Reforming taxation for salaried class
Talking to members of the All Pakistan Textile Mills Association (Aptma) on Monday, the ombudsman said that tax revenue collection could be increased 'only through a fair, just, easy and efficient tax system'. PHOTO: FILE
Listen to article
The tax system in Pakistan is constitutionally required to be fair, just and equitable. However, a review of the current system reveals a concerning trend: those who are tax compliant are increasingly burdened, while those who avoid the tax net, often by conducting transactions outside the banking system, face little to no consequences.
The salaried class exemplifies this disparity. Despite being among the most tax-compliant segments, regularly filing returns and having taxes withheld at source by employers, they frequently face increased tax rates and the erosion or elimination of available tax benefits.
This unjust treatment is often justified by the government's inability to collect adequate revenue from other sectors due to weak enforcement or political constraints.
As a result, the salaried class becomes the default target for higher taxation. While this may offer short-term relief in revenue collection, it undermines long-term objectives and fuels a culture that incentivises staying outside the tax net.
With the federal budget due within a month, this is an opportune moment to advocate for reforms that support the salaried class, drawing inspiration from international best practices. It's worth noting that the government has projected a 55% increase in revenue collection from the salaried class for the current fiscal year compared to the previous year's collection of Rs368 billion.
This increased reliance on the salaried segment will make it more challenging to introduce equitable and supportive tax measures. However, these challenges can be overcome with political will, sound policy design and robust enforcement. It is concerning that tax laws are often amended under pressure from external lenders, yet domestic reforms that promote fairness across all income groups are rarely prioritised.
First and foremost, the tax rates applicable to the salaried class must be revisited. The current tax-free threshold should be raised from Rs0.6 million to Rs1.2 million per annum.
Moreover, Pakistan rarely indexes its tax brackets to inflation, a globally accepted practice that prevents fiscal drag or bracket creep. Indexing ensures that rising nominal incomes due to inflation do not result in higher effective tax burdens, especially for low and middle-income earners. Far too often, modest salary increments are negated by disproportionate increases in tax liabilities.
Another issue that lies with tax rates of salaried class includes that if a person's annual salary exceeds Rs4.1 million, a flat 35% tax rate applies, down from a previous threshold of Rs6 million, creating a steep cliff effect. There is a clear need to introduce additional tax slabs to avoid such abrupt increases.
Additionally, inconsistencies between income slabs also merit attention. A salary increase from Rs2.2 million to Rs3.2 million results in a marginal tax rate hike of 5.26%, whereas an increase from Rs3.2 million to Rs4.1 million leads to a lesser rise of 3.64%. Such disparities disproportionately impact middle-income earners and highlight the need for comprehensive slab rationalisation.
Unfortunately, Pakistan tends to emulate other countries' tax rate structures without adopting the corresponding tax benefits those countries offer. A recent example is the additional surcharge introduced via the Finance Act 2024, under Section 4AB of the Income Tax Ordinance 2001 (the Ordinance), applicable where the taxable income exceeds Rs10 million. This surcharge is levied even on individuals, including salaried persons and associations of persons (AOPs), and must be reconsidered or withdrawn.
A holistic view reveals that the effective tax rate on salaried individuals often exceeds that paid by small business owners, especially those operating informally or under the minimum tax regime based on turnover.
Salaried taxpayers are not allowed to deduct any personal expenses from their income. A standard deduction, offered in many countries, including India, should be introduced. India currently allows a standard deduction of INR 50,000 under the old tax regime and INR 75,000 under the new regime.
Pakistan could implement a similar deduction without requiring any supporting evidence to cover the basic costs of employment, such as transportation and meals. This deduction could vary depending on the taxpayer's circumstances, with higher deductions for senior citizens, disabled persons, teachers, etc.
Lawmakers in Pakistan could also consider introducing dual tax regimes for salaried individuals. One regime could offer lower tax rates but limit deductions to a standard deduction and a few basic tax credits. The other could allow a broader range of deductions and credits in exchange for slightly higher rates. Taxpayers should be given the option to choose the regime that suits them best.
Other commonly available deductions internationally for salaried class include those for house rent, mortgage interest, life and health insurance premiums and expenses related to supporting dependents with disabilities or chronic illnesses. These costs significantly reduce their disposable income and should be deductible under a fair tax system.
Pakistan currently allows a limited deduction for children's education expenses, but thresholds are too low to be meaningful. These limits should be substantially increased and eligibility should be extended to include the taxpayer's own education and that of other dependents.
Additional incentives could include offering tax credits or benefits to salaried individuals who consistently file their returns on time. The ordinance contains multiple penalties for non-compliance, but very few rewards for voluntary and timely compliance.
A simple tax credit could be granted in the next fiscal year for taxpayers who filed on time during the preceding year. Since most salaried tax is collected through withholding, this measure would not significantly impact revenue but would encourage compliance.
Furthermore, the government could exempt compliant salaried individuals from audits and assessments, except in high-net-worth cases or where specific risk factors are identified. The language of Section 149 of the ordinance should be clarified to clearly outline which claims are permissible when tax is withheld by an employer.
In cases where a salaried person receives refund in a prior year, the refund should either be allowed under Section 149 of the ordinance or processed automatically through a streamlined verification mechanism.
Many additional reforms could help make the taxation of salaried individuals more just, efficient and supportive of broader economic goals. This segment is among the most documented and compliant in the country, yet it continues to bear a disproportionate tax burden due to weak enforcement in other parts of the economy. It is time to prioritise fairness and equity in tax system not just in principle, but in practice.
The writer is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Pakistan
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
18 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Senate rejects 18% tax on solar panels
Listen to article The Senate has approved with a majority vote the report of its standing committee on financerejecting an 18% tax on solar panels, sales tax on homeopathic items and stationery, and tariffs on the steel sector. In its report, presented in the upper house of parliament on Saturday, the committee also opposed increased taxation on 800cc vehicles, suggesting a 12.5% cap. It proposed no increase in tax on print media and IT services and urged that taxes on services falling under provincial jurisdiction be reconsidered. It also called for a review and further increase in government employees' salaries. The committee also proposed setting the minimum wage at Rs40,000 or Rs50,000 and exempting income tax for monthly salaries up to Rs100,000. The Senate session began under the chairmanship of Deputy Chairman Syedaal Khan Nasar. During the session, Senate Standing Committee on Finance Chairman Saleem Mandviwalla, presented the report containing the budget proposals and recommendations. Earlier, Senate Leader of Opposition Shibli Faraz objected that the report had not been presented to them earlier and questioned how a 100-page document could be read and reviewed in 10 minutes. He criticized the government for not reducing its expenditures and instead taxing those already burdened with taxes. Responding to the criticism, Senator Mandviwalla stated that he had remained in contact with Shibli and Mohsin Aziz of the PTI. He said all parties, including the PML-N, the PPP, and the PTI, participated in the discussions, offered suggestions, and voiced their concerns. He said the committee staff worked till 2 am and while the draft may not have been shared due to an oversight, all recommendations in the final version reflected the committee's discussions. Concluding the budget debate, Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb acknowledged the valuable, balanced, and constructive input provided by senators over the past one and a half weeks. He said this consultation helped guide the government's economic policies and reinforced its commitment to transparency, fiscal responsibility, and sustainable development. "During the past fiscal year, no mini-budget was introduced, inflation was brought under control, foreign reserves increased, and the current account improved significantly," he added. He announced tax relief for salaried individuals earning between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million annually by reducing the income tax rate from 2.5% to 1%. This, he said, was a symbolic and practical gesture to show that the government does not wish to overburden the middle class. He also announced a 10% increase in government employees' salaries and a 7% raise in pensions. Taxes on agricultural pesticides were removed, and, following the prime minister's direction, 1,000 graduates would be sent to China for further opportunities. Regarding solar panels, the finance minister said the proposed 18% sales tax on imported parts was meant to protect local industry and create a competitive environment for solar technology investment in Pakistan. However, after consultation, the government decided to reduce the tax to 10%, applicable only to 46% of imported components, resulting in a 4.6% price hike for imported panels. He warned against profiteering, noting that some opportunistic elements had already begun increasing prices before the tax's implementation. He assured that the government would take strict legal action against such exploitation in the public interest. Aurangzeb said the relief and social protection measures included in the 2025-26 budget are not merely temporary reliefs but a practical reflection of the state's recognition and acceptance of its responsibilities. "A key measure is the increase in the budget of the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) from Rs592 billion to Rs716 billion. "Expanding the scope of financial assistance under BISP reflects the government's commitment to providing economic protection to the most vulnerable segments of society," he added.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Budget FY26: Aurangzeb announces major tax relief for salaried class, solar sector
Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb, in his address to the Senate, on Saturday, announced key relief measures in the federal budget for FY2025-26, including a significant income tax cut for the salaried class and a reduction in General Sales Tax (GST) on imported solar panels. He emphasised that individuals earning between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million annually will now be taxed at just 1%, down from 2.5% proposed in the budget for FY2025-26. It is pertinent to mention that, according to the budget proposals for FY26, the tax rate for those earning between Rs600,001 and Rs1.2 million was reduced to 2.5% from 5%. Pakistan salaried class rejects govt's claim of giving relief in income tax Addressing the Senate on Saturday, the finance minister said that low- and middle-income individuals play a vital role in our economy. 'This is the segment that endures inflation and pays taxes,' he acknowledged. The Senator said that the proposal to reduce income tax on this salaried class was already part of the budget suggestions. 'In this regard, the government, amid directives from the prime minister, has reduced the income tax rate for those earning between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million annually — from 2.5% to just 1%,' he told the house. The minister was of the view that the implementation of a 1% income tax rate is both 'a practical and symbolic recognition' by the government that it does not want to burden this class. 'We hope this step will not only increase compliance but also restore their confidence in the tax system,' he said. Meanwhile, Aurangzeb stated that the salaries and pensions of government employees have been increased by 10% and 7%, respectively. The finance minister reiterated that the government did not introduce a mini-budget during the outgoing fiscal year and maintained fiscal discipline. He informed the upper house that the federal government expenditure for FY26 has increased marginally by 1.9%, far lower than in previous years. GST on solar panels lowered to 10% Additionally, Aurangzeb told the Senate that the proposed 18% GST on solar panel imports has been lowered to 10% following consultations with lawmakers. 'The government in its budget proposed to impose an 18% GST on imported solar panels. This was done to protect local industries and provide a level playing field, and promote the development and investment in solar technology in Pakistan,' he said. However, in light of detailed deliberations on the budget in both houses, the government has decided to reduce the proposed tax to 10%. Moreover, this tax will apply only to 46% of imported components, said Aurangzeb. 'With this measure, the price of solar panels will increase by 4.6%,' he said, adding that the government remains committed to promoting renewable energy. Aurangzeb informed the house that the government has received reports of profiteering and hoarding of solar panels by certain elements. 'It is condemnable that these opportunistic actors have artificially increased prices even before the proposed measure has come into effect. I strongly warn such elements that the government will take every possible step in the public interest,' he said, adding that legal action will be taken against those involved.
Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
Stocks fall as Mideast conflict sparks selling
Listen to article Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) ended lower by over 450 points on Thursday following a volatile session as early gains, driven by policy optimism, were wiped out by selling pressure amid escalating Middle East tensions. Earlier, trading opened on a robust note in the wake of federal cabinet's approval of a large-scale circular debt resolution plan worth Rs1.2 trillion, which fuelled broad-based buying in energy sectors. However, news of Iran's missile strikes on Israel rattled investors, leading to a sharp reversal. The heightened tensions spurred profit-taking, particularly in fertiliser and cement sectors. Banks emerged as a safe-haven, providing some support. Arif Habib Corp MD Ahsan Mehanti commented that stocks closed lower on fears of escalation in Middle East tensions. "Weak rupee and a slump in global equities were factors behind panic selling," he said. At the end of trading, the benchmark KSE-100 index registered a drop of 463.34 points, or 0.38%, and settled at 120,002.59. Arif Habib Limited Deputy Head of Trading Ali Najib noted that geopolitical ripples drove bulls to sidelines as the KSE-100 index extended losses by closing at 120,003, just above the key psychological level of 120k. The index reflected a day-on-day decline of 463 points. The trading session opened with a strong bullish momentum following the cabinet's approval of over Rs1.2 trillion for circular debt resolution. This development was well-received by investors, prompting heavy buying in key energy stocks, including OGDC, Pakistan Petroleum Limited (PPL), Pakistan State Oil (PSO) and Hub Power, he said. However, news of Iran's attack on the Israeli capital weighed on bullish sentiment, triggering profit-taking. As a result, the index lost its upward momentum and briefly fell below the 120,000 mark, hitting the intra-day low of 119,770, down 696 points, Najib added. KTrade Securities, in its report, stated that stocks extended their downward trend as escalating Israel-Iran tensions weighed on investor sentiment. The KSE-100 index shed 463 points to close at 120,003, retreating from the intra-day high of 121,745. Market activity remained muted, with total volumes at 598 million shares. Sector performance was broadly negative, where power, cement and oil and gas sectors faced steep losses, it said. Key index laggards were Pakgen Power, Engro Fertilisers, Engro Holdings, Lucky Cement and Mari Petroleum. The banking sector was the sole bright spot, largely supported by UBL, KTrade added. Topline Securities reported that the bourse kicked off trading on a strong footing, buoyed by news that the federal cabinet had green-lighted a financial restructuring plan aimed at slashing Rs1.275 trillion in circular debt within the power sector over the next six years. Riding on that optimism, the index surged to the intra-day high of 1,279 points. However, the bullish momentum was short-lived as profit-taking set in later in the day in line with global market trends, it said. Rising geopolitical tensions, particularly the intensifying stand-off between Israel and Iran, dampened investor sentiment and led to a broad-based pullback, overshadowing the earlier euphoria and highlighting the fragility of market confidence. On the upside, index heavyweights from the banking sector provided some support, contributing 203 points. However, the gains were offset by power and cement sectors that pulled the index down by 270 points, Topline added. Overall trading volumes decreased to 604.5 million shares compared with Wednesday's tally of 707.3 million. Shares of 459 companies were traded. Of these, 155 stocks closed higher, 269 fell and 35 remained unchanged. WorldCall Telecom was the volume leader with trading in 64.6 million shares, down Rs0.01 to close at Rs1.49. It was followed by Sui Southern Gas Company with 35.6 million shares, falling Rs0.96 to close at Rs43.28 and First Prudential Modaraba with 30.3 million shares, losing Rs0.3 to close at Rs4.31. Foreign investors sold shares worth Rs7.6 million, the National Clearing Company reported.
