FWC chair: Miami Herald misrepresented 2022 boating tragedy investigation
In recent months, media coverage, most notably from the Miami Herald, has cast doubt on the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission's (FWC) investigation into the tragic boating accident that occurred at Cutter Bank in Biscayne Bay on Labor Day weekend in September 2022.
This devastating accident resulted in the heartbreaking loss of a young life. Our deepest sympathies remain with the victims and their families.
Regrettably, I believe much of the Herald's reporting has been one-sided, misrepresenting the diligent and comprehensive efforts undertaken by FWC officers. The FWC is firmly committed to conducting thorough, impartial investigations of all boating accidents within its jurisdiction. This case was no exception.
The investigation was led by seasoned professionals who followed all protocols. Investigators collected physical evidence, analyzed GPS data, interviewed witnesses and consulted experts. These findings were reviewed in coordination with the Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office. Allegations that key evidence was ignored or mishandled are not supported by facts.
Contrary to the Herald's portrayal, the investigation was transparent and rooted in forensic analysis and eyewitness accounts. I feel that the Herald downplayed or buried critical context, favoring narratives that mislead the public and undermined the professionalism of our officers.
All individuals with potentially relevant information were ultimately spoken to. Many declined to speak with investigators the night of the accident, and others either did not come forward or offered information unrelated to the core findings.
The vessel's operator, George Pino, was interviewed on-site by a certified drug recognition expert who observed no signs of impairment. None of the officers on scene reported any indicators of intoxication; however, in the deposition of an FWC officer taken more than two years later, he said Pino had bloodshot eyes and smelled of alcohol. Let me note that the officer had failed to mention this to the onsite investigator or include it in his initial report.
Despite no signs of impairment, the lead investigator requested a voluntary blood draw, which Pino declined. As clarified in the U.S. Supreme Court case Missouri v. McNeely (2013), officers cannot compel blood or breath tests without probable cause. The Herald's misinterpretation of training materials to suggest otherwise is legally incorrect and purposefully misleading.
Even the Herald's own cited legal experts support FWC's approach. Tampa-area attorney Leslie Sammis stated that officers would have needed reasonable suspicion of impairment to request field sobriety exercises — and probable cause to obtain a warrant for a non-consensual blood draw. Miami attorney Michael Mirer echoed that sentiment.
FWC's final report concluded that the accident was caused by Pino's failure to maintain control and operate his boat safely. This determination was based on GPS data that contradicted his claims about evasive maneuvers.
The presence of alcohol containers, which were only discovered after the submerged vessel was recovered, does not alone constitute probable cause. Nor does Pino's admission to consuming two beers earlier in the day. The determination of impairment requires multiple indicators — none of which we feel were present.
I believe the Herald has also wrongly suggested that the absence of body camera footage from four officers indicates misconduct.
In reality, under FWC's prior policy, supporting officers categorized their videos as 'incidental,' which triggered automatic deletion after a set retention period. No officer deleted footage. While we acknowledge the policy was not aligned with our intent, we are actively revising it to ensure proper retention and supervisory review in the future.
The Herald further attempted to link this incident to a recent reconfirmation hearing where I was reappointed to the FWC Commission. Despite not a single Florida senator raising any concerns about the investigation, the Herald misleadingly implied a connection.
Any suggestion that I influenced the investigation-based on my professional relationship with Miami-Dade State Attorney Katherine Fernandez Rundle is baseless.
From the outset, the Herald's coverage has relied on speculation, mischaracterization and selective omission of facts. This undermines public trust and disrespects the seriousness of this tragedy.
FWC officers have remained focused on uncovering the truth and ensuring that justice is served for the victims and their families. I stand by the integrity of our investigation and welcome scrutiny rooted in facts — not sensationalism.
I'm committed to transparency and will continue to work with the affected families.
Justice belongs in a courtroom — not in headlines.
Rodney Barreto is the chair of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Speed boat driver charged in Florida Keys crash that killed a Hialeah woman: FWC
Months after a Hialeah woman was killed when a speedboat crash ejected six people, a Miami Beach man captaining the craft was charged Friday with her death, authorities say. Reinaldo Aquit, 48, was piloting the 39-foot speedboat on Nov. 7 from Miami to Key West in a 120-boat 'poker run' event to celebrate the Race World Offshore World Championship, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission said. MORE: Boat crash in Florida Keys kills Hialeah woman and injures several others, FWC says In the Calda Channel, north of Key West, the agency said Aquit was driving carelessly, speeding and 'disregarding navigational rules. The channel is narrow, and when Aquit took a sharp turn, the speedboat rolled, ejecting six people who were on board. Stephanie Rodriguez, 28, died, and several others were injured. On Friday, Aquit was arrested and charged with vessel homicide and eight misdemeanors. It's unclear what the other charges are. The Miami Herald has requested his arrest warrant. 'The tragic death of this young woman was completely avoidable,' Maj. Alberto Maza, FWC South Bravo Regional Commander, said in a statement. 'We continue to think of Ms. Rodriguez's friends and family as they grieve her loss.'
Miami Herald
a day ago
- Miami Herald
Speed boat driver charged in Florida Keys crash that killed a Hialeah woman: FWC
Months after a Hialeah woman was killed when a speedboat crash ejected six people, a Miami Beach man captaining the craft was charged Friday with her death, authorities say. Reinaldo Aquit, 48, was piloting the 39-foot speedboat on Nov. 7 from Miami to Key West in a 120-boat 'poker run' event to celebrate the Race World Offshore World Championship, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission said. MORE: Boat crash in Florida Keys kills Hialeah woman and injures several others, FWC says In the Calda Channel, north of Key West, the agency said Aquit was driving carelessly, speeding and 'disregarding navigational rules. The channel is narrow, and when Aquit took a sharp turn, the speedboat rolled, ejecting six people who were on board. Stephanie Rodriguez, 28, died, and several others were injured. On Friday, Aquit was arrested and charged with vessel homicide and eight misdemeanors. It's unclear what the other charges are. The Miami Herald has requested his arrest warrant. 'The tragic death of this young woman was completely avoidable,' Maj. Alberto Maza, FWC South Bravo Regional Commander, said in a statement. 'We continue to think of Ms. Rodriguez's friends and family as they grieve her loss.'
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Posts claim ICE is removing foster children for deportation. Here's what we know
Videos that circulated on social media in June 2025 claimed ICE was removing children in the country illegally from their foster homes for deportation. A report published by the Miami Herald (archived) on June 11, 2025, said child welfare authorities in Florida turned over a 17-year-old Honduran foster child to ICE agents. However, the Herald's reporting relied on information from anonymous sources, so Snopes was unable to replicate it. The Florida Department of Children and Families provided the following statement to Snopes via email: "The individual referenced in your inquiry has been in the care of the U.S. Office of Refugee Resettlement (U.S. ORR). The individual absconded and, due to his actions, was intercepted by Florida law enforcement. The Florida Department of Children and Families may provide temporary care but must work with all partners to return the individual to the appropriate legal custody, which in this case was U.S. ORR." ICE had not responded to Snopes' request for comment at the time of this writing. A White House spokesperson provided a statement addressing its efforts to "conduct welfare checks" on migrant children "to ensure they are not being exploited and to reunite them with their families when possible." However, they did not directly address the claims about federal agents removing foster children for deportation. Videos that circulated on social media in June 2025 claimed U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement was removing undocumented children from their foster homes for deportation. One of the earliest iterations of the claim was shared on TikTok (archived) on June 10, 2025, with overlaid text that read, "Foster Children Removed for Deportation." In that video, which has garnered more than 800,000 likes and 100,000 shares as of this writing, a user said: It's time to speak up. ICE is now removing undocumented foster children from their foster homes. Removing foster children from their foster homes for deportation. Several Instagram (archived) users (archived) shared the video on their accounts, while other (archived) users (archived) on social media used the audio as voiceover in their posts. Snopes readers also emailed us and searched our site looking for information about the claim. At the time of this writing, Snopes found a report published by the Miami Herald (archived) on June 11, 2025, that said child welfare authorities in Florida turned over a 17-year-old foster child to ICE agents. The Herald's reporting relied on information from anonymous sources, so Snopes was unable to replicate it. The Herald's deputy investigations editor, who worked on the story, told Snopes via email, "As the story indicates, support for our reporting includes sources whom we are unable to name, and a document we are not at liberty to share." ICE had not responded to Snopes' request for comment at the time of this writing. A White House spokesperson provided a statement addressing the administration's efforts to "conduct welfare checks" on migrant children "to ensure they are not being exploited and to reunite them with their families when possible." However, they did not directly address the claims about federal agents removing foster children for deportation. The statement read: Under the Biden Administration, countless migrant children were illegally smuggled and sex trafficked across the wide-open Southern Border. Not only did the Biden Administration allow this to happen, but once the children arrived to the U.S., Biden's Administration lost track of tens of thousands of them. DHS is leading efforts to conduct welfare checks on these children to ensure they are not being exploited and to reunite them with their families when possible. Unlike the Biden Administration, the Trump Administration takes the safety of these children seriously. In response to Snopes' questions about the teen referenced in the Herald report, the Florida Department of Children and Families provided the following statement via email: The individual referenced in your inquiry has been in the care of the U.S. Office of Refugee Resettlement (U.S. ORR). The individual absconded and, due to his actions, was intercepted by Florida law enforcement. The Florida Department of Children and Families may provide temporary care but must work with all partners to return the individual to the appropriate legal custody, which in this case was U.S. ORR. The Florida agency did not confirm whether the teen was in foster care at the time, as the Herald reported. In its story, the Herald reported that a 17-year-old Honduran boy was removed from his foster home in Pensacola, Florida, "in handcuffs and shackles" and "transferred immediately into ICE custody." He and his mother "had crossed the southwest border into the U.S. without permission," sources told the newspaper. According to the Herald, the teen traveled from Texas to Pensacola in search of work after being separated from his mother, who was later deported. The report said, in part: He entered foster care after he was found living in a shed with no source of food, shelter or income, records show. The boy, whose first name is Henry, also may have been a victim of labor trafficking. The Herald is not fully naming him to protect his privacy. The decision to alert immigration authorities to Henry's status as an undocumented migrant is at odds with decades of child welfare practice in Florida – and it appears to violate a 30-year-old state Department of Children and Families rule that prohibits workers from acting upon a child's status. Republican Florida state Sen. Ileana Garcia, who co-founded the group Latinas for Trump but has openly criticized the president's immigration policies, declined to name the child but told the Herald she is "concerned his case may be part of a larger pattern in which children in the state's foster care system could be picked up at the homes of their foster parents by federal immigration authorities," the newspaper reported. In a post on X (archived) on June 9, 2025, Garcia wrote: Stephen Miller has made it a point to include undocumented minors in foster care, many of whom are victims of human trafficking, in his efforts to fulfill a desperate weekly quota of deportations. These individuals are being picked up at the homes of foster parents. This is unacceptable! Regardless of their citizenship status. Miller serves as the White House's deputy chief of staff. The White House did not directly address any of Garcia's allegations. Garcia told the Herald she could "only provide specifics about the Pensacola case," according to the newspaper. Snopes reached out to Garcia via phone and email to ask for additional information about such incidences and evidence corroborating her claim. We will update this story if we receive a response. Lawyers told the Herald it had been years since they had heard about Florida child welfare agencies, such as the Department of Children and Families, notifying ICE about children in their custody, the newspaper reported. The Herald report also documented Henry's journey to the United States and his time in Pensacola. Henry, whose father is dead, was 13 when he crossed the border with his mother. A source told the Herald that he was initially released into his uncle's custody, though details about his early time in the U.S. aren't entirely clear, according to the newspaper. Henry moved in with his mother at some point before she was arrested in Texas and ultimately deported to Honduras. He made it to Pensacola, where his brother lived, and ended up working for $10 a day. Henry "ran away" when he "realized he was being overworked," and may also have been a victim of labor trafficking, records obtained by the Herald show. In November 2024, a report made to the Department of Children and Families' child welfare hotline alleged Henry was homeless and "did not have a caregiver available," the Herald reported. He was briefly placed with a local family before leaving over disagreements about a visitor and sleeping arrangements, according to the newspaper. The state agency filed a petition in April 2025 asking a judge to designate Henry as a dependent of the state and he was then placed in foster care, the newspaper reported. According to sources who spoke to the Herald, a DCF administrator reported Henry to ICE on June 6. Three days later, ICE agents took him from his foster home "in handcuffs and leg irons," a source told the Herald. Henry is now in the custody of the Office of Refugee Resettlement, as DCF mentioned in its statement to Snopes. He does not have a deportation order, according to a source who spoke to the Herald. The Herald also reported that the Department of Children and Families' decision to report Henry to ICE appears to conflict with state policy. DCF passed a governing procedure in 1995 called the Undocumented Child Rule, which "requires the agency to screen and respond to child abuse hotline calls 'without regard to the immigration status' of the child or family at the center of the report," the Herald reported. According to the Herald, the rule reads, in part: "No such status check or other contact shall be made for the purpose of seeking the child's or the family's detention by [immigration authorities] or the initiation or resumption of deportation or exclusion proceedings against the child or the child's family, irrespective of the outcome of the dependency proceeding. No Department of Children and Family Services staff member may attempt to place any alien child in [immigration] custody." A Florida legal expert told the Herald that "DCF appears to have violated that rule by reporting Henry to ICE." The state agency did not address Snopes' question about allegations that it violated the Undocumented Child Rule. ICE typically does not detain unaccompanied children. Instead, the "responsibilities related to the care and custody of unaccompanied undocumented children" falls under the Department of Health and Human Services' Office of Refugee Resettlement, according to ICE's website. The person referenced in Snopes' inquiry "has been in the care of" ORR, the Florida Department of Children and Families said in its emailed statement. Under federal law, the ORR is required to "feed, shelter and provide medical care for unaccompanied alien children until it is able to release them to safe settings with sponsors (usually family members), while they await immigration proceedings," according to the website for the federal Administration for Children and Families. All sponsors must pass background checks and agree to ensure the child attends their immigration proceedings. They also have to agree to "ensure the minor reports to ICE for removal from the United States if an immigration judge issues a removal order or voluntary departure order," according to the ACF. Miller, Carol Marbin, et al. "Florida Child Welfare Agency Calls ICE on Teen Migrant in Foster Care, Sparking Criticism." Miami Herald, 11 June 2025, Accessed 19 June 2025. Kochi, Sudiksha. "'Unacceptable and Inhumane': Latinas for Trump Founder Blasts Immigration Arrests." USA TODAY, 9 June 2025, Accessed 19 June 2025. Syra Ortiz Blanes. "'Inhumane:' Latinas for Trump Founder Condemns White House Immigration Crackdown." Miami Herald, 7 June 2025, Accessed 19 June 2025. X (Formerly Twitter), 9 June 2025, Accessed 19 June 2025. "Detention Management." Accessed 19 June 2025. "Unaccompanied Alien Children Released to Sponsors by State." 10 Jan. 2025, Accessed 19 June 2025.
