bus accident. Ten party supporters died and scores of others were injured when their bus collided with a long-haul truck near Vryheid, north of the province, on Monday night. They were returning from the party's Youth Day commemoration rally, which was held at King Zwelithini Stadium in Umlazi, south of Durban, on Monday. Malema's return to the province was confirmed by the party provincial secretary, Vukani Ndlovu, on Thursday. According to Ndlovu, the party's top leadership would attend the mass funeral over the weekend in remembrance of the fallen heroes and heroines. 'We are expecting our Commander-In-Chief, Julius Malema, and the top national leadership to come back to the province to honour the funeral of our tragically departed fighters.' He said the funeral will take place on Saturday in Vryheid, but the venue still needs to be confirmed, adding that the party is finalising the preparations, including securing a ground or an open space to erect marquees. The party will also carry all funeral costs. Ndlovu said 37 injured people have been discharged, except four who are still in the hospital. Provincial Transport MEC Siboniso Duma visited the scene with department officials, visiting the hospital to see the injured passengers as well as the families of the deceased. Although police are still investigating the cause of the accident, it is believed it was caused by poor visibility in the early hours of darkness, which may have led the bus driver to not be able to see the truck. The MEC said both the SAPS and Road Traffic Management Cooperation will conduct a comprehensive investigation to establish the cause of the accident; however, he received conflicting versions about what happened from the survivors. 'There are allegations that the bus driver tried to overtake. Other survivors have alleged that the bus driver fell asleep at the steering wheel. We do not want to speculate at this stage. We are confident that the investigation will shed light. Critically, we have in the past expressed our concerns about accidents involving trucks,' said Duma. The MEC said trucks are not supposed to be on this road in the first place and should be using the N2, adding that many innocent lives have been lost due to a huge number of trucks on the roads. The truck was believed to be headed to the Richards Bay port to offload coal for export. Over 303,000 trucks, or almost 6,000 trucks every week on average, used the Richards Bay port in the 2024 fiscal year, according to Transnet, Duma stated. He said it has been stated that the port's infrastructure was originally designed for a much smaller volume of trucks, approximately 200 per day. 'Working with the national government, we are doubling our efforts to ensure that we strengthen plans to move cargo from road to rail,' concludes Duma. [email protected]
Daily Maverick
3 days ago
- Daily Maverick
Can a new leader elevate the Hawks, help SA mount a more effective response to serious crime?
To effectively tackle serious crime, South Africa's Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation requires a strong leadership team. The process to appoint a new head of the Hawks – officially South Africa's Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation – is under way. This key criminal justice appointment should receive broad public attention. Lieutenant-General Godfrey Lebeya, who headed the Hawks from 2018, retired on 30 May. The Hawks' deputy head, Lieutenant-General Siphesihle Nkosi, is currently the acting head. Under the South African Police Service (SAPS) Act, the appointment is made by Police Minister Senzo Mchunu, with concurrence by the Cabinet. It is not clear how long the new appointment process will take. In early June, Mchunu withdrew the initial advertisement, indicating that the time frame for applications would be extended to find the best possible candidate. Against the backdrop of high levels of serious crime in South Africa, what are the prospects for this specialised unit? Could a new head help the country mount a more effective response to serious crime? A high-performing Hawks unit is crucial to tackling organised crime, financial crime and corruption, which are the focus of its mandate. Most of these crimes have cyber-forensic elements, and some have complex international dimensions. The global intergovernmental body, the Financial Action Task Force, requires South Africa to prove its ability to prosecute money laundering, illicit financial flows and terror financing. The Hawks must provide specialised investigation services to get these cases to court. During his time as Hawks head, Lebeya reported publicly each quarter on the directorate's successes. For the January to March 2025 period, he indicated that the unit had made arrests for various crimes, seized firearms, shut down drug laboratories and secured convictions against 239 persons. While there have been achievements, external observers have highlighted the Hawks' shortcomings, including a lack of skills. These hinder its ability to conduct complex investigations such as the 'proactive identification' of money laundering networks. The unit has never received sufficient budget funding to reduce its vacancy rate below 50%. Last week, Ian Cameron, chair of the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Police, lamented how long it was taking for the Hawks to complete an investigation into corruption at the SAPS training centre in Philippi, Cape Town. When Mchunu announced the extension of the Hawks head application period, Cameron emphasised the need to make the 'right appointment'. Lebeya may have wanted to turn things around. But like his National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) colleague Shamila Batohi, he has had little room for manoeuvre. Turning criminal justice organisations around requires more than simply appointing good heads. A programme of strategic institutional strengthening must be directed by a skilled executive team that has political backing and financial support. The Hawks' history is intertwined with State Capture. Its predecessor, the Directorate for Special Operations, or Scorpions, was closed in 2009 by supporters of former president Jacob Zuma as a way to neutralise its investigations against Zuma and others. Following the Hawks' establishment, Zuma used his power over senior appointments to manipulate and undermine the unit and other criminal justice agencies. Following legal challenges, the Constitutional Court ruled in 2011 and again in 2014 that the state was obligated to establish an effective independent anti-corruption agency. The judgments said the Hawks should perform this role and that legislation must be amended to strengthen its independence. Notwithstanding these rulings, the process and criteria for senior leadership appointments remain challenging throughout the criminal justice system – including for the SAPS, NPA, Independent Police Investigative Directorate and the Hawks. While constitutional provisions entrench executive influence over certain senior criminal justice appointments, the extent to which this can be used to weaken such agencies must be curtailed. A key requirement is that independent professional panels run merit-based, competitive and transparent selection processes, and make recommendations. Rather than considering how to strengthen the Hawks, debate in Parliament and elsewhere has focused on setting up alternative structures to investigate corruption. At this point, it's unclear what responsibility the Hawks would retain in this regard. Either way, there is more than enough for the specialised unit to work on. South Africa must establish strategic centres for fighting organised and financial crime. Priority must be given to taking down networks that support the use of assassinations, particularly the killing of whistle-blowers, political leaders and community activists. The country also needs answers on where illegal guns are coming from and how to stop the supply. The new Hawks head should boost staff confidence by leading vigorous and independent investigations of priority crimes that demonstrate the unit's vital role in South Africa. This will require a strategic leadership team to galvanise public support and build the Hawks' capacity to work on complex crimes. The team should establish the Hawks as an employer of choice and a highly skilled law enforcement agency. The new head should also contribute to the overall strategic leadership of South Africa's multi-agency system for investigating organised crime, financial crime and corruption. This should include advocating for a crime intelligence and analysis apparatus aligned with the realities of crime in the 21st century. DM
