Ali Khan Mahmudabad: Who Is The Historian Arrested For His Social Media Post On Operation Sindoor?
Last Updated:
Born in Lucknow on December 2, 1982, Ashoka University's Ali Khan Mahmudabad is known for his scholarly work on nationalism, political Islam, and South Asian history
Ali Khan Mahmudabad – a historian, political scientist, and associate professor at Ashoka University – was arrested from his Delhi residence on May 18 over a social media post that questioned the optics of women officers addressing a press briefing after Operation Sindoor.
Mahmudabad's arrest has since ignited a national debate on free speech and drawn sharp reactions, particularly within Uttar Pradesh's political circles. A complaint filed by BJP Yuva Morcha's Haryana general secretary Yogesh Jatheri alleged that his post was 'anti-national" and 'demeaning to India's armed forces".
The post in question, published on Facebook, reportedly questioned the 'representational intent" behind showcasing women officers after the military operation and asked whether their presence signified a genuine shift or was limited to symbolism. The Haryana State Commission for Women took suo motu cognisance of the post earlier on May 12.
On Sunday evening (May 18), he was produced before a magistrate and remanded to two-day police custody. He has been booked under Section 152 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) – a newly introduced provision replacing sedition – alongside charges related to outraging religious sentiments.
Mahmudabad's legal team, led by senior advocate Kapil Sibal, has approached the Supreme Court seeking immediate relief. Chief Justice BR Gavai assured the matter will be heard on May 20 or 21.
WHO IS HE?
Born in Lucknow on December 2, 1982, Ali Khan Mahmudabad is known for his scholarly work on nationalism, political Islam, and South Asian history.
A PhD from Cambridge, he currently teaches political science at Ashoka University in Haryana's Sonipat. He is the author of 'Poetry of Belonging', a widely acclaimed book exploring Muslim political imagination in colonial India. His academic articles, essays, and columns – published in journals and media outlets across the world – reflect a nuanced engagement with issues of identity, democracy, and religious pluralism.
Fluent in Urdu, Hindi, English, and Arabic, he is one of India's few multilingual academics who also bridges the gap between scholarship and public debate. He studied Arabic at Damascus University and conducted fieldwork in Iran and Iraq.
ARISTOCRATIC ROOTS, POLITICAL PAST
Mahmudabad belongs to the storied royal family of Mahmudabad in Uttar Pradesh. His father, Mohammad Amir Mohammad Khan – popularly known as Raja Sahib Mahmudabad – was a two-time Congress MLA and fought a decades-long legal battle to reclaim family properties seized under the Enemy Properties Act.
His grandfather, Mohammad Amir Ahmad Khan, was the last ruling Raja of Mahmudabad and a key financier of the Muslim League in the pre-Partition era. On his maternal side, he is the grandson of former foreign secretary Jagat Singh Mehta and nephew of policy expert Vikram Mehta.
In 2017, Mahmudabad joined the Samajwadi Party and served as its national spokesperson until 2022. Though he distanced himself from formal politics in recent years, he continued to comment on national issues through writing and lectures.
With the Supreme Court set to hear his plea this week, all eyes are on how the judiciary will interpret the use of the new sedition-like provisions under the BNS. As of now, Mahmudabad remains in police custody, even as the chorus for his release grows louder from scholars, opposition parties, and rights activists.
Mahmudabad's arrest triggered widespread condemnation from civil society, opposition leaders, and academic communities both in India and abroad.
Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge called the arrest 'unconstitutional and dangerous". 'Professors, students, journalists – none are safe from state-sponsored targeting if they dissent. This regime has made it clear that critical thinking is now a punishable offence," he said.
Senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor described Mahmudabad's arrest as an 'alarming blow to academic freedom". 'The criminalisation of a social media post – one that seeks introspection rather than instigation – is deeply troubling. This is not nationalism; this is paranoia," he said.
Congress leader Pawan Khera said the case was less about legality and more about a political message. 'This arrest sends a signal: critique the government's narrative, and you will face jail. We cannot let this become the new normal."
The SP, which Mahmudabad was associated with between 2017 and 2022, also issued a scathing statement. 'This government is terrified of intellect," SP chief Akhilesh Yadav said. 'It jails those who write, think, and question, and celebrates those who polarise and provoke."
More than 100 academics from institutions, including Oxford, Yale, and Jawaharlal Nehru University, have signed a petition demanding Mahmudabad's immediate release. The signatories condemned the 'weaponisation of law to suppress intellectual discourse" and termed the arrest 'chillingly reminiscent of authoritarian regimes."
Watch India Pakistan Breaking News on CNN-News18. Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated!
tags :
ashoka university
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
May 20, 2025, 08:00 IST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Iran TRAINS Advanced Missiles At Israel, Humiliates ‘Fake News' On Arsenal Stockpile
Indus Water War Heats Up: Now Omar Abdullah Refuses To Divert Water To Punjab, Congress Hits Back A fresh water dispute has erupted between Jammu & Kashmir and Punjab, just weeks after Punjab's clash with Haryana. This time, it's over the proposed 113 km canal to divert surplus Indus water from J&K to Punjab, Haryana, and Rajasthan to prevent it from flowing to Pakistan. J&K CM Omar Abdullah has rejected the idea, saying Jammu itself faces water scarcity. 'Why should I send water to Punjab?' he asked, reminding that Punjab already has three rivers under the Indus Waters Treaty. He also invoked the decades-old Shahpur Kandi barrage dispute, insisting J&K won't give up more water. Reacting sharply, Congress MP Sukhjinder Singh Randhawa accused Abdullah of undermining Punjab's sacrifice and patriotism, pointing to Punjab's suffering during Operation Sindoor, saying 'Pakistan attacked Punjab more than Jammu & Kashmir.' The conflict exposes deeper fault lines in India's federal water-sharing model, raising questions of equity, national interest, and regional politics — especially with Pakistan watching closely as India attempts to control its Indus water allocations.#waterdispute #punjabvsjk #induswaters #shahpurkandi #operationsindoor #omarabdullah #sukhjinderrandhawa #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews 6.0K views | 5 hours ago
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Operation Sindoor reflects control, inner strength of troops, gained by practising yoga: Rajnath Singh
India's armed forces displayed restraint, balance and precision during Operation Sindoor, which is a reflection of their inner strength attained by practising yoga, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh said, speaking in Jammu and Kashmir where he celebrated the 11th International Day of Yoga on Saturday (June 21, 2025). He performed various asanas and breathing exercises with approximately 2,500 soldiers of the Northern Command in Udhampur. International Yoga Day updates: June 21, 2025 Crediting Prime Minister Narendra Modi for the global popularity of yoga, the Defence Minister said that the practice provides a holistic approach to health and well-being. Those who practice yoga in their daily lives have control over their body and mind, he said, adding that it makes the practitioner proactive, not reactive, and pointing to Operation Sindoor as a good example. Sindoor not over yet Claiming that India's social and communal unity was targeted through the Pahalgam terror attack, Mr. Singh said that Operation Sindoor was a clear message to Pakistan that it would face the consequences of supporting terror activities against India. 'Operation Sindoor is the natural progression of the surgical strike of 2016 and the air strike of 2019. It was executed in such a way that Pakistan requested for a ceasefire, and only then have we put a pause to the operation. As I have said earlier, Operation Sindoor is not over yet. India is fully prepared to take all kinds of action against terrorism,' Mr. Singh said. He also asserted that Pakistan wants to weaken India from within, but it should never forget that just like Major Somnath Sharma, Brigadier Usman too sacrificed his life for the unity and integrity of the country. Yoga's battlefield benefits When the nation is celebrating the International Day of Yoga, people should remember the true meaning of the practice, which is to connect every section of society with the culture and soul of India, the Defence Minister said. 'If even one section is left behind, the wheel of unity and security is broken. Therefore, today, we should perform yoga at the level of society and thought, and not just body,' he added. Yoga prepares a soldier physically and mentally and its benefits can be seen in the battlefield, he said, encouraging the soldiers to continue practicing it daily. The event was attended by Chief of the Army Staff General Upendra Dwivedi, General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Northern Command Lt Gen Pratik Sharma.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Op Sindoor paused after Pakistan requested for ceasefire: Rajnath Singh
NEW DELHI: Operation Sindoor is the natural progression of the 2016 surgical strikes and the 2019 Balakot airstrikes in Pakistan, and it was conducted in a manner that forced Islamabad to ask for a ceasefire, defence minister Rajnath Singh said on Saturday, articulating India's firm resolve to fight terrorism. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh interacts with the armed forces personnel during 'Barakhana' at Northern Command headquarters, in Udhampur, J&K, on Friday. (PTI) 'It was executed in such a way that Pakistan requested for a ceasefire, and only then have we put a pause to the operation. As I have said earlier, Operation Sindoor is not over yet. India is fully prepared to take all kinds of action against terrorism,' Singh said at an International Yoga Day function organised by the army in Udhampur. The army's Northern Command based in Udhampur is the nerve centre of counterterrorism operations in Jammu and Kashmir. India launched the operation in the early hours of May 7 and struck terror and military installations in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK) following the Pahalgam terror strike in which 26 people were shot dead. It triggered a four-day military confrontation with Pakistan involving fighter jets, missiles, drones, long-range weapons and heavy artillery before the two sides reached an understanding on stopping all military action on May 10. Singh led the armed forces' yoga day celebrations, with around 2,500 soldiers taking part in the Northern Command event. Army chief General Upendra Dwivedi and Northern Army commander Lieutenant General Pratik Sharma were present. 'Yoga gives clarity to the people in chaos. It is an art, a science, a philosophy, and spirituality. Those who practise yoga in their daily lives have control over their body and mind. It makes us proactive, not reactive,' he said in his address, describing Operation Sindoor as a shining example of that 'control.' The Indian armed forces showed restraint, balance and precision during the operation, which is a reflection of their inner strength attained by practising yoga, he said. The operation was a clear message to Pakistan that it will face the consequences for supporting terror activities against India, he said. Pakistan wants to weaken India from within, but it should never forget that just like Major Somnath Sharma, Brigadier Mohammad Usman too sacrificed his life for the unity and integrity of the country, Singh said referring to the bravehearts who fought valiantly during the 1947-48 India-Pakistan war. Sharma and Usman were posthumously awarded the Param Vir Chakra and the Maha Vir Chakra, respectively --- the country's highest and second highest wartime honours.
