Human Rights Watch Warns Of Migrant Worker Deaths In 2034 World Cup Host Saudi Arabia
Human Rights Watch on Wednesday said grave abuses were being committed on giant construction sites in Saudi Arabia and warned the risks to migrant workers could increase as the building of stadiums for the 2034 World Cup gathers pace.
HRW said "scores of migrant workers in Saudi Arabia die in gruesome yet avoidable workplace-related accidents, including falling from buildings, electrocution, and even decapitation".
The NGO, which has studied nearly 50 cases of deaths in Saudi Arabia, said Saudi authorities had "failed to adequately protect workers from preventable deaths, investigate workplace safety incidents, and ensure timely and adequate compensation for families" including through life insurance policies and benefits to survivors.
"The risks of occupational deaths and injuries are further increasing as the Saudi government ramps up construction work for the 2034 World Cup as well as other 'giga-projects'," HRW added.
The Gulf kingdom was handed the right to host the 2034 World Cup at a FIFA Congress last December despite concerns about its human rights record, the risks to migrant labourers and criminalisation of same-sex relationships. It was the only candidate.
The NGO called on FIFA to ensure all work-related deaths in Saudi Arabia are properly investigated and that bereaved families receive compensation.
FIFA has committed to establishing a workers' welfare system, which it says includes "dedicated mandatory standards and enforcement mechanisms applicable to all companies and workers involved in... World Cup-related construction and service delivery" in Saudi Arabia.
But HRW said football's world governing body did not provide "details on concrete measures to prevent, investigate, and compensate migrant worker deaths such as risk-based heat protection measures or life insurance".
The NGO claimed "FIFA is knowingly risking yet another tournament that will unnecessarily come at a grave human cost", referencing the decision to award the 2022 World Cup to Qatar.
Similar concerns over workers' welfare dogged Qatar ahead of its hosting of international football's showpiece tournament.
Amnesty International and other rights groups claimed thousands of migrant workers died in the lead-up to the 2022 tournament, though Doha has said only 37 workers on World Cup projects perished -- and only three in work-related accidents.
HRW stated in its report that the majority of migrant worker deaths in Saudi Arabia are attributed to "natural causes" and are therefore neither investigated nor compensated.
According to figures provided by the NGO, for example, 74 percent of 1,420 Indian migrant worker deaths recorded at the Indian embassy in Riyadh in 2023 were attributed to natural causes.
HRW added "even work-related death cases categorised as such in a migrant worker's death certificate are sometimes not compensated as they should be according to Saudi law and international labour standards".
"In migrant death cases that are compensated, the process is long and burdensome," the report said, providing an example of one such compensation process that took a decade to be completed.
"My sons are 11 and 13 years old. When my husband died, they were 11 months and two years old. If we had received compensation right after his death, it would have provided so much relief," the wife of a deceased worker, who was not named, told HRW.
In response to the report, FIFA shared with AFP a letter it sent last month to HRW from its secretary general Mattias Grafstrom.
The letter says Saudi Arabia has "in the past years been investing heavily in the development of its society and economy", using international companies.
Grafstrom notes that Saudi Arabia "has taken significant steps to reform its labour laws since 2018", including the abolition of parts of the kafala system which ties workers to their employers, and introducing standardised contracts for workers.
The Saudi government, he says, has also committed to working with the United Nations' International Labour Organization (ILO) "on the further expansion and effective implementation of these reforms".
"In line with its human rights commitments, FIFA seeks to play its part in ensuring strong protections for workers employed by third parties in the construction of FIFA World Cup sites," Grafstrom adds.
AFP has also contacted the Saudi government for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
a day ago
- Int'l Business Times
Malaysia's Dayaks Mark Rice Harvest End With Colourful Parade
Dressed in colourful costumes, some sporting feathered headgear and traditional swords, several thousand of Malaysia's ethnic Dayak people paraded in the streets of Sarawak state on Borneo island Saturday to celebrate the ending of the rice harvest season. The Gawai Dayak 2025 Parade in state capital Kuching is the only annual gathering by representatives of around 11 of Sarawak's main Dayak groups -- which participants said helps to keep alive a unique part of the Southeast Asian nation's culture. Marchers gathered from early Saturday under the blistering tropical sun, many of them travelling long distances by bus to walk in the parade along the banks of the Sarawak River. "This gathering is something that is very important to me," said Joel Zacchaeus Anak Ebi, sporting the traditional Iban headgear worn by one of Borneo's best-known tribes. People "must know and realise that Sarawak has traditions and cultures that must be preserved," he told AFP ahead of the march, which was also attended by Sarawak Premier Abang Johari Tun Openg. "A day like this brings our people together, especially the younger people, who can easily lose touch with their roots when they move away from Sarawak," said Dayak village elder Ngindang Rambo, 61. Watching the parade, Masha Timosha, 34, a tour guide from Russia, said she was amazed by the costumes and atmosphere. "This is just very impressive. I even have my own Sarawakian costume but I didn't put it on," she told AFP. Malaysia's Dayak people are mainly riverine and hill-dwelling, made up of dozens of ethnic groups, each with their own distinct dialect, customs, laws and practices. Dayak communities however have become increasingly under threat from encroaching palm oil forestry and industrial logging, human rights groups and Indigenous groups have said. Many Indigenous communities in Sarawak face challenges in accessing basic services, Human Rights Watch said in a statement last month, including access to running water, electricity and land titles. Local groups and international observers have also called on the government to "urgently legislate Indigenous customs and traditions through which Indigenous people have acquired rights to their lands, territories and resources," the Sarawak Dayak Iban Association (Sadia) said last year. Rainforest-clad Borneo is the world's third-largest island and is shared between Malaysia, Indonesia and Brunei. Indigenous Iban women gather for the Gawai Dayak Culture Parade in Kuching AFP
DW
a day ago
- DW
Will India step in to mediate amid Iran-Israel escalation? – DW – 06/21/2025
With close ties to both Israel and Iran and as a self-proclaimed leader of the Global South, could Delhi help end the current conflict? DW's security podcast Global Eyes takes a look. With close ties to both Iran and Israel, India has the opportunity to mediate between the two as their confrontation continues and risks further geopolitical escalation. Delhi has increasingly sought out Israeli military technology but also long maintained good relations with Tehran for energy and other economic reasons. As a self-proclaimed leader of the Global South, will India step out of its traditional role of avoiding any strong position? Khinvraj Jangid, Director of the Jindal Center for Israel Studies in Delhi and Nicolas Blarel, a researcher on Indian foreign policy at Leiden University in the Netherlands, join the hosts of DW's security podcast, Global Eyes, to examine India's ties to both Israel and Iran. Should Delhi step up or stay on the sidelines?
DW
3 days ago
- DW
Is India leaving South Asia behind? – DW – 06/19/2025
India is aiming for a global leadership role, but strained ties and regional instability in South Asia are testing its Neighborhood First policy. India, the world's fourth-largest economy, aspires to become a top power on the international political stage. "India is emerging as a global leader in different aspects of technology, be it space, AI [artificial intelligence], digital innovation, green technology and more," Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on X last month. However, some experts told DW that India's global ambitions come at the cost of its relationship with regional neighbors that have turned hostile to New Delhi's quest for regional hegemony. India's rise comes as economic instability and political fragility are threatening South Asia. As India positions itself on the global stage, questions remain over whether it can truly rise without its neighbors Image: DPR PMO/ANI Photo More than half of Afghanistan's population has slipped below the poverty line since the Taliban came to power, while Myanmar grapples with political instability under military rule. Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh have turned to the International Monetary Fund for bailouts, and India itself faces a rise in sectarian violence. China is meanwhile expanding its influence across South Asia through deepening economic and strategic partnerships. Neighborhood First — on the backburner? After coming to power in 2014, Modi signaled a revitalization of India's Neighborhood First Policy, aimed at repairing and bolstering its ties with countries in the region. But Chietigj Bajpaee, senior fellow for South Asia at the London-based Chatham House, said that a decade on, "the neighborhood remains a weak component of India's foreign policy." He suggested that there has been "a degree of benign neglect by New Delhi." Despite rhetorical nods to regional solidarity, India's foreign policy has primarily focused outward, toward the US, Europe and East Asia — rather than toward South Asia. Bajpaee said there is little appetite in India to reactivate the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC), a regional bloc comprising Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. "Everyone except India is interested in reviving it," Bajpaee said, but noted that the "India-Pakistan relationship ... undermines any prospect of [reviving] SAARC." Hostilities between India and Pakistan have effectively frozen the bloc since 2016, when India withdrew from a summit in Islamabad following a deadly attack in Indian-administered Kashmir. Kanak Mani Dixit, a Nepal-based writer and founding editor of Himal South Asian magazine, says India has often taken a unilateral approach on regional issues. Citing the launch of the SAARC satellite in 2014, Dixit says Prime Minister Narendra Modi "bypassed regional consultations." "Courtesy requires talking with your neighbors," said Dixit. "This strategic aloofness has fed resentment against India in countries like Nepal and Sri Lanka." Dixit noted that other rising powers, most notably China, invested first in regional networks before turning outward. "China regionalized before it globalized. India is attempting the opposite," Bajpaee added. Tracking the tense relationship between India and China To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Missed opportunities South Asia is now widely considered the least economically integrated region in the world, according to the World Bank. Intra-regional trade makes up barely 5% of total trade in the region. By contrast, intra-EU trade stands at about 60%. "There is a strong market of 500 million people outside of India in South Asia," said Biswajeet Dhar, a former economics professor at New Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University. He pointed to textiles, pharmaceuticals, energy and services as areas with huge potential. "We studied regional value chains for the Asian Development Bank. The complementarity was incredible," Dhar added, noting that the "potential remains largely unrealized due to narrow political disputes." Dixit echoed Dhar's sentiment: "This is the region that could benefit the most from trade, and yet there is none." Sri Lankan economist Ganeshan Wignaraja said that India could benefit economically if it fostered closer links across its borders. "If India neglects its neighborhood, it will let others, such as China, enter the neighborhood, and that would compromise India's national security," said Wignaraja. India's trade with Pakistan collapsed following diplomatic hostilities, depriving both sides of economic links that could foster stability. China has already benefited from the regional gap, by investing in Bangladeshi ports, Sri Lankan airports and Pakistani motorways. Are India, the EU ready for a free trade agreement? To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video India's diplomacy of domination Dixit challenged what many people perceive to be India's diplomacy by domination. "It would like the rest of South Asia to be subservient," Dixit said. "For India to do well on the global stage, it has to make peace with its neighbors by accepting a one-on-one sovereign relationship." Bajpaee said that India "cannot control these countries' internal politics. The era of spheres of influence no longer exists." In the past, India has sacrificed long-term regional cooperation for short-term geopolitical alignment. Citing the Iran-Pakistan-India gas pipeline as an example, Dixit says that it was abandoned under former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh due to US pressure. "Had that happened, we would have created forward and backward linkages for gas to keep flowing, and that would have compelled peace," Dixit said. Is India setting a new diplomatic course? India's focus has shifted towards the Indo-Pacific, the Quad group — which is made up of the US, Japan, Australia and India — and the West. However, for India to be sustainable, its borders would need to be stable. "India's engagement with East Asia is held hostage by instability in Bangladesh and Myanmar," Bajpaee said. "It needs to have good relations with countries on its borders if it wants to engage more broadly." Dixit explained that India's global aspirations, including its efforts to become a veto power in the UN Security Council, also suffer from the regional deficit. "A UNSC seat needs regional credibility. But when the region is in a mess and India isn't reaching out, it weakens its case," he told DW. Wignaraja concluded that "India can [perhaps] rise alone — but it will be in a stronger position if it can rise with its neighbors." Edited by: Keith Walker
