Netball's dress debate mirrored in Ireland's camogie skort fight
The protest from Ireland's camogie players refusing to wear "uncomfortable" uniforms that conformed to tradition mirrors the discussion about whether netballers in Australia should still be mandated to wear dresses.
After years of discontent and backlash from players, the Camogie's ruling body last Thursday ended the obligation to wear skorts (a skirt with built-in shorts underneath), which critics said had deterred girls from taking up the sport.
The Camogie Association made the change after Dublin and Kilkenny players turned up at their provincial Leinster semifinal in shorts.
After the referee threatened to abandon the game, the players changed into skorts. However, the protest galvanised public solidarity with their cause.
This echoes a discussion point in recent years around the netball dress here in Australia, as some leaders have been calling for change, citing the uniform as uncomfortable and restrictive.
Bess Schnioffsky, a researcher at RMIT University, whose thesis looks at femininity in Australia netball, said the tight-fitting, very short nature of the netball dress often left players pulling down their uniform.
"A lot of netball moves involving putting your hands over your head, so if you're constantly worrying about pulling down your dress then you're not playing the game to the fullest of your ability," Dr Schnioffsky said.
Dr Schnioffsky said there's an interesting tension at the moment in netball at the higher levels, with some players loving the traditional dress and others finding it outdated.
"(Some) players are like 'Why are we still playing in a dress in 2025, this makes no sense' and other players are like 'No, I love playing in a dress, it's part of the game and I love that I can be feminine and sporty'," Dr Schnioffsky said.
When the option was given at the Team Girls Cup, the sport's official pre-season tournament, most players still opted for the dress despite some choosing a shorts or leggings and singlet combination.
GWS co-captain Jo Harten told ABC Sport last year that behind the scenes, she's been pushing for a more inclusive uniform policy at club level.
"I think, the broader options we can have as a uniform, the more people it will attract, because it doesn't have to be one body type playing this sport," Harten, who has played netball at the top level for close to 20 years, said.
"We should be looking at people of all different sizes, ethnicities, styles of hair, because essentially, that is what makes a global game and the more we can be inclusive, the better."
A state of the game review in 2020 found that a lack of flexibility in uniforms was proving to be a barrier to girls taking up the sport.
A 2021 national study by Victoria University found 58 per cent of girls do not want to wear skirts while playing sport outside of school, and 65 per cent do not want to wear skirts during school sport.
Following this, Netball Australia revealed changes to their uniform policy in late 2022, which would allow players and umpires to choose between a dress, singlet, bodysuit, short-sleeved or long-sleeved shirt, skirt, shorts and long pants.
These changes were implemented for the first time during the Super Netball pre-season Team Girls Cup by three teams.
However, once the main season commenced, all teams returned to the netball dress.
The discussion around netball uniforms has been simmering for years.
Former Diamonds world champion Ash Brazill, in 2023, said that when she started playing netball, she didn't know where she belonged, partly because of the attire.
"You know, I didn't have the blonde ponytail with the ribbon in their hair and I would have preferred to wear shorts than a dress," Brazill told The Age in 2023.
"And going into footy and hearing [people] asking girls 'why did they stop playing netball', and a lot of it was not feeling like they belonged."
Similarly, Dr Schnioffsky said if she was choosing a sport to play as a girl today, she'd likely opt for football over netball, given the comfort of the kit.
"That was the part of the game that I really had to grapple with, how I felt in a dress," Schnioffsky said.
"Because I didn't like it and I was very conscious of how my body looked in the dress and how I was being perceived in the dress. Whereas if I was growing up now I think I would have played footy.
"Because even though the uniform is still somewhat restrictive in terms of the short shorts, there's a greater diversity of bodies at that higher level who are modelling how it looks to fit in a footy jumper versus how, if you look at the elite professional netball bodies, that diversity isn't there."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
21 hours ago
- News.com.au
Super Netball 2025: Housby, Nweke vs. Kopua in derby clash of NSW titans
One of Super Netball's greatest players has turned super fan of a game in which she'll be a central character. Champion goaler Helen Housby has snuffed out any idea the Swifts are disappointed the Giants are hitting their straps ahead of the NSW derby, saying she's excited at the prospect of playing in one of the most anticipated games of the season. The teams may be sitting at opposite ends of the competition ladder, with the Swifts on top and Giants in sixth place having just lifted themselves from the cellar. But it's the Giants who head in with the best form line, their back-to-back wins the first time they've had consecutive victories in two years, while the Swifts lost outright lead of the competition after two straight losses in the last fortnight. Throw in the Giants' recruitment of Silver Ferns legend Casey Kopua setting up a clash between New Zealand netball's past and future - in super shooter Grace Nweke - and there's every ingredient needed for a fantastic feast. 'It's the kind of game that you want to play in,' said Housby, who believes the form guide has to be thrown out ahead of Sunday's match in front of a sold out crowd of about 10,000 fans at Ken Rosewall Arena. 'It's got a story to it, and it's got excitement to it and we love trying to figure out ways to play on different players, special players - and I think this is no different.' As strong a player as Kopua is in her own right - despite having been retired for the past six years - it's the way she's bringing the Giants' young defenders into the game that's helped them take such a step forward and Housby will have her own battle against outstanding young goal defence Erin O'Brien, who has flourished under the former Fern's on-court guidance. 'I think she was a really great recruitment for them,' Housby said of Kopua. 'She's obviously been retired for a little while but I don't think she's lost any of her game sense, game smarts … and more than anything, it's the confidence and the composure that she gives to the defenders around her. 'I think they've probably been desperate for a little bit of leadership back there and especially with Jodi-Ann (Ward's) sad (knee) injury, she was the perfect person to come in and kind of wrap them into a solid defensive game plan and mindset. 'She's an absolute stalwart of netball, one of the best defenders that the Silver Ferns have ever produced and for the (Giants) to have picked her up, they'll just be gaining information from her, learning from her and in turn, they can use her body, her physicality, to their advantage, so she's going to be huge for them and I'm quite excited by the prospect (of playing her).' Kopua's likely direct match-up will be Nweke though, the outstanding shooter who has given up her New Zealand eligibility this year to cross the ditch and play Super Netball with the Swifts to improve her game. 'I've got no doubt that most young Silver Ferns probably see Casey as a bit of an idol,' Housby said. 'I haven't actually spoken to Grace personally about it, I'll have to have a few words with her and see how she's feeling about it but I think it's going to be incredible. 'I think if you are a Silver Ferns supporter, you'll definitely be tuning in to watch this across the ditch, because I think it's a pretty special match-up … and it's pretty awesome to see the changing of the guard in the Silver Ferns superstars and I can't wait to be involved and to see, hopefully Gracie shine.'
The Australian
a day ago
- The Australian
2025 Melbourne Cup: Ethical Diamond wins at Royal Ascot
Irish master trainer Willie Mullins has unveiled a potential Melbourne Cup candidate in Royal Ascot winner Ethical Diamond. Ethical Diamond, raced by owners of stablemate Absurde, who ran seventh and fifth respectively in the Cup the past two years, won the Duke Of Edinburgh Stakes (2400m) by two lengths under champion jockey Ryan Moore. 'We will give him a little break and look at York – that is normally where we go from here,' Mullins said. • PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW! 'The Ebor would look possible. We would love to go to Melbourne. 'If we can get him qualified, that would be wonderful. 'We might see if we can get him Group-placed. I think he would suit the race (Melbourne Cup).' • 'Zachariah the Electrifier': Jockey targets darts glory Mullins has wanted to win the Cup since he fell in love with the race that stops a nation in 1993 as a spectator when Irish champion Vintage Crop, trained by Dermot Weld, triumphed at a Flemington. Mullins has placed in the Cup twice previously with Max Dynamite. Mullins travelled Vauban, now trained by Gai Waterhouse and Adrian Bott, and Absurde to Melbourne the past two years without luck. The Ebor Handicap at York offers the winner a golden ticket into the Melbourne Cup. • Moody, Purton, Tapp join turf legends in Hall Of Fame Vauban won a 2800m handicap at Royal Ascot in 2023 and then qualified for the Cup with a Group 3 victory in Ireland. Ethical Diamond must at the very least now place in a Group race at 2400m and beyond to be eligible (pass ballot clause) for Cup consideration. An Ebor win would assure the emerging stayer a start in the Cup but also attract a weight penalty. Vauban carried 55kg in 2023 Melbourne Cup, finished 14th of 23, and melted in hot conditions. Royal Ascot has coincidently been held under Australian-like conditions this year, with a good to firm-rated track and temperatures nudging 30C. Ethical Diamond revelled on the fast ground. 'There is a big win over hurdles in Ethical Diamond too but, at the moment, we will concentrate on Flat,' Mullins said. 'To me, I wouldn't think he loves this type of (fast) ground, but all the flat people tell me horses by Awtaad often like it.' Gilbert Gardiner Sports reporter Gilbert Gardiner is a sports reporter for the Herald Sun and Sunday Herald Sun. @gilbertgardiner Gilbert Gardiner
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
British and Irish Lions lose 28-24 to Argentina in Dublin ahead of Australia tour
The British and Irish Lions of 2025 have had an inauspicious start to their tour of Australia, losing 28-24 to Argentina at a raucous Aviva stadium in Dublin. It is the first time that the Lions have lost an opening tour match since 1971 and 20 years since Argentina drew with the Lions in Cardiff. First-half tries to Ignacio Mendy and player of the match Tomás Albornoz gave Argentina a 21-10 lead at half-time, local favourite Bundee Aki crossing for the Lions in a sloppy defensive display. But after that disappointing first half the contest developed into a thrilling game in which both teams threw the ball around with the apparent abandon of a post-season friendly. The Lions hit back early in the second half through a penalty try and a Tadhg Beirne score to give the hosts the lead. But a trilling score by Santiago Cordero saw the Lions fall to a deflating defeat as the Pumas celebrated in style on the pitch and reminded the Lions hierarchy that perhaps South America too would one day be a worthy tour destination. The Lions rarely play matches on home soil and, in the bright sunshine of a summer Friday night in Dublin, there was a degree of frivolity in the sold-out stands far from the pressure cooker of a Test match — albeit one where the Lions were not handing out official Test caps. Any suggestion that this was a fun kickabout in the Dublin sun was dispelled by the stern words that veteran tourists Maro Itoje and Elliot Daly imparted in the post-match huddle. No doubt those conversations will continue on the plane Down Under, with the squad departing for Australia on Saturday morning. "I think there are a few learnings. I think we showed glimmers of what this team can be about," Itoje said post-match. "I think there were a few teething issues, [it was] our first run out. "We'll take our lessons … we'll learn from our mistakes and move forward." Many of those teething issues came at the lineout, where the Lions were awful, and in defence, where Argentina's pacing attack tore the line to shreds. This is not the first-choice Lions team that will likely suit up in Brisbane on July 19 — just three Irish players made the starting XV due to the Leinster contingent's participation in the United Rugby Championship final last weekend. But it was still an all-star-packed side that will have been chastened by the enthusiasm and skill of the Argentina side, who were missing plenty of players themselves, in front of them. "We're building a team," Itoje added. "We were nowhere near as consistent or accurate. "We'll learn, we'll get better." Despite the defeat, that improvement was evident as the game went on. The Lions offered a glimpse of how Farrell wants his side to play and, against a ready and willing Argentine side that have claimed the scalps of all three southern hemisphere giants in the past 12 months, they showed glimmers of real class. The scrum was utterly dominant — even with Irish pair Andrew Porter and Tadhg Furlong not involved — as Ellis Genge showed all his power. It also indicated some combinations that Farrell may be interested in using, including a power-packed centre partnership of Aki and Sione Tuipulotu. Fin Smith started at 10 but Marcus Smith, playing 15, popped up at first receiver with abandon in the latter stages of the match, flashing his fast feet and poking his nose through the line with increasing regularity. That being said, both were overshadowed by the superb play of Benneton flyhalf Albornoz. The polish may not have been there from the Lions, but the speed at which they attempted to play was indicative of the assault the Wallabies line will be under whenever they are without the ball — this Lions team will be coming to entertain as well as win. Winger Tommy Freeman in particular was supreme in the air, a warning to avoid kicking in his direction should he make the cut for the test team. But the pack, admittedly shorn of many of its key personnel, will need to step up — particularly in the lineout, which was desperately poor. The Lions will have precious little time to regroup, with post-match briefings perhaps taking place on the long flight Down Under this weekend. The nine-match tour, with three Tests and six tour matches, kicks off in Perth on Saturday, June 28 against the Western Force, where the Lions will no doubt be desperate to kick off their tour proper with a win. British and Irish Lions: Marcus Smith; Tommy Freeman, Sione Tuipulotu, Bundee Aki, Duhan van der Merwe; Fin Smith, Alex Mitchell; Ellis Genge, Luke Cowan-Dickie, Finlay Bealham, Maro Itoje (c), Tadhg Beirne, Tom Curry, Jac Morgan, Ben Earl. Replacements: Ronan Kelleher, Pierre Schoeman, Tadhg Furlong, Scott Cummings, Henry Pollock, Tomos Williams, Elliot Daly, Mack Hansen. Argentina: Santiago Carreras; Rodrigo Isgró, Lucio Cinti, Justo Piccardo, Ignacio Mendy; Tomás Albornoz, Gonzalo Garcia; Mayco Vivas, Julián Montoya (c), Joel Sclavi, Franco Molina, Pedro Rubiolo, Pablo Matera, Juan Martin González, Joaquín Oviedo, Replacements: Bautista Bernasconi, Boris Wenger, Francisco Coria Marchetti, Santiago Grondona, Joaquín Moro, Simon Benitez Cruz, Matías Moroni, Santiago Cordero.
