Money, power and violence in Philippine elections
Cecil Morella,
Agence France-Presse
Philippines election hopefuls like mayoral candidate Kerwin Espinosa have to ask themselves whether the job is worth taking a bullet. The country's elections commission, Comelec, recorded 46 acts of political violence between January 12 and April 11, including the shooting of Espinosa. At a rally this month, someone from the crowd fired a bullet that went through his chest and exited his arm, leaving him bleeding but alive. Others have been less lucky.
A city council hopeful, a polling officer and a village chief were among those killed in similar attacks in the run-up to mid-term elections on May 12. Comelec said 'fewer than 20' candidates have been killed so far this campaign season, which it notes is a drop.
'This is much lower, very low compared to the past,' commission spokesperson John Rex Laudiangco told AFP, citing a tally of about 100 deaths in the last general election. Analysts warned that such violence will likely remain a fixture of the Philippines' political landscape. The immense influence of the posts is seen as something worth killing for. Holding municipal office means control over jobs, police departments and disbursements of national tax funds, said Danilo Reyes, an associate professor at the University of the Philippines' political science department.
'Local chief executives have discretion when it comes to how to allocate the funding, which projects, priorities,' he said. Rule of law that becomes weaker the farther one gets from Manila also means that regional powerbrokers can act with effective impunity, said Cleve Arguelles, CEO of Manila-based WR Numero Research.
'Local political elites have their own kingdoms, armed groups and... patronage networks,' he said, noting violence is typically highest in the archipelago nation's far north and south. 'The stakes are usually high in a local area where only one family is dominant or where there is involvement of private armed groups,' Arguelles said.
'If you lose control of... city hall, you don't just lose popular support. You actually lose both economic and political power.'
In the absence of strong institutions to mediate disagreements, Reyes said, 'confrontational violence' becomes the go-to.
Espinosa was waiting for his turn to speak at a campaign stop in central Leyte province on April 10 when a shooter emerged from the crowd and fired from about 50 metres (164 feet) away, according to police. Police Brigadier General Jean Fajardo told reporters this week that seven police officers were 'being investigated' as suspects.
Convictions, however, are hard to come by.
While Comelec's Laudiangco insisted recent election-related shootings were all making their way through regional court systems, he could provide no numbers. Data compiled by the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data project show that in 79 per cent of violent acts targeting local government members between 2018 and 2022 the perpetrators were never identified. National-level politicians, meanwhile, reliant on local political bases to deliver votes, have little incentive to press for serious investigations, said Reyes.
'The only way you can ensure national leaders win positions is for local allies to deliver votes,' he said.
'There are convictions but very rarely, and it depends on the potential political fallout on the national leaders as well as the local leaders.'
It's part of the 'grand bargain' in Philippine politics, Arguelles said.
Local elites are 'tolerated by the national government so long as during election day they can also deliver votes when they're needed'.
Three days after Espinosa's shooting, a district board candidate and his driver were rushed to hospital after someone opened fire on them in the autonomous area of Mindanao. Election-season violence has long plagued the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao, known as the BARMM. Comelec assumed 'direct control' over the municipalities of Buluan and Datu Odin Sinsuat after municipal election officer Bai Maceda Lidasan Abo and her husband were shot dead last month.
Since last year, Comelec has held the power to directly control and supervise not only local election officials but also law enforcement.
Top police officials in the two municipalities were removed for 'gross negligence and incompetence' after allegedly ignoring requests to provide security details for the slain Comelec official.
Their suspensions, however, will last only from 'campaigning up to... the swearing-in of the winners,' Comelec's Laudiangco said. The commission's actions were part of a 'tried and tested security plan' that is showing real results, he said. But he conceded that the interwoven nature of family, power and politics in the provinces would continue to create a combustible brew.
'You have a lot of closely related people in one given jurisdiction... That ensures polarisation. It becomes personal between neighbours. 'We all know Filipinos are clannish, that's our culture. But we're improving slowly.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
4 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Israeli army says 'too soon' to know results of US bombing on Fordow
The Israeli military said Sunday it was checking the results of a US bombing raid on the deeply buried Iranian nuclear facility in Fordow, while continuing its own offensive against Tehran. Asked whether Iran had removed enriched uranium from Fordow or if it had been buried under the rubble in the overnight US strikes, military spokesman Effie Defrin told reporters it was "too soon" to know. "We are constantly checking the situation. It is too soon to determine. I suppose we will know later on," he said during a televised briefing. Reporting by AFP
Gulf Today
4 hours ago
- Gulf Today
Iran says over 400 killed, 3,056 injured since start of war with Israel
Israeli strikes on Iran have killed more than 400 people since they began last week, Iran's health ministry said in an updated toll on Saturday, as fighting raged between the two foes. "As of this morning, Israeli attacks have claimed the lives of over 400 defenseless Iranians and left 3,056 others wounded by missiles and drones," health ministry spokesman Hossein Kermanpour said in a post on X. US-based NGO, the Human Rights Activists News Agency, said on Friday that based on its sources and media reports, at least 657 people have been killed in Iran, including 263 civilians. Strikes in southwest Iran, northern Israel Several "powerful explosions" were heard in the afternoon in southwestern Iran's Ahvaz, the daily Shargh reported, as Israel's military said it was conducting strikes on "military infrastructure" in the area. A man injured in an Israeli strike, receives medical care at the Rasoul Akram hospital in Tehran. AFP Ahvaz is the capital of Khuzestan province, which lies on the Iraqi border and is Iran's main oil-producing region. "Fighter jets are currently striking military infrastructure in southwestern Iran," the Israeli military said in a statement. Earlier, Israeli rescue services said an Iranian "drone strike hit a two-storey residential building in northern Israel" following a wave of attacks reported by the military. At least 19 people were injured in Haifa the day before following a strike on a building by the city's docks. Israel strikes Isfahan nuclear site Israel targeted "two centrifuge production sites" at Iran's Isfahan nuclear facility overnight in a second wave of strikes on the location since the start of the war, a military official said. "Isfahan we targeted in the first 24 hours of our operation, but we carried out a second wave of strikes there overnight, deepening our achievements and advancing the damage to the facility," the military official told reporters during a briefing on condition of anonymity. An injured woman is treated in a hospital in Tehran on Saturday. Reuters The repeated raids by the Israeli air force have "dealt a severe blow to Iran's centrifuge production capabilities", the official added. Iran arrests 22 over Israeli spy links Police in Iran's Qom province said 22 people "linked to Israeli spy services" had been arrested since June 13. Citing the head of police intelligence in Iran's Qom province, the Fars news agency reported that "22 people were identified and arrested on charges of being linked to the Zionist regime's spy services, disturbing public opinion and supporting the criminal regime". A European national was also arrested for alleged spying, the Tasnim news agency reported on Friday, without giving their nationality or the date of the arrest. Norway-based NGO Iran Human Rights said at least 223 people have been arrested nationwide on charges related to collaboration with Israel, cautioning that the actual figure was likely higher. Iran FM arrives in Istanbul Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi arrived in Istanbul, Tasnim reported, for a meeting with regional diplomats to discuss Tehran's conflict with Israel. Abbas Araghchi leaves after a meeting on Tehran's nuclear programme, with European diplomats at the Intercontinental Hotel in Geneva. AFP Around 40 diplomats are due to join the weekend gathering of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, as Israel and Iran continue to exchange attacks. "At this meeting, at the suggestion of Iran, the issue of the Zionist regime's attack on our country will be specifically addressed," Araghchi said, according to the news agency. Agence France-Presse
Al Etihad
6 hours ago
- Al Etihad
US 'devastated Iranian nuclear program': Defense secretary
22 June 2025 16:32 Washington (AFP)The US defense chief said on Sunday that strikes ordered by President Donald Trump overnight had "devastated" Iran's nuclear program and urged Iranian leaders to seek peace to avoid further attacks."We devastated the Iranian nuclear program," Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth told a Pentagon press briefing, adding that the operation "did not target Iranian troops or the Iranian people." Trump "seeks peace, and Iran should take that path," Hegseth said. Israel-Iran Conflict Continue full coverage
