How AI pales in the face of human intelligence and ingenuity
Gary Marcus is right to point out – as many of us have for years – that just scaling up compute size is not going to solve the problems of generative artificial intelligence (When billion-dollar AIs break down over puzzles a child can do, it's time to rethink the hype, 10 June). But he doesn't address the real reason why a child of seven can solve the Tower of Hanoi puzzle that broke the computers: we're embodied animals and we live in the world.
All living things are born to explore, and we do so with all our senses, from birth. That gives us a model of the world and everything in it. We can infer general truths from a few instances, which no computer can do.
A simple example: to teach a large language model 'cat', you have to show it tens of thousands of individual images of cats – being the way they are, they may be up a tree, in a box, or hiding in a roll of carpet. And even then, if it comes upon a cat playing with a bath plug, it may fail to recognise it as a cat.
A human child can be shown two or three cats, and from interacting with them, it will recognise any cat as a cat, for life.
Apart from anything else, this embodied, evolved intelligence makes us incredibly energy-efficient compared with a computer. The computers that drive an autonomous car use anything upwards of a kilowatt of energy, while a human driver runs on twentysomething watts of renewable power – and we don't need an extra bacon sandwich to remember a new route.
At a time of climate emergency, the vast energy demands of this industry might perhaps lead us to recognise, and value, the extraordinary economy, versatility, plasticity, ingenuity and creativity of human intelligence – qualities that we all have simply by virtue of being alive.Sheila HaymanAdvisory board member, Minderoo Centre for Technology & Democracy, Cambridge University
It comes as no surprise to me that Apple researchers have found 'fundamental limitations' in cutting-edge artificial intelligence models (Advanced AI suffers 'complete accuracy collapse' in face of complex problems, study finds, 9 June). AI in the form of large reasoning models or large language models (LLMs) are far from being able to 'reason'. This can be simply tested by asking ChatGPT or similar: 'If 9 plus 10 is 18 what is 18 less 10?' The response today was 8. Other times, I've found that it provided no definitive answer.
This highlights that AI does not reason – currently, it is a combination of brute force and logic routines to essentially reduce the brute force approach. A term that should be given more publicity is ANI – artificial narrow intelligence, which describes systems like ChatGPT that are excellent at summarising pertinent information and rewording sentences, but are far from being able to reason.
But note, the more times that LLMs are asked similar questions, the more likely it will provide a more reasonable response. Again, though, this is not reasoning, it is model training.Graham TaylorMona Vale, New South Wales, Australia
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Geeky Gadgets
39 minutes ago
- Geeky Gadgets
Maximize Your iPhone Dynamic Island: Essential Tips for 2025
Dynamic Island, a feature introduced on iPhones, has transformed how you interact with your device. By merging live activities and app interactions into a compact, multitasking-friendly interface, it provides a seamless way to stay productive and informed. The detailed video below from Pete Matheson explores its setup, core functionalities, practical applications, and third-party integrations, helping you maximize the benefits of this innovative tool. Watch this video on YouTube. Getting Started: Setup and Activation To begin using Dynamic Island, ensure the feature is enabled on your iPhone. Follow these steps to activate it: Open your device settings. Navigate to the 'Live Activities' option and toggle it on. Once activated, Dynamic Island integrates effortlessly with Apple's native apps and an expanding list of third-party applications. It becomes a central hub for live updates and quick interactions, streamlining your multitasking experience. By allowing this feature, you unlock a powerful tool designed to enhance both productivity and convenience. Core Functionalities: What Dynamic Island Can Do Dynamic Island is designed to provide real-time updates and enable quick actions without disrupting your workflow. Its core functionalities include: Live Updates: Stay informed about music playback, timers, navigation, phone calls, and Face ID authentication in real time. Stay informed about music playback, timers, navigation, phone calls, and Face ID authentication in real time. Quick Actions: Perform tasks like pausing music, switching audio sources, or dismissing notifications with a single tap. Perform tasks like pausing music, switching audio sources, or dismissing notifications with a single tap. Multitasking: Monitor updates from up to two apps simultaneously, allowing you to keep track of multiple activities without switching screens. For example, you can track a countdown timer while navigating directions, all within the Dynamic Island interface. This functionality ensures you remain informed and in control, even during busy moments. Practical Applications: Everyday Use Cases Dynamic Island is more than just a visual enhancement; it's a practical tool for managing daily tasks. Here are some ways you can use it effectively: Timers: Keep track of countdowns for tasks like cooking, parking, or work breaks without unlocking your phone. Keep track of countdowns for tasks like cooking, parking, or work breaks without unlocking your phone. Navigation: Receive turn-by-turn directions and updates from apps like Apple Maps or Google Maps directly in the interface. Receive turn-by-turn directions and updates from apps like Apple Maps or Google Maps directly in the interface. Phone Calls: Manage call duration, mute, or switch audio sources without leaving the Dynamic Island. Manage call duration, mute, or switch audio sources without leaving the Dynamic Island. Screen Recording: Pause or stop recordings with a single tap, making it easier to manage content creation. Pause or stop recordings with a single tap, making it easier to manage content creation. Accessory Monitoring: Check battery levels and connection status for AirPods or other Bluetooth devices at a glance. Check battery levels and connection status for AirPods or other Bluetooth devices at a glance. Flashlight Control: Adjust brightness and beam width without navigating through multiple menus. These features make Dynamic Island a valuable tool for simplifying everyday tasks, improving efficiency, and staying organized. Third-Party App Integrations: Expanding Functionality Dynamic Island's compatibility with third-party apps significantly broadens its utility, making it a versatile tool for various needs. Notable integrations include: Health and Fitness: Apps like Sugar display blood glucose levels, while Heavy tracks gym workouts and rest timers, helping you stay on top of your health goals. Apps like display blood glucose levels, while tracks gym workouts and rest timers, helping you stay on top of your health goals. Travel and Transportation: Use apps like Flighty for real-time flight updates or Uber to track your driver's arrival and journey progress. Use apps like for real-time flight updates or to track your driver's arrival and journey progress. Weather: Apps like Carrot Weather provide rain forecasts, temperature updates, and other weather insights directly in the interface. Apps like provide rain forecasts, temperature updates, and other weather insights directly in the interface. Customization: Personalize your experience with apps like Shelf , which lets you add shortcuts, photos, or daily affirmations to the Dynamic Island. These integrations enhance the functionality of Dynamic Island, making it a central hub for everything from health monitoring to travel planning. Entertainment: Adding Fun to Functionality Dynamic Island isn't just about productivity—it also brings an element of fun to your iPhone experience. Here are some entertaining features: Hit the Island: A Pong-style game that incorporates the Dynamic Island as part of the gameplay, offering a unique and interactive experience. A Pong-style game that incorporates the Dynamic Island as part of the gameplay, offering a unique and interactive experience. Pixel Pals: A virtual pet that lives in the Dynamic Island, adding a whimsical and playful touch to your device. These features demonstrate how Dynamic Island can cater to both practical needs and entertainment, making your device more enjoyable to use. Whether you're taking a break or looking for a lighthearted distraction, these options add a layer of fun to your daily routine. Maximizing the Potential of Dynamic Island Dynamic Island is a powerful tool that enhances productivity, simplifies multitasking, and adds convenience to your daily routine. By exploring its core functionalities, using third-party app integrations, and embracing its entertainment options, you can transform your iPhone into a more efficient and enjoyable device. Whether you're managing tasks, tracking fitness goals, or simply having fun, Dynamic Island offers a versatile and customizable solution to meet your needs. With its blend of practicality and entertainment, it's a feature that continues to redefine the smartphone experience. Stay informed about the latest in Dynamic Island by exploring our other resources and articles. Source & Image Credit: Pete Matheson Filed Under: Apple, Apple iPhone, Guides Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Cook up your favorites with $70 off the legendary KitchenAid 9-speed hand mixer with multiple attachments: 'This is the best mixer EVER'
Imagine using just one tool to make meal preparation easier. There's a huge reason why thousands of shoppers consider the KitchenAid 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer their go-to for countless tasks in the kitchen. Whipping? Shredding? Stirring? Kneading? Fluffing? Blending? Let's just say this device does it all — and it won't set you back. Normally $109, it's currently reduced to just $89.98. Enter code WELCOME20 to score an extra $20 off your first order, bringing your total to just $69.98. KitchenAid 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer Snap up this game-changing small appliance for a huge discount! It comes with Flex Edge Beaters, dough hooks, a Pro Whisk, and a Blending Rod, and is equipped with nine speeds to simplify any task in the kitchen. Available in your choice of three gorgeous colors (red, silver, and white), it's on sale right now — and when you enter WELCOME20 at checkout you can score it for an extra $20 off! $69.98 (was $109) Shop You don't need to be a skilled chef to use this handy small appliance. In fact, it's perfect for novices and experts alike. It comes with everything that you need to perform assorted steps, all while speeding up and streamlining preparation. You'll get a pair of Flex Edge Beaters, ideal for handling everything from batter-blending to swirling ingredients together. Two dough hooks recreate the act of kneading, which can be a game-changer if you find that a tiring task. With these hooks, you'll save time and spare yourself the discomfort, too. Also included is a Pro Whisk, which masterfully whips up everything from cream to egg whites and leaves everything gorgeously fluffy and light. And with the Blending Rod, you can create all of your favorite sauces, creams, broths, dressings, and other liquid dishes with ease. KitchenAid has a lock on small appliances that simplify cooking, and this beautifully designed hand mixer is no exception. The beauty of the device is that it's equipped with a whopping nine speeds, allowing you precise control of every task. That's crucial when you need to mix ingredients lightly or are slowly incorporating dry ingredients into a mixture. The device makes it easier than ever to follow your recipes' directions to the letter. It's even got a handy Soft Start feature, which is absolutely essential for preventing the unnecessary splattering that otherwise leaves your surfaces a mess. That's no longer an issue here! Ready to change the attachment? Just press the oversized ejector to swap the existing one for another. It's quick, easy, and won't slow you down while you're preparing dishes. Unsurprisingly, KitchenAid's 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer is stylish, too. Like the brand's legendary mixers, this handheld model comes in assorted colors like Empire Red, White, and Contour Silver. All are dazzling shades that fit nicely into any kitchen. Is it any wonder that shoppers love it so much? It boasts over 1,200 five-star reviews, with plenty of people expressing delight for its efficacy, speed options, and design. 'This is the best mixer ever!' exclaimed one user. 'Love the quiet operation. It's the best. I would buy again!' 'I love it,' declared another. 'Works great and looks beautiful. Powerful and quiet! It makes one-hand operation much easier. Cord wrap is a very nice feature, too!' Take this as your sign to upgrade your kitchen. Snap up the KitchenAid 9-Speed Digital Hand Mixer while it's on sale for this super low price — you can't beat it!
Geeky Gadgets
3 hours ago
- Geeky Gadgets
Garmin Index Sleep Monitor: A Deep Dive into Its Sleep Tracking Tech
The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is a specialized wearable designed to provide in-depth sleep tracking without the need for a wristwatch. It caters to individuals who prioritize comfort during sleep or prefer to charge their Garmin watch overnight. Equipped with Garmin's fifth-generation heart rate sensor, the device delivers detailed insights into your sleep and overall health. However, its functionality is focused solely on sleep tracking, distinguishing it from all-day health and activity trackers. The detailed video below from DesFit gives us a look at the device and its range of features. Watch this video on YouTube. Comfort-Oriented Design The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is designed with comfort as a top priority. Unlike traditional wrist-based wearables, it features a soft, wide, Velcro-adjustable bicep band. This thoughtful design eliminates the discomfort often associated with wearing a watch to bed. The band is machine washable and comes in two sizes, making sure a secure and personalized fit for a wide range of users. This focus on comfort makes the device particularly appealing to those who find wrist-based devices inconvenient or uncomfortable during sleep. By prioritizing a non-intrusive design, Garmin has created a product that seamlessly integrates into your nightly routine without compromising on functionality. Advanced Sleep Tracking and Health Metrics The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor goes beyond basic sleep tracking by monitoring a variety of health metrics that provide a comprehensive understanding of your sleep quality and overall well-being. These include: Heart rate and resting heart rate and resting heart rate Blood oxygen saturation (SpO2) Heart rate variability (HRV) Skin temperature Breathing disturbances These metrics are analyzed to generate detailed sleep scores and insights into sleep stages, such as light, deep, and REM sleep. The device also integrates with Garmin's Body Battery and training readiness features, helping you understand how your sleep impacts your energy levels and fitness potential. For women, the monitor includes menstrual cycle tracking, offering an additional layer of personalized health insights. Furthermore, the device features a smart alarm that gently vibrates to wake you during an optimal sleep phase, making sure a more refreshed and energized start to your day. Seamless Integration and Data Management The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is designed to work independently or in conjunction with Garmin watches, providing flexibility for users. It syncs effortlessly with the Garmin Connect app, where you can access detailed sleep data, trends, and insights. When used alongside a Garmin watch, the system prioritizes data from the watch to maintain consistency and accuracy across your health metrics. This seamless integration ensures that your sleep data is not only comprehensive but also complements the broader health tracking capabilities of Garmin's ecosystem. Battery Life and Charging Efficiency The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor offers a battery life of up to seven days, even with continuous SpO2 tracking enabled. This extended battery life minimizes the need for frequent charging, making it a convenient option for users with busy schedules. Charging the device is straightforward, using Garmin's standard charging port and cable. This compatibility allows the device to integrate seamlessly into your existing charging routine, making sure that it remains ready for use without added hassle. Key Limitations to Consider While the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor excels in sleep tracking, it does have some limitations that may influence its suitability for certain users: It is not a 24/7 health and activity tracker , meaning it cannot monitor daily activity levels or provide round-the-clock health insights. , meaning it cannot monitor daily activity levels or provide round-the-clock health insights. Sleep data may take longer to populate if you wake up earlier than usual, which could be inconvenient for users with irregular schedules. These limitations make the device less ideal for individuals seeking a comprehensive health tracking solution. However, for those focused specifically on sleep optimization, it remains a highly effective tool. Pricing and Value Proposition Priced at $169, the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is positioned as a sleep-specific device. While it offers advanced features and detailed insights, some users may find it lacks the versatility of a more comprehensive health tracker. However, for individuals who prioritize optimizing their sleep, the device delivers excellent value. Its combination of comfort, advanced metrics, and seamless integration with Garmin's ecosystem makes it a worthwhile investment for those seeking to improve their sleep quality. Enhanced User Experience The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is designed with ease of use in mind. Its bicep band minimizes light leakage from the sensor, making sure accurate readings without disrupting your sleep. Additionally, by allowing you to charge your Garmin watch overnight, the device provides added convenience for users who rely on their watch for daytime tracking. This focus on user experience ensures that the device not only delivers accurate and detailed sleep data but also integrates seamlessly into your daily routine, making it a practical and user-friendly option. Overall Assessment The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is a purpose-built device that excels in sleep tracking. By combining comfort, detailed health insights, and seamless integration with Garmin's ecosystem, it offers a valuable tool for understanding and improving your sleep patterns. While its lack of broader health and activity tracking features may limit its appeal for users seeking an all-in-one solution, it remains an excellent choice for those focused on sleep optimization. For individuals looking to gain deeper insights into their sleep and overall well-being, the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor provides a reliable, comfortable, and effective solution. Discover other guides from our vast content that could be of interest on Sleep tracking. Source & Image Credit: DesFit Filed Under: Gadgets News, Guides, Technology News Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
