Supreme Court Revives Suit From Victims of Botched F.B.I. Raid
The Supreme Court on Thursday unanimously revived a suit from a couple whose home was mistakenly raided by the F.B.I., giving them a fresh opportunity to try to persuade lower courts that they should be able to sue the federal government for the harm they suffered.
The case, Martin v. United States, No. 24-362, arose from a raid very early on a fall morning in 2017, when F.B.I. agents used a battering ram to knock down the front door of the home of the couple, Hilliard Toi Cliatt and Curtrina Martin. Guns drawn, the agents set off a flash-bang grenade and charged inside.
The couple barricaded themselves in a closet. The agents dragged Mr. Cliatt out at gunpoint and handcuffed him. They told Ms. Martin to keep her hands up as she pleaded to see her 7-year-old son, who had been asleep in another room.
As they questioned Mr. Cliatt, he gave his address. It was different from the one the agents had a warrant to enter.
One of the agents, Lawrence Guerra, had earlier identified the correct house, which he said looked similar and was nearby, on a different street. But on the morning of the raid, he said he went to the wrong house because he had been misdirected by his GPS device.
The couple sued for false arrest, false imprisonment, assault, battery and other claims but lost in the lower courts on a variety of grounds, notably that government officials' actions are protected from lawsuits when they perform a duty that involves discretion.
The case turned on the Federal Tort Claims Act, which sometimes allows suits against the government notwithstanding the doctrine of sovereign immunity. A 1974 amendment to the law made it easier to sue over wrong-house raids after notorious ones in Collinsville, Ill. But the law is subject to a tangled series of exceptions and provisos.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
18 minutes ago
- Washington Post
MAGA is divided over Trump's decision to bomb Iran. Will it last?
Stephen K. Bannon sounded uncertain as he absorbed President Donald Trump's strike on Iran and his national address explaining it. 'An interesting talk,' Bannon said warily on his 'War Room' podcast, adding that he was not quite sure that it was what 'a lot of MAGA wanted to hear.'
Bloomberg
33 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Netanyahu Says Iran Nuclear Site Damaged as Full Results Unknown
The US airstrike on the best-defended Iranian nuclear facility delivered 'a great deal of damage,' but the full extent is not yet known, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said. The Israelis pressed their own strikes after the US sorties. Netanyahu pledged in a news conference to continue Israel's military campaign in Iran as well as in the Gaza Strip.
CBS News
34 minutes ago
- CBS News
3 dead, 10 shot during violent weekend in Baltimore
Three people died, and 10 people were shot during a violent weekend in Baltimore. On Sunday, police said two men died after a shooting in Southwest Baltimore. Officers responded around 1:30 p.m. to the 2200 block of Christian Street, where they found a 31-year-old man unresponsive and suffering from apparent gunshot wounds. While investigating, an unresponsive 24-year-old man who had also been shot was located in the 2100 block of Wilkens Avenue. The men were taken to the hospital, where they were pronounced dead, according to police. Stabbing death investigated Early Saturday, police said a man died after being stabbed in the 100 block of South Broadway in the Fells Point area. Officers said the man was taken to the hospital, where he later died. Five gun violence victims were 21 or younger Baltimore police were busy this weekend, responding to several shootings, including five younger than 21 years old. Shortly after midnight on Sunday, a 17-year-old girl and an 18-year-old girl went to the hospital with gunshot wounds after a shooting in the 2600 block of Erdman Avenue in East Baltimore. Police said evidence of the shooting was found in the area. They are expected to survive. Around 2:30 a.m. on Sunday, police responded to the 200 block of East Lombard Street in downtown Baltimore, where an 18-year-old man was found injured from a shooting. He was taken to the hospital for treatment. Around 3 a.m. on Sunday, a 21-year-old man was found injured from a shooting in the 2600 block of Dulany Street in Southwest Baltimore, according to police. He was taken to the hospital in stable condition. Officers said a 19-year-old man was found at a hospital injured from a shooting on Saturday. He is expected to survive. Police said the shooting happened as he was walking in the 3800 block of Belle Avenue. More weekend shootings Baltimore police responded to a reported shooting around 3:45 p.m. on Saturday in the 200 block of Marion Street, where a 29-year-old was found suffering from a gunshot wound. Police said he is expected to survive. Around 3:30 a.m. on Saturday, a 25-year-old man went to the hospital after he had been shot in the 600 block of South Broadway in Fells Point, police said. The man is expected to recover. On Friday, shortly before 6 p.m., a 51-year-old man was shot in his upper body, according to police. Officers said the shooting happened in the 1400 block of Mosher Street in West Baltimore. He was listed at the hospital in stable condition, according to police. Gun violence in Baltimore According to the CBS News Gun Tracker data, within the past 12 months, there have been 26 deaths involving people younger than 21 in Baltimore. There have also been 98 people younger than 21 years old who were wounded by gunfire in Baltimore within the past 12 months. Earlier this month, Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott touted a 23.6% decline in homicides in 2025, and a 23.4% decline in non-fatal shootings.
