‘Forced Joy': The New Corporate Mandate Of Employees Gone Too Far?
Some big businesses are peddling "forced joy," mandating that employees put on a happy face even if ... More they're not feeling it.
First it was return-to-office (RTO) mandates, forcing the American workforce out of remote working and back into the office, causing a huge back lash, especially among younger workers. Now, there's a new movement afoot called 'forced joy"--acting 'as if' on steroids, smile or else, if you will--a simple, yet powerful tool that says you can lift your mood by acting as if you already feel better than you actually do.
According to Beth Kowitt, Bloomberg opinion columnist, 'forced joy' is a new job requirement that Starbucks Corp. is imposing on their baristas. She adds that as other corporations end their remote work policies, 'they want butts back in seats--and they want employees to be happy about it.' She calls 'forced joy' a miserable corporate trend at companies like Starbucks and Tiffany where fun has become a job requirement.
Kowitt raises a larger question of why corporate America feels the need to force anything upon employees in today's job market--given that the American workforce is so disengaged. It's one thing to mandate workers back into the office. But mandating specific feelings is quite another, treating employees like robots, expecting them to manufacture feelings on cue while selling products.
I asked Dr. Jason Helfrich, co-founder of 100% Chiropractic, to identify some of the signs of 'forced joy' in the workplace. "Any savvy consumer can tell sincere joy and appreciation from forced," he told me. 'The tell-tale signs are insincere smiles and laughter, work attitude doesn't match (i.e. name on a cup with a heart and then slams down the pen). The message is not consistent, one consumer may get a smile while the next three do not and finally the way the employee treats their coworkers does not match up with the forced smile and gratitude they show to customers. '
Helfrich points out that his organization tries their best to provide a culture where "forced joy" isn't needed, but we all have those days . . . put on a smile, turn up the music and watch that mood turn around. I asked Helfrich about 'forced joy's' purpose, and he explains it as twofold. "The owner or manager wishes to create an environment conducive to first class service and experience for their customer. Or the owner or manager strives to provide an enjoyable work environment leading to happier and more productive employees.'
By nature, joy is drawn, not driven. I asked Helfrich how employees can handle 'forced joy' when it's dictated from top down. He explains first of all, it's important to understand the purpose is to create an environment that promotes business and financial success, leading to job security, promotions and competitive pay for employees. 'Sometimes the 'fake it till you make it' mentality works and often changes one's mood by simply smiling or saying something nice to a customer.'
And he's right. I have written for Forbes.com about the research on how a simple smile tricks your mind into a positive workday mood. Smiling can change your attitude, even if you don't mean it, tricking your mind simply by how you move your facial muscles. When you smile, you feel good not just because it reflects how you feel, but the facial expression contributes to how you feel.
Neuroscience shows when we 'force joy,' it stimulates the amygdala—the emotional brain center, which in turn releases neurotransmitters to encourage an emotionally positive state. Although there's a science behind 'forced smiling,' it's doubtful that it's part of corporate America's rationale. The major difference is that the 'forced smiling' is an authentic technique that draws from within, not coerced from an outside force.
Kowitt points out that the 'forced joy' directive comes from CEO Brian Niccol. She asserts that the underlying message to employees is this: 'It's not enough to manufacture a product for customers; they must also manufacture a feeling. And if Niccol can't motivate workers to do so organically, he'll decree it by edict.'
And that's the bigger issue. The American workforce is tired of decrees and edicts that resurrect dinosaur leadership practices that we already know don't work. The old fashioned hatchet-boss leadership style destroys employee engagement and the company's bottom line. Younger employees are unwilling to crouch behind the potted plant in the corner or pay the price of coercion, humiliation or burnout from iron-fisted leadership to climb the career ladder.
'The power of making someone's day is often overlooked,' Helfrich says. 'You may be the best part of someone's day. Take the responsibility seriously, one smile can change someone's day, and in turn they treat everyone in their life a little bit differently. Some research suggests the average person passes 1,000 people per day. Imagine the impact you can have by showing a smile.'
We all want to put our best foot forward in our jobs. But workers want authentic joy in supportive work environments where empathy, inclusion and compassion are expressed--not mandated--by leaders. According to Kowitt, 'In the age of forced joy, employers are requiring positivity and passion because workers aren't voluntarily producing a whole lot of either right now.'
Bringing joy back to the workplace is critical, especially with RTO mandates, massive layoffs, 'boreout syndrome" sweeping the country and 50% of workers 18-34 feeling burnt out.
Vickie Chen, CEO and co-founder of the mobile gaming company Avia, believes authentic strategies bring joy to the workplace. Her company placed two foster cats in its office, and employees collaborate to take care of them. More than 75% of Avia's employees believe the office cats have strengthened team cohesion, and the animals have become like mascots in the office.
Paycom, a leading HR tech software and payroll provider, has created an employee campus that more closely resembles a college campus than a corporate office. The company has created spaces where people go to relax, work away from their desk or even take time for themselves. Also included are a fitness center, a courtyard with fountains, cafes, zen rooms and sound-proofed privacy booths.
When steps are available that draw authentic joy, it's begs the question why companies need to demand or manufacture 'forced joy' when they can have the real thing. Plus, it's more effective for employees, customers and company profitability .
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
12 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Netherlands Defence Minister: NATO-wide 5% defence spend would be "historic"
Ruben Brekelmans, Netherlands Minister of Defence said they and their European partners support President Donald Trump's calls to encourage Iran to the negotiation table in order to "come to a sustainable solution". Speaking about the upcoming NATO meeting, he told Bloomberg's Oliver Crook "if we agree to 5% spending on core defence and defence-related matters, that would be a historic step" and said it would be of particular significance "if 32 allies in unity agree on this". (Source: Bloomberg)
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israel Ups Iran Attacks as World Awaits Response to US Strikes
(Bloomberg) -- Israel ratcheted up attacks on Iran even as Tehran vowed to retaliate against US strikes on its nuclear facilities over the weekend, fueling fears of a wider war in the Middle East and rattling global markets. Bezos Wedding Draws Protests, Soul-Searching Over Tourism in Venice One Architect's Quest to Save Mumbai's Heritage From Disappearing NYC Congestion Toll Cuts Manhattan Gridlock by 25%, RPA Reports Israel launched a fresh attack on Iran's Fordow nuclear site to obstruct access routes, its military said. It also struck targets including airports and an internal-security headquarters run by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, Defense Minister Israel Katz said. Israel, he said, is acting with 'unprecedented force.' The Islamic Republic fired another missile against Israel on Monday, though its attacks appear to be waning. Subscribe to the Bloomberg Daybreak Podcast on Apple, Spotify and other Podcast Platforms. Tehran has yet to announce whether or how it might strike American targets in the Middle East. Its envoy for the International Atomic Energy Agency said the weekend strikes have delivered an 'irreparable blow' to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, rendering it ineffective. He did not specify whether Iran would look to leave the NPT, something that would probably mean the United Nations' nuclear watchdog can no longer inspect the country's atomic facilities. US President Donald Trump's decision to deploy bunker-busting bombs and cruise missiles on the country's three main nuclear sites on Sunday pushed the Middle East into uncharted territory and boosted risks in a global economy already facing severe uncertainty over his trade wars. After a nervous start to the trading week, in which Brent crude advanced as much as 5.7%, oil prices ended up fluctuating and US equity futures inched higher on bets that Iran's response to the US strikes won't ultimately disrupt the flow of energy from the Middle East significantly. Global bonds still fell on concern the conflict could fan inflation. 'An expanding conflict adds to the risk of higher oil prices and an upward impulse to inflation,' said Bloomberg Economics analysts including Ziad Daoud. Major airlines including British Airways and Singapore Airlines Ltd. canceled flights to the Persian Gulf, disrupting air traffic to critical hubs such as Dubai. The extensive US operation — which targeted nuclear sites at Fordow, Natanz, and Isfahan — included 125 aircraft, strikes by Tomahawk missiles from a submarine and the use of 14 Massive Ordnance Penetrator bombs, the first time the large bunker busters were used in combat. It also marked the US entry into the war that began on June 13 when Israel unleashed attacks on Iran's nuclear and military facilities, and killed senior commanders and atomic scientists. US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said the strikes had a 'limited' objective, focused on destroying Iran's atomic program. At the United Nations on Sunday, Iranian Ambassador Amir Saeid Iravani told an emergency Security Council meeting that the 'timing, nature and scale' of Tehran's response 'will be decided by its armed forces.' The IRGC which answers to the Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, said it would continue targeting Israel and cited American bases in the region as a vulnerability for the US, without openly threatening them. Trump said he would respond with 'far greater' force to any Iranian retaliation on US assets. He also floated the possibility of regime change in Iran, although US officials, including Secretary of State Marco Rubio, have said that's not their objective. Israeli officials have said that while toppling Iranian government isn't a war objective, their attacks could undermine the government so much as to ensure that happens. Fordow Damage Trump said the three nuclear sites US bombers hit were 'totally obliterated.' Others were more cautious, especially in the case of the enrichment site at Fordow that's deep underground. Hegseth and Dan Caine, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, were among the US officials who said the extent of the damage wasn't yet clear. The head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, which officially has the task of monitoring Iran's program, on Monday said that 'very significant damage is expected to have occurred' at Fordow. 'Craters are now visible,' Director General Rafael Grossi said. One concern for the IAEA is that it no longer knows the location of Iran's more than 400 kilograms of uranium enriched to 60%, a level not far off what's needed to make a nuclear bomb. Hormuz Traffic A key area of focus for global markets fretting about Iran's possible venues for retaliation is the Strait of Hormuz, a major artery for the world's oil and gas. Iran's parliament called for the closure of the strait, according to state-run TV on Sunday. But such a move — unprecedented in the Islamic Republic's nearly five-decade history — could not proceed though without the approval of Khamenei, the supreme leader. His office controls decisions of this magnitude, typically in coordination typically with the Supreme National Security Council. Naval forces in the region warned that ships, especially US-linked ones, could be at heightened risk. Greece, home to more oil-tanker capacity than any other nation, cautioned its vessels owners to think again if they're considering entering the Persian Gulf. Two supertankers both capable of hauling about 2 million barrels of crude U-turned in the strait on Sunday. They entered the waterway and then abruptly changed course. One factor that may complicate Iran's decision on how to retaliate is that it is largely isolated on the world stage. Its top allies — Russia and China — are offering only rhetorical support, while the militia groups Tehran has armed and funded for years are refusing or unable to enter the fight. Russian officials have made it clear that a cooperation treaty the two countries signed in January doesn't include mutual-defense obligations. And China, which gets many of its oil and liquefied natural gas imports from the Gulf, including Iran, said it's willing to join international efforts to restore peace in the Middle East. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi met Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow on Monday. Putin denounced 'absolutely unprovoked aggression' against Iran. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani, meanwhile, said he had spoken with Rubio and invited Washington and Tehran to Rome for peace talks. He added he would soon speak to Araghchi. Rome, which enjoys good relations both with the US and Iran, hosted two rounds of nuclear talks between the two countries this year. --With assistance from Donato Paolo Mancini and Henry Meyer. Luxury Counterfeiters Keep Outsmarting the Makers of $10,000 Handbags Is Mark Cuban the Loudmouth Billionaire that Democrats Need for 2028? Ken Griffin on Trump, Harvard and Why Novice Investors Won't Beat the Pros The US Has More Copper Than China But No Way to Refine All of It Can 'MAMUWT' Be to Musk What 'TACO' Is to Trump? ©2025 Bloomberg L.P. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
UPI
22 minutes ago
- UPI
Britain, U.S. warn Iran against Strait of Hormuz blockade
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio (R) and Britain's Foreign Secretary David Lammy (L) at a meeting at NATO Headquarters in Brussels in April. File Photo by NATO/UPI | License Photo June 23 (UPI) -- Britain cautioned Iran Monday that attempts to block the Strait of Hormuz or to strike at American military facilities in the Middle East could lead to escalation, even as Israel continued its strikes on Iran. British Foreign Secretary David Lammy said Monday that such actions would be a "catastrophic mistake." "It would be a huge, catastrophic mistake to fire at U.S. bases in the region at this time. We have forces in the region at this time," said Lammy in an interview with BBC Breakfast. The Iranian parliament moved Sunday to approve a measure to close the Strait in response to the American strikes on Iran over the weekend. The strait serves as a critical route for oil being shipped from Persian Gulf countries, but ultimately it will come down to whether Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei decides to move forward with such a plan. Close to 30% of the world's seaborne oil shipments are moved through the strait. U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio also commented Sunday against Iranian interference with movement through the strait. He spoke with Fox News and called on China to prevent Iran from closing the Strait of Hormuz. "I encourage the Chinese government in Beijing to call them about that, because they heavily depend on the Straits of Hormuz for their oil," said Rubio, as China is a key oil customer of Iran. "The Persian Gulf and nearby waters are important route for international trade in goods and energy. Keeping the region safe and stable serves the common interests of the international community," Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Guo Jiakun said in a press conference Monday. "China calls on the international community to step up effort to promote de-escalation of the conflict and prevent the regional turmoil from having a greater impact on global economic growth." Meanwhile, Israel Defense Forces announced Monday on social media that it "struck routes in order to obstruct access" to the Fordow nuclear enrichment site in Iran's Qom province. The IDF also proclaimed it attacked six Iranian airports "across western, central, and eastern Iran, destroying runways, underground hangars, refueling aircraft, F-14, F-5 and AH-1 aircraft." It further alleged the strikes "impaired takeoff capabilities from these airports, as well as the Iranian military's ability to operate its air force from them."
